Private Credit Investors Want Their Money Back… And It’s Getting Worse

Loan Hub
4 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Blue Owl, oh Blue Owl, our favorite sad hooter, still getting hit with enormous redemption
requests, even as the private credit giant continues to insist that the underlying loans
remain resilient. Where have we heard that before? Investors in the roughly $5 billion
Blue Owl Technology Income Corp. asked to withdraw 39% of the fund's share in the third
quarter, slightly more than in the previous period. Blue Owl says many of those requests
came from investors rejoining the redemption queue, but then argues that fears about this
growing credit downturn are disconnected from the fund's actual credit fundamentals.
But when investors repeatedly ask for their money back and withdrawals have to be capped,
that denial just doesn't work. Just look at the stock prices of some of these publicly
traded credit funds. No one believes the industry spin any longer. The world has moved on to
wondering if there is anything, to now thinking about how far this could end up going. Because
Blue Owl isn't the only warning coming from debt markets right now. Spreads on the riskiest
part of the junk market have surged. There's even been some selling and investment grade debt.
Meanwhile, the KBW Bank Index has fallen roughly 14% from its August peak, putting bank stocks
firmly into a correction and right near a critical trend line. That's happening even though higher
interest rates are supposedly good for banks. Add another weak payroll report to this mounting
pressure across both public and private credit, and the picture becomes harder to dismiss. In fact,
the more the Blue Owls protest, the more you know that's the case.
So it's not one thing or another. Private credit is still in the focus, but it is spreading beyond
private credit. So Steve, private credit, credit cycle, it's not even private credit anymore. And
this is where we were going with this from the very beginning. It started out with tri-color
and first brands and cockroaches. But as we said last year, this is the beginning of this thing
that's going to spread throughout the entire credit market because that was just the announcement
of the beginning of a credit cycle shift in the credit cycle downturn. And now we're getting all
these continued confirmation. That's the case. There is a credit cycle downturn underway right
now. Yeah, absolutely, Jeff. And then we start somewhere. It's like the housing downturns. Oh,
it's just subprime. It can't affect anything else. Well, meanwhile, it was clearly affecting a lot of
other things. And that's the same thing we see right now. And we know investors want out of
private credit. It's not that they just only want out of private credit. They're looking at the
economy slowing down and they're looking at wage growth slow. Consumers are dealing with higher
prices. And they're saying, look, very clearly is we know that these loans are back by receivables,
payables, inventory. And we're starting to wonder now, are we going to get our money back? Because
if things slow down, yeah, we're getting a really great coupon. And I know Blue Owl tells us
everything's OK, but we've seen in the past things can change in a moment. It's not like we have full
liquidity. It's not like we just pull our money and walk. We have to beg them and ask them to give
us some of our money. So we better get it now because the trend continues to be going the wrong
direction. It's the trend, right? That's exactly it. And so what Blue Owl says and some of the
others in the industry, what they say is that we see no change in trend. We're still on the bubble
type of upswing, whereas investors are saying, OK, we're not afraid that everything's going to
fall apart. We're going to see a mass waves of defaults and non accruals tomorrow. We're doing
the math here during doing small economic math, which the Fed, of course, and the mainstream is
incapable of doing. But doing some small economic math, we can see the trends are not favorable.
You've got a whole bunch of them, too. You had the fragile economy, the labor market. We just
got the payroll report for the month of September, which was unexpectedly bad after only one single
month where it wasn't as bad. So the trends in the labor market trend in income, as you just
mentioned, Steve, for consumers as well as businesses, especially smaller businesses.
Plus, on top of everything, what do we have? We've got an energy shock. The trends for the
energy shock are not inflationary. It's not the economy is going to suddenly boom. It's going to
be more pressure on the business sector, more pressure on consumers, more than there already
has been. So, again, these investors are doing the small economic math and saying, I don't care
what Blue Owl tells me about yesterday. I'm looking at tomorrow and next week and next year and saying
there is not the trends are all moving in the wrong direction. And even A.I.
where A.I. could be contributing to the economy in the short run, where it comes to all of these
credits, people are looking at the A.I. portfolios or the A.I. susceptible portfolios, all these
software companies, software is everywhere in these portfolios. And if A.I. really does start
to erode some of their some of their revenue opportunities in their in their business model,
then again, it's another trend that's going in the wrong direction. And that's really what the
share prices are telling us. So you see Blue Owl's BDC share price that is just absolutely tanked.
What there's what the investors in the stock market, even the stock market are saying is that
we're doing the math. We're looking at things and where all these lines are going and where
they're going into the later part of this year and next year is nowhere, nowhere good for the
credit side. Before we go on with our video today, let me ask you a question. What if your gold could
actually pay you every single month in more gold? That's what today's video sponsor, Monetary Metals,
lets you do. And here's how it works. You still own the gold. It's still in your name. It's fully
insured. But instead of just sitting there doing nothing, it actually starts working for you.
Monetary Metals has built a system that turns idle gold into productive gold, earning real yield
paid in physical gold, not dollars, no selling, no trading, no converting. You keep your gold and
every month you get more of it. It's a simple idea, but it solves a big problem. If gold is
money, it should act like money. And now it finally can. If you're a long term gold holder looking for
a smarter way to store value, check them out at Monetary-Metals.com slash Snyder. Again, that's
Monetary-Metals.com slash Snyder. I highly recommend booking a call with them today to see if
they're the right fit for you. We thank Monetary Metals for their sponsorship, but now let's get
back to the rest of our video. And, you know, Jeff, you mentioned, you know, corporate income,
corporate profits. And this is interesting because if you look at the chart, it's actually up. But
of course, we're always looking backwards at the prior quarter. You know, it's something I've been
really looking at lately because I know the market's trying to say, look, everything can
keep going higher. Everything's fine because corporate profits are going to continue to go up.
But if you start looking at corporate profits during periods where you have energy shocks,
it's real simple. You can look at rising diesel prices. And we already know that businesses have
been squeezed and they've got a little bit of relief here, but they're not in a position they
can go out and say, hey, we're going to raise prices. Now, we heard that from the ISM and S&P
Global Manufacturing PMIs at the factory level. Look, prices are going way up. And yes, we're
going to be raising them. The only question, and we keep coming back to this, Jeff, is who's going
to be able to afford these higher prices, which we know is virtually nobody. So the issue comes
is when you get a spike in diesel prices, what do businesses, particularly the small and midsize
ones, what do they have to absorb? That rising increase in price at their margin. They know they
can't pass it on to their customers. And so that's what we're seeing here is I think a lot of
investors are going, wait a minute, this energy shock, it's not going to be transitory. And we
see that in the past where they'll spike up and then quickly they'll drop. Everybody's pretty
convinced now that this is going to last at least for a few months. And if that's the case, all these
businesses that you've got money against on their loans, well, they're going to have a problem. And
when they have a problem and they can't lay off any more people because they already have gotten
rid of all their employees except their key ones, what goes next? And that is you start looking at
and saying, well, maybe I can skip the payment on this loan or this other loan. And that's the fear
is that these loans that are good today soon could be seeing delinquency start to build up.
And that, I think, Jeff, from my perspective, is really why some of these people want out.
They want out before that hits. Yeah, they know the weakest credits who have been kept alive by
the constant influx of refinancing money. The weakest zombie companies that are out there are
going to have a real big difficulty if this credit cycle really does shift. And that's another thing
to point out, too. And we've talked about this before, Steve, both on on air and off, is that
this is the first time we've seen a credit cycle turn since 2008, really 2006, 2007. We haven't
been through this before in really 20 years because in many ways, the credit cycle upswing
before recently has been so terrible. There's no reason for it to get into a situation like this.
But now we get to the twenty twenties. Now we're really starting to experience a full blown credit
cycle. And many people are either in denial or sort of just looking at it like, oh, this doesn't
look all that bad right now. But as you point out, it's got to start somewhere, which I think is why
you remember about a week ago, there was an article all over social media from Freightways
that said 16 trunking trucking companies had declared bankruptcy and gone into bankruptcy
court in a space of just like a couple of weeks. Now, it wasn't big. I mean, these are smaller
trucking firms. We're talking about losing a couple hundred jobs. And though we never want
to lose a couple hundred jobs, it wasn't thousands or let alone tens of thousands. But the reason why
it hit home so hard is because everybody knows in a credit cycle downturn, it starts with the
weakest player. Those who can't afford the economy as it is are barely being kept alive by an influx
of refinancing money, as I just said. They're not going to be able to stay alive. And then you
compound the situation by an energy shock that is not going away. I mean, what has it been now?
We're we're seven months into this thing. It is with no sign of it really going away. In fact,
there's still a lot more signs pointing to it getting worse. So if you're an investor in anywhere
in the credit markets, especially at the at the weaker edges, you're looking at your portfolio
and saying, yeah, I don't think I want to own triple C rated companies, no matter, you know,
the coupon looks great on paper. But with this, with all of the, you know, doing the economic
math, with all the trend lines going in the direction that they are, the last thing you
want to do is be exposed to the macro economy as it moves along with the credit cycle in the wrong
direction. Yeah, absolutely. Jeff, because when you think about investing in private credit,
you're not just investing in, you know, like in receivables, payables and inventory,
you're really investing in the American consumer and their ability to say, hey,
I'm going to go out and buy those things at some point, because the moment they do,
that means revenue comes into the company. And that means they can make their loan payments. And
then everybody's happy at this point. But again, we look back to the American consumer. And yeah,
we had a blowout retail sales report that everyone got excited about and said, hey,
this is a sign that the last month pay report was indeed validated, which as it turns out,
it wasn't. This is why we need higher interest rates. This is why the Fed needs to hike,
because look, the economy's turning around. And if you bought into that narrative,
then if you're in private credit, you really don't have anything to worry about.
But suddenly they're worried. And why is that? Again, you come back to the energy shock,
and we know food prices, they're going to go up. And you talk about trucking companies,
when we've heard from, you know, big shippers coming in from China, you know, and they're
saying their prices are going to double. That means this is going to feed into consumer prices,
whether people can afford it or not. The bottom line is here, why are they trying to get out?
It's because they realize their bet on the American consumer is about to go bust.
Yeah. Well, I mean, we've seen job growth or the absence of job growth going back,
you know, a couple of years now, and eventually that's going to catch up with everybody. So
it becomes an increasingly difficult bet to hold on to. I mean, that was what everybody
was saying from the very beginning. You go back to 21 and 22, everybody bet on the resurgent US
economy that's fueled with all of this government money. And therefore, you know, Warren Buffett
said the economy's red hot and inflationary and kept hearing about inflation and everybody
associates inflation with a red hot economy. So it was easy to make that sort of bet. Even in 23
and 24, when things started to go the wrong way, they didn't fall off right away. They didn't fall
off into, you know, 2009 Great Recession 2.0. And because they didn't, a lot of people said,
well, look at how resilient this is. We've got all these headwinds across the economy,
including sky high interest rates. And the economy appears to be holding up just fine.
The thing is, thing was, it wasn't. The economy wasn't holding up. It was showing signs of
weakening, which the bond market picked up on, which is why rates started to go lower
way back in late 2023. Because it was increasingly difficult to make the same bet on this
future soaring, booming economy that had left the 2010s behind and had been re-engineered into
something that was going to be a sustainable, multi-decade trend, super cycle, secular growth,
and all the other words that were thrown around by Wall Street trying to sell what they knew
was increasingly garbage paper, to use Jeff Gundlach's term. So, you know, in 23, you can
get away with it. 24 gets a little bit harder, especially as Japanese start to say, no, thank
you. We don't like where things are going. And then 25, you get tricolored first brands and
people are like, OK, this is getting really difficult to make, to say with a straight face
that we're going to bet on the economy being resilient forever forward. Because again,
look at all of where everything is going. It doesn't look like 2009, but that doesn't mean
it's good. And increasingly, since nothing has changed, that just means more and more people
are saying, since nothing has changed, I got to get out of this thing before it really does become
a full blown thing that when everybody's scrambling for the exits, there's never enough
exits. But Jeff, isn't that the problem that nothing actually has changed? I think everyone
needed something to change. I mean, again, we go back to mid 2024, as you said, what has the labor
market done? On net, is it create a few jobs? Yes, but that's about it. So if you're looking
for this economic rebound that everybody's really hoping for, because as you said, we've forgotten
not only how to grow an economy, but in terms of options now, what do we really have? Fed rate
cuts? Are they going to really do anything right now? No, not going to do anything at all. Because
the economy is really being held up. There's a lot of production in the manufacturing sector.
On the war side, you have also we've seen in the data, a lot of AI stuff. But at some point,
this all the stuff is not transmitting into real jobs when you're hearing people say, hey,
you know what? I used to love to go to McDonald's and get a Big Mac. But even now I can't afford
that I can't even afford it when they give away free French fries. So the problem is we're seeing
it back again, from consumers are saying, look, my spending habits are going to change. And they
have to because when we look at what's been driving, you know, demand, and I think, you know,
when people just look at the raw data, Jeff, and you know, this as well, you say, well,
what retail sales have been going up and look at that big one off month that you guys are saying
is one off. But how do we know it's not a trend? Look at the personal savings rate,
you can literally see as one goes up, the other ones going down. And the problem is consumers
have been drawing down their savings month after month after month on the hope of again, the same
thing that something would change. And once again, it's not that something isn't the problem
is something nothing is changing. But what is going to change is consumers are going to say,
look, I can't continue down this path. I can't go broke here. Because when I look at the labor
market, I'm starting to worry that I might not have a job. And that's going to become the next
big issue when you have a net zero job creation over two months coming out of the summer. That's
a huge problem. Because what it's already telling us is that holiday spend is probably going to be
weak. And when businesses figure that out, they're not going to hire enough people or
part time people to fill in the gaps. What's even worse is coming out of that, we're going to see
just so we typically see in the past, after the holiday season, the layoffs hit the market hits.
And next thing you know, all of this that hasn't changed starts to become a problem of change in
wrong direction. That's really it, the trends, the math, right? In the labor market, the credit
cycle, basically everything. It's been on sort of like autopilot going back several years. And
every single time we keep hearing, okay, the trend is going to change favorably. Therefore,
I want to be in, you know, the old FOMO mentality. I got to be in risk assets, because once this
thing starts to pick up, it's going to be terrific. And then it doesn't pick up, but it doesn't
actually fall off sharply either. So it's easy to try to plot the middle road where it's okay,
we'll just wait for it to pick up because it has to eventually. I think the best way to see that
and really illustrate this divergence is in the credit spread. You look at the triple C's, the
triple hooks, spreads and triple hooks have been rising pretty sharply, really, more importantly,
steadily. Since last September, which was tricolor in first print, we got the cockroaches show up and
suddenly portfolio managers like I'm going to take a little bit off the table as far as the risky
stuff. So, you know, triple C credit spreads have been rising steadily for over a year. Meanwhile,
investment grade credit spreads have been the opposite. They have been low. In fact,
many of them have been historically low. So that is the marketplace saying on the one hand,
macroeconomic story really isn't all that favorable. I want to stay out of risk. However,
I'm going to bet on AI. I'm going to bet on, you know, AI leading to some kind of
being the trend change, the positive trend change. And therefore, I'm not willing to bet my entire
portfolio on it. But I'll bet with the safe stuff, the investment grade stuff, I'll stick to that,
because maybe eventually it will work out the same way. But as we keep going through 2026,
when we're time and time again, we hear that, you know, things are going to pick up.
We got the last retail sales report, as you pointed out, Steve, that's going to be huge.
It's going to be the start of many, many months. We heard it with the payroll report. August payroll
comes in way above expectations. And what did everybody say? Oh, this is the start of the boom.
Here it comes. And then the next one falls off sharply. And you realize nothing has actually
changed. But when nothing has actually changed and you're not really sure about everything,
you start to become more and more cautious, not more and more aggressive. And so the marketplace,
the credit cycle is becoming more and more and more cautious. And we keep seeing more and more
signs of that caution all over the place, not just Blue Isle, not just in private credit,
but in public markets and things like leveraged loans. And another thing, another topic you've
been talking about a lot, Steve, banks, just the banking sector. Suddenly the stock market's
looking at the banking sector and saying higher rates. That's supposed to be good for you. But
hell, I'm going to sell. I'm going to sell Wells Fargo anyway. Yeah, Jeff, a lot of people don't
really look at bank stocks and they really should right now, because as you said, you know, when you
see a rising interest rate environment, that's usually a plus for the banks, particularly if
you come off a very low interest rate environment or a prolonged period, because they make money on
the spread. So as rates go up, they can make money and it's more profitable. And we should see bank
stocks rising, particularly looking over the last month, there was this big shock in the bond
market, rates went up, and this should be a big boom for the banks. But what happened? At the same
time rates were going up, we saw bank stocks go down. And what a lot of investors are saying,
well, who really cares? Well, you should care because I know people are looking at the Nasdaq
today and saying, look, on Friday, a new all-time high. Look at the S&P. It's, you know, almost back
in rally to get up to your hat level, Steve. I mean, this is what we've been waiting for.
But if you do an overlay and look at where bank stocks go and what happens to the broad market,
what the banks are saying very clearly here is forget about S&P 8,000. It might actually happen.
But what's going to happen if bank stocks continue to drop, it's a warning that the economy is going
the wrong direction. And we don't need higher rates right now. We don't need the fact that we
don't think that consumers can afford this. That's what banks are trying to say here is, look,
consumers are getting squeezed. The rates are going the wrong direction. Energy prices are
going the wrong direction. Food prices are going the wrong direction. And what that means for us
is delinquencies are going to start to go the wrong direction. And that's what we're starting
to see is exactly what these blue-owl investors are doing. The only difference is it's not like
a publicly traded stock where you say, well, I'll just hang on to it. If it goes down more,
I'll sell it. It's not like an ETF. You're locked in. If you want out every quarter,
when that door cracks a little bit, you better have your hand there waiting and say,
give me everything I can because there's going to be a point when that door gets slammed and
and your money's going to get tied up and they know this is coming. That's why they want to get
out. Yeah. So you have the banks that are saying, look, yeah, it might be higher on a net interest
spread, though. That's that's kind of a question, too. But if who cares if you can make more on a
loan, if fewer people are paying back on their loans, that's really what the market is saying
is that we're really worried about maybe this is going to be one of those situations where,
yeah, maybe net interest income looks better, but it's not just income that of future charge
offs and delinquencies and non accruals that are that are really starting to concern people.
Like I said, and to start here, banks were you know, they sold off pretty hard in the tariff
disorder of March and April of twenty twenty five and they came right back. So there was an
identifiable, identifiable catalyst there. They sold off pretty hard March and April of twenty
twenty six. The energy shock and OK, the markets were chaotic at that point. Identifiable catalyst
there. This time, you know, the KBW Bank Index is down for the Nasdaq, I think 13 percent from
its high over a little bit all closing in on two months. So the market is clearly concerned
about something, but there's no identifiable catalyst this time around to to really connect
the selling. So that's the market saying, yeah, we don't like the way the things are going. And
therefore, even if it doesn't look catastrophically bad for the banking sector, it is another signal
that's consistent with more people recognizing the credit cycle for what it is and therefore
the broader dangers to what they represent moving forward. So you're right, Steve, it's not just
blue isle investors pulling their money out. Everybody is looking ahead into twenty twenty
seven and saying nothing changed in twenty twenty six. And that was not good.
