Taste not waste - squash vs. pumpkin I How to have a more sustainable Halloween.
4 Video Views·Oct 4, 2026
Taste not waste - squash vs. pumpkin I How to have a more sustainable Halloween.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the environmental impact of Halloween pumpkin traditions, highlighting the massive amount of food waste generated annually. Through an interview with a farmer at Baderford Farm, the content advocates for shifting away from decorative, tasteless pumpkins toward sustainable, edible alternatives like winter squash to reduce waste and reconnect with the land.
Comments are disabled for this video.
It's likely when someone says Halloween, one of the first things that comes to your mind
is pumpkins. The tradition of carving ghoulish faces into them is an annual event for families
and children across the world. But there is an even scarier side, and that is the food waste
impact of growing them. In the UK alone, around 14 million pumpkins get wasted every year,
which is the equivalent of 18,000 tonnes of food waste. What drives this waste,
and are there alternatives for a more nutritious, sustainable and tastier Halloween?
We've come to Baderford Farm to find out.
Guy, can you tell us a bit about your farm and what's going on in this field?
We grow a lot of vegetables, almost all for Riverford, including squash. We don't grow
pumpkins anymore, so we've got lots of different varieties of squash. We've got crown prince here,
we grow onions, squash, Hokkaido. You mentioned that you don't grow pumpkins anymore,
what's the reason for that? They're a lovely crop to grow,
I love the way that they spread out, they can be very vigorous. I suppose over the years,
the idea of growing something which you're going to throw away, it becomes a problem.
So every bit of farming we do has an environmental impact, and I suppose more and more I feel that
that's not justifiable if you're not producing food. I mean, it sounds a bit kind of killjoy,
but I don't think it's okay anymore. All of us have got to learn to tread more lightly
on this planet, and that will involve questioning things which we all assume to be okay.
Why do you think that so many of them are wasted? I mean,
they're not the most tasty pumpkin when you compare them to something like squash.
Yeah, some of the small pumpkins can be just about okay to eat, but the big
ones which are grown for Halloween are, you know, if I'd said they were bland,
it would be flattering. Actually, they are really quite unpleasant in flavour,
they tend to be kind of soapy and very watery. Yeah, so they're not bred for flavour,
unlike the squashes, which most definitely are, and you know, given the choice,
I don't think anyone's going to eat a squash. Who do you think is to blame around the food
waste with pumpkins? Is it the supermarkets? I mean, you can pick them up for about a pound,
can't you really? Does that devalue them, do you think? I just can't understand how anyone can grow
and get into the supermarket for a pound, I just can't. I guess they're being sold as a
lost leader. I'm reluctant to say whose fault it is, you know, I'm not sure how much that helps,
it just is, you know, that's what we've arrived at, you know, you could blame the people who buy
them, you could blame the people who sell them, you can blame the people who grow them, you could
blame the journalists who write about them. I really don't think that's a helpful approach,
you know, that's just the way it is, and you know, the question is, is it okay in 2022? And I suppose
I've reached the conclusion that it's not. What I'd like us to do is move away from the sort of
Halloween thing. I mean, it's a right old mixture, isn't it, from the day and the dead and something
that's imported from America, but overall it has been, you know, it's just a really commercially
driven opportunity for people to sell us a load of crap. Though, I mean, you know, we were, let's
put our hands up, you know, we've been doing it for years and inviting people to the farm and it's
been a big jamboree and a celebration and I think everyone's enjoyed it, but I think like so many
things we need, you know, that we've done for years unthinkingly, I think we need to question
it. What I want to celebrate is the bounty that nature has delivered that year, so what I would
love us to do is to come together for some sort of harvest festival, harvest supper and I, you know,
that's what I would really like to see us all celebrating and within that, that we are eating
the produce of the land, that sort of real connection to the land and, you know, I think
it is one of the absolute key celebrations of the year. It feels like there are alternatives
out there, do you think? I mean, crown prince for one, we stood in the field here, these taste so
much better, don't they? What else, what are the other benefits of squash over pumpkins? In the
right conditions, they'll keep right through into next summer, you can still be eating them in July
next year with very little wastage, you know, a Halloween pumpkin, if it makes it to Halloween,
quite a lot of them don't, some of them just collapse in the field, I mean, they just want
to rot, you know, the squash, you know, far, far superior from a culinary point of view, you know,
and they have much lower sort of wastage because they don't go off and you can be eating them, you
know, right through the winter and even right through the hungry gap, this crown prince is
definitely the best variety for that. I mean, you've definitely convinced me, I love squash,
I think the flavour is completely incomparable, so what's your favourite recipe, what would you
Probably my favourite is to roast it and eat, you know, like a crown prince, cut it in half,
always open it before putting it in the oven, otherwise it will explode, cut it in half, scoop
out the seeds, roast it for, I don't know, half an hour or something, perhaps with a bit of oil and
some rosemary on it, then scoop it out and make a risotto in the normal way and just incorporate
that, you know, towards the beginning and it just makes a really hearty, kind of winter,
warming dish. So as much as carving pumpkins is fun, it does feel like there is a strong argument
for assessing our traditions and perhaps opting for more sustainable options moving forward and
it does feel like squash can do this. So the key is creating a fun Halloween or harvest festival
display with them instead of trying to carve them and then afterwards you can enjoy them
their amazing flavour instead of throwing them in the bin.

