Psychiatrist Fact Checks Mental Health Slop

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Psychiatrist Dr. Eric Bender analyzes viral online content and fact-checks common mental health misinformation, debunking myths and separating psychological science from misleading advice.
#Psychiatry #MentalHealth #Psychology #FactCheck #MentalHealthAwareness #DrEricBender #Psychiatrist #Wellness #Science #HealthEducation
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDr. Eric Bender, a psychiatrist, fact-checks AI-generated mental health content, debunking \"AI slop\" and misleading tropes. He corrects misconceptions regarding psychiatric medications, personality disorders, and trauma, while providing evidence-based grounding techniques and explaining the systemic reasons why people are turning to AI for mental health support.
Comments are disabled for this video.
That makes no sense whatsoever.
This is garbage.
I don't know what is going on with this guy.
It's loaded up with a lot of nonsense,
fake data, fake words, fake numbers.
I'm psychiatrist and therapist, Dr. Eric Bender.
Let's fact check some AI slop.
All right, let's watch this first video.
Psychology facts, number one.
If you don't dream, you might have a personality disorder.
Studies show everybody dreams.
The difference is not everybody can recall their dreams.
In fact, some people with personality disorders,
borderline personality disorder, for example,
they do dream and in fact, it's often nightmares.
If a baby stares at you for a long time,
it means you are attractive.
Babies are looking at certain things
because they're finding them interesting.
Not a psychology fact.
Enough of this.
Next.
One of the best mental health tips I've ever read.
If you feel like you hate everyone, eat.
That makes no sense whatsoever.
If you feel like everyone hates you, sleep.
If we could all sleep on demand, that would be amazing.
This is weird.
If you feel overwhelmed by your thoughts, write them down.
That's actually not bad.
There's something about getting them out of your head,
getting them onto paper.
I often tell patients who have insomnia,
write down everything that's on your mind before bed.
Sometimes that can really help.
If you feel like you're not enough, list your achievements.
I don't think achievements being listed
are gonna help necessarily.
So that's actually a big problem
when people feel that all they are is their achievements,
that they only deserve to be thought of or loved
when they've accomplished things.
If you feel unloved, do something kind for yourself.
This sounds more like trade information
that got off of Hallmark cards
as opposed to working through something.
If you feel invisible, help someone in need.
If you feel too much pressure, do a simple task.
I don't know how you're gonna get up
and do all these things.
It sounds miserable.
And honestly, that is when I start to see people
that come to therapy because they feel
like they can't do any of these things
that they're being told in this video to do.
Next.
This is supposed to be Sigmund Freud talking
to his student, Carl Jung, back in the day.
When Freud and Jung finally met after much correspondence,
they said that they spoke for 13 hours straight.
They sat together and just talked.
And so there was this incredible bond right away.
Freud considered Jung his pupil, his disciple in a way.
And then there was a split later on
as the ideas developed in different directions.
I imagine someone fed into AI images of Freud
and images of Jung and came up with these images
and the glasses and the beard.
That's kind of the classic trope of the psychiatrist
because Freud did have a beard and wore glasses.
Freud had these ideas that there were developmental stages
as you grew up.
Starting at a young age, there was the oral phase.
Then there was the anal phase.
And then later there's a latency phase.
And it was all about libido and sexual drive.
Jung said, no, there's more than just sexual drive
in libido.
There's also psychological energy.
There's a universal energy.
Freud said it was very personal, unconscious, individual.
And Jung said, well, we do have an individual unconscious,
but there's also a collective unconscious.
Freud wanted Jung to really espouse his ideas
and to bring them forward,
particularly in the psychoanalytic community.
And when Jung didn't, that was really a break
from the two of them.
Next video.
Let's learn SSRIs, because half of you are swallowing
brain altering chemicals daily
and don't even know why your orgasms disappeared.
I don't know what is going on with this guy.
If I walked into his office and this is the way
he treated me, I would not want to hang out with him.
What usually happens with these medications
is it can affect libido,
meaning someone's desire for sexual activity.
These medications can affect orgasm in the sense
they can delay orgasm.
And sometimes for some people, they can't climax.
You don't know this until you're going to try.
But again, everybody is an individual.
Not everyone gets side effects.
Basic ones are fluoxetine, sertraline, escitalopram,
citalopram, paroxetine, fluvoxamine.
Oh, and don't forget them,
because I'm going to pimp the out of you
at the end of this video.
This AI character's use of pimping is actually appropriate.
In the medical education system,
the word pimping means that people senior to you.
So if you're a med student, it might be residents,
might be attending doctors.
If you're a resident,
it might be some of your senior residents.
They're asking you questions
about the topics you're discussing.
It's called pimping.
And that is often done in front of the group of people
you're walking around with.
But serotonin is an instant happiness.
You're depressed, lazy, good for nothing.
He's using the voice of somebody who's depressed
that often uses his negative voice towards themselves.
So that language is really sharp and harsh.
And that's actually how people who are depressed often feel.
SSRIs treat depression, anxiety, panic attacks,
OCD, PTSD, social anxiety, and more.
That is correct.
SSRIs treat all those things.
It doesn't mean that it's a panacea.
It's not gonna cure you of everything.
Oftentimes, combinations of medication and therapy
work really well, particularly for anxiety.
Serotonin can increase BDNF,
brain-derived neurotrophic factor.
That's what actually helps nerve cells repair
and sustain their lives.
The big SSRI side effects with the three S's,
stomach, sex, and serotonin syndrome.
Serotonin syndrome is when there's a flood of serotonin
that actually causes people
to have a pretty severe reaction.
You might find high fevers and sweating and muscle rigidity.
You do need to go to the emergency room or call 911
if that ever happens.
Again, I'm not prescribing something
where the risk of something terrible happening
is outweighing the risk of something good.
Next video.
Ever wondered why some people can't stop overthinking?
Psychology says it's actually a side effect
of high intelligence.
Maybe it's a side effect of high intelligence.
Maybe it's anxiety, but there is no evidence to say
that somebody overthinking
means they have a high intelligence quotient.
Every decision triggers dozens of mental simulations.
What if I do this?
What if it goes wrong?
What if they think I'm weird?
This actually sounds a lot more like anxiety
than it does someone having high intelligence.
You can have anxiety
no matter what your intelligence level is.
It's your prefrontal cortex working overtime,
analyzing outcomes faster than your emotions can process.
The prefrontal cortex is a part of your brain
right here above your orbital area, above your eyes.
It helps us with organization of things.
It's very normal for anybody
to think about events in their lives,
to go back to conversations they had in the day.
It's when you get stuck, when you can't sleep,
when you keep going over something
again and again and again and again.
That's called a rumination.
People who are very anxious have a lot of ruminations,
and it's because they're actually really lonely.
Sometimes that ruminative language,
it's almost keeping them company.
The same mind that overthinks everything
is also the one that understands the world the deepest.
I don't see any evidence for that.
I'd love to see studies that suggest that.
So next time you catch yourself lost in thought,
don't say, I'm broken.
Say, my brain is just doing its job.
That actually is pretty good advice.
I tell patients all the time,
the way we talk to ourselves is really important.
If you can be kind to yourself,
you're more likely to be confident
and to try different things.
Next video.
Did you know trauma survivors develop
what scientists call supernatural
pattern recognition abilities?
Okay, unfortunately, trauma survivors
have a lot going on in their lives,
and it is not supernatural.
It comes from having been through a pretty awful experience,
and they want to make sure it doesn't happen again.
Chronic hypervigilance rewires neural pathways
to process micro expressions.
The chronic hypervigilance is being described here
like it's a gift.
It's actually incredibly difficult for somebody
who is chronically hypervigilant.
They're looking at everything as if it is threatening.
They have to keep their eyes peeled.
They're looking over their shoulders.
You see this sometimes with people who have been at war.
Hypervigilance is actually one of the criteria
to diagnose post-traumatic stress disorder.
They can detect threats others completely miss.
They're not seeing dangers other people don't see.
They're actually seeing dangers
that maybe other people don't see
because they're not necessarily dangerous.
People who have been traumatized
are really concerned about being hurt again,
even in situations where there's not a need to worry.
They can instantly sense when someone is lying,
predict relationship outcomes
within minutes of meeting people.
This is garbage.
You can't predict relationships
within minutes of meeting somebody.
And also in terms of knowing whether someone is lying or not,
in some of the worst cases of traumatized individuals,
meaning there's a complex post-traumatic stress disorder
where they've been repeatedly traumatized,
they don't necessarily assume everyone's lying,
but they can't trust other people.
Threat detection systems have been neurologically enhanced
through peer survival necessity.
Neurologically enhanced is way overstating this.
Neurologically affected, yes.
I don't know one person who's been traumatized
that says, I have these amazing abilities now.
Next video.
Anxiety is nothing more than your mind traveling
to a future that hasn't happened yet
and sounding an alarm in a body that is perfectly safe.
I don't know if I agree with that.
You're not necessarily perfectly safe when you have anxiety.
Anxiety is what helped us evolve
when we were out hunting for food
and we didn't want to get eaten by a saber-toothed cat.
So not all anxiety is just made up.
When you catch yourself worrying,
you are leaving the present moment.
I imagine this video has 7 million views
because people think, oh, a monk,
he's got it figured out.
He knows how not to be anxious.
And a lot of people suffer from anxiety.
A lot of these AI generated videos,
aside from the really bad cartoonish ones,
generate these images that look like humans.
So we see these images and it sounds like real advice
and we really want that advice.
Sometimes we're too afraid to ask for it.
So we might just take the advice of the AI
just because it looks like a human being.
You are wandering into the what ifs,
letting your thoughts spin until they become a storm
that pulls you out of control.
That's a good description of anxiety.
A lot of times people do have the what if.
What if this happens?
What if that happens?
What I try to help people do is think,
if this happens, then you would do what?
If that happens, then what would you do?
When the mind begins to race, count backward.
That's one way people can try to tame their anxiety
when they start to feel it.
There are a few other things I talk to people about.
One is having them inhale for a count of, say,
three seconds through your nose
and then exhaling for twice as long through your mouth.
If you're in the moment
and you're really stuck and you're panicking,
there is the 3-3-3 rule
where you can name three things you see,
name three things you hear,
and move three body parts.
I move my hand, I move my whole arm, I'm turning my head.
And being aware of those things,
it just brings you out of the moment
that you're stuck in to a place where you're grounded.
Instead of asking, what if it fails?
Ask yourself, what if it all works out?
That is something I ask people
when they're focused very much on the negative
and they're really anxious.
I say, wait, what happens if you actually do
the things you wanna do?
What if it goes well?
Sometimes it can jar people to say,
oh, I haven't really thought about that.
And for everyone who has been following this journey,
my new book, The Way Back.
You always have to be aware of any video
that's just trying to sell you a product.
There can be some good advice,
but it sounds like in the end,
this AI-generated monk wants you to buy
his AI-generated book.
Next video.
If you were born in 2008,
you grew up during constant change.
You learned early to stay alert instead of relaxed.
You often understand what someone feels
before they explain it.
This is bananas, B-A-N-A-N-A-S.
There's nothing distinct about 2008.
I think what they're talking about
is what's called the cohort effect.
That means that a group of people
who were born in a certain time
have had certain experiences
that maybe other people have not.
People born before the depression, the Great Depression,
the way they dealt with money or saw money
is different than people who did not go through that.
Your mind replays moments, analyzes reactions,
and searches for meaning long after others have moved on.
Psychologically.
That could be anybody,
and also that was really weird
with this dude's head exploding.
The cohort effect might be happening
for someone who was born in 2008
in the sense that they were around 11 or 12
when COVID happened,
and that was really impacting lots of people,
not just those born in 2008.
We're still learning the effects
of what it was like to grow up as a kid
during the COVID era.
We do know that some kids are behind in academics
and reading and writing,
but again, it's not distinct
for just people born in this year.
Hey, Kyle, my name's Will.
I'm gonna be your nurse today.
How are you feeling?
Oh, great.
Another idiot trying to poison me with meds.
Listen, Will, can you please just get this over with?
This seems to be a training video
for people in nursing school.
How do you deescalate a situation?
This patient, this mock patient,
is supposed to have, per the video, schizophrenia.
A lot of times with schizophrenia,
there is, in fact, a feeling of persecution
or a feeling of paranoia,
and I think they do get that right.
I'm just used to, in emergency rooms,
seeing people who have positive symptoms of schizophrenia.
That means things that other people don't experience,
so they might have the hallucinations
or they might have voices that they're hearing.
Typically, patients have more auditory hallucinations
than visual hallucinations,
and visual hallucinations are not very distinct.
Sometimes they can be blurred.
Sometimes they can be in the background,
but auditory hallucinations are way more common.
And all these stupid meds
you keep trying to shove down my throat.
I know what you're trying to do.
So this is something we can see
with patients who are schizophrenic
or patients who have psychosis,
is this paranoia of people trying to do something
and then people trying to give them medication,
trying to take them over.
One thing that's noticeable here,
and I think it's actually more an artifact of the video,
there's that pause between when the student says something
and when the patient says something.
What exactly do you think we're trying to do?
Don't play dumb, Will.
Sometimes in real life,
someone with schizophrenia or psychosis does pause
because they're responding to internal stimuli.
They might be hearing things inside or voices,
and it takes them a while to focus on your voice
because they're hearing something else.
Next video.
This video is incorporating sounds
that about 20% of the population
would find soothing or relaxing or pleasurable.
This is called ASMR, Autonomous Sensory Meridian Response.
The people who hear this,
they start to feel this feeling,
it starts with their scalp,
it's a little bit of a tingling,
might go down to their neck,
and they feel pleasure or calmness or relaxation,
just hearing that noise.
About 80% of the people,
they either don't find it pleasurable,
that they could take it or leave it,
or they find it kind of gross,
and I'm in that category.
So the ADHD one had all these colorful things,
but not everybody with ADHD
feels like they're bouncing off the walls.
A lot of times people feel like
they have inattentive type ADHD
where they can't pay attention.
This is a pretty common stereotype of OCD
that everybody with OCD,
obsessive compulsive disorder, is organized.
There are lots of different kinds of OCD,
and there are plenty of people
who are disorganized that have OCD.
Obsessive compulsive disorder
means you have an obsession,
there's a thought,
and you have discomfort from the thought.
The compulsion is the behavior
or what you do to try to get rid of the discomfort
from the obsession.
Sometimes people have obsessive thoughts,
and the compulsion is not something that's external.
Classic example is people feel dirty and contaminated,
that's the obsession.
Compulsion is they wash their hands.
Sometimes you don't see people
doing the compulsive behavior.
It could be a checking in their head.
It could be ruminating on the same thing.
It could be that they have to count to a certain number.
So it's not all about organization.
Next video.
Scientists discovered that chronic sadness
triggers a chemical war inside you
that can kill you decades early.
This is really crazy.
Yes, being sad for too long,
it doesn't feel good.
It doesn't necessarily mean it's something horrible.
When people lose a loved one, for instance,
they're grieving, they're gonna be sad for a long time.
There are reasons people are sad.
It's being human.
When you're depressed,
your brain floods your bloodstream with cortisol,
a stress hormone designed to save your life in emergencies.
But when it stays elevated for months, it becomes poison.
This is not the complete picture.
In some cases, depression, cortisol is very high.
In other cases of depression, cortisol is very low.
This hormone destroys your immune system from the inside,
making you 62% more likely to end up hospitalized
with severe infections.
Let's take a closer look.
I see 62% of something.
I see a lot of numbers that don't mean anything.
And I see a whole bunch of razzles in these columns here.
This number 4016Z looks like a percent sign.
76% one, this makes no sense.
It's loaded up with a lot of nonsense,
fake data, fake words, fake numbers.
The danger in giving information like this
is that people start to feel like, oh, this is important.
I better learn what's going on here.
But there's nothing of value here.
This video feels more like a scare tactic
to try to make sure, don't be sad.
And that's really impossible.
Next video.
The way a narcissist starts the day can tell you a lot
because for them, mornings are not always about peace.
You can't necessarily tell a narcissist
because of the way they get up
and grumpily look at their phone.
They make their mood everyone's problem.
If they are irritated, the whole house feels it.
Some of this can be true.
It's not every day, but narcissistic individuals
can sometimes make people feel like it's their job
to take care of that person.
A lot of narcissists have an underlying vulnerability
or a fragility and people around them sense it
and feel like, oh, we need to make sure dad's okay.
Mom's okay.
We need to make sure everything's okay.
Otherwise things could turn horribly wrong all of a sudden.
They act normal after a cruel night.
You are still hurting.
They are making coffee like nothing happened.
This video to me is depicting more
of what's called malignant narcissism.
It's someone who's narcissistic
and shows a lot of the traits,
almost on that end of lack of empathy
and not caring about other people.
More towards the psychopathic end.
So this is not all narcissists.
Next video.
The most dangerous thing that can happen
in home is not a fight.
It's a husband who has to beg for affection.
Okay, right now I get a little bit
of a red pill vibe from this.
The woman might also feel pretty terrible
if she has to beg for affection.
Anybody would feel terrible.
Affection is not a reward you hand out
when he gets everything right.
It is the oxygen that keeps a marriage alive.
When there's no room for affection,
there is something that needs to be worked on.
When I do couples therapy with people,
I'll talk to couples about,
imagine you have a child.
If you do have a kid,
you need to give that kid attention.
You need to see that child.
You also have to imagine yourself,
your couple as a child.
Are you giving that child enough attention?
When a man loses hope and closeness,
he stops fighting for connection.
So this is getting a little ridiculous.
This video feels like it fell
out of the manosphere a little bit.
The important point is that both people need affection.
It needs to go both ways.
Let's move on.
If I'm going to exercise,
I should eat first.
If I'm going to cook,
I should have coffee first
so I can have energy to cook.
If I'm going to make coffee,
I should clean the coffee maker.
So right away,
I will say that I have had patients tell me
this is how their brain works.
Certain patients with ADHD,
they feel like they start thinking about one thing
and it goes to another
and it goes to another.
If I'm going to clean the coffee maker,
I should clean the kitchen.
If I'm going to clean the kitchen,
I should clean the apartment.
If I'm going to clean the apartment,
I should put some music.
This could also be someone who's quite anxious.
There's often a presentation of somebody
that can look like anxiety
or it can look like ADHD
and you have to sort through that.
Is there an underlying sense of worry
or is someone actually having just ADHD symptoms
which can be either hyperactive,
impulsive type.
You think about that classic picture
of a kid bouncing off the walls,
seeming like they're driven by a motor
or is it someone who's predominantly inattentive?
Meaning they can't focus on
what's going on in front of them.
Some people have asked me,
is there an uptick in the diagnosis of ADHD?
We have looked for it more.
We've now included women more and girls more
because it used to be thought that,
wait, girls don't present with this hyperactive picture.
So we're including more people.
We dropped the number of requirements
from say six criteria to five.
And also the language in the DSM
changed from severely impaired
to having your functioning impaired.
That change sometimes incorporates more people.
So maybe we're catching people
that have always had these symptoms,
but now we're just aware of it.
Let's move on.
I am Sertraline.
I am an SSRI,
a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor.
I increase serotonin levels inside your brain.
That is an important thing to correct.
Serotonin is a neurochemical,
it's made in your brain
and it does have an implication in mood.
These medications affect the way serotonin is transported,
affects the way the receptors react with serotonin.
It used to be taught,
and this was picked up largely
because of the pharmaceutical industry,
that these medications increase
the level of serotonin in the brain.
It's much more complicated.
I am considered a first-line treatment
for depression and many anxiety disorders.
That is true.
SSRIs are the first-line treatment for this
if you're using medication.
Sertraline is the generic name.
The brand name of this medication is Zoloft.
Other medications in this category,
you might recognize brand names,
Prozac, Lexapro, and Haxel.
I do not work overnight.
It usually takes two to four weeks to notice improvement.
That is true.
Anywhere from two to six weeks from a dose increase,
that's when you start to see a change.
Possible side effects include nausea,
headache, sleep changes, and reduced sexual desire.
Not everybody gets side effects.
Sometimes patients will say to me,
wait a minute, I don't want to take the medication
because of the side effect list.
I understand that.
As a psychiatrist, I would never recommend something
that I didn't think had benefits
that could outweigh the negative.
But sometimes people do have side effects
that make them want to stop the medication.
And in that case, I'll work with them to say,
okay, let's figure out what's going on.
We'll try a different medication.
Withdrawal symptoms from stopping your medication
are really uncomfortable.
They can be flu-like symptoms.
You might have a headache, a stomach ache.
Some people describe feeling that their head is in a tunnel.
So you want to taper these down
the same way you want to taper them up.
Next video.
These are stimulant medications.
Stimulants are the first-line treatment for ADHD.
In ADHD, dopamine in your brain isn't functioning
the way it would in a brain of somebody
who doesn't have ADHD.
The stimulants raise the level of dopamine
in different ways.
How someone reacts to these stimulants is very individual.
Doesn't mean that everybody's going to have Ritalin
go in their body fast and leave fast.
What I think it's trying to say
is these short-acting medications,
they usually last for three to four hours.
And you might feel a spike and then a decrease.
Adderall and Ritalin help dopamine function
in the brain better.
What dopamine does is it allows you
to put the brakes on things
so that you can actually focus on one thing at a time.
People often think if they're going to take a stimulant,
they're going to be all sped up.
But if it's a prescribed dose that is right for you,
if you have ADHD, it slows things down
so that you can focus.
In fact, when you're on too much stimulant,
you can feel like a robot.
A lot of times people take Adderall or Ritalin
not prescribed.
I do not recommend that.
These medications have side effects.
They can increase your heart rate.
They can make you feel nauseated.
They can give you bad headaches.
So it's really important to only take the medication
if it is prescribed by your doctor.
Next video.
I don't know why they're turning mental illness
into bedrooms.
First of all, this doesn't tell me
that this person has any particular disorder.
They've labeled it at the bottom,
dissociative identity disorder.
That's what used to be called multiple personality disorder.
Maybe this bedroom is showing that someone
has a lot of different sides to themselves.
We all have different sides to ourselves.
I don't know what this is.
The complex PTSD bedroom looks really lonely.
A lot of times people with complex PTSD
do suffer from loneliness.
Depersonalization is when you have the experience
of living outside of your life.
You're not in touch with yourself.
It feels like you're watching a movie,
not experiencing life themselves.
Sometimes depersonalization is used
as a way to cope through trauma.
If someone is getting repeatedly abused,
they almost dissociate to the point of not experiencing
their life because it's so terrible.
People with antisocial personality disorder
break the law sometimes.
Maybe this is supposed to imply that this is stolen items.
I don't know exactly what's going on.
I've had enough of this video.
Next.
Why is your gut called a second brain?
Because it literally has one.
Your gut doesn't literally have a brain.
There are a lot of neurons in your gut
and they do send messages to your brain.
I think that's what this is getting to.
Around 90% of the fibers in that nerve
carry signals going up.
So your gut is talking to your brain
way more than your brain is talking back.
That is true that there are a lot of signals
going from your gut to your brain
and it can impact mood.
In fact, about 95% of your body's serotonin
is made down there.
It is true that the gut makes a lot of serotonin.
That serotonin doesn't cross the blood brain barrier.
So it's not as if your gut is directly connected
to your mood.
It's giving signals that impact your mood,
but it's not a direct communication here.
What can cross are precursors to serotonin.
Something like tryptophan.
Tryptophan is a precursor, a building block for serotonin.
If that is low,
and if a lot of the short chain fatty acids
needed to build certain molecules,
if you don't have enough of them,
then that can affect how much serotonin is in your brain.
Perhaps that impacts mood.
Take a look at this last video.
Option one, put your pointer finger
and your thumb together and take an inhale.
Notice how it's a little higher.
That's gonna help you activate.
I'm not sure exactly that this is super helpful.
As I've said before,
getting to that place where you're really anxious
and remembering how to breathe
and put your fingers in certain places,
that's really hard.
Also, when it comes to breathing, it's the exhale.
And people often forget that it's the exhale
through your mouth that helps you calm down.
Breathing though,
to have somebody just lead you through something,
to feel like someone's there, that can also help.
So if this furry animal creature can be present
when someone's really anxious, that might help them.
Option number two,
go ahead and take your thumb and your middle finger.
Inhale.
Notice how that enters into your ribs.
That's gonna help you calm down.
The finger stuff might actually help somebody
just focus on something else
other than their anxiety in the moment.
So that's why that might be helpful.
I think a lot of people are leaning on AI
for their mental health,
in part because not everyone has access to mental health.
In reality, it's really expensive.
It's time-consuming.
Not everybody has coverage for their insurance.
People don't know how to get a therapist.
They don't know who to trust.
They don't know whether they're getting good therapy.
So AI is a quick, easy way
to try to get some kind of emotional release
or some kind of guidance.
