The Wind Rises, written and directed by Hayao Miyazaki of Studio Ghibli, is my favorite of any of his films that I've seen. It isn't based in fantasy like many of Miyazaki's films, but still has strong and mature themes that should be talked about!
Josh Taylor analyzes Hayao Miyazaki's 2013 film *The Wind Rises*, arguing it is the director's crowning achievement. Moving away from fantasy, the film explores the life of Jiro Horikoshi, the designer of a WWII fighter plane, to examine the tension between the pursuit of beauty and the destructive reality of war, as well as the tragedy of tunnel vision and false hope.
I'll be honest, up until a few years ago, I didn't really know much about the Japanese
animation scene, at least beyond Pokemon.
And I never really understood why Hayao Miyazaki was seen as such a brilliant storyteller.
I'd watched some of his films from Studio Ghibli, and they really didn't connect with
me in the same way that Disney or Pixar films connected with me emotionally.
That is until I saw what I believe is Miyazaki's true crowning achievement.
An emotional film that has a melancholy, humanitarian message, and a movie that finds itself hoping
for a better future through a story about our past.
Stop.
What the hell are you talking about?
I'm talking about the 2013 animated film The Wind Rises.
My name's Josh Taylor, this is 1901, and today I need to talk to you about why Hayao Miyazaki
decided to make a movie about one man's life and how hope fails him.
This video is part of a larger collaboration with other YouTube video essayists, where
each month we pick a different director and celebrate their stories and life.
This month we're celebrating animation writer and director Hayao Miyazaki.
This is my contribution to that playlist, and if you'd like to check out the full playlist
of different videos all about Hayao Miyazaki and his films, you can see that in the link
above my head or in the description box down below.
You can also make your own video and add it to our playlist by sending a tweet over to
my friends at Culp Popture, and they'll make sure to put your video into the playlist with
the rest of us.
But let's talk about Miyazaki for a moment, as I think some details of his life and his
own story really help enrich The Wind Rises as a film.
It only showcases how personal The Wind Rises was to its creator.
First and foremost, Miyazaki's films with Studio Ghibli have always had some elements
of fantasy within them.
They've always introduced otherworldly settings and creatures, letting us know that we're
not grounded in reality within these films, despite how emotionally invested and real
those worlds may seem.
Second, his father actually owned an airplane manufacturing company, which helped put together
the Mitsubishi A6M0 planes.
The most popular Japanese planes to take flight during World War II, and possibly the most
destructive weapon the Japanese ever had.
Hayao Miyazaki's love of aircrafts and his use of flight as a story element throughout
many of his films has been something that's come from his father's business.
His mother would also be diagnosed with tuberculosis early on in his life, something that she survived,
but she spent many years in the hospital fighting.
Another key piece to knowing Miyazaki is that he's anti-war.
His family actually had to evacuate their home and move somewhere else during World
War II after the place they'd lived had been bombed.
And in 2003, he actually declined an invite to the Academy Awards because he didn't want
to visit America while it was fighting and bombing Iraq.
And last but not least, before doing The Wind Rises, he had already announced his retirement
after making Ponyo in 2008.
So on the surface, it seems really strange that Hayao Miyazaki would come out of retirement
to make a brand new film, a war film essentially, and a biographical film about one man, Jiro
Hirokoshi, the man who designed the Mitsubishi A6M0.
And again, it was arguably one of the most destructive weapons that the Japanese had
during World War II.
When The Wind Rises came out, it was actually met with controversy, with critics stating
how it romanticized World War II and the airplane's creator.
But Miyazaki was compelled to make this film after reading a quote from Jiro Hirokoshi
himself, stating all I wanted to do was make something beautiful.
The Wind Rises lacks all of the fantastical elements we've seen from Miyazaki and Studio
Ghibli in the past, and instead replaces them with historical moments, like the 1923 Great
Kanto Earthquake, or we see visions of Jiro's real-life aviation designer idol, Giovanni
Caproni.
But remember this, Japanese boy, airplanes are not tools for war, they're not for making
money.
Airplanes are beautiful dreams, engineers turn dreams into reality.
Yes.
But there are roots within this film that lead to a very personal attachment for Miyazaki
as well.
Throughout the two-hour or so runtime of The Wind Rises, we see two major plotlines running
throughout Jiro's life, the first of which is based solely on his love of aviation and
his desire to design aircrafts.
The history of aviation in and of itself is a fantastical history that we really don't
have time to go into, but in the early 20th century, this new technology of flight was
being used and adapted time and time again for the purpose of war.
In one of Jiro's dreams, when he meets up with his idol, Caproni asks him if he'd rather
live in a world with or without pyramids.
Which would you choose?
A world with pyramids or without?
What do you mean?
Humanity has always dreamt of flight, but the dream is cursed.
The idea here stating that innovations in technology, especially in designing aircrafts
in this case, may not necessarily be used in the way you desire.
Horikoshi didn't get into designing airplanes because he wanted to create weapons, but it
was really the only way that he knew how to make money in doing something that he loved.
In another dream, Caproni starts talking about how he wants to create airplanes for travel,
and that's something that plays a theme in the background of this entire film.
We consistently see the need for transportation as an important element to the story.
Jiro moves out of his boyhood home by taking a train, cars and trolleys can be seen in
the background shots of various scenes, and Jiro and his sister even take a boat through
Tokyo to meet up with his family.
Because of this dream that he has and this subtle background movement of transportation,
we might think that Jiro's dream to build aircrafts might have been for the purpose
of transportation itself, and we see the possibilities and delight of air travel here.
We see the smiles on the people on the plane in Jiro's dream, while in reality when he
takes the train out of his boyhood hometown, we see such anger and discontent on the train.
Jiro's hope while studying in school and eventually working for Mitsubishi is to create
something beautiful.
He's hopeful for the future, for innovations, even if that's a false hope, or what they
say in the film, a cursed dream.
In the film's other plotline, Jiro falls in love.
After seeing a girl on the train as he rides out of town, he meets her later in his adulthood
life.
When we first meet Naoko, she actually saves Jiro's hat from flying off the train, and
when they meet up again in adulthood, Jiro saves her umbrella from flying away.
Throughout the film, we see a little bit of flirting and romantic tactics that lead Jiro
and Naoko to fall in love, and when Naoko learns that she has tuberculosis, Jiro hopes
for the best.
The two actually end up rushing their own wedding so that they can live together, and
even though both know that Naoko is getting sicker, they still continue on with their
daily lives.
Naoko stays home and tries to get well while Jiro goes to work and stays late into the
night.
Jiro continues to work as if nothing is wrong, and even in one evening when he comes home,
he continues to put down a table and work on it.
Simultaneously working and holding his wife's hand, we see this moment as him grasping on
to the two things he absolutely loves the most and just trying to hold on for dear life.
And then one day Naoko opts to just leave their home, walk away, so that Jiro can remember
her for who she was and not as some overly sick person or to come home and find her dead.
These two plotlines that go throughout the film share this idea of false hope.
Both in his career and his love life, Jiro ignores all of the problematic pieces that
line up that will eventually make him a widower and to create a weapon that will ultimately
hurt thousands and thousands of people.
This masterpiece of a film doesn't just talk about the harmfulness of war, but the
harmfulness of tunnel vision.
The harmfulness of not stopping to reassess your own life.
If Jiro were to have stopped and taken notice, he may have questioned why he was helping
the government build a weapon of war in the first place.
Instead of building the transportation machine that he probably wanted to build.
If he would have stopped to think about Naoko's health instead of working so much, he may
have been able to help her overcome her sickness or at least postpone her death.
Similar to Miyazaki's mother who lived well into her 70s.
Lots of Miyazaki fans talk about whether or not the man is a pacifist, but I think it's
much more complicated than that.
He doesn't just want to see peace instead of war.
But he wants people to see the true beauty in their lives.
He wants them to stop wishing and looking towards the future.
And to recognize the present that they're in now.
And to judge themselves for the place that they're at in life.
This isn't simply about being anti-war.
But it's about creating and innovating for the betterment of our own society, for the
world around us, for the people that we love, and for ourselves.
There is a ton of beautiful animation in The Wind Rises, I can't deny that, and the musical
score is gorgeous, and the voice acting for the English dub, because yes, I'm that kind
of person, is fantastic.
But this is a story, truthfully, about hope and love.
And it's a lesson in understanding who we are in the present, so that we can start designing
a better tomorrow.
If you like this video, make sure to hit the subscribe button, the likes, the shares, all
that fun stuff.
And also, this is a monthly ongoing series that we have talking about different directors,
so if you're interested in hearing about a certain director, leave a comment down below
and let us know what directors you'd like us to talk about in the future.
Also the entire director project playlist will be up on the screen right now so you
can click on that.
And in the meantime, thank you for watching.
I hope you have a pleasant day, keep moving forward.