SandRhoman History tagged products below. Learn more
Spartan Spirit Hoodie sandrhoman-shop.fourthwall.com/products/spartan-spirit-hoodie?variant=52c7e6eb-8d5a-425b-891a-e7b366dd0332&srsltid=AU7gw4WPi1HBm4nq96RRO6MEUH4gdWWhgMm_wTqDI6a5GnC1LRsUbv3RMZQ 🌎 Get an exclusive 15% discount on Saily data plans! Use code "sandrhoman" at checkout. Download the Saily app or go to https://saily.com/sandrhoman ⛵
In the summer of 480 BC, a Persian army marched toward Greece. According to the ancient historian Herodotus, the army was so enormous that its footsteps shook the ground, and its thirsty soldiers turned rivers into sad rivulets. In late summer, the Persians approached the pass of Thermopylae at the Malian Gulf. There, the Spartan king Leonidas awaited them with several thousand soldiers, determined to block their way to Greece. The Battle of Thermopylae has become one of the most famous events of antiquity through politics and pop culture—most notably Zack Snyder’s movie 300. The story is epic and gripping but also highly dramatized and overdrawn. This video examines the accuracy of the popular story and explores what really happened at Thermopylae.
Check out our Amazon Storefront for all sorts of military history, military SIFI and military fantasy books that we recommend: https://www.amazon.com/shop/sandrhoma...
Bibliography: Cartledge, Paul, Thermopylae : the battle that changed the world, London 2007. Macan, Reginald Walter. “Herodotus: The Seventh, Eighth and Ninth Books with Introduction and Commentary: Commentary on Herodotus, Histories, Book 7, Chapter 228”. The Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). pp. section 8. Retrieved October 18, 2007). Morris, Ian; Scheidel, Walter (2009). The Dynamics of Ancient Empires: State Power from Assyria to Byzantium. Oxford University Press. S. 77. SandRhoman History contrasts the dramatized depiction of the conflict in popular media with the historical realities recorded by Herodotus. The analysis
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video examines the historical accuracy of the Battle of Thermopylae, contrasting the dramatized pop-culture narrative—such as the movie *300*—with academic evidence. It explores the strategic motivations of the Greek alliance, the actual troop numbers involved, and the pragmatic reasons behind King Leonidas' famous last stand.
In the summer of 480 BC, a Persian army marched toward Greece. According to the
ancient historian Herodotus, the army was so enormous that its footsteps shook the ground,
and its thirsty soldiers turned rivers into sad rivulets. In late summer, the Persians
approached the pass of Thermopylae at the Malian Gulf. There, the Spartan king Leonidas
awaited them with several thousand soldiers determined to block their way to Greece.
The battle of Thermopylae has become one of the most famous events of antiquity
through politics and pop culture, most notably Zack Snyder's movie 300. The story is epic and
gripping, but also highly dramatized and overdrawn. This video examines the accuracy
of the popular story and explores what really happened at Thermopylae.
In the 6th century BC, the Persian Empire expanded westward, bringing Greece, a patchwork of rising
city-states under Persian influence. When the Ionians, who had settled in Asia Minor,
rose against the Persians in 490 BC, Athens supported their revolt. With this intervention,
they stepped on the Persians' toes. King Darius I, commonly known as Darius the Great,
sent a punitive mission to Greece in 490 BC, but his armies were repulsed by the Athenians
in the famous Battle of Marathon. Darius was furious and sought revenge, but due to domestic
political problems, a further retaliatory strike was delayed so long that only his successor,
Xerxes I, could launch another invasion of Greece. When the Greeks learned of the imminent attack,
they gathered in Corinth and formed an alliance. With the united forces led by Sparta, they aimed
to stop the Persians by following a battle plan proposed by the Athenian Themistocles.
He suggested halting Xerxes' advance at two key points. The fleet would guard Cape Artemision,
while the land forces block the bottleneck at Thermopylae. Themistocles had chosen these
choke points because they prevented the Persians from exploiting their numerical superiority.
The Greeks quickly took up their assigned positions. Although films and stories suggest
we know everything about the Battle of Thermopylae, very little is historically
verified because only a few ancient sources report on the events. The most important source
is the Greek historian Herodotus, however, his reports must be taken with a grain of salt,
as he presents information as he learns about it and leaves it to the reader to judge its
plausibility. Nevertheless, for the Battle of Thermopylae, his writings are indispensable.
According to Paul Cartledge, an expert on the event,
we either write a history of Thermopylae with him, Herodotus, or not at all. However,
it's crucial to consider the difficulties associated with the ancient sources when
reconstructing the events. When the Persians reached Thermopylae, they set up camp north of
the pass. The Greeks, led by the famous Spartan king Leonidas, aged sixty at the time, awaited
them at the narrowest point, where they had reinforced their position with a wall.
Perfect for navigating, uploading your travel photos, or diving into historical facts on the
go. I personally save about $35-45 for their 5GB plan compared to what my local provider
charges for roaming. Just visit their website before your trip, pick your data plan, download
the app, and activate your eSIM right on your phone. No physical SIM card, no hassle. Once
it's activated, steady make sure you don't accidentally connect to expensive foreign
networks, and you can skip sketchy public Wi-Fi altogether. It works both on iOS and Android,
comes with a 24x7 customer support, and if your phone isn't compatible with an eSIM,
they offer a full refund. Don't leave your travel connectivity to chance. Go to saley.com
slash sandroman and use code SANDROMAN for an exclusive 15% off your first purchase.
Five days after the Persians arrived, the battle began. According to Herodotus,
Xerxes first sent his archers against the Greeks. This was likely largely ineffective because the
Greeks fought in a phalanx, an infantry formation where soldiers covered each other with their
shields. In this context, Herodotus mentions the phrase made famous by the 300 movie,
then we shall fight in the shade. A Spartan allegedly said this when a barrage of arrows
was so dense it blocked out the sun. The Persians reportedly advanced 10 000 light
infantry next. When this second wave was also repelled by the Greek blockade,
Xerxes ordered the famous Immortals, the elite Persian infantry, to attack. But they fared no
better. At this point you might be wondering how the Greeks withstood these successive waves
without dropping with exhaustion. Herodotus attributes their survival to a key element
of Greek tactics. Like most armies of the time, Leonidas' men fought in groups based on their
origin. They rotated these groups throughout the battle, with each unit taking turns in the
fighting. For example, the Spartans fought first, then the Thespians relieved them, then the Thebans
took over, and so on. While this is plausible, a scholarly debate exists about the nature of
warfare in ancient Greece and the specifics of phalanx combat. For more details, check out our
video on warfare in ancient Greece. On the second day, the Persians continued their attack.
Xerxes had hoped Leonidas' men would finally reach their breaking point, but it was not to be. He
watched as his troops suffered yet another defeat. By now it should be clear that 300 men couldn't
have held out so long, even with the most sophisticated tactics. This brings us to
another controversial aspect of the battle, the numbers. The battle of Thermopylae is an example
of a David versus Goliath narrative. For a good 100 years it has been portrayed in studies and
history books as the heroic last stand of a few Greeks against millions of Persians. While it's
true that the Greeks were outnumbered at Thermopylae, the disparity was not nearly as extreme
as often believed. Because religious festivities were taking place at the time of the battle,
and the Spartans feared an uprising by the Helots, a subjugated part of their population,
the members of the Greek alliance only sent a small vanguard to Thermopylae and Artemision.
These troops were meant to stall the Persians until the main Greek force arrived.
According to Herodotus, the Spartan contingent of the vanguard consisted of Leonidas'
hypaeus, the traditional bodyguard of the Spartan kings, accompanied by around 1000 perioikoi,
the three subjects of Sparta, and 1000 Helots. According to Paul Cartledge, this amounted to
around 16% of Sparta's total military capacity. On the way north, contingents from numerous other
city-states joined Leonidas, including Phocians, Corinthians and Thebans. In total, Herodotus
mentions around 4700 men from other cities. So, if Herodotus is to be trusted, the entire force,
numbered around 7000 men, if not, they were likely still far more than 300.
The size of the Persian army is more complicated. Herodotus speaks of 2.5 million fighters,
accompanied by roughly the same number of auxiliaries. Modern historians consider this
simply impossible. This would have been 14-29% of all Persian men, including the elderly and
children. By comparison, Germany never deployed more than 16% of its men in the Second World War,
and the Germans did not live off agriculture like the Persians. Sending so many workers away
and risking their lives would have been madness. Because of this, more recent estimates range from
50'000 to 250'000 Persian soldiers. These estimates are usually based more on the logistical
capabilities of the Persians than on written sources about the battle. Despite their superiority,
the Persians could not break through the Greek blockade at Thermopylae until a traitor named
Ephialtes told them of a hidden path in the mountains that led past the pass. Ephialtes,
whose name means nightmare, became the stereotypical traitor of the Greeks.
When Leonidas learned that the Persians had found a way to bypass his men and attack from behind,
he faced a difficult decision. Should he retreat or stand his ground? As the third day dawned,
the Persians had nearly encircled the Greeks. Leonidas convened a council of war. Some of his
men spoke in favor of retreat and marched off while it was still possible. Leonidas must have
known that this was his last chance to retreat to safety. Nevertheless, he stayed, standing his
ground with about 2'000 men. Leonidas' last battle became an example of patriotism and heroic
sacrifice that even made it into Nazi propaganda. Hermann Göring, for instance, referred to Leonidas'
steadfastness when he was motivating the German soldiers surrounded by the Red Army at Stalingrad
in 1942 and 1943. Like Leonidas, they were expected to sacrifice themselves for their fatherland
and fight heroically to the death. Of course, this is highly ideologized and it is unclear
whether Leonidas was truly motivated by patriotism and heroism. To this day, historians
are puzzling over the real reason he did not retreat. There are several possible explanations.
For example, some historians believe Leonidas fought to the death because of a prophecy from
the Oracle of Delphi or that the Spartans had a law forbidding retreat. This is supposedly
confirmed by a monument to the battle that reads, quote, Go tell the Spartans, passerby,
we lie here, obedient to their laws. The Greek word remasi has sometimes been mistranslated as
laws, when it simply means words or things said. Today, most historians consider it unlikely that
such a law ever existed in Sparta because the Spartans had reportedly retreated in other cases.
A much more plausible explanation is that Leonidas stayed for pragmatic reasons.
The Greek strategy depended on holding the pass for as long as possible,
as this was the only way the Allies could prepare and mobilize their troops.
Moreover, as a leader of the alliance, Sparta had a duty to set a good example. If Leonidas had
given up Thermopylae without a fight, it would have jeopardized not only the Greek strategy,
but also Sparta's supremacy within the alliance. The Greek fleet would also have been at risk of
being cut off from the homeland, and the Persian cavalry would have been unhindered in their
pursuit of the retreating Greeks. Overall, there are many uncertainties surrounding the battle of
Thermopylae. Exactly what the last stand of Leonidas and his men looked like remains unclear.
Archaeologists have found Persian arrowheads on a hill just behind the narrowest point of the pass,
leading them to suspect that Leonidas fell back to this elevated position to stall the Persians for
as long as possible. After the last Greeks had fallen, the Persians moved on to the mainland,
plundering several cities, including Athens. It was not until the battles of Plataea and
Salamis that the Greek alliance succeeded in stopping the Persian invasion.