Decoding the Arch of Constantine: Recycled Art

What Was The Life
13 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 8, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Arch of Constantine is the last great arch constructed in Imperial Rome.
We'll examine its location, its purpose, and the huge amount of reused material that makes it so
unique on Ancient Rome Live. Thanks for watching this video and subscribing to our channel.
Let's dive in.
Today we are talking about the Arch of Constantine and issues of spoliation.
This is a very famous example of reused or recycled history
in one of the best preserved monuments from Imperial Rome.
We can see right here in this image two different styles, two different periods.
In the Spandrel, it's a contemporary relief that's created at the time of the creation
of the Arch, and then the Roundel, which we date to the reign of Hadrian.
So let's take a look at this fantastic, fascinating arch.
So first of all, we want to set the stage where we are.
We're in the shadow of the Colosseum.
We're in a corner of the Palatine Hill.
And we have, lucky for us, a fantastically preserved monument, but also with an inscription
which sets the stage of its meaning, which we'll get to.
Just want to share with you then some of these incredible views of this layered, storied arch
from the attic all the way down to the ground.
We see Dacian prisoners.
We see large panels dating to the age of Marcus Aurelius.
We're pivoting down to the Roundels of the Hadrianic era
and the narrative frieze contemporary with Constantine.
So Constantine, born in Serbia, dies in Constantinople.
He has a very long reign, and he establishes himself
with the victory of the Milvian Bridge, October 28, 312.
There's a famous statue from the Baths of Constantine now in St. John Lateran.
That very battle is depicted on the arch.
So we're at the corner of the Palatine Hill next to, in this patch of grass here,
the original location of the Meta Sudans, the Sweating Fountain, the Sweating Meta.
And it is a turning post here symbolically because you're turning the corner.
You're going up into the Via Sacra.
You're going into the Forum area.
So it's a critical corner, one of four, of the Palatine Hill where Romulus founded the city.
And this arch in particular celebrates the 10th anniversary of Constantine.
And his purpose, we can ask, triumphal?
Well, we will take a look at the inscription in the shadow of the much earlier Flavian Colosseum.
We have the Latin.
We have the English.
To the Emperor Caesar Flavius Constantinus, the greatest, pious, and blessed Augustus.
Because he, inspired by the divine, not by the sign of the cross or the Christian God,
which is handed down to us in the Christian tradition, but inspired by the divine,
purposefully vague, as most of Rome is still non-Christian, and by the greatness of his mind,
has delivered the state from the tyrant Maxentius and all of his followers,
at the same time, with his army and with just force of arms.
The Senate of the Roman people have dedicated this arch,
and here's the kicker, Arcum Friumphus Insignum, decorated with the mark of triumph.
So a triumph is supposed to be for victory over the enemy, the non-Roman.
Here it is, celebrating the victory over fellow Romans.
This is a civil war.
Although he says this guy is not legitimate.
He is a tyrant.
That is the previous emperor approved by the Senate, Maxentius.
So here we go with reuse of previously existing reliefs and statuary.
Pre-Constantinian, we'll have Trajanic large panels on the attic story,
on the short ends, as well as the inner arch,
and the Dacian prisoners on this schematic in green,
that might have come from the Forum of Trajan, celebrating the conquest of the Dacians.
The roundels are yellow, eight of them, four on each side,
but then there are two added on the short sides, dating to the time of Constantine.
Marcus Aurelius has four attic reliefs on each side, so eight total,
and they are going to be made anew by replacing the heads of the emperor,
Marcus Aurelius, with that of contemporary Constantine.
And finally, lots of Constantine narrative frieze, spandrels, column bases, and those roundels.
So there's a whole bunch of pre-used material we can identify stylistically,
we can identify by the figures, we can identify by the figures depicted by the Dacians,
to then confirm that these are indeed taken from other monuments in the city of Rome,
put to new use in a new novel construction, this arch, this triple arch of Constantine.
So here we can then see some of those layers of that history.
We have the Aurelianic panels at the attic story,
we have the Dacian prisoners on Cipollino marble bases,
we have porphyry framing the roundels dating to the time of Hadrian.
We're going to walk through these various components,
and then there's that little narrative frieze.
And in the spandrels over the arches, we have river god figures,
we'll have victory figures, depending on what we're looking at,
and then we have, even on the bases of the columns, victory figures annealing barbarians,
although this is not a celebratory monument against the foreign foe,
they're the foreign foe appearing at the base as that kind of generic symbol of conquest.
So here we have, again, conquered barbarians,
there's a barbarian woman and a child at her feet,
even though they do not figure in the narrative of Constantine's conquest of Maxentius.
And behind those figures, there is the trophy.
We've given talks on the Roman trophy.
There is then the arms of the defeated foe put on a tree trunk,
which we can see replicated through these bases of these freestanding columns
that are mostly shallow Antico marble.
And here we have a victory figure, which you'll be familiar with
if you take a look at the column of Marcus Aurelius and the column of Trajan.
Here is victory riding on a shield.
It's an old, old motif at this point,
appearing then as familiar victory language on the arch of Constantine.
We can see again from here, zooming into the spandrels,
who do we have?
Contemporary carved Nike figures, victory figures in the style and the age of Constantine.
In great contrast then to the roundel figures on the right,
but we can see the victory figures are holding what?
Trophies.
Again, this quintessential symbol of conquest appears time and time again
throughout any triumphal arch.
So let's take a look now at these pieces that are contemporary with Constantine.
There's a lot of original work here.
So the roundels on the long sides of the Hadrianic era
are matched on the short sides by two novel constructions, two novel roundels.
On one side, we have here Sol, Sun, Ascending.
And then the other side, we're going to have Luna.
But these are created at the time of Constantine in the style of that of Hadrian,
although the styles are of a different era.
This is obviously going to be a later period production
and would have had a frame with porphyry or some kind of colored stone,
which has been robbed out.
Here's the other side.
It is the descending Luna figure in her own chariot.
We have the Sun and the Moon, kind of that cycle of life.
We have the seasons that are also depicted in some of the spandrels.
So we're getting a cosmological and annual kind of depiction
in some of these figures as well.
We have this fascinating narrative frieze
that narrates the battle of and victory of Constantine.
So we have the setting out for war and we have the army,
we have the troops,
again with the hats in the style of contemporary Constantinian soldiers,
more cookie-cutter kind of figures for legibility,
more typical of the period of the 4th century.
Excuse me.
And what we have then is the short side facing the Palatine Hill
going to our first major battle in Verona.
Verona is depicted on the right.
And the troops outside the walls are the troops that win
because they have a floating victory figure above them.
So we have here Obsidio or the sieging scene
and it is the victory in Verona that we see.
And then we have the next panel, the Prolium,
the big battle at the Milvian Bridge.
And we actually can see the wavy lines of the Milvian Bridge.
We can see the bridge itself on the left.
And who's that woman that's marching across?
It's Roma leading the charge.
There's also a victory figure and the horsemen that win are on top.
And the poor soldiers, the poor soldiers being defeated
are literally swimming with the fish.
Those are the troops of Maxentius that perish in this battle,
frowning, bodies dumped into the Tiber River.
And then we turn the corner, the other short side,
and we have Ingressus.
We have the entry into the city.
There's a parade.
There's the regalia of the various troops and their flags and so forth.
We see that and there's the emperor in his chariot
making their way into Rome.
And in Rome, whoops, in Rome, they're in the forum.
And the central speech is given by a now headless Constantine
on the rostra with the balustrade.
Who's sitting on the rostra and the corners in the left and right?
None other than Antoninus Pius and Hadrian.
Their statues are then present on the rostra balustrade.
And you can even make out the tetrarch columns in the background
with statues on top.
And the fifth central column is that of Jupiter.
And then we have the arcades on the left of a basilica.
And on the right, the Basilica of Julia.
And on the right, we have the three arches,
the three arcades of the Arch of Septimius Severus,
roughly of the same dimensions as the Arch of Constantine.
You can see in the sand rolls, the other seated river god figures.
So we have a lot of contemporary carving on the Arch of Constantine,
this narrative frieze, and the spandrel figures.
We're finally at the liberalitas.
Liberalitas is the largesse.
It's the donatives.
It's the gifts being distributed from the basilicas
to the people who are extending their hands out.
And then the central figure, but the keystone is none other than
Constantine himself, his inserted portrait head is lost.
Let's pivot up into the short side past Sol up to the attic relief.
So now we're talking about these attic reliefs.
You see they're flanked by Dacian figures,
but the attic reliefs we're going to attribute to the time of Trajan.
In fact, there's one of these on each short side,
and then there are going to be two on the interior arch,
the central part of the Arch of Constantine.
And all together, they've been reassembled in a study
showing that they all belong to one continuous large narrative.
So one, two, you can see it's a continual related battle.
And here it is again, close up, three.
And now we're on the interior arch of the Triple Arch,
and we can see it's the same sort of scene.
It's the same narrative.
And a lot of the figures on the edges actually match up from one to another.
So these are spectacular scenes.
They're all recarved.
The central protagonist of Constantine is now visible.
But who was it originally?
The idea is it was Trajan,
and quite possibly, according to other scholars,
originally Domitian that was being depicted.
So that's kind of the scholarly debate.
Passing on to Hadrian are these roundels.
We can see here there's a scene of hunt,
and then there's a scene of sacrifice.
And the horsemen on the left killing the boar
is none other than Constantine.
So the heads of the emperor have been replaced.
But stylistically, we place this in the Hadrianic period,
also because a lot of the surrounding figures
are identified as companions of Hadrian.
But these are magnificent.
You can see right here between the two roundels,
there's a little bit of porphyry,
so that this would be indeed a nice framing element
with precious porphyry stone.
Here's another one, another pair.
And in this case, we can see the porphyry is intact.
Quite impressive.
And if this is created as an anniversary,
a celebrating anniversary of Constantine's rule in 10 years,
we then have this one for their vows
are celebrating 20 years of his reign.
So that's an add-on feature.
So they're just quite spectacular.
There's a lot of questions
as to what the original location was for these roundels,
because they're not showing battle,
they're showing a pastime, they're showing hunting,
they're showing leisure,
and they're showing reverence to various deities
from Apollo to Hercules.
Now, the twist to all of this
is this height of the arch and below
has recently been identified
as actually an original pre-existing arch of Hadrian
to which these roundels belong.
And the rest of it in the attic story
has been subsequently plopped on top
in the reign of Constantine.
That's a debatable interpretation
of the archaeological evidence
and a look at the foundations, which are not very clear.
I thought I'd mentioned that.
It's a little more than you probably want to know,
but we are able to discern
as we're looking at this particular frame,
the various kinds of styles.
We don't have to be an expert here.
We can see the spandrel figures,
we can see the narrative frieze
is one type of carving and representation of the human form,
and the roundels are another.
Here's another one, another hunt scene,
another sacrifice scene.
So we have these magnificent roundel pairs,
two, four, six, eight of them
that are quite unique in Roman art
and seem to be then placed here
as an added benefit,
as an added coloration of the narrative of this arch,
although they do not have any relevance
to the theme and the narrative
of Constantine's story of this arch.
So either preexisting
or somebody considers it to be an appropriate,
additional decorative form
that adds to the glory of the emperor,
the glory of his victory, and so on.
Finally, to the attic story,
we have these magnificently preserved figures
of a, well, reliefs,
two, four, six, eight of them
from a lost arch of Marcus Aurelius.
Now, how are we so confident about that?
Well, the heads of the emperor we can see here,
twice the emperor Constantine.
So essentially the portrait has been given a shave and a haircut,
but we have panels very similar of the same dimensions
now stuck on a wall inside the Kaplan Museum.
So here we feel very confident
that these are indeed originally for a lost
or a dismantled or destroyed or damaged arch
of Marcus Aurelius that find their way here.
And that's no mean feat.
It's not easy to lift up these massive marble reliefs
that are almost three-dimensional
up to this great height without damaging them.
So we have on the left,
the emperor who is entering the city
and he's got Mars Ultor with him in Roma.
And another one here looks like he's setting out
because he looks like the figure
on the sprawled out on the ground has a wheel by her arm.
And that would then be setting out for Rome,
from Rome along the Via Appia, something like that.
We have other addresses to people.
So he's raised up on a podium
and then magnificently framed by these Dacian figures,
remains of which we can see in the Forum of Trajan
still today in the Imperial Forum Museum
in the Marcus of Trajan.
And they're resting on these Cipollino marble,
green marble bases.
What a fantastic framing element we have
for the Attic story reliefs.
So these are in great detail.
And now, with binoculars or with the zoom lens,
we can really, really appreciate it.
We can appreciate these small encapsulated narratives,
the Alicuccio, the address to Roman soldiers.
And we can feel the drama.
We can feel connected to the power
and the influence of the emperor in each of these scenes.
Here he is again.
And finally, or ironically, there is on the bottom right,
the emperor Constantine making a sacrifice
to a Sera Turelia.
So that's a bull, a sheep, and a pig all figured in this scene.
And this is the first Christian emperor.
But he is still performing in each of these scenes
the traditional actions of the Pontifex Maximus,
of the emperor of the Roman Empire.
So they're pretty extraordinary.
Extraordinarily well-preserved,
but also extraordinary in their subject matter
that we have here.
Not explicitly an arch that references the Christian god,
although historically, you know,
that's the narrative that Constantine
is eventually going to push.
But here he is showing a typical scene of a Roman emperor.
So this is an appropriate, a shrewd use
of spoliated or reused reliefs to tell that narrative
that everyone is used to seeing
in the long history of the Roman Empire.
From the grass, which has the Metaseudan fountain,
Palatine Hill in the distance,
we've been taking a look at the Arch of Constantine
and issues of reuse and spoliation
and original narrative
for one of the greatest monuments preserved
in Imperial Rome.
It is Darius for Ancient Rome Live.
Thank you so much for watching,
for liking this video,
for subscribing to our channel.
We are so enthusiastic to share with you
the hidden aspects,
special access to Ancient Rome and its empire.
Thanks for watching.
