In this episode, I sit down with investigative reporter Joshua Philipp to uncover the deeper ideology behind communism and how it connects to AI, technocracy, and Universal High Income. We explore whether “free money” could become a tool of control, what happens when machines replace human work, and why protecting faith, purpose, and real community matters now more than ever.
Chapters: 00:00 - Intro 03:07 - What Is Communism and Socialism? 11:31 - How Communism Became a Political Religion 23:14 - Technocracy, AI, and Universal Basic Income 32:35 - Government-Run Grocery Stores in New York City 45:45 - How to Protect Your Freedom and Stay Human
Chapter compares every Medicare plan nationwide for free to recommend coverage based on your doctors, prescriptions, and budget. Call (773) 801-5366 or visit http://chapter.com/man.
DISCLAIMERS: Some of the links in this description are affiliate links and pay me a small commission if you use them. I hope you do! Thank you so much for the support, it really helps to keep this show truly independent. Guest views are their own and are not financial, medical, or professional advice; consult a qualified professional before acting on anything discussed.
PROTECT YOUR FINANCES: -- Learn more about investing in gold & silver, visit http://goldwithseth.com, or call 626-654-1906
STAY HEALTHY: -- Age well by restoring your cellular health with NMN-3 from Brightcore 25% Off with code: MIA at https://brightcore.com/mia Or call (888) 575-6488 for up to 50% OFF and Free Shipping. ONLY when you call!
-- Detox your body from everyday nano-toxins, including heavy metals, forever chemicals like BPA, and pesticide residues: https://zeolite123.com. Use code SETH to save.
Seth Holhouse and Joshua Phillip discuss the rise of centralized control systems, arguing that government-run necessities and technocracy lead to authoritarianism. They trace the ideological roots of communism from the Enlightenment to modern AI, warning that the erosion of individual independence and faith paves the way for a disposable human existence and state dependency.
There are two things happening right now that I think are very important to watch,
because both represent systems that fundamentally oppose so much of what this country was founded
on. In New York City, Mayor Mamdani is preparing to roll out government-run grocery stores. Now,
supporters say they're going to make food more affordable, but critics are warning they're going
to undermine the small, independent grocery stores and mom-and-pop businesses that have
been the cornerstone of New York City for generations. At the same time, though, Elon
Musk is now talking about what he calls a universal high income. And recently, while
standing beside Musk, President Trump basically appeared to throw his entire support behind the
idea. Now, on the surface, cheap groceries and a guaranteed income probably sound pretty good
to a lot of people. But we've seen versions of these ideas before, and history gives us plenty
of reasons to be very careful whenever the government promises to provide the basic
necessities of life. Because whoever provides those necessities ultimately has tremendous power
over the people who depend on them. My guest today is Joshua Phillip. He's a longtime investigative
reporter with The Epoch Times, host of Crossroads and The Joshua Phillip Show. And he's spent much
of his adult life studying communism and the systems of control that have emerged around the
world. And so Josh actually works in New York City, so he's watching what's happening there
up close. But he's also looking at the bigger picture. He's looking at artificial intelligence,
automation, guaranteed income, and an increasingly centralized technological system that he believes
could be pushing America towards something different from traditional communism,
technocracy. That's really the question at the heart of today's conversation. Are we watching
two separate political ideas emerge at the same time, or are they pieces of a much larger
transformation of America? It's a pretty important conversation that you don't want to miss.
Welcome to Man in America. I'm your host, Seth Holhouse. Before we jump in,
please hit that like button, the share button, and the subscribe button. It's free, it's easy,
and it helps me stay independent and continue to bring this content without having to put it behind
a paywall. So thank you. All right, now let's get into my conversation with Joshua Phillip.
Joshua Phillip, man, it is great to have you on the show. I've been following your work for a
long time with The Epoch Times, and thank you so much for coming on the show today. I'm looking
forward to talking with you. Yeah, so it's great being here, and great to finally do the show
also. I watch your stuff too sometimes. Thank you. Thank you. We've been trying to do a show
for some time now, but sometimes it just takes time and it just lands. I think that today's
topic, which we'll begin to, is a really interesting one, because I know that you're
working out of New York City. I also know that in addition to that, you've spent much of your
adult life studying communism, and not just what's happening over in China, but global communism,
all the different movements. So you're kind of in a unique petri dish of understanding and
seeing what a lot of communist-like principles are in real life, which is what we're seeing
under Mondami. So I guess you can start wherever you want to, but I'd like to see,
what are you seeing happening in New York City? Yeah, well, I'd say New York right now is kind
of putting in place communist light. I know a lot of people would say, well,
it's socialism, it's not communism. There's a lot of different definitions. I think we should
probably start by defining what these things are, because I don't think a lot of people could even
say, what is communism, what is socialism? You have a million different definitions,
and I think that's a good point to start on with that. So simply put, what is socialism?
Socialism is communism when practiced by government. That's the simplest answer.
Prior to the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917, socialism and communism were used interchangeably.
If you want to define it, socialism later became defined as the state capitalist monopoly.
Basically, when the government has achieved the stage of seizing the means of production.
A lot of people say that Lenin said socialism leads to communism, or socialism is
depro-communism. He didn't say that as a pull quote, but he did write a paper that explained
that. Shortly after the Bolshevik Revolution, Vladimir Lenin wrote a paper, I believe it was
called, How Can We Advance to Communism If We Fear the Stage of Socialism? It was kind of his
sleight of hand. He's like, okay, everyone, we're marching towards the communist utopia.
Then everyone's like, great, how about that utopia? Then he's like, surprise,
it's a state capitalist dictatorship. Basically, we say, okay, so state capitalism,
in essence, when the means of production, I think also in the distribution of goods and
the output of the production becomes centralized. When the government seizes control of who gets
how much this person needs, how much this person needs, how much this person produces,
in essence, as you're defining it. Here's the thing. There's no such
thing as a communist government. Communism exists through the negation of systems.
You cannot have a communist government. What you can have is a government run by a communist
ideology. That's what socialism is. You see, that's what socialism is.
If you want to understand what communism really is, the simplest answer is dialectical materialism,
which is identify, contradict, and eliminate the middle. Communism is more like a religion
that has become completely material, based in total materialism. It's more like a belief.
It's more like that than it is anything else. It's not an economic system. It's not
like a government system or anything like that. It's a belief.
Communism, the whole theory was based on Hegelianism, or at least this part of it.
Hegel, prior to Marx, wrote about what he called the negation of the negation.
Hegelianism was one of the big metaphysical theories in Germany at the time,
of Karl Marx. It was the main metaphysical theory going around at that time.
What he talked about was this theory of the negation of the negation. Basically,
through the destruction of an existing institution, a new one is born, or a more
evolved system is born. He talked about how through the negation of the egg, the chicken is
born, through the negation of the seed, the plant sprouts, through the negation of whatever
institution something exists in, something else is created. They took that and applied it to
everything. Marx took that and applied it to basically literally everything.
Communism requires the negation of all things. If you really want to break it down, what he
talked about was the negation of the God-made world. The theory is we've all existed in a
society that has been based on religion and morality, right? How do you create a system
whereby man's pure, unrefined human urge creates a system? You can only do that if you destroy
everything that the God-made world created. Culture, tradition, history,
governments, everything, right? It's almost like there's this idea that
this system that God, the divine, created, with all these things you mentioned, your culture,
the natural order that occurs, that someone might look at that and say,
yeah, that's a system full of restraint, and it's full of restraining our innate human nature.
So the only way to create something better is to negate or just destroy the old system,
to absolutely just bring the old system to ash and rubble, and then let the human nature-driven
system emerge from a phoenix rising from the flames. That's exactly what it is. They believe
you can only achieve that if you destroy not only everything, but even the memory of it,
right? And so if you look at what China did, they did that with the Cultural Revolution.
They had the campaign against the four olds, right? Old beliefs, old customs, old traditions,
you know, everything. Architecture, sculpture, people were digging up artifacts and destroying
everything. And then the new culture is communist culture. Mao's Mao Zedong thought became the basis
of everything. Now Xi Jinping thought it's the basis of everything. So that's what they do.
They've all done this to different degrees, actually. It's why communism persecutes religion,
basically. It's why communism kills and purges all the intellectuals, at least the ones who hold
traditional values. It's because they're trying to destroy those things. If you want to get into
the kind of origins of it, this is where it gets weird. So communism was actually originally more
of a religion. And I'm not the only one saying this. You know, Pope Pius XI, this was his big
thing. It's one of the reasons why communists used to be excommunicated from the Catholic Church,
for example. It's more of a religion. And in fact, even during the time of Karl Marx,
one of the big debates was whether they should be religious or atheistic. And the main competitor
with Marx to kind of dominate the communist ideology was what was called the communist church,
in fact. And if you read their writings, they were freaky. They literally talked about merging
God into Satan, like in their own writings, actually. If anyone wants to read that,
by the way, you can read it in the History of Austrian Economics volume two. But wild stuff.
If you or someone in your family is on Medicare or turning 65 soon, I really think you should
listen to this because most people don't find out their plan doesn't exactly fit when they pick it.
They find out later at the pharmacy counter. And that's the part that no one warns you about.
The bill shows up months after the decision did. So I've partnered with Chapter and these guys are
fantastic. One of the best in the business. Chapter's independent advisors are the only
Medicare advisors that compare every plan nationwide. They look at your doctors, your
prescriptions, what matters to you. Then they compare every plan against all of that to match
you with the best plan for your life. They're honest. They're not paid to steer you anywhere.
If you're already on the correct plan, they're going to tell you that. But if you're not,
they'll help you switch. It takes under 20 minutes to do. There's no promo code because
working with Chapter is always free. So don't wait. Go to askchapter.org slash man. Again,
that's askchapter.org slash man, as in man in America. Going deeper into this, if you want to,
I mean, we can talk about the old beliefs of communism for days, but if you want to really
break it down, there's effectively two different schools of thought. So communism basically comes
from Hegelianism and this whole rise of Gnosticism that was taking place 1700s, 1800s, if you want to
break it down. You could define also the global kind of paradigm between the American-led system
and the communist system and kind of the back between these, even between the differences
in the American Great Awakening and the European Enlightenment. So in Europe, you had this kind of
belief that new technologies were coming about, technology was advancing, and people said, well,
how does God fit in with this new world? How does God fit in with human advancement and so on?
And so they had the Enlightenment, right? And so I think some of it was good. You could even argue
that the American idea of the Republic was part of that, although I'd argue the Republic was going
back to like ancient Roman philosophy or so, or even ancient Greek, but more so the Roman model.
But in Europe, they moved away from God. In Europe, part of that movement led to the French
Revolution. They had the de-Christianization movement. They had the first government-run
institute of atheism, which was called the Cult of Reason. They killed Christians. They took over
the churches. I mean, everything. This is stuff no one talks about. And that's what the Enlightenment
looked like. Communism was born out of that movement. So what happened was you had Robespierre
and the Committee of Public Safety that ran the French Revolution. Within it, you had two
factions, the Giroudins and the Montagnards. The Montagnards killed the Giroudins, you know,
spoiler alert, and then created, of course, their system. Later on, you had a guy named
François-Noël Gracous-Babouf, who tried launching his own revolution after the French Revolution
failed. And he became kind of the, it failed, his movement also. But he was named kind of the first
revolutionary communist. The Marxist schools, those first came out of what was called the,
it was called the Society of Outlaws. Then they called themselves the Society of the Just.
That led into different debates, which formed the workers' organizations, which Marx and Engels
were later part of. And that's the long story short of communism. It has a direct lineage within
the French Revolution. The American side was different. You know, during the whole debate of
how does God fit in with the world, America was going with it for a bit, and then did a 180,
and America had the Great Awakening, right? We had revivals, we had religious revivals in America.
So America moved back to God, Europe moved further away from God. And that kind of
dialectical shift is what created, I think, the two different worldviews that we're living under
right now. We're really having more of a religious debate disguised as a political
debate right now. You know, and I think that's the real story of the world that we're living in.
And so, you know, with that history, then what is communism, right? Well, as they began moving
away from it, they started, you know, there was a lot of philosophers, and they were looking into,
well, what is society without God? What is morality without God? How can we create these
things without a religious foundation? And what they found, basically, is a couple things. Well,
the only way you can have social order without God is through what they call strong government,
meaning totalitarianism. If there's no internal morality, then morality needs to be entirely
external. It needs to be a totalitarian system that basically watches everything you do.
And that's what you get with that system. You know, it's actually interesting that when people
are able to govern themselves, they need less government. And that's also kind of the American
idea, right, was more person—and that's what the founding fathers talked about also—was that
people being able to have a moral code which holds them to a certain standard
basically makes totalitarian regimes unnecessary. And they believed, you know, with the American
system, that a strong system of law that, you know, just punishes wrongdoing if you're caught
doing it, but that also has faith in the ability of the individual to govern themselves, can create
a prosperous society. And this is basically what you have now. If you want to get into the crazy
beliefs which really formed communism, as they started abandoning the idea of God, many of them
started pulling up old Gnostic beliefs. At the time, you know, the Rosicrucians were having kind
of a revival. They're Luciferians, by the way. And I'm not just saying that, you know, they would
call themselves that. In fact, I've known Rosicrucians who call themselves Luciferians.
The Rosicrucians, 1700s, 1800s are coming out. They released different pamphlets saying they
were going to launch a revolution and they were going to overthrow kings, the kings and gods of
Europe, right? Which, you know, if you understand in Europe, of course, the Catholic Church was
basically part of the government, so you could argue based on that. But they were publishing
stuff saying this. And they published a lot of really weird, esoteric pamphlets, retelling
old stories, trying to rewrite history and morality. It was a lot of weird stuff happening
around that time. But when you get into the beliefs that form communism, it gets into the
kind of two different divergent theories over God and why evil exists. Why does evil exist?
So these are, as you highlighted, though, it's not just two political systems. These are very,
very fundamental, not even worldviews, but just almost like ideologies or understandings of where
we came from, why we exist. You bring in the Rosicrucians, I mean, a lot of the mystery schools,
like they've got some really strange stuff without digging into that, where, you know,
strange sciences, I think a lot of them, a lot of the old world sciences and knowledge get kind of
hidden within these mystery schools. So they're doing things that might go back a few thousand
years ago. And so there's just, yeah, there's some really strange stuff. But again, as you're
saying, what happens when you use government A versus government B? Like it's kind of,
you can't get into that without looking at what is the belief of mankind and where we came from,
and whether we came from God and our rights come from God, or whether we did not,
and our rights come from our own will, like, you know, do as thou wilt, right?
Yeah. Well, and on that point, I don't think many communists these days, like,
understand any of this stuff. You know, I think we're at a point now where the systems are just,
people pay attention to the surface practice of the system, but without understanding kind of
what the ideology actually is, right? I think for the most part, a lot of people who follow
these things, they're like, okay, totalitarianism, big corporations, I don't want to have to live
under some, you know, system that basically strangles me out with, you know, high costs
of living, and communism says, well, hey, everything's free over here, little buddy,
you know, come and get it. I would actually say, as would many economic philosophers during like
the early 1900s, like Ludwig von Mises, that actually what we're living under right now
is still a form of communism. A lot of the early thinkers were just as much deposed to,
you know, corporate monopoly as they were to government monopoly, and on that point too,
communism and socialism don't just exist through government. You have military communism, you have
even religious communism that even infiltrates different religions, for example. You know,
in Latin America, for example, you have like, you know, there's revolutionary theologies that
exist even within like the shell of like, you know, religions down there. You have, for example,
communism through unions, which is syndicalism, like there's all kinds of stuff. It's not as
black and white as people think it is, right? Even the systems we have right now is what would
be called a mixed model system. So we don't live under pure capitalism right now. And the irony is,
a lot of people who have problems with capitalism, most of what they criticize
are the state interventionist policies that come from socialism, right? The high taxation,
the restraints, you know, I'll give you one clear example. Why is rent so dang high? It's because
of red tape preventing new construction of homes. And if you have a finite resource and you
artificially increase competition through, say, like mass migration, but you don't build enough
new homes to compensate for it, you create more competition for a finite resource and the price
goes up. You know, it's like, this is like the most basic economics you can deal with. And then
there are a lot of people who do it intentionally because they want to make money. You know, you
have the politicians who own, you know, invest in real estate, and they're the ones opening the
floodgates. Like, what do you think is going on here? Or the financial institutions, for example,
the banks that have massive investments in, you know, real estate, even where they're buying up
all the single family homes, for example. And they're some of the biggest advocates for mass
migration and for red tape on new construction. So, you know, what do you think is going on here?
That's state interventionism. That's not free market capitalism.
Yeah. I feel like that, you know, in America, at least, it's almost like we live more in a
corporatocracy, right? Where it's not even really just like we had this government. The government
in many ways is just a pawn for the giant corporations, whether it's the massive pharmaceutical
companies, the oil and gas companies, the banks. I mean, it's almost like, you know, obviously,
you have lobbying and it's easy to say, oh, well, the lobbyists, they're spending all this money.
I think it's just so much deeper than that. Especially if you get into, you know, some of
the work of John Perkins, right? He wrote, you know, the Confessions of Economic Hitman. And
I've interviewed him before. Fascinating guy. I really like his work where he's talking about
these corporations that have their own private armies and that they're setting up these debt
based slavery deals with these second and third world countries where they know they're going to
go in, they're seizing resources, they're seizing military ports, they're seizing farmland, they're
seizing oil resources. And so, yeah, it's the idea that, you know, America is the land of the free
and the home of the brave and, oh, we're a constitutional republic and it's the will of
the people. I think the founding fathers, if they saw what the country has become,
and they're like, well, you guys are like paying 40% a year in taxes and no one's revolted and,
you know, taking your pitchforks to the local government office. It was like, well, no,
because the Super Bowl is on. We got to watch the Super Bowl instead, right?
Yeah. So technically, what we're living under is a mix of technocracy and syndicalism.
So technocracy, I love it. What's syndicalism?
Syndicalism is communism through the use of unions, basically, right? Or a syndicalist state
where, you know, big corporations are basically a form of the government, right? So a lot of the
big, and by the way, the technocrats was also kind of this view that corporations and, you know,
the advance of technology could create consolidations of power and whoever controls
that controls government, basically. You know, that was the whole technocratic movement,
which was also around all of this. But, you know, this is the problem when we try to debate
communism and capitalism. It's like, it's not so simple. You know what I mean? Like, it's not like
some simple free market versus closed market debate. Like, that's not really what it is, right?
Yeah. And I'm glad you mentioned technocracy because I've been really hammering on that
a lot lately. You know, with the data centers, the flop cameras, that's just like, that's just
the tip of the iceberg. But even in the past, you know, couple of days or recently, there was,
you know, I think someone was asking President Trump as a conference, you know, Musk was there
and they're asking Elon about universal basic income or what he says is universal high income.
And Trump is just kind of throwing a support behind it. And I'm thinking,
and you have all these people, I was just looking on Twitter, you have all these,
you know, very, very pro-Trump accounts saying, do you guys realize what this is doing? This is
amazing, universal high income for everybody, you don't have to work anymore. And I'm just thinking,
this does not seem like it's a good thing, right? This is bad. How long before universal basic
income becomes, you know, programmatic income based upon your social credit score, you know,
based upon your flock driving record, based upon your social media activity? I mean, I just,
maybe I'm too much of a conspiracy theorist or too much of a doomer, but I'm looking at this
thinking, this leads to a very bad place. And that's without even getting into Curtis Yarvin
and some of the, you know, the dark enlightenment and some of these other philosophies of the
technocrats, which have completely surrounded the current administration. So anyway,
maybe I'm going off on a little tangent there, but I think it's a pretty big deal right now.
So what's actually really interesting is that whole movement of a high tech kind of communist
society of universal basic income, you know, basic free services, and you know, what is man?
This is what Karl Marx actually wrote about as what communism would lead to.
Really?
And a lot of people have never read any of this because it's about halfway through Das Kapital,
you know what I mean? And Das Kapital is a big book, right? I think most people,
when they understand Marxism, they understand the Communist Manifesto because it's a quick read. And
frankly, I think a lot of communists are not big readers, you know what I mean?
But if you read Das Kapital, and I don't recommend it, by the way, the first half,
Karl Marx basically just lays out, you know, the problems of the economic systems and so on,
and, you know, destroy everything. And he's going against the factories and going against
all this. The second half, he's praising all of it, like he does a reverse course.
And he's talking about, you know, technology and all this stuff. And he proposes this idea
of what communism will lead to, which is basically a high tech society where people don't have to
work and robots do our work for us effectively. And, you know, we can all be poets and musicians
or wherever else. And, you know, hey, we don't have to do anything now, like the machines do
the work for us. Like, we're heading towards that. I think we're in a weird state now, though,
where AI is even replacing the creative jobs. It's hard to be a poet or a writer or a musician
because AI is taking up the creative jobs. Like, I think we're going to end up with a really weird
state soon where there's going to be a real question of what it means to even live. Like,
what is the purpose of life if everything that defined who we are as people is taken over by
something else? Do we just exist to indulge in entertainment? Do we just exist to sit around
playing video games all day? Is that a good life? I think if you look at SSRIs and depressants and
everything like that, people are miserable these days. And so what is the purpose of life? We're
heading in that direction really quickly. Yeah, I agree. I agree. And that's the thing, too, is
that what value do humans even give society? Because you could argue that for now, if the
leaders or the rulers need countries to have power, they want to have high levels of consumer
spending, they want to have money moving through, they want to have a workforce, they want to have
all these things to populate an army to drive the economy. But if the army is now robotics,
right, which is also, you look at Elon Musk and how he talks about his robot, and he refers to
them as legions, which is a very strange term considering legions were the groups of, if I
believe that correctly, the Roman soldiers, right? These are war terms, a legion. And he talks about
unveiling these and you think, okay, well, maybe they won't need us for the military because they
can have either drones or robotic foot soldiers. They won't need us for a lot of the production,
you know, factory workers, etc. Even a lot of restaurants you go to now, you might place an
order at the drive-thru at fast food, and it's just an AI. It's not a real person behind there,
right? Then, you know, food delivery, all that. But then you're right, though, then
creative skills. You know, you'll see stuff, you're seeing movies going around Twitter that
some dude made in his basement that would have cost Hollywood $30 million to make a five-minute
clip. And so you get to the point, like, okay, well, then what role do humans need? And if you
look at a lot of the people that have a lot of power and their ties in, their family history
is into eugenics and depopulation, I think it's naive to think that they're trying to create some
sort of utopia where we all have unlimited money because the robots are working for us and we can
just, you know, sit around and drink, eat grapes and drink wine all day. I think that if more than
anything, we almost become disposable. And that's not good. Well, and there's a question, too,
of what defines the value of human life at that point, right? You know, is it necessary? What is
the value of people? If you eliminate value, then, you know, it's actually interesting. I was reading,
funny enough, I was reading Starship Troopers by Heinlein. And the book is way different than the
movie, by the way. The book is actually more philosophy. He talks about the difference between
the bugs and the humans. And if you read it, actually, he defines the bugs as being the perfect
communists. They live in a perfect communist society. And he defines the humans as being a
place where a lot of value is placed on the individual. And he describes how they can kill
a thousand bugs, but if they lose one human, it's a great, it's a loss, basically, because
the bugs don't value the lives of their own, whereas people do. When you don't create,
when you don't place value on individuals, then why care about preserving their life?
You know, and I think you see this in China. You see this in the way that communists fight wars,
where the Soviet Union was even using human wave tactics, where they just threw bodies
at the Germans, you know? You have a machine gun nest, and they just throw people at it until they
run out of ammo. And then that's how they fight. Like, how can you care so little about human life,
right? The same thing with the Chinese.
Organ harvesting is probably the greatest example of that, where you're treating
a human body the same way you would treat a stalk of corn.
Yeah, well, and then at that point, too, the people who then create value,
why should they see value in the lives of others, if we get to that point, right?
Whereas individualism, you can appreciate what makes an individual valuable because
they do different things. You know, we produce different things. We have different skills and
different talents. A lot of us are really defined in terms of value by what we're good at.
Really. And if alongside that, you destroy morality, and if alongside that, you destroy
tradition, and you destroy the systems that establish the idea of what's right and wrong,
which is mostly about whether it's okay to hurt or take from people,
that's a scary place to be in, actually.
No, it really is. And so, it's funny because we started off talking about Mandami and New York,
and now we've gotten into a deep philosophical discussion about communism and technocracy.
And so, you know, I guess, you're looking at, I guess, you're pulling in the whole New York
situation through just a little bit of a lens to kind of, as an example, and applying it to
some of these larger topics. You know, when you see these things, like what they're doing, you
know, I lived in New York City for a decade, and you know that the bodegas are the heart of the
city, right? The people that run these things, or even the taxi drivers. There's all this economy
that's built around, you know, hardworking people that give a service. And so, you know, what happens
to a city like this when you bring in government and taxpayer-subsidized grocery stores where
they're undercutting the costs? I mean, even, you know, some of the really nice kind of grocery
stores I used to go to, I think it was the Garden of Eden in Union Square, and there's all these
really nice little grocery stores there. What happens to them when the government takes over?
But then it's also, historically looking at things, it's like what starts as the government
coming in and giving something for cheaper, once all the competition's gone, why would the government
need to actually keep their prices down low, right? Because then they could just do whatever
they wanted to. So what do you see playing out in some of these examples, kind of real-world
examples there? I see playing out exactly what every communist government or socialist government
that tried this before experienced. People talk about the Soviet breadlines. It wasn't just the
Soviets who tried this, it was most of them. Even the Nazis, you know, they were national,
they were socialists, you know, National Socialism. And people talk about them on the race level, but
no one talks about their actual political policies. They did similar things. They had
mandates on milk and stuff like that that led to basically the exact same problems.
Effectively, when you have the government create an artificial subsidy of an industry on a blanket
level, not based on what people actually consume and desire, because in normal terms, availability,
production, it's all directed by what people want, right? It's what people buy.
If people want more of one thing, people are going to be incentivized to create more of it.
And that's the way that the free market directs availability, right? And also sets prices when
you have actual competition, because people compete on not only production, but many economists note,
also based on quality and price, right? That's how the free market works.
State interventionism was you put your finger on the scale, right? You force one side to succeed.
But when you force one side to succeed, by virtue of that, you force others to fail.
And so it always causes that. So this is my prediction on New York.
Bandami is going to experience, you know, with doing this, the same thing that happened to every
other country that tried it. So they're going to create these state run, right, or government run,
I guess, I guess, New York City, so city run, I guess you could say, grocery stores.
What's going to happen? Well, the only benefit of having this is lower prices. If they cannot
create lower prices, there's not going to be a purpose. People are going to go somewhere else.
They're going to go to the bodegas, or they're going to go to Whole Foods, or they're going to
go somewhere else, because the only reason you'd want to shop there is for lower prices. Otherwise,
what is the purpose, right? What is the purpose? So they're going to do lower prices.
When you do lower prices, you're going to immediately force all your competitors to also
lower their prices. And so you're going to watch some people getting fired. You're probably going
to watch the big stores, like Whole Foods or wherever else, try to keep up, and you're going
probably see more automation. You might see them replace some of the checkout people with
self-checkout kiosks, right? You might see more of that taking place, right?
The bodegas will likely go out of business. And already they see this coming, because they're
already suing the city, in fact. They're already trying to sue over this, because their profit
margins are very thin. They don't make a lot of money. So the bodegas, most of them probably go
out of business. The big grocery stores will then compete with the government ones. And then
you're going to have a demand for more locations, because how do bodegas exist? People buy from
them. So when people stop buying from them, they have to go somewhere else. You're going to see
more foot traffic then to the corporate stores and the government stores. What does that mean
for the government stores? For the government stores, that means it's going to be breadlines,
basically, because people are going to be going for finite resources. You're going to have some
goods that are more in demand than others. And the way communism works is we direct what needs
to be sold, not what people want to buy. So we believe people need vegetables. We believe people
need this or that. People might not buy it, but when you mandate it from the top and you're not
listening to free market capitalism and what people actually buy, you're going to have stuff going bad.
And you're going to have fewer or less of what people actually want. So there's going to be
demand for finite products. What's very likely going to happen then is you're going to have
scalpers go in, and they're already trying to solve this and they can't. They can't find a
solution to it. You're going to have scalpers go in, and they're going to buy all the things people
want. And they're going to grab as much as they can, and they're going to empty the store shelves,
and they're going to go outside and sell it on the street corner or sell it across state lines,
like they do with cigarettes and stuff like that, because they get around the taxes.
So you're going to watch markets spreading, probably outside of Manhattan, probably into
New Jersey, probably upstate outside the city, maybe even into Connecticut. You're going to
watch that take place if the prices are low enough to justify it. New York also, because good old
communism, they also legalized, because they don't go after real criminals these days,
they also legalized where you can go outside of a shop and just put a little booth there and start
selling, like street side markets, which don't have to be taxed. So you're going to have people
doing that outside the stores and all over the place. I think very likely you're going to start
seeing that the bodegas are out of business. The whole food stuff will probably, I don't think
they'll be able to do this either. And the government stuff is going to have lines and
shortages and scalpers. And that's going to be the reality of it, because this is what happens
every time. I think what happens is that when you get down to these finite resources where
you're going to get your bread, your eggs, I imagine they'll put restrictions on meat,
right? That's part of the overall agenda. You have to limit your meat or you get your
cricket milk instead of regular milk or whatever it is that they're doing. That cockroach milk.
There you go. You have plenty of those in New York City. You can milk them if you have them.
But then I can imagine though that for a lot of people in New York City, again,
we're living there for so long, there is a very large class of people that are on poverty line,
right? That you go into the projects, you go into Alphabet City. There's a lot of areas where
people are literally living meal to meal, paycheck to paycheck. And so then what happens when
there's some sort of disruption and all of a sudden there's no bread or eggs,
right? Because say there's some sort of new bird flu threat and everyone's burning down
all the eggplants and who knows what. I think that could easily spill over into obviously
obvious black market stuff, but then more violence. You might have gangs emerging,
running black market distribution of eggs. And this is all things that happened in communist
countries. Though often as the party officials were involved in it, they've got their own side
gig going on. They're making money off of their black market products. But you could see how this
could destabilize and spiral into something where you've got large scale food riots.
Yes. A couple of things. So first off on the affordability thing, it's not even just people
below poverty line living in poverty. In fact, I think in New York because of welfare and everything
else, poverty is kind of like middle class. I went to the bank the other day, Bank of America,
and I was talking to the guy at the bank. He told me he has three housemates. You can be a banker,
although lower end banker, and you can't even afford an apartment. That's what New York looks
like. It's really hard to get by. And so your mid-level guy because of taxes is living almost
the same as a low income person here because of the way the taxes and redistribution works.
And then if they incentivize the people who make a lot of money to just leave,
like with wealth taxes like they're doing in California, then yeah, you're going to
implode the whole system. On the part of the gangs, you'll probably see that too.
So there's a couple of ways this is going to go, I think. I'll give you a couple of examples,
when I was investigating Chinese organized crime and Chinese spy networks, a lot of my
early work as a reporter was investigating those things, especially in New York. A lot of their
business is illegal, but a lot of it is also gray market, like semi-legal or illegal, but not super
illegal. So one of the big things is counterfeit cigarettes, and they sell counterfeit cigarettes.
Why? Because of New York state cigarette taxes. So there's a huge market of going out of state,
buying cigarettes, and then just shipping them into the city and selling them a little bit cheaper
than what they cost here. And that's one of the big black markets in New York is things just built
around selling a little bit cheaper. You see the same thing with scalpers. If anybody tries to
go see a football game or a baseball game, I know like Pokemon playing cards are one of the big
things of this, where the scalpers go in and fight over boxes of it. There was a big thing at
Costco recently. Go and just buy everything and then go on the corner and sell it.
Your little five-year-old kid can't buy his Pokemon card because the 40-year-old man bought
all the goods, and he's selling it at like a 200% markup. So you're going to have those scalpers
competing with gangs. And so you might see territory wars. You might see people getting
threatened. You already have this within some of these markets.
Do you ever watch The Office? I never did, actually.
Anyway, there was a part where one of the characters bought all the popular Barbie
dolls for Christmas and was then selling them for quadruple the markup on them because he
kind of cornered the market on these. Anyway, it was a good one. If you could go back in time
and buy oil before the world relied on it, would you? Of course you would. Anyone would.
So why aren't you buying silver right now? You see, the people who recognized oil early didn't
just make money. They got ahead of one of the biggest economic shifts in history.
And today, a similar opportunity is unfolding with silver because silver is a lot more than
just a precious metal. It's a critical resource used in solar panels, electric vehicles, defense
systems, AI infrastructure, and even these massive data centers that are powering our digital world
and the surveillance grid. So while demand keeps growing, it's actually still affordable
enough that the average American can start accumulating it right now. And that's why
investors are turning to silver to protect against inflation and own one of the world's
most important strategic resources. Don't be the person who looks back in 10 years and says,
I saw it coming, but I just didn't act. I'm sorry. So visit goldwithseth.com and learn just how easy
it is to own physical silver. Again, that's goldwithseth.com. And here's something a little
extra. If you just mention my name, when you reach out to Noble Gold, they're going to send you a
one-tenth ounce of gold coin just as a thank you when you open a new qualified account. So again,
that's goldwithseth.com. I'm taking a step back because obviously we see these things
happening in New York City. And that's, I think, a good, I guess, a petri dish, right? Watching
what happens when this is kind of growing and just observing it. But when you step outside,
as we talked about earlier, and you look at just the country as a whole, and you're seeing the
government involvement in investing in AI companies, investing in technology companies,
where the government's actually owning a share of these things. But then you look at, again,
what we talked about with technocracy and the ideas of universal basic income and UHI, right,
et cetera. I mean, for people that are, I think for a lot of people in America, I think for one,
there's a very large population of Americans that have completely lost faith in the political
system. And they're just like, we're screwed either way, basically. They kind of see it as
a uniparty. But then beyond that, they're also watching the data centers, the flock cameras,
and not just those, the new vehicles now coming with all the AI kind of surveillance tools built
into the vehicles. You're seeing this kind of very rapid kind of accelerationism of this
technocracy, this technical grid, not to mention the really, starting with Doge, the integration
of these big military industrial complex technology companies that are integrating
fully into our own government, Palantir, a lot of these other larger companies like that.
So, obviously, you could see where that could take us down into a path where Terminator looks
more like a documentary and not a fiction film. So, what do we do? It's important to kind of
get to this in general. You know, for the average American that sees the writing on the wall
and sees what's happening in New York City, but also sees what's happening in their own regions,
where should people channel their energy into? What do you recommend people do about this?
My own thought is this. I think on an individual level, we don't have to live like that. I'm not
saying burn your cell phone and throw your TV out the window or whatever else like that. But I think
that develop hobbies. Don't abandon your faith. Keep your religion. Find hobbies. Get involved in
some kind of creative thing because you might not be able to make money with it in the future.
For example, I like to play music. I have quite a lot of hobbies. Photography. I play Warhammer,
tabletop stuff, random stuff like this. Find the communities. Do things like this.
Because the reality is I think the outer world does have all these kind of encroaching
systems. As you mentioned, smart cities, AI integration, wars, the negation of what it even
is to be human. What it's going to negate is the ability to make money on a lot of these things,
which sucks. But it doesn't mean you can't do it still. It doesn't mean you can't be an artist.
It doesn't mean you can't paint. It doesn't mean you can't be a sculptor. It doesn't mean
you can't write music and play music. It doesn't mean you can't live a normal life.
All the things of the 90s that all of us grew up loving, they're still there.
You can still have them. But I think maybe we just need to change our relationship with them
in some extent. At the same time too, I do think on a political level, I don't want to have mass
surveillance. I don't like the fact that basically private businesses can do things that are
unconstitutional because they're not government, like mass data gathering and predatory terms of
service agreements and everything else, and then government just buys the data from them.
I think we should advocate for a stop on these things. We're like government workarounds to
violate our rights is not allowed. I think we should require that. But I do think when it comes
down to it, the choice on whether you abandon tradition and religion is yours. I think as long
as you keep these two things, nothing can take it from you really. I think maybe that's also
a big part of the solution. Just stay human. Hold on to your humanity. Even if it means moving
out of the city, which is where I'm at. I'm in upstate New York now, coming from living in a
high rise in New York City for a lot of my adult life. Now it's like, okay, things are kind of
crappy, but we're surrounded by nature. We've got animals, we've got chickens that produce our food,
we've got vegetable gardens, we've got guns, which you can't have in New York City. I tried at one
point trying to legally go through that process. It was a nightmare. I had to pay some guy like
$9,000 and I ended up not doing it to get me a handgun permit because I was working in the
jewelry industry at the time. I could have maybe got it. It was such a nightmare. But it's also
I think making some of those decisions of getting back closer to the land. But you also mentioned
community. I think that's also important is just building stronger communities is a big one.
Doing real things with other people, having families over for meals and working together.
I think that those are the things that are important. I think they'll become increasingly
more important too as our humanity becomes more of a target for this system, this encroaching
system, that it's kind of like the most rebellious thing you can do is just to be a human being.
Fully agreed. Because it can't take that from you. It may make it a little more,
it doesn't even make it more difficult. I think in some ways what's being removed is maybe the
profit margin, right? And so do we just do these things for money? Do we just create poetry and
music for money? Do we just paint and draw for money? Maybe we need to rethink why we do what
we do, right? Yeah, that's a good point. Well, Josh, it's been great talking to you. I know that
you're obviously a prolific reporter and you have a lot of stuff with the Epoch Times. So
where can people find you? What are you doing with your show right now? Where can people tune
into what you're doing? Thank you. So, I mean, I have the show Crossroads on YouTube twice a week,
but I have a new show that I'm trying to kind of just start right now called The Josh Phillips
Show. Check that out on YouTube. It's my in-depth reporting app. Let me pull it up real quick. So
The Josh Phillips Show. And Philip with two L's and one P, right? One L, two P's, no S.
Always spelled wrong. Oh, yeah, you're right. I have a weird spelling. Yeah.
I always reverse it. Okay, here we go. Oh, great. Okay. Yeah, here we go. Awesome.
There we go. So yeah. So right now, go subscribe Josh Phillips Show over on YouTube. And so this
is more of your just kind of solo, your kind of investigative reporting. What are they going to
find here? Yeah, so I do that with Epic Times still, but I mean, I have almost total autonomy
for the most part. It's in-depth reporting, it's philosophy, it's everything. It's kind of what
defines my work. So I go into news, I go into ideology, I go into tradition, I go into everything
on that. I think kind of, honestly, kind of the way I normally talk, kind of maybe how this
interview today went, that's kind of my general tone. And so people could find it there. Oh, this
is great. I didn't know about this. This is really good. It seems like, I mean, in your own way,
you're doing something similar to kind of what I'm trying to do here is just to have just a show
about just having real conversations and looking at what's happening. I see even like right here,
loneliness is the beginning, isn't it? And it's the beginning. Like, I want to go watch that.
That seems really good, actually. So, well, good, man. Well, this is great.
Yeah, it's been great. I've been wanting to interview you for quite a long time. You've
done such good work with the Epoch Times. I appreciate all that you've done, especially
a lot of your early reporting on China. It was really helpful. I followed a lot of your stuff
very closely. And so thank you for doing what you're doing, and I hope to have you back on.
Yeah, it'd be my pleasure. And yeah, glad to be here too. Hit me up anytime, man.
Okay, great, man. Thank you. Thank you.
Did you know that in the last few centuries, over half a million bells have been destroyed?
There were literally bell graveyards. Now, the textbooks tell us that this was to use the metal,
but if you've ever gone down this rabbit hole, you discover that the sounds that these bells made had
amazing healing properties. There are even claims that certain regions with lots of these bells,
church bells, et cetera, were mostly untouched by the bubonic plague. Now, your doctor might
call you a conspiracy nut for thinking that, but even modern science recognizing the healing power
of sound. So check out this study from the NIH. Doctors used sound therapy on chronic back pain,
and they found, quote, significant reductions in pain sensation and pain-related disability.
But here's the best part. You don't need some fancy, expensive sound equipment to find relief.
So a woman named Linda Bamber Olson created something called the WaveWatch.
So this little device has over 1,200 frequencies that you can use for everything from joint pain
to brain fog to insomnia. So I've got one, and I've been using it for about six months. This
is it right here. And I can tell you honestly that it works. If I'm feeling sickly or have
something coming on, it's the first thing I'll reach for. And honestly, I start feeling better
within minutes. And that's literally my firsthand experience with it. Even my little kids love
wearing it. And here's how much Linda believes in this watch. So if you get one and you don't
notice any improvements, you can send it back for a full refund within 30 days. No questions asked.
So do something for yourself and for your family and get a WaveWatch for yourself today. Just go
to wavewatch.com slash Seth, or just use the promo code Seth to save 15% on your purchase.
Again, that's wavewatch.com slash Seth, or just use promo code Seth to save 15%
on your purchase. And those details are in the description below.