CLARIFICATION: (The common pleco is a substantial problem in Florida, unlike most fish that escape and do not cause any problems.)
The Lacey Act amendment, one of 600 in the COMPETES bill currently before the Senate, restricts the importation and interstate transport of ALL animals except specific items on a list to be determined by the Secretary of the Interior. The purpose of this? To end the possibility of invasive species and solve the problem once and for all. Amendments to the Lacy Act will end the importation of new and rare fish into the hobby as well as most fish we have become accustomed to having. That much we know with certainty. The thousands of serious, skilled hobbyists who maintain inventories of these fish will no longer be able to acquire or trade their fish. This will destroy a wealth of knowledge and expertise that is protecting rare and endangered species. The areas where these fish are collected will be abandoned to the loggers and miners. Thousands of species will be lost forever. This is the real legacy of those who want to control destructive invasive species by banning nearly everything.
LIVE STREAM TIMES: Sunday 6:00PM est Friday 8:30PM est See you there.
24/7 live on Discord: This is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need. Join us at Father Fish Server on DISCORD - https://discord.gg/8DmmRE9Nq4
The Lacey Act. The Lacey Act has seen a lot of serious animal hobbyists, collectors, and supporters
imprisoned and fined massive amounts of money and many years in jail. The Lacey Act is easily
the most aggressive law on the federal books. For first offenses it recommends fines of $25,000
per offense. If you have a hundred fish that are illegal, that's a hundred offenses.
And $25,000 in fines and five years in prison per offense. What is being recommended
in the bill before the Senate, approved by the House of Representatives, are a series of
amendments to the Lacey Act. Up to this point, the Lacey Act has maintained a list of forbidden
species. With this new legislation, that will no longer be true. There will no longer be a list
of dangerous and restricted species. Instead, there will be a list of approved species.
The recommendation in the legislation is that those items that are most popular and most
widely distributed will comprise the initial list in the white list of approved items.
Every other animal will be banned and forbidden to be either imported into the U.S.
or allowed to cross state lines. This includes not only imported items from other countries,
it includes domestic items as well. A little fish in a creek back behind your home
cannot be collected and sent or carried to someone out of state. That will be a violation.
Unless, of course, it's on the list. There is little to no chance that such items as their
local fauna, their local animal life, will be included on that list. So, what's the real issue
here? There are currently 10,000 tropical fish that are marketed here in this country. That is
10,000 different species that are marketed here in this country. What happens to those fish?
There is a body of collectors, fish keepers, who are themselves very serious and very
skilled husbandrymen. That is, people who care for animals.
Enough of these people exist in our country to be able to maintain all or virtually all
of those 10,000 fish. I have had the good fortune through my life to know many such people
and have been able to visit their fish rooms and see what they are able to do. It is remarkable.
There is an inventory of 10,000 tropical fish species here in this country,
sufficient to replenish stocks in the wild should they become endangered or extinct.
Indeed, that is happening. Species are being reintroduced routinely by hobbyists,
serious hobbyists, who take it upon themselves to collect, sustain, to breed, to support
species, especially those that are at risk of being endangered. Some 10,000 such hobbyists
exist here in this country. There may be more. There certainly are not fewer. It depends in
some part on how you define that. I'm looking at those people with large fish rooms,
substantial numbers of tanks, who have been maintaining species of fish
for at least 25 years, some 10,000 of those. Now, I don't know every one of them by name,
but I know there are clubs around the country. There are organizations, local and national,
to which these hobbyists subscribe and participate. So the numbers are real.
What will happen to them when this bill is approved and becomes law? First of all,
they will no longer be able to share their fish, their animals, with others outside their own
state, nor will they be able to use their stock to replenish endangered stock. It will be a federal
crime to cross state lines with any of these animals unless, of course, they're on the white
list. What about this white list? Well, we don't know a whole lot about it yet.
The scuttlebutt coming out of the bureaucracy is that there will be 1,500 animals of all types
on the list. When you consider that there are more than 20,000 animals currently being traded
within the industry, that's a tiny fraction, a very tiny fraction. What about the rest?
In Australia, when they implemented this law, they requested all hobbyists who had animals
that were not on the approved list turn them in to be destroyed. The hobbyists rose up against this
and refused to do so. And because it was not specifically written into the law,
but was simply a request, the request was abandoned. Nor is it written into the law here,
at least not yet. But rest assured, if this passes, the Secretary of the Department
of the Interior will be coming after your fish. You may win that battle, but we will all have
lost the war. And what is the war? It is a struggle to sustain, to maintain large numbers
of species, in our case of tropical fish from around the world. They're new species being
collected all the time. Species that exist in areas that no one has collected in before.
These hobbyists who I described are anxious to get these new species, to maintain them,
to learn how to breed them, and to be able to sustain stock and inventory. So virtually every
known fish of an ornamental type, that is something small enough to live in an aquarium,
is currently in private hands. Being sustained, being nurtured, being bred,
stocks are being improved, quantities are growing, and local collectors and local environments
are being supported by these hobbyists who are spending money, substantial amounts of money,
to purchase these new unusual animals. That money goes back to the local collector,
not all of it. There's a chain, a supply chain, but it gets back to the local collector. He makes
money from the items he collects. Now who is he? Who is this local collector? They're called
Piavas in South America, in Brazil, Peru. They are natives, aboriginal people, living in what
we refer to as the jungle, way out on the Amazon and its tributaries, who are maintaining a very
meager lifestyle for themselves and their families. This is greatly enhanced by their
ability to collect local fish and sell them through the trade. By so doing, the environments
that they are living in are protected, protected by them, and protected by the economic interests
of those who care about the animals living in those environments. There are many,
many such places around the world that are currently being protected and supported
by people who collect and love and cherish and care for tropical fish.
What happens when they no longer can be sold, when a new species may not enter the country?
What happens? The collectors can't collect anymore. They can't make any money out,
so they're not going to, and their lifestyle becomes so problematic.
This has happened again and again and again. They move into a city, an urban center,
where there's a chance of getting a job and supporting their families.
So what happens to the land they've abandoned, their ancestral grounds? Well, there are many
interests who are looking to get access to these properties. Loggers and miners are chief among
them. They are the destroyers of the earth. When they move in, animal life moves out or dies in
the process. There are farmers looking to clear-cut this land and create vast swaths
of monoculture. There are cattlemen, certainly the least obtrusive and the least destructive,
but they nevertheless break down the areas that are currently being protected
and supported by this industry. So that's the long and the short of it.
This bill does nothing to protect anything. It simply is a matter of brandstanding the whole
issue of invasive species, as though every animal that comes in, every fish that's brought in,
is a potential danger. That is, of course, aberrant nonsense. Down here in Florida,
there are a few species of fish that have been able to establish themselves in niches,
with rare exception, the Plecostomus being one. These aren't surely invasive,
but they are not threatening any other species, nor are they in any way changing
the local environment. They maintain themselves because they have found an available niche
where there was nothing else. They've moved in, set up housekeeping, and they're doing just fine.
Thank you very much. They're friendly with their neighbors. They get along well with everyone,
and we welcome them. Funny how we can welcome anyone who wants to cross our southern border,
but we dare not allow a little fish to swim in our creeks. Funny.
Well, I've rambled on about this long enough, and I guess I've told the story I wanted to tell.
This is dangerous. It will destroy our hobby. It will especially destroy the ambitions
and the efforts of the many, many, many serious aquarists who are seeking to sustain, to maintain,
and to support aquatic life, little tiny fish from all over the world. It must be stopped.
It can be stopped. We must all do our part to make it stop. This is not a good thing.
This is a very, very bad thing. Thank you for listening. This is Father Fish. Love you all.
Bye for now.