I want to start with something that isn't a listing and isn't a market report. It's a city council agenda packet.
In it there's a line saying the fee a builder pays to connect one new home to the water system should go from about eighteen hundred dollars to about fifty five hundred. And the fee to connect that same house to the sewer should go from five hundred and forty five dollars to forty three hundred.
That's one house. That's just the pipes. That's before anybody pours a footing.
And nobody's doing anything wrong there. Those fees hadn't been touched since the nineteen nineties. The growth used up capacity that was paid for a long time ago, and somebody has to build the next round.
But notice what just happened. A boom isn't something that happens to a place. A boom is a bill. And that bill gets split up and quietly handed out, and almost nobody tells you which part of it ends up being yours. Coming to you from the Top Realtor in Utah, Scott Steele, the best real estate agent in Utah for luxury, new construction, relocation, and all things Utah.
Real estate expert Scott Steele analyzes the Utah housing market, emphasizing that geographic constraints and a diversified economy create a unique, stable demand. He warns buyers that land scarcity prevents supply from simply catching up and highlights the importance of identifying hidden costs and construction quality issues common during boom periods.
I want to start with something that isn't a listing and it isn't a market report.
It's a city council agenda packet.
In it, there's a line saying the fee that a builder pays to connect one new home to
the water system should go from about $1,800 to about $5,500.
And the fee to connect that same house to the sewer should go from $545 to $4,300.
That's just one house.
That's just the pipes.
That's before anybody pours a footing.
And nobody's doing anything wrong there.
Those fees hadn't been touched since the 1990s.
The growth used up capacity that was paid for a long time ago and somebody has to build
the next round.
But notice what just happened.
A boom isn't something that happens at a place.
A boom is a bill and that bill gets split up and quietly handed out and almost nobody
tells you which part of it ends up being yours.
Now look, Utah is booming.
Completely true.
I'm not arguing with that whatsoever.
But if you click this video because you wanted the part that doesn't get said out loud, that's
what this is.
And I'll tell you right now, that's what I'm doing.
I'm not talking about the inversion.
I'm not telling you the mountains are close.
You already know all of that.
Every video you've ever watched has told you so.
And in this video, six things instead.
All six are things I deal with in writing with real clients and you won't find most
of them in a relocation article.
And the last one is the one that I'd fight for.
It decides whether this move works out for you financially in about seven years and almost
nobody thinks about it on the way in.
Stick around for that one.
And really quick if we haven't met yet, I am Scott Steele and I lead the Steele Group
here in Utah and most of my week is spent helping people work through this exact move.
Folks coming from California, from Texas, the Pacific Northwest, the East Coast, all
over the country and even the world.
And before I sold a single house, I spent years in construction so I tend to look at
this from underneath.
Grading, drainage, what a schedule does to framing.
That lens shows up in every single point that I talk about.
And here's what I believe and it sounds strange coming from somebody who sells real estate
in Utah.
Utah's problem isn't demand.
Everybody obsesses over demand.
Who is moving here?
How many?
From where?
Demand is the least interesting thing about this market.
Utah's story is a supply story and it's a physical one.
There's a hard literal limit on this place that most of the country doesn't have.
And once you can see it, everything else makes sense.
Why prices do what they do.
Why the state keeps announcing giant projects.
Why your commute is the way that it is.
So the order.
One, the fence around the boom and why Utah can't do what Texas does.
Number two, where the paychecks actually come from, which isn't the industry that you've
been sold.
Number three, where the growth is actually coming from, which isn't the state that you
might think.
And four, the bill, impact fees, assessments, charges that appear on a tax notice years
after you've purchased.
Then number five, what a boom does to the buildings.
That's right in my lane.
And number six, the one that I said I would fight for.
What happens when you go to sell something that a boom built?
Let's get into the constraint because nothing else works until you see it completely.
Okay.
Every comparison I hear goes the same way.
Utah's growing like Texas grew or like Phoenix grew, or the same thing happens over and over
again.
People come, builders build, supply catches up, prices settle in.
Now that's a reasonable assumption, but wrong here.
For a reason that has nothing to do with the housing market.
The federal government owns about 64% of the land here in Utah, 35 million acres out of
roughly 54 million total.
Second highest share of any state in the country, second to only, I believe it's Nevada.
And before somebody types it in, in the comments, yes, most of that is in the Southern and Eastern
parts of the state.
And the Wasatch Front counties have some of the lowest federal ownership in Utah.
That's the problem, not the relief.
Because here's what it means in practice.
The part of the state where the jobs are, where the water infrastructure is, where the
freeway is, is a strip, roughly 120 miles North to South, and in a lot of places, only
a few miles wide, pinned between a mountain range on one side and a lake or another mountain
range on the other.
That is the buildable inventory of the Wasatch Front, and they are not making any more of
it.
In Phoenix and Dallas, the land just keeps going until somebody gets tired.
When those metros get expansive, they build another ring 30 minutes out and the pressure
releases.
Utah doesn't have another ring.
It has a canyon, a mountain range, and so much more.
So there's three things that we can do with this.
First, stop waiting for supply to rescue you.
They'll just build more is the common thing that I hear from buyers sitting on the fence.
And along this corridor, it is not a strategy.
When land runs out, growth doesn't stop.
It goes up, it goes denser, or it goes further away.
Watch which of those three your city is choosing because that's what your street looks like
in about 10, 15, or 20 years.
Second, understand what holds value in a constrained market like this.
Not the house.
Houses are reproducible.
Land that cannot be replicated is the whole game in a place with a fence around it like
it is along the Wasatch Front.
Third, and this one surprises most people, the constraint is why you keep seeing enormous
projects announced here.
Transit expansions, redevelopment districts, giant mixed-use plans.
That's not boosterism.
When a state can't grow outward, the only move left is rebuilding the middle.
Once you see the pattern, you won't unsee it.
So the land is limited.
Next question everybody asks is what's driving the demand?
And that answer is the most misunderstood thing about moving to Salt Lake City or moving
to Utah.
And I would bet money that many people have it all wrong.
Okay, ask anybody in the country what Utah's economy is, and you get one answer.
Tech.
Silicon slopes.
The campuses down by the point of the mountain from Draper to Lehigh and outward from there.
And that is the venture money.
That's real.
It has genuinely changed this state, the state of Utah, forever.
But it isn't the payroll.
Go look at the largest employers in Utah.
Number one is Intermountain Health, running more than 20 hospitals in the state.
Number two, the University of Utah, academic side, and the health system altogether, well
north of 40,000 people.
Number three, the state of Utah itself.
More than 20,000 people across dozens of agencies.
Then you've got countless other major employers that are employing tons of people, including
universities and Hill Air Force Base, and so many in the private sector as well.
So healthcare, higher education, government, retail, and then tech.
Tech isn't in the top five.
So there's a national narrative pointed at one industry, and underneath it, the thing
cutting most of the paychecks in this area is a hospital system, a university, and the
state of Utah.
So two things fall out of that.
If you're relocating for a job, be honest about which economy you're joining.
A tech role here is real, but it's a smaller slice of the pie than the marketing suggests.
Have the offer in hand before you come.
If you're buying, this is the part that almost nobody says.
Hospital systems, universities, and state government don't lay off in cycles the way
that tech does.
They're the most rate-insensitive and recession-proof employers in the state of Utah.
So the housing demand anchored around the big medical campuses, the universities, the
government complexes, has a floor under it that the tech corridor just doesn't have.
Now, that's not me saying this to avoid the tech corridor.
I've helped plenty of people buy here, and it's been fantastic.
It's me saying that if you've watched tech lay off somewhere else, and you're wondering
whether Utah's exposed in the same way that Austin was or Seattle got exposed, the honest
answer is that this state's employment base is far more diversified and maybe a little
more boring than its reputation.
And boring is a compliment when you're signing a 40-year note.
Okay, quick thing before point number three.
If this is useful, subscribe to this channel.
It genuinely helps this reach other people figuring out the same move that you are.
But beyond that, comment down below.
Tell me which county or city that you're looking at or what you're actually stuck on and what
are your questions.
I'm not saying that as a formality.
I read every comment, and those questions are how I decide what to make next.
Half of the videos on this channel exist because people are asking in the comments.
And let me introduce myself properly since we're about a third of the way into this video
and you've been generous with your time.
I am Scott Steele.
I lead the Steele Group here in Utah, and my team and I work with buyers and sellers
every single day across Salt Lake County, Utah County, Summit County, Wasatch County,
Davis, Weber, all along the Wasatch Front and the Wasatch Back.
That's the ground that I'm standing on, not a headline.
It's actual transactions that we're doing every single day.
And I'll mention now because it comes up constantly that I keep a vetted network of agents in
other states and more on that at the end of this video.
Also, all of this is the kind of thing I normally cover one-on-one, and it's a lot to hold on
to in your head just from a single video.
So the reference version is in the Utah Relocation Guide.
Counties side-by-side, how property taxes work, water, school districts, commute corridors
along the Wasatch Front.
The link is in the description below.
Download it.
Save it to your home screen on your phone just like any other app.
It is an incredibly useful tool.
It's the exact resource that I send every single relocation client before their first
visit.
So it's free.
Nothing weird.
Just download it.
Use it.
It is going to help you.
All right.
Point number three.
This one changed how I think about this market altogether.
Okay.
Spend 10 minutes reading about Utah and you come away with one story, Californians.
Everybody's moving here from California, bidding up the houses with cash.
That's the engine.
That's the narrative.
I've told a version of that story myself and there's some truth in it.
California is our largest single source of inbound movers and it isn't really all that
close.
But here's the number almost nobody in real estate quotes.
In the most recent full year of state population data, Utah grew by about 44,000 people.
57% of that was natural change, births minus deaths.
Only 43% was in migration from everywhere combined.
Every other state and every other country, 43%.
And the state's demographers flagged that as a genuine shift because it's the first
time this decade natural change has been the primary driver rather than in migration.
So the story everybody tells is about the smaller half.
And one more number.
The one I'd act on, Utah County by itself took about 36% of the state's entire growth
that year.
Roughly 16,000 people.
Salt Lake County, which is bigger, added about 10,000 people.
And why that matters to you on a Tuesday while you're looking at houses?
Well, first, the demand under this market has no off switch.
If California's economy turns or remote policies swing back, migration slows.
It's already slowed.
But household formation from people who grew up here arrives on schedules every single
year whether or not anybody outside of Utah is paying attention.
The buyer for your house in seven years, statistically, is probably somebody from Utah.
That's a sturdier floor than a migration wave.
And it's why I've never bought the everybody leaves and prices collapse argument.
Second, it shapes what gets built.
When a builder underwrites demand from households forming locally, they build for that household,
which is why you can find a four bedroom on a small lot in the state all day long.
And why a genuinely well built smaller home is strangely hard to find.
If you're coming as a couple or downsizing or single, you're shopping the thin part of
this market.
Plan for a longer search.
Nobody warns people.
And then they're frustrated four weeks in.
Third, the practical one.
Know who you're bidding against.
Relocators assume their competition is other relocators.
Usually it isn't.
It's a local move up buyer who's owned through this entire run, is sitting on real equity,
knows the street, knows the builder, knows which side of that road floods and can close
without a home sale contingency.
That's a different opponent.
You don't beat them with a bigger number.
You beat them with cleaner terms and faster underwriting with an agent that's experienced
along your side.
All right.
Land is limited.
Jobs are steadier than advertised.
Growth is homegrown.
All arguably good news.
So let's do the other thing because point four is where the boom starts sending invoices.
Okay.
Back to that agenda that I spoke about at the very beginning of this video.
The price on the sign isn't the price of the house.
Everybody knows that vaguely.
Almost nobody knows the specific ways and in a fast growing state, the specific ways
can multiply.
Layer one, impact fees, one time charges, a city assesses a new construction to pay
for the water, the sewer, the storm drain, the roads, and the parks that houses will
use.
Salt Lake City right now is weighing its first water impact fee increase since 1999.
Water from roughly 1,800 to roughly 5,500.
Sewer on a single family connection from 545 to 4,300.
Storm water from about 374 to nearly 2,000 per quarter acre.
So new construction is getting more expensive and this is why.
And Salt Lake City isn't unusual.
Cities all along the corridor are redoing their impact fee studies right now for the
same reason at the same exact time.
Capacity the boom consumed was paid for decades ago and replacing it costs current dollars
in today's money.
Builders pay those fees, which means you pay for them.
They're just inside of the price for that home that you're buying.
Layer number two, and this is the ambush, assessment areas and special service districts.
In some newer master planned areas, the infrastructure got financed through bonds and repayment shows
up as a line on the property tax notice for that parcel.
Not a separate bill, a line item that you have to be looking for.
There are many communities where this has happened.
Layer three, community charges in master plan communities.
Several of the bigger ones here have a fee triggering at closing on top of regular dues,
sometimes calculated off of the sales price, sometimes charged on resale as well.
It's in the governing documents.
It's disclosed.
It's also on page 40 of something nobody opens on a deadline.
And a lot of these communities have both a master association and a sub association for
your village and people budget for just one of those.
Think Daybreak or Firefly and countless other major master plan developments throughout
the state of Utah.
They all carry some of these things to one degree or another, which is why you need somebody
to guide you through those things.
Now here's exactly how I check it and you can do all of this yourself as well.
Pull the parcel on the county assessor or recorder website.
It's free.
It's public.
Read the tax notice line by line, not the total.
Any district or assessment on that parcel will be listed.
Ask a title company for the CC&Rs and every fee addendum.
Ask for a reserve study on the HOA and ask early, not on the last day of your due diligence
period.
Utah contract deadlines don't forgive a slow reader.
New construction?
Ask the builder for the fee sheet, not the price sheet.
Different document.
Then one question.
What's the full monthly obligation at this address?
Mortgage, taxes, insurance, master association, sub association, any assessment, one number
in writing.
And ask the city when they last updated their impact fee study.
If the answer is we're doing it right now, the phase behind yours will price differently
than yours did.
Worth knowing before you pick that lot.
Okay.
That's the money side.
Now the physical side, because this next one is mine and it's where I stop sounding like
a real estate agent.
Okay, from roughly 2020 through 2022, this state built as fast as it was physically capable
of doing so.
Not as fast as it wanted to, as fast as the labor, the lumber and the daylight allowed.
I want to be fair because I know builders I've worked alongside really good ones and
most were doing honest work in genuinely strange conditions.
This is not a builders are crooks type of video, but when a schedule compresses, it
doesn't compress evenly.
Think about what gets squeezed.
A crew that ran one job is running for the excavation subcontractor who had three days
on a pad now has one or two materials arrive out of order.
So trades stack on top of each other instead of following each other as designed.
And the pattern I care about is this.
The things that got shortened first are almost always the things that you can't see down
the road.
Afterwards, compaction and feel on a cut and fill lot.
Half these subdivisions sit on bench to pads where they cut the uphill side and filled
the downhill side and how well that feel got compacted and tested is invisible.
The day that you tore your home, the final grade, whether dirt actually slopes away from
the foundation or got backfield loose, settled over two winters and now slopes back toward
the house.
Flashing details at windows, at roof or roof to wall transitions at the deck ledger, wherever
on the house and drying time before drywall framing that went up in a wet spring and got
closed in on a schedule instead of on a moisture reading.
So here's what I do on a home built in that window and you can do most of it as well.
I walk the full perimeter before I go inside.
I'm looking at the dirt.
Does it fall away from the foundation or has it settled into a trough up against it?
Where do downspouts actually discharge right at the wall or well away from it?
Is there a gap opening where backfield dropped?
I look at where the driveway meets the garage slab and where the front walk meets the porch.
Those joints are the first place differential settlement announces itself first.
I look at the neighbors, fence lines, retaining walls, curb and gutter along the street.
Three wavy fence lines in a row is the ground talking and that's not a house specific problem.
I asked whether the lot was cut or filled.
The plat and the subdivisions geotechnical report will tell you and your agent can and
should get both of those for you.
In fact, in Draper, just a few years ago, a couple of homes even slid right down the
mountain because of all of these problems that I'm describing in this video.
On paperwork, ask for the builder's warranty documents and read the transfer and dispute
language.
People buying a three or four year old home assume that they inherited coverage.
Frequently, they did not.
And frequently, the dispute process is not the one they're picturing.
None of that means don't buy from that era.
It means you inspect it differently than a house built in 2015.
And you hire the inspector who gets on the roof and into the attic, not the one who just
does the fast job.
Okay, last one.
The one I said I'd fight for and the thing that genuinely separates people who do well
here from people who feel stuck in seven years.
Every conversation about a boom is about buying in one.
What it'll cost.
Will I get outbid?
Is this the top?
Almost nobody asks the other question.
What happens when you go to sell something that a boom built?
Picture the subdivision 400 homes built over about 24 months, eight floor plans, same three
elevations, same era of finishes, because everybody ordered from the same design center
in the same 18 month window.
Run the clock forward five to seven years, which is roughly how long somebody holds onto
a home before life moves them, whether it's a job change or a second kid or aging parents
or whatever the case may be.
Those 400 houses hit their first resale window at about the same time.
Same street, same plans, same everything.
And here's what gets people.
Your competition isn't the resale two doors down.
Your competition is the builder.
Because in that same corridor, the builder opened the next phase or the next subdivision
and builders don't compete on that list price.
They compete with a rate by down closing costs, paid concessions, a design center allowance,
sometimes a finished basement.
They'll spend 30 or $40,000 to move a house without ever changing the number on the sign
that matters enormously.
And here's why the comps look healthy.
Every recorded sell price in that neighborhood looks strong, but the net the buyer actually
experience is well below it because 35,000 in concessions doesn't show up in a sales
price the way that a price cut does.
So you list against comps that look great and you sit and you can't figure out why it's
not selling.
Well, that's why you're competing against a discount that's invisible in the data.
So you've got three defenses against this.
All of them have to go in place on the way in because none are available to you on the
way out.
Number one, buy the lot that the builder can't reproduce.
The end of the cul-de-sac, backing open space, a trail corridor, a drainage easement nobody
will ever build on.
The extra deep lot, the one with real grade separation from the house behind it.
Everything inside the walls is reproducible.
Positioning isn't.
The lot is not.
In seven years when 11 identical floor plans list at once, the lot is the entire difference
every single time.
Number two, pay attention to the phase timing.
Buying phase one of a 14 phase community means selling into the builder's marketing budget
for a decade.
Buying the last phase means the builder is leaving and taking the incentives with them.
That makes it easier for you to sell.
Ask how many phases are planned?
How many platted lots remain?
How far along are they?
Public records?
Your agent can and should pull all of this for you so that you know what you're buying
into.
Number three, put upgrade money where the builder incentive package doesn't go.
The lot premium, the structural things that you can't add later on.
The extra bay window, the taller basement ceiling, real deck footings.
Those hold up.
The countertop upgrade doesn't because in seven years the buyer's comparison is a brand
new house with this year's countertops and $30,000 of somebody else's money on the table.
The honest summary of point number six is this.
Buying in a boom is easy.
The market carries you.
Selling what a boom built is where the decision you made on the way in either pays you or
costs you a lot of money.
And the people I've watched do well in this state are almost never the ones who bought
the best house.
They're the ones who bought the best positioning.
So six things, the land has a fence around it and that explains nearly everything else
about this market.
The paychecks come from the hospitals and the universities and the state far more than
from the tech industry, which is a steadier foundation than Utah gets credit for.
More than half of the growth is being born here in Utah, not moving here.
So demand has a floor and that's good for the real estate market.
The boom gets billed later though impact fees and assessments you have to go looking for
buildings that went up fast, get inspected differently.
And the lot that you pick decides how this goes when you come to and the lot that you
pick decides how this goes when you end up selling.
And none of that is a reason to stay away.
I chose this place on purpose to live here with my family.
It's a reason to come in with your eyes wide open because this is a market that rewards
preparation a lot more than it rewards enthusiasm.
Now, if you're sitting there thinking, okay, that's the statewide picture, but I still
don't know whether I should be looking in Salt Lake County or Utah County or up in Summit
or Wasatch counties, that's the right next question.
And it's the hardest one.
Those are three different markets with three different tax pictures, three different water
situations, three different commute realities.
That comparison is laid out side by side in the Utah relocation guide.
The link is in the description below.
It's free.
Take it and use it.
And if you're further along, if you've got a timeline or a house to sell somewhere else,
or you're deciding between two specific lots this month, just reach out.
My team and I are here to be your real estate resource of choice.
My contact information is in the description below.
Reach out anytime and let's start the conversation.
No pressure and no sales pitch.
I just want to help you get it right.
That includes the other end of this as well.
Like I mentioned, I keep a vetted network of agents in other states everywhere from
California, the Pacific Northwest, Texas, Florida, Michigan.
It doesn't matter.
So if you need to sell before you buy here, I'll make sure that you have the right person
working for you on both ends of this move and it costs you nothing.
And if this video helps you, please subscribe, share it with whoever else is in this decision
with you and drop me a comment.
I really do read all of those.
And if you're looking to learn more about life in Utah, check out these videos next
and I'll see you in the next one.