An educational overview featuring a collaborative commentary between a prominent historian and an archaeologist to fact-check ten popular misconceptions and understandings regarding the ancient past. The analysis debunks highly dramatized pop culture elements and internet beliefs, exploring behavioral history anomalies such as the actual battle forces at Thermopylae and the true origins of the political salute. It further evaluates historical structures and cultural transitions, breaking down structural core defects of the Great Pyramid, the gradual decline of the Library of Alexandria over centuries, Nero's relief response during the fire of Rome, and the mutual tracking of religious identities between ancient Greeks and Romans.
An ancient historian and an archaeologist collaborate to debunk ten widespread misconceptions about the ancient world. The discussion corrects popular myths regarding military history, architectural precision, cultural origins, and archaeological theories, replacing pop-culture narratives with evidence-based historical facts.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
If you would like to support the channel and become part of our ancient history fan community,
visit patreon.com slash world of antiquity.
Today we're going to talk about popular misconceptions about the ancient past.
And for this, I've teamed up with Raven from the Dig It With Raven YouTube channel,
which is all about archaeology.
Anyway, what happens when an ancient historian and an archaeologist
team up to talk about common misconceptions about the ancient world?
This is where you're going to find out.
Raven and I are making two videos on this subject.
This one is going on my channel, and a completely different one with the same theme on hers.
If you haven't seen her channel yet, head on over to Dig It With Raven and give her a sub.
Okay, so Raven and I wrote up a list of what we felt were fairly
common beliefs about ancient times that were not in fact true.
We came up with 20 and wrote them up on slips of paper,
which we're going to pick out of a hat and then respond to.
We're doing 10 of them on this video and the other 10 on the video over on her channel.
We did prepare for these ahead of time, so don't think we're doing it off the cuff.
We're not that good.
So let's get to it.
Okay.
Only 300 Spartan soldiers held off the Persians at Thermopylae for three days.
Yes, we get to talk about Gerard Butler!
You know I love to talk about Gerard Butler.
So we're all familiar with the movie 300 and the stunning
graphics that were performed on Gerard Butler's abs.
And yeah, while it's a really great story for pop culture,
it wasn't just 300 Spartans that defended Thermopylae from the Persians in the year 480 BCE.
It was a lot of other people too.
In fact, there were at least 4,000 allies that were involved in the fighting against
the Persians in the first two days.
And it's a lot more than 300, but don't get too disappointed because it's still a very
small fraction in comparison to the supposed 100,000 Persians, probably exaggerated,
who were trying to barge their way in through the hot gates.
It is true that of the 4,000 Greek allies who were fighting, there were only 300 Spartans.
What happened was that the Spartans could not spare any of their soldiers because of
the harvest that was taking place at the time of the battle,
as well as they were having a very important religious festival coming up.
And they are religious people, very religious, the Spartans,
so they didn't want to, you know, anger the gods at all.
So for them, that was more important.
So instead, King King Leonidas, he went with 300 war veterans to help out the Greek allies.
The Spartans then joined up with the other Greek states at Thermopylae,
which is a very narrow passage between two mountains.
And it was where they would have the best vantage point of trying to fight Xerxes's troops.
It would be where they could have the best chance, especially with their smaller numbers.
And that is where they fought for three days, very valiantly.
And they probably did surprise Xerxes with how well they were doing,
especially if Xerxes had so many people.
Unfortunately, Thermopylae did have a loophole.
They had this other little narrow path that you could get around.
And the Persians ended up finding out King Leonidas, instead of risking all of the Greeks,
he told all the Greeks to retreat.
He said to go back and he and the Spartans would just, you know,
they'd fight to the end and they would defend it.
And most of the Greeks did retreat, except for the Thebans and the Thespians.
They stayed behind to help the Spartans,
which added up to about 1500 people at the last stand against the Persians.
Everyone was wiped out except one Spartan, apparently, who lived to tell the tale,
which is how we get the legend of the 300.
But of course, as you know, now there weren't just 300.
There were a lot of other Greeks involved.
The Romans invented the Nazi salute.
In recent years, as part of their rebranding to make themselves look more palatable to the public,
neo-Nazi organizations have been referring to the Nazi salute as the Roman salute.
And it seems there are some, even beyond them,
who actually believe that the salute did originate with the Romans.
But it turns out that's not true.
That gesture is not found in any ancient Roman art or described in ancient Roman literature.
The earliest appearance of it that has been found
is on a painting from 1784 by Jacques-Louis David titled The Oath of the Horatii.
From there, the pose seems to have made its way into the popular consciousness
and into the early films about the Romans.
And then it was picked up by the fascist party in Italy in the mid-20th century,
who apparently believed it linked them to their Roman forebears.
But yeah, it's not an ancient Roman salute at all.
All right, what do you have next for me, little jar?
Ooh, all right.
The Library of Alexandria went up in flames in one big fire.
Oh, my heart.
This one hurts.
Like, I'm still not over the Library of Alexandria being destroyed.
So the story goes that the Library of Alexandria
was just destroyed in this big huge fire about 2,000 years ago.
But it likely did not go down this way,
and we will probably never know exactly what happened to it.
But it was most likely just a series of catastrophic events
and decay and destruction that led to it sort of just falling into disrepair and disuse
and eventually just disappearing altogether.
Suspect numero uno is Julius Caesar in 48 BCE,
when he was trapped in the royal palace during his occupation of Alexandria.
He set fire to some Egyptian ships,
and they say that the fire sort of spread and got out of control
and burned a lot of Alexandria.
Some ancient writers did say that's when the library caught fire and was destroyed.
But then a few hundred years later, other writers said
it was just a warehouse of squirrels.
So we're not exactly sure.
Then in 391 CE, Emperor Theodosius I,
who was really big on just wiping out all of paganism,
decided to destroy the temple of Serapis.
He built a Christian church on top of this site,
and it is said that the royal library was destroyed in the process.
And yes, while it is possible that the manuscripts from the Serapion were destroyed,
there's no real indication that the royal library was even still in existence at this time.
Jumping further in time, we're going to head over to 640 CE.
What might have occurred then is that the Caliph Omar,
who captured Alexandria at the time,
gathered up all the manuscripts and used them to heat the bathhouses.
And because there's so many, it apparently heated the bathhouses for the next six months.
This event was written down like hundreds of years later though,
so we do not know how reliable this is.
Alexandria was very often an unstable city,
so pinning down this one event that would have destroyed the library of Alexandria
is very difficult when the city is constantly being sieged and on fire.
And it's just it feels like it's just constantly smoldering.
There's just constant like low embers all over Alexandria.
Because of centuries of repeated destruction and neglect
due to changing over of hands and politics and religions and beliefs,
it's more that the library probably sort of just went into a decline
over four or five hundred years and eventually disappeared.
So that's probably what happened to the library.
It wasn't this dramatic movie scene where it burst into flames
and people were trying to run in and save the scrolls.
Like it would be great, but it's probably not what happened.
The Great Pyramid was built to perfection.
Ah yes.
You'll often hear people talking about how the Great Pyramid at Giza
was built with such accuracy that its measurements are extremely precise.
And considering the sheer number of blocks that was used in it,
that was an amazing feat.
And yes, it is true that there was great accuracy in its construction,
which the Egyptians needed to prevent the entire thing from tumbling down.
But the precision was mainly seen in the outer surface of the pyramid,
the completed chambers, and the overall measurement of the pyramid.
The rest of it is a bit of a mess.
The outer casing now is mostly gone.
The remnants of it indeed show beautiful workmanship.
But if you get a close look at the backing stones,
that's the stones that were underneath the casing,
which are mainly exposed now,
they may look like neat steps going all the way up,
but the steps are not at all regular.
They were placed rather sloppily.
And they're not all the same size either.
They get progressively smaller towards the top.
Behind the backing stones,
the core stones are actually even more irregular.
We know this because you can see them from the hole
that Howard Weiss opened up in the 1830s.
Here, the stones are all kinds of whatnot.
They're big blocks, small chunks of rock, wedge-shaped pieces,
oval and trapezoidal pieces,
as well as smaller stone fragments jammed into the spaces between the larger blocks.
Not a single vertical joint corresponds with another.
None of the blocks are the same size,
and there are no clear impressions of regular rising joints.
Even the horizontal joints are not very clear.
I should mention too that beams in the king's chamber
cracked during construction,
and the builders thought,
eh, let's just leave them like that.
And they did.
So yeah, the Great Pyramid,
impressive as it is,
is far from perfect.
Ooh, more fire.
Nero fiddled while Rome burned.
Nero is one of my all-time favorite emperors.
I love him.
All right, so in 64 CE,
Rome was engulfed in a fire that lasted for six days.
It destroyed about 70% of the city,
and it left more than half of its population homeless.
Now, we all know the expression that during the fire,
the emperor at the time, who was Nero,
fiddled while Rome burned.
But I am sorry to disappoint you.
He did not.
Nero was not a popular leader by any means,
and rightly so,
because he was a little bit crazy,
and he was very, very full of himself.
But that being said,
he actually showed up and put the work in
when the fire happened.
The historian Tacitus wrote that Nero was rumored
to have sung during the fire of Rome,
but he also writes that there were no eyewitnesses
to this account.
So technically, we have no proof whatsoever.
It's just purely conjecture,
and it's probably based on his very poor standing
within the public eye.
Also, the fiddle just didn't even exist back then.
The vial class of instruments wasn't invented
until the 11th century CE,
so it was impossible for Nero
to actually have played the fiddle.
If Nero had played anything,
it probably would have been either the kithara,
which is this big, heavy instrument
that has about four to seven strings,
or it would have been the lyre.
Nero wasn't actually in Rome at the time.
He was in Antium on the outskirts,
but once he learned about the fire,
he rushed back to the city and started relief measures.
He opened his gardens and other public buildings
in order to house people that had lost their homes,
and he brought in grain from other towns.
So yeah, maybe he wasn't the best emperor,
but he definitely did not fiddle literally or figuratively.
Of course, in the aftermath of the fire,
he did start to build his golden palace on the ruins,
which did not bode well for his reputation,
but at least there were no string instruments involved, right?
The Romans took their gods from the Greeks.
Ah, yes.
When we first learn about classical mythology,
it's easy to get the impression
that the Greek gods and the Roman gods are the same.
They just have different names, right?
Jupiter and Zeus are the same.
Venus and Aphrodite are the same.
Diana and Artemis are the same.
And we go on.
Although the gods of the Greeks and Romans
bear very strong resemblance to each other,
that's not because the Romans took their gods from the Greeks,
or vice versa.
Neither does it mean that they developed their gods
in collaboration with each other.
There was a time when there was no equation
between their gods.
Yeah.
Before the Greeks and Romans met,
they already had their gods.
Jupiter was worshipped before ever being equated with Zeus.
The Roman gods Jupiter and Mars, Vesta, Diana,
Ceres, Vulcan, Janus,
they were worshipped by the Romans from very early times.
It wasn't until the 4th century BCE
when the Romans encountered the Greeks,
mainly the ones who colonized Italy,
that Greek mythology became known to the Romans.
At that time, as often happens when two cultures meet,
the people begin to notice similarities
between their existing gods,
and they start to equate them.
Oh, your Aries is kind of like our Mars, and so forth.
When that happened, in this case,
the myths of the Greeks began to be absorbed
or adopted into Roman thought,
and that's why we then see all these similarities
between the stories associated with the Roman gods
and the stories associated with the Greek gods.
Next one.
All right, here we go.
Ooh, okay.
The ancient Egyptians knew about helicopters.
Okay, let's just tackle this one.
This is one of my favorite conspiracies,
ancient alien mumbo jumbo,
because it's just ridiculous.
Okay, so this is a fun one,
and I do like getting into it, so let's do it.
The helicopter image is actually just the result
of stone being reused over time.
That's it, but let's break it down.
The initial carving was made
during the reign of Seti I,
and translates to,
he who repulses the nine enemies of Egypt.
This carving was later filled with plaster
and recarved during the reign of Ramses II,
with the title,
he who protects Egypt and overthrows the foreign countries.
These inscriptions are super old.
They're from ancient Egypt.
They're thousands of years old,
and plaster is not as durable as stone,
which means that eventually over the years,
the plaster started to erode away,
and now we can see partially both sets of hieroglyphs,
which means it's kind of left us
with this palimpsest-like effect,
where you can see overlapping hieroglyphs,
and they just happen to look like a helicopter
if you sort of look at it the right way.
It's a really simple explanation,
and if you come at me for this in the comments,
I will just refer you to the Wikipedia page
for Occam's razor.
Cruder work is never found under megaliths.
Ah yes, proponents of the view
that there was an advanced civilization
that existed during the Stone Age
will sometimes use the argument
that cruder work or smaller stones
are never found under megaliths, the large stones.
The implication is that instead of civilization growing,
it fell,
that we went from a high point in civilization
down to a low point.
But think about it for a minute.
The claim that cruder work is never found under megaliths
suggests that there was never a growth of civilization
in the first place.
In other words, it seems to argue
that building technology started at the top.
People woke up one day
and suddenly knew how to build with large stones
before they ever practiced first with small ones.
But then there is the evidence itself.
It turns out that the statement simply is not true.
Cruder work is found under megaliths.
Here's some examples.
At Stonehenge, underneath the megaliths
were found evidence of earlier timber structures
that preceded the megaliths.
This is the case at many of the henges.
At Baalbek,
underneath the 800-ton trilithon stones
are smaller stones.
And underneath those are remnants of earlier structures
that use smaller stones.
And underneath that,
the remains of a village
with even more inferior building technology.
The Western Stone,
a megalith of immense size
and weighing somewhere between 300 and 500 tons,
found in the Western Wall Tunnel in Jerusalem,
has underneath it
stones of considerably smaller size.
The Pyramid of the Sun at Teotihuacan
and the Pyramid of the Moon, for that matter,
huge, impressive structures,
have underneath them
the remains of an earlier, cruder, inferior building phase.
The Pyramid of the Moon, more than one phase.
Same with the Pyramid of Kukulkan at Chichen Itza.
Yes, there are places like Pumapunku
where the impressive stone walls
are built right on the bedrock.
But at most archaeological sites,
we see a progression of building tech over time,
with inferior work often being found
underneath superior work.
We find the other way around, too,
with inferior work on top.
But the point is,
the claim that cruder or smaller work
is never found underneath is false.
Okay, next one.
Museums are hiding artifacts from the public.
Yes, it is true that museums do keep
most of their artifacts in storage
and not on display.
But that's not because they're hiding them from you,
it's because they just have too many artifacts
to show off.
That's it, that's the tea.
It's a very simple explanation.
Display and exhibition space
is usually much smaller than storage space
and you just,
you can't pack everything in there
for everyone to see.
And if you did,
you wouldn't be able to see it all.
You wouldn't understand it all.
You wouldn't appreciate it.
It would just be object overload.
And the point of a museum
is to curate the objects
in order to tell the story,
in order to convey the information
in a really intriguing, informative,
and wholesome way.
And that is why we have curators.
Another reason that not everything is on display
is due to conservation.
Some artifacts may be too fragile for display
or they also just need to be taken off for rotation
because of the 10 agents of deterioration.
And if you don't know about them,
I've made 10 videos all about it
so you can learn about
how different sort of factors
will play into the degradation of an artifact.
So we want to make sure
that we are either rotating them
or safeguarding the objects
in order to keep them preserved
and in as best condition as possible
for as long as possible.
So yeah, museums,
they're not hiding anything from you.
They just have space issues
and they are protecting the objects.
Taksila was home to the world's first university.
The city known as Taksila by the Greeks
and Takshashila to the Indians
was, and actually still is,
a famous place.
In ancient Indian, especially Buddhist literature,
it is known as a famous seat of learning
where religion and philosophy,
literature and grammar and medicine,
the art of war,
and many other subjects
were taught by famous teachers.
If we take the word university
in its technical sense,
as an institution offering tuition
in mainly non-vocational subjects
and typically having the power
to confer degrees,
Taksila probably doesn't fit.
There was no campus with lecture halls
or classrooms or residential units
and most everyone would agree with that.
The first university in that sense
was the University of Bologna, Italy,
founded in 1088.
But what if we just took the word university
to mean a center for higher education
and leave it at that?
Would it be the earliest now?
The most commonly cited example
would be Plato's Academy,
founded in Athens in 387 BCE.
But does Taksila beat it?
The first remains of human habitation at the site,
it goes back to the late 4th millennium,
early 3rd millennium BCE,
and there are remains of Stone Age hunters there.
And then you start to see
in the late 3rd millennium
sedentary agriculture with Neolithic tools.
The village was occupied continuously
through the Bronze Age.
And then in the late 2nd millennium BCE,
you see the first city arise there
on the mound Hathial.
So the first town in Taksila
was situated on the Hathial mound.
It's the beginning of a very slow rise
that city lasted us up
through the Achaemenid period.
That's the period of the Persian Empire.
A second city developed on the Burr mound,
which is in that area too.
And that's commonly dated
to the late Achaemenid period
and going up through the early Hellenistic period.
A Burr mound level four and level three
belong to the 4th and 3rd centuries BCE
and then levels two and level one
to the 2nd and 1st centuries BCE.
Now it's the Burr mound city
that is the Taksila of legend.
That's where we started to hear references to it
from this period,
even from Greek sources
that a lot was going on.
There was a very important city.
To Alexander the Great and his men,
it gave them their first taste of Indian society.
Yes, they visited it.
And they talk about it as a flourishing metropolis.
The writer Arrian spoke of Taksila
as the greatest of all cities
between the Indus and the Hydaspes River.
And according to him also,
it was very prosperous and thickly populated.
And then you have the geographer Strabo, the Roman.
He remarked that Taksila was a very large city too,
extremely fertile, governed by good laws.
On the other hand,
there's no mention by them
of any architectural splendor
and the excavators correspondingly
haven't found any remains
of any monumental buildings from that period.
And in the period after Alexander,
Taksila became a part of the strong Mauryan Empire
and under stronger Indian influence as well.
It's during the period of the Mauryan Empire
that we find the earliest references to Taksila
as a center of higher learning in Indian texts.
These references are from the Jataka tales,
Buddhist stories,
written between about 300 BCE and 400 CE.
In the Jatakas,
there's a story that a famed philosopher of old
named Aruni was educated at Taksila.
Aruni is estimated to have lived in the 8th century BCE.
So those who believe the Jatakas
take this as historical
and therefore conclude
that Taksila was a center of higher learning
as early as the 8th century BCE.
But historians do not automatically take as credible
stories that come from centuries
after the events they purport to describe.
If we had something from the 8th century BCE,
that would be one thing.
But to have a story from hundreds of years later
testifying to this,
and not even a historical document,
but a folktale,
well, that's not solid evidence.
Keep in mind that when the Jatakas were written,
the city was already a center of higher learning.
It's feasible that the storytellers
were projecting a current state of affairs
onto the past.
Anyway, I hope you enjoyed
going over these popular misconceptions.
If you haven't seen Raven's video yet,
go on over to Dig It With Raven
and check out the companion piece.
We do another 10 misconceptions over there.
If you're new here
and you came over from Raven's channel,
welcome!
I hope you'll subscribe
and check out some more of my videos.
All kinds of cool stuff going on here
concerning ancient history.
Anyway, we'll see you next time.
You might like my little e-booklet,
Why Ancient History Matters.
It's designed to persuade people
that the subject is important,
even in the modern world.
You might also wish to use it
to help spread the word.
So feel free to share it with someone you know.
It's free for anyone who wants it.
I've left a link in the description box
below the video for you to grab a copy.
Catch you later.