FATHER FISH is an advocate for natural aquariums. His research over 25 years provides a wealth of information about the creation and maintenance of natural aquariums. On this channel you will find scientific research as well as personal testimonials by countless hobbyists who have applied the Father Fish System and are enjoying its amazing benefits.
THE FATHER FISH SHOAL on Discord is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need. 24/7 live on Discord: https://discord.gg/father-fish-shoal
Should I fertilize my plants? Should I use a filter or should I not? What about all this
bubbling? Should I feed my fish? How can an anaerobic dirt environment provide nutrients
the plants need? Hello, come right on in. You're in father fish. I would like to spend a few minutes
with you discussing some of the issues that are coming before me from people who are having
problems setting up a deep substrate system. The very first advice I can offer
is to get a set of directions and follow them. Simply trying to wing this on your own is not
necessarily going to be effective. You can make mistakes. We have been able to troubleshoot this
system sufficiently to be able to prevent simple errors. For example, the amount of soil that is
put in the tank needs to be in a 55 gallon or less, no more than one inch. The composition of
the soil is also more involved than simply using dirt from the backyard or a garden. We have a
formula for that. To learn what this formula is and what the steps are, use the shoal. This is a
resource that is developed specifically to help people from do it right the first time. So go on
the shoal. The link is posted here and you'll be able to get an amazing amount of support. There
are dozens of people on that site anxious to help you to make this work and to make it right.
What about all this bubbling? It's perfectly normal and it is not methane. It is not what you
would see rising out of a swamp. These are gases, CO2 and nitrogen, that are arising primarily
due to the interaction of chemicals, minerals, compounds that are being put together for the
first time in a brand new tank and are reacting with each other. It is a process called chelation.
Chelation occurs when chemicals interact with each other and continue to interact until the primary
ingredients change and a stable condition is achieved. Its importance is that it creates
materials that are then much more adaptable to the cycle of life that's being developed in your
system. So don't worry about the gas bubbles. They're perfectly normal. They will go down,
slow down over a period of time. Now the CO2 may not. You may continue to get CO2 for a long,
long time because the substrate is a CO2 machine. That's a big part of what it's doing. It's breaking
down waste and part of that is creating carbon dioxide. CO2, of course, is a primary ingredient
in photosynthesis, which plants perform in order to be able to create nutrients, to create sugars
that nurture the plant and that also provide oxygen for the vertebrates and invertebrates
in the tank that require oxygen. It's part of the cycle and it's a critical part of it. Without CO2,
the plant cannot grow. Should I use a filter or should I not use a filter? The primary function
of a filter is to create a water flow. Now, in a planted tank, you don't want a high water flow,
but it is good to have a slow water flow. Typically, a power head is much too much flow.
You need something a bit slower than that. A sponge filter is best to provide that because
it provides a slower, more natural kind of flow in the water. The flow is important because it
allows all areas of the water to come in contact with the surface. Until the water comes in contact
with the surface, CO2 cannot be released and oxygen cannot be dissolved into the water.
So, it's critical for that to happen. One of the concerns that comes up routinely,
particularly among people who understand the importance of oxygen for plant roots,
is how can an anaerobic dirt environment provide nutrients the plants need O2,
they need oxygen. And that's true, they do. They get that oxygen from carbon dioxide. Remember,
this is a plant. Its job is to take in CO2, to break it down, and to release oxygen. In point
of fact, the little tiny cilia, which are the little tiny, almost invisible hair roots that
grow on the new roots of the plant, those are actually the agents of nutrition. They are the
parts of the plant that absorb, that take in nutrients. In order to be able to create precisely
the nutrient they want, they create an anaerobic environment around themselves in order to break
down the material so that they can ingest it, take it in. Should I fertilize my plants?
The problem with fertilizers is that it only is needed in an environment that lacks nutrients.
If you follow the system that we have designed, the substrate has a wealth of nutrients that are
built into it. There is no need at all for fertilizers. So far as the water column is
concerned, if you have floating plants, certainly they need nutrients. They will get all of the
nutrients they need from the waste, from vertebrates and invertebrates living in the
tank. Plants need animals, animals need plants. This is why I recommend that you start your tank
on day two with some fish, some snails, perhaps some other inverts. Not a lot, just a few. You
don't want to stress the environment. But having a few in there creates a nutrient base for the
plants to be able to be nurtured. You want to load the tank up with plants right at the beginning
and put a few fish in at the beginning. Now I say a few because you don't want to create a
stressful environment. However, after a week, if the fish you have put in are doing well,
put a few more in. It is not that a dirt and substrate can only manage a few vertebrates or
a few invertebrates. It can manage quite a lot, but you don't want to introduce them all at once
because you don't want to create an environment that is stressed. So do it slowly. In point of
fact, the argument can be made that putting a few plants in at a time is more desirable than
loading it up at the beginning, and undoubtedly that's true. However, plants are far more
forgiving and far more capable of surviving in a nutrient-poor environment for a period of time,
so long as they're adequately moisturized, that they're in water. These are aquatic plants.
They're going to be able to maintain their integrity, and they will pull out of the water
column whatever nutrients are available. So getting a few fish in there in the beginning
is very important for the plants. Plants absorb ammonia directly. The minute it's produced,
plants are taking it in. They take in ammonia. They take in nitrite. They take in nitrate. So
having lots of plants in the beginning, you need not worry about the ammonia level because it's
being taken care of by the plants. This is one of the reasons I recommend you do not become addicted
to testing your water, because if you have the elements that are needed in order for that system
to balance, you can depend on it that it will do so. If anything about it is out of balance,
it'll bring it back in balance. What happens if the water becomes murky? If it becomes brown?
It means that soil is leaching up through the sand into the water column. That's a perfectly natural
phenomenon. It will only come up, however, the height of its depth. If it's one inch of sand,
it will expand to two inches. The sand needs to be double the depth of the soil. One inch of soil
requires two inches of sand. Now, can you use an inch of sand and an inch of gravel? You can,
although the gravel really ought to be increased to two inches. You wind up in a 10-gallon tank
with six inches of substrate, kind of like what this is. It's really a bit much. Truthfully,
in a 10-gallon tank, you can do half an inch and then an inch or a little better of sand,
and that will be a perfectly adequate substrate for a 10-gallon tank. If the water is cloudy,
kind of from the beginning and is not clearing up, it is microscopic dust that is so fine,
it does not precipitate. It stays in the water column. Clay will do that. Clay is extremely fine
mineralization that is sufficiently fine. It has no effective weight and does not precipitate.
It does not fall down into the water column. A sponge filter, a fine mesh sponge filter,
will go a long way towards straightening that out. If it does not clear up, start doing some
small water changes, 10% at a time. You can do that every few days. In truth, you can do it every
day. If you do no more than a 10% water change, you're not going to be substantially affecting
the quality of the water. You will only be affecting what is in the water. So you can
do these small water changes without creating any stress or any changes in the aquarium.
That will help clear up that cloudiness problem. I have a tank here that's taking a long time to
clear up. I pulled a lot of plants out. It created a lot of cloudiness in the water,
which has been slow to resolve. It gradually is doing so. In this tank, I probably will do a
partial water change just to get that last little bit of cloudiness out of it. It's been about two
weeks like this. It's better, but only marginally better. You do not need to plant the plants
more than one inch into the sand. The roots will develop and reach down. Their job is to find
nutrients. So trust the plants. They know how to find food. Put them one inch into the soil.
In a new tank, if you plant them more deeply, all of that, remember the chemical processes
we were talking about, that generates a harsh environment that can kill the plant roots.
So don't plant them so far down that they're going to be affected by that early chelation
that's occurring. In time, after six months or so, when all of that is settled down,
you can plant all the way to the bottom and it'll be fine. Well, of course you should. Fish need to
eat. Now, are the fish getting some nutrients from the tank itself? They certainly are. There
are organic substances, little microscopic animals that are living on the plants. When
you put them in the tank, you're putting those little animals in with them. If you develop a
resurrection jar and begin bringing some wild material in and putting it in your tank,
you're going to be building biodiversity in your system. That's a vitally important component
to having a genuinely balanced tank.
I have people all the time who tell me that adding biodiversity increases the likelihood
of pathogens coming into your tank. In fact, precisely the opposite is true. They may come
into the tank, but they are not going to become a dominant problem. For example,
the ick parasite ravages fish tanks. It does so because those tanks have no effective
biodiversity. There is nothing in that tank to be able to control those baby parasites when
they're hatching out or the eggs when they're being laid. They lay the eggs, they hatch out,
and virtually 100% of the babies become fully parasitic. They enter the water column
without any competition at all, without any predation against them at all, and ravage the
fish. The kind of parasitic infestation that you find in an aquarium from ick, for example,
is virtually non-existent in nature. It does not exist to that extent in nature because
the natural environment contains a wide diversity of microbiotic life. 50% of microbiotic life
is parasitic. That is to say, amoeba paramecium, all of these little animals that are growing and
thriving in that environment, half of them are parasitic. Now, they are parasitic on each other.
They control each other, and that's the key. Having that environment in place means that
no one pathogen can take over the tank because it's being controlled. It's being controlled at
that earliest stage before it becomes something that can ravage the fish. While it's still just
hatching out or still just a baby, just tiny little critter, it's being parasitized by other
microfauna. So, a few may escape that. You may see a few spots. In this tank, I have had, I've seen
ick in the tank two or three times over the last 10 years or so brought in by a new fish.
I watch it carefully. There's one spot on a fish. I know it's ick because I know what it looks like.
The spot drops off, and I observe very carefully. What happens with absolute consistency is I never
see another spot. It never comes back. It never becomes an explosive population because it's being
controlled at that microbiotic level, which prevents more than very few of those little
parasites that are hatching out from actually becoming a problem in the water column. So,
biodiversity is absolutely fundamental to being able to have a healthy, balanced aquarium. It
controls pathogens rather than, of course, it brings them in, but it brings them in in a way
that is controlled, in a way that will not become a problem for your fish. It's really a matter of
trusting nature, and that is, in fact, what this experiment is all about. It's all about trusting
that nature is able to sustain itself in a way that is healthy, in a way that is dynamic,
in a way that is not deteriorating, but is continuing to flourish. That's the lesson to be
learned from a natural system. A natural aquarium is one that does not collapse upon itself unless
there is something dire that has occurred that is not a normal condition. Maintaining a natural
aquarium is a wonderful life experience. It teaches you the power and the integrity
of the natural world. Bring that into your home and enjoy the lessons to be learned from a natural
aquarium.