The Justice Department is seeking to revoke the U.S. citizenship of 40 naturalized Americans. Among them is a former Navy sailor accused of selling U.S. military secrets to China for $12,000.
A Chinese American woman has been arrested by the FBI on charges of spying for China and surveilling the son of Taiwan’s president. Senior Intelligence Officer Nicholas Eftimiades provides analysis.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s visit to Iceland highlights the growing U.S. focus on the Arctic as competition with China intensifies.
Germany has detained a former intelligence chief on suspicion of attempting to betray his country by working for a foreign government. The case is being described as one of Germany’s biggest intelligence scandals since the Cold War. Russia is not involved.
00:00 Intro 00:59 DOJ to Strip Citizenship From 40 Criminals 02:39 Chinese Woman Arrested for Spying on Taiwan President’s Son 07:26 U.S. Bolsters Arctic Outpost Against Chinese Activity 09:28 Former German Spy Chief Arrested for Attempted Treason 10:21 Bolsonaro, Lula Da Silva Move to Presidential Runoff 16:15 U.S. Investigates Chinese Woman Arrested at LAX
Welcome to China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. Our top story, the Justice Department is seeking to
strip 40 naturalized Americans of their citizenship. Among them, a former Navy sailor
who sold U.S. military secrets to China for $12,000. The FBI arrests a Chinese-American woman
accused of spying for China and surveilling the son of Taiwan's president. Senior intelligence
Rubio's Iceland visit highlights growing U.S. focus on the Arctic as competition with China
intensifies. They call it one of the biggest intelligence scandals since the Cold War.
Germany detained a former spy chief on suspicion of trying to betray his country
by working for a foreign government. Russia is not involved.
The largest denaturalization effort in modern U.S. history. The Justice Department is seeking
to strip 40 naturalized Americans of their citizenship. Among them, a former Navy sailor
sentenced for spying for China, plus a former Verizon engineer who pleaded guilty to collecting
intelligence on Chinese dissidents for Beijing. The others have been convicted of various crimes,
including voluntary manslaughter, money laundering, child sexual abuses, among others.
The former Navy sailor Jing Chaowei sold U.S. military secrets to Chinese intelligence officers
for $12,000. He had been sentenced to over 16 years in prison. Jing was a mechanist's mate on
an amphibious assault ship at San Diego Naval Base. Amphibious assault ships resemble small
aircraft carriers and allow the U.S. military to project power. He leaked sensitive details
about the ship's weapons and capabilities to the Chinese officer. He also sold around 60 manuals
about U.S. Navy ships to the Chinese officer. The manuals contain details on the operation
of multiple systems aboard the warship. Jing's mother had encouraged him to work for China,
telling him it could help him land a job with Chinese authorities someday.
Li Ping, a former Verizon engineer, has been sentenced to four years in prison. That's for
helping Beijing collect intelligence on Chinese dissidents and followers of the spiritual
meditation practice Falun Gong. Most of the people among the group of which the DOJ seeks
to strip citizenship are from Mexico, China, and Pakistan. Others hail from Egypt, Nigeria,
and the Philippines. The FBI arresting a Chinese-American woman from California at
Los Angeles International Airport, accusing her of spying for China. Huang Yin-chang,
also known as Heather, was taken into custody Sunday by agents as she was departing for China.
Federal authorities allege she surveilled the son of Taiwan's president,
sending photos, video, and license plate information to Chinese officials.
For more insight, I spoke on Monday on 50 Mile Tonight with Nicholas Eptimiadis.
His government career includes employment in the CIA, State Department, Bureau of Diplomatic
Security, and the Defense Intelligence Agency, where he served as a senior intelligence officer.
He's also the author of Chinese Espionage Operations and Tactics.
I think this was intelligence gathering. I think this was collection. I think this was
the potential to get something that might be usable against the individual down the road,
whether it be collecting on finances, which I'm sure they did on the side as well,
and family data. So it's part of an overall collection campaign targeting
Taiwan's presidency, actually.
In today's press release, an FBI official said,
quote, Huang Yin-chang's arrest for allegedly acting as an unregistered agent of the Chinese
government makes clear how far China's authoritarian regime will go to advance its goals.
For viewers learning about China's transnational repression for the first time,
how far is the CCP willing to go to achieve its goals?
Well, to be frank, we've never seen anything like this in modern history. I mean, even Russia
in its most powerful days in the Soviet Union didn't go after people abroad the way China does.
China has gone after tens of thousands of people overseas, blackmailing family members at home,
acting financially against them, all to try and extend Beijing's or the CCP's,
let's call it repression, globally. So it really is quite an extraordinary effort involving
hundreds of thousands of people globally.
And on that note, zooming out a bit here, is this just the tip of the
iceberg, or do you expect more arrests tied to China's transnational repression network
in the near future?
These types of actions are pretty pervasive. We've seen in Arcadia, California, Aileen Wang,
who recently arrested Mike's son before her, John Chen before him, Wang Shijun in New York.
So these cases are absolutely massive in numbers, and that's what makes it so difficult
for law enforcement to contend with it. I mean, the United States has more resources than anyone
to throw at this problem, and they still are nowhere near being able to slow it down significantly.
And digging into that, talk to us about how difficult is it for federal investigators to
uncover an operation like this?
The FBI has worked here for over a year. So that's fine. You can work one case and you're
going to make one arrest in this case, and working agents, which includes surveillance,
which includes wiretaps, which includes subpoenas and forensics on telephones and all those things
that has to happen to make this case happen. And what do you do when there are thousands
of people like this? And that's literally what they're facing.
We've also seen the MI5 and other spy agencies coming out talking about the threats,
the multi-pronged threat from the CCP. FBI Director Kash Patel posted photos of federal
agents arresting Deng at the airport, writing, quote, foreign adversaries take note. America
is not your playground under President Trump's leadership. This FBI is hunting national security
threats wherever they hide and putting them in cuffs. What kind of threat do these operations
pose to U.S. national security and sovereignty?
Well, it certainly poses a threat to both. I mean, on the sovereignty issue,
we've seen in Eric Swalwell and Fang Fang and Aileen Wong and a number of cases where the
CCP has tried to infiltrate American political figures at lower levels with the understanding
and expectation that they would grow into positions that they would be powerful in the
United States and can influence U.S. policy. So this is very long term, very calculated,
integrated not only with recruiting individuals, but also with information operations, with the
applications of AI. We're starting to see tremendous use of artificial intelligence
to manipulate public opinion and isolate senior officials. And China's actually produced,
Chinese universities have produced papers on that. So we're starting to see this grow as a
massive overall strategy to do, which clearly affects American sovereignty. I mean, it is
literally attacking a political system in a way that we're not used to defending.
In his visit to Iceland, Secretary Rubio called the Northern Ireland a critical outpost for
watching clandestine behavior as Washington watches growing Chinese activity in the region.
Since the Second World War, Iceland has allowed the U.S. military to project power
and collectively working together, using your land, your air, your sea, giving us a critical
outpost and for monitoring clandestine behavior and deterring our adversaries from entering
your sovereign territory and the sovereign territory of our mutual allies. Rubio said
the United States is open to doing more with its NATO ally that has no standing army of its own.
Rubio later toured a U.S. Navy maritime patrol aircraft based in Iceland,
a platform designed for long range surveillance and anti-submarine missions.
The trip comes just weeks after Washington signed a new defense agreement with Denmark and
Greenland. The deal expands American military access on the world's largest island with two
new defense areas across Greenland. Rubio has separately warned that China, despite not being
an Arctic nation, is operating in the region and seeking influence over sea lanes and critical
infrastructure. The location of this country between the United States and Europe and the
high north means that it sits at the, Iceland sits at the center of many of the questions
surrounding the security and the defense of our shared region. There are direct threats and those
threats in the 21st century aren't just military threats, there are also economic, commercial
threats that have implications on the national security of our respective countries. According
to a Brookings study, China has its sights set on becoming a polar great power by 2030.
Analysts at the American Enterprise Institute have long warned that Chinese research stations
and investments in Iceland could serve dual use purposes. Rubio's visit signals the Trump
administration intends to raise the cost of those activities. Next, Rubio heads to Greece
and Portugal to continue the NATO outreach. One of Germany's biggest intelligence scandals since
the Cold War, former German spy chief August Hanning was detained on Tuesday on suspicion of
attempted treason. Hanning's then office manager, identified as Manfred D., was also arrested on
Tuesday. Here's what the spokesperson for the German federal prosecutor general had to say.
Specifically, this concerns a case in which he used classified information he had received from
Manfred D. to prepare an analysis for an intelligence officer from another country.
The name of the foreign country was not disclosed. According to the German newspaper
Deutsche Zeitung, the case does not involve Russia. Prosecutors say Manfred D. supplied
Hanning with around 2,000 documents over the years, with some of them on high secret level.
The newspaper reports the documents covered Iran's nuclear program and the Russian military.
Sunday's election in Brazil did not go as many expected. Conservative candidate Flavio Bolsonaro
won just shy of 48 percent of the vote, while incumbent president Lula da Silva finished
just a few points behind. Will Brazil follow the trend in Latin America's shift toward more
conservative leadership, and what could that mean for the U.S. and China? To discuss this,
NTD's Kerry Dunst was joined by Marcos Jacquez, editor-in-chief of the Epoch Times Brazil,
and Michael Waller, senior analyst for strategy at the Center for Security Policy and former CIA
operative. Marcos, for those who are not too familiar with Brazilian politics, can you frame
why this election matters to us here in the U.S., as well as offer your analysis on what
happened last night? Sure, so this election is massively important in the U.S., and I'll highlight
two of the biggest reasons why. On the one hand, Brazil is about 50 percent of South America's land
mass, but it's also its biggest economy. It's the biggest democracy in the Americas, other than the
United States, when you talk about population. Brazil has a specific problem with organized crime,
and we're talking transnational organized crime. So two Brazilian cartels, the PCC and the CV,
have been designated as FTOs, Foreign Terrorist Organizations, by the second Trump administration,
the current administration. The second thing is when we talk about geopolitics and the U.S.'s
competition with the Chinese Communist Party, Brazil has the world's second largest reserves
of rare earths, right? So those are critical minerals that you need for everything, like,
I don't know, an F-35 fighter jet, the weapons that are being sent to Ukraine, the weapons that
are needed to fight against Iran right now, right? So those critical minerals right now have the U.S.
in kind of a hold with the Chinese Communist Party, because the CCP provides almost all of
the critical minerals that not only the U.S., but the world needs when we talk rare earths. Brazil
has the second largest reserves and could be an alternative for the U.S. to source these materials.
Absolutely. Wow. And when you frame it like that, there certainly is a lot at stake and there's
only about three points in those polls separating them, or I should say in last night's results.
Michael, I want to shift to another area of this story. Some are citing that the Trump
administration's cutting of USAID negatively affected the Lula campaign. So why would U.S.
aid funds have any impact on a foreign election? Well, we would think of foreign aid as helping
people in need by helping disaster victims, helping against disease, helping people get
clean water. But what's happened over the years is you've had this cultural Marxist
marching, long march through the institutions that took over the USAID bureaucracy and without much
congressional oversight. So what they did was they took funds that were meant to help people in need
to train community organizers, to train militant activists, to train political activists who then
aren't partisan officially. Of course they are, and they're almost always very left wing.
So you had USAID over the years training and paying the salaries of these cadres of people
who would get out into the streets to organize, to turn out to vote. And Marcus, with what he
was describing, I wanted to get a sense that that was USAID. Where does China sit particularly in
I mean, when you talk specifically about China's action in Brazil, it's very widespread.
This goes from the economic side to the political side, and it spans a lot. So over on the economic
side, China has a lot of leverage because you talk about Brazil being the receiving country
of about 40 percent of China's total investment in the region. So when you talk about specific
senators, when you talk about specific congressmen who get a lot of Chinese lobby money,
essentially, we're talking about a lot of leverage that China has to be working with local parties.
We saw in 2018 and in other incidents, instances where the Chinese Communist Party was actively
working with local politicians to prop them up, not specifically interfering in the elections,
but just before the elections, trying to get their position up on certain communities or showing them
over on community projects. And the leverage they have economically is very big, right?
But other than that, you have to remember that the Brazilian hard left is essentially a legacy
organization coming from the international communist movement. And we saw over in 2022
and in other local and federal elections in Brazil, Chinese officials talking openly
about coordinating with local officials, and not only in Brazil, but throughout the region.
Yeah, fascinating that the CCP has essentially taken the baton from the KGB, as you're pointing
out, and with that book that you're explaining. Michael, as we start to finish up, I just want
to get your final thoughts on what's at stake with this particular election, and more broadly,
what you're observing with USAID now significantly trimmed down and with this sort of trend that
we're seeing more toward Trump aligned candidates in Latin America.
Brazil is a hugely important country. It was an ally of ours in World War II. It's been a strong
supporter until Lula fighting the communists in Latin America. It allied with communist China.
Now with BRICS, Brazil is the B in BRICS, Russia, India, China, South Africa. It's working with
communist China to destroy the US dollar. It has advanced technology. I think a lot of the jet
aircraft that we fly in in America are made in Brazil. And it's been a good neighbor until this
Marxist movement, backed by originally the Soviets and now by the communist Chinese,
has come to make the country go its own way, which is Beijing's way.
Coming up, a California woman has been arrested as the US accuses her of spying on the Taiwanese
president's son for Beijing. How extensive are Chinese surveillance operations on US soil?
That and more after the break here on China In Focus.
Welcome back to China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. Investigation is now underway as a
California woman is accused of spying for Beijing on the son of Taiwan's president.
She was arrested at Los Angeles International Airport. What do allegations against her say
about the extent of Chinese surveillance operations on US soil? And today's Stephanie
Alcock spoke to David Zhang, host of the podcast David on China, for his take. Here's more.
We know the CCP has spying operations in the US. The president also acknowledged that recently.
But how extensive are China's surveillance and influence operations here?
Right. Well, just using the woman that was arrested, she is a graduate of the University
of International Relations. And this is through her former association relationships with her
classmates that she was assigned this job to spy all the way from California to Seattle. And this
is one of the many cases. She also attends these so-called welcoming parties or protests against
anti-CCP protesters. And others, especially many who are known now have been arrested,
have been engaged in transnational repression. And this really happens a lot in bigger cities,
like in LA, in New York, in San Francisco. And many times these are hosted by local associations
that are tied to the United Front networks. But individuals, whenever they feel like,
or at least the CCP's intelligence apparatus feels like that they can be abused,
they will be approached and they could be offered monetary rewards or simply a feeling of nationalism,
so to speak. And many times people fall for that. But overall, I think there's a huge issue
with individuals becoming so easily turned over to work on behalf of the CCP.
And that's something I think this arrest really serves as a warning because you sometimes don't
necessarily know that what you're getting into is of national security or intelligence or
counterintelligence areas. And that's really important because a lot of people think that
they're just simply, quote unquote, helping the CCP or the motherland.
And how are these operations carried out through people already living in the US?
Right. So in this case, again, she's a nationalized US citizen,
and it seems like the earliest communications went back to as early as 2022.
So in four years, she was keeping contact. And it wasn't until last year, about a year ago,
that she was really, you know, so-called approached to begin this task of surveillance.
And so I think they often cultivate these relations, make you feel like that you're
more important than you really are to the Chinese Communist Party. And a lot of times
they don't explain what you're actually getting into. And so, you know, you see young people,
right? There were cases of these Chinese nationals or Chinese Americans who spied on
behalf of China for, you know, maybe $20,000 or something like that. But they don't understand
the severity of it. And so over time, they cultivate many of these candidates.
Now, there's also deliberate spies. So there's half and half. There's people that have been
turned. There's people that came out of China with a mission. And I think the FBI is trying to,
in my opinion, crack down on both.
Now, how difficult is it for U.S. law enforcement to identify and stop them before
surveillance actually turns into intimidation or other forms of transnational repression?
Right. This is actually the core question here. The FBI has to build a case, right?
For this particular woman, Heather, so-called, you know, the surveillance case is actually of
at least a year or more longer in terms of building a case against her, because you need
to collect the evidence. You have to have the affidavit and everything else. And so by the time,
you know, they could have already done something or the damage is already done, right? And so
it takes a much longer time for them because this is a country of rule of law. You can't just
detain or arrest somebody because, you know, of what they believe in or what they said.
And so, you know, you're never going to catch everybody. And that's why I say
you find the few that are doing the worst things possible. And once they've been arrested
on charges or possible charges, then, you know, you start to serve this as sort of a warning to
others who might want to engage in similar things and in hoping to deter those people from committing
the crimes. Now, this lady from California who's been charged most recently, she, if convicted,
would face a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison. How do you see that as an equivalent
punishment or what kind of warning that might serve to others in similar situations?
Yeah, well, look, just speaking to the Chinese Americans out there, you know, you or your family
work very hard to become a U.S. citizen. And, you know, this could all go away in a blink of a second
because of something that you did. Right. You know, there's a lot of people who immigrated to
the Western world from China, but they don't realize that what they have
or what they enjoy is something that, you know, many more people want to enjoy or want to cherish.
And so don't throw that away. But, you know, 10 years maximum sentence is something that I think
will shock a lot of people, especially those that before didn't think that this would carry any sort
of punishment at all. Right. Because they think that especially I think what the CCP agents would
tell them is that, you know, do this for us and, you know, we've got your back, those kind of
things. But these are very disposable, you know, candidates when it comes to intelligence gathering.
So I don't think that they realize what the severity is. That's all for today's China in
Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. If you have any feedback on the show or have something you'd like to see us
cover, send us an email at ChinaInFocus at NTD.com. We'd love to hear from you. For on the
clock original news coverage, visit us at NTD.com or download our NTD app. Thanks for watching.
See you tomorrow.