WATER is millions of years old. There is no new water. Thus begins our journey of discovery about the nature of water. Father Fish leads us through a labyrinth of myths and fantasies at the heart of traditional fish keeping. These 2 videos will change your understanding of water in the aquarium.
Louis Foxwell, known on YouTube as Father Fish, is an old-time fish keeper with 70 years of experience. His simple, easy, and guaranteed methods insure healthy, happy tropical fish in your aquarium.
Lou adopted the role of Father Fish many years ago when he opened a tropical fish store as a retirement business. Prior to this, he served as a missionary for 25 years, following in his father's footsteps by ministering to a congregation of deaf worshipers. Lou fondly recalls his grandmother in Berlin, Germany, who inspired his love for fish keeping as a child.
As a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, Lou played a significant role in its development, serving as chair of the Community Relations Committee and participating in the Search Committees. With extensive experience across nearly every level of the fish industry, Father Fish offers a wealth of knowledge and products, including plants, soil supplements, and more, to enhance your aquarium experience.
I just want to ask you some questions Father Fish.
Just like everybody else.
That's right, the tough questions.
You know the hard questions.
The trap questions.
I like that best.
Yes.
That's my favorite one.
Well let's snare you in the first trap right now.
Go for it.
Do your best.
Should you change the water in a natural aquarium?
And if so, when?
Excellent.
Never.
Never change your water in a natural aquarium.
Not from the time you set it up to the time you break it down.
Which in my case is going on 25 years.
That is to say when the water becomes impossibly polluted.
Clearly something needs to be done.
Changing it really doesn't do more than dilute the problem.
Which is a band-aid, right?
The reality is that a polluted tank, once the primary pollutants are removed,
will clear up in a matter of two to three days.
If you have plants, right?
Well regardless.
Okay.
If removing the pollutant causes the bacteria that are the effect of the pollution
to break down, to die, to disappear.
Which allows the water to return to a normal state.
Water will always seek to return to a normal state.
Always.
It can develop very high levels of solubleness.
And the solubles are the reason people change their water.
Yes.
To remove solubles.
Yep.
There are other ways to do that.
One of the primary ways that it is done in nature is with plants.
Plants are a filtering agent.
That's what they do.
They have little holes in them that they pump water through into
in order to be able to filter out the water.
To remove the solubles that are nutritional for the plant.
A heavily planted tank will always have water that is as clear and clean and pure
as it's possible for water to be.
Kind of like that tank right behind me.
Which has a lot of fish but it has a lot of plants in it.
People try to balance their tank by changing water parameters.
Yes.
Artificially or by water changes.
You change the pH.
Yep.
You change the hardness.
Yep.
Now all that does is create a stress environment for the biologicals.
It's the biological material in the tank that actually balances the water.
Yeah but the internet says those chemicals make the water good for the fish.
You're saying they don't.
I'm saying they do the opposite.
Yeah I tend to agree with you.
I'm saying they tend to create a stressful environment
for the biological life in the system.
The biological life is what is primary.
That's what controls pH, hardness.
All of those parameters are controlled and balanced by the biological systems in the tank.
So you pay attention not to the chemistry of the tank but to the biology of the tank
if you want to have a balanced tank.
That makes sense.
When you refer to the biological system what are you referring to exactly, specifically?
Well what I just said.
The plants, the fish, the microfauna, the macrofauna, the bacteria.
So here's the problem.
If you have six big Oscars in a 150 gallon tank sitting on top of an inch of gravel,
no hardscape, and a couple of big powerful canister filters filtering the water.
What do you have?
No problem.
Well you've got a system in which the biology of the tank struggles to maintain balance.
Right.
The gravel contains a certain amount of biologicals.
Yep.
The canisters contain a certain amount of biologicals and the fish themselves of course
are biological.
So you've got those three systems.
Plus whatever is in the water of a biological nature.
You've got those working to try to maintain a balance.
You're going in there every week taking 50% of that water out and putting 50% new in.
Every time you do that you throw the biologicals off keel.
You throw them back on their heels.
So they're struggling again to catch up.
It's a constant catching up.
By not paying attention to the primacy of the biological system and treating the tank
as though it is a chemistry experiment, you're not respecting the life that is in the tank.
And I'll just leave it at that.
We have published our magnificent home on the natural aquarium.
The natural aquarium, a complete guide based on the father fish method.
It is an extensive piece of work ranging approximately 500 pages.
This is not the sort of book you read cover to cover.
It is rather a detailed description of every aspect of a natural aquarium.
And that makes a lot of sense father fish because you really and you always have been
very stringent on saying the water is what it is.
You have to let the water be what it is.
We don't and you don't want to change it.
You don't.
Your word does not go bad.
Not per se.
Not in the ways that I think a lot of people are thinking that it does.
It changes.
It ages and it matures.
Water matures like wine in my opinion.
I like to make that comparison.
It doesn't get worse.
It gets better.
Well here's the interesting thing.
I spent a lot of years on fish farms in Florida.
Seeing yeah.
Those working with people and being around people who have spent their entire lives.
Older people who spent their entire lives working on those farms.
Working with breeding the fish.
Yep.
The one thing that to a person every one of them who've been there for any length of time
have the utmost respect for is old water.
Old water.
Old water is gold water.
So they do a lot of their breeding in old water.
Oh yeah absolutely.
So they're not constantly flushing their systems out.
Their breeders are kept in water that's been there for 25, 30 years.
See I wouldn't have thought that.
Even I would have thought they would be a constant.
Never change water.
That's interesting.
Absolutely never change water.
Because the biology is there.
After all those years it's there.
That's exactly right.
That makes sense.
Right.
It's about the water chemistry.
Water is what it is.
Water is ancient.
There's no virtually no new water on earth.
The water that we have right now has been here for a hundred million years.
Or more.
Same water.
Same identical water.
Not an atom of difference.
The only difference is what is in the water.
Right.
So you need to pay attention not to trying to change the parameters of the water.
Which you can't do anyway.
I mean that's the reality.
If you're trying to maintain the stable pH.
Every time you introduce new water you're changing the pH.
So you're not maintaining a stable pH.
We do want stable water.
That's really important.
The only way to do that is to put the biological system in charge.
Are there any times in which it is appropriate to do a water change on a planet aquarium?
Because we do them.
We do it.
Right.
But we're also in a retail setting.
Well we're doing it for visual effect.
We do do it.
Mainly for aesthetics.
Yeah.
We do.
We've got people coming in staring into our tanks all the time.
If the water is a little yellow, a little off color, it creates a winter roll.
It honestly does.
No.
So we try not to allow that.
But you as a fish keeper in your personal tanks.
You prefer the tannic water, the darker water, the natural water.
Yeah.
It depends.
I mean I do and I don't.
If you've got a lot of plant life, that'll tend to keep it clear.
Yes.
Okay.
So it tends to absorb those tannins.
The fish don't but the plants do.
So it's just on a case by case basis.
Yeah kind of.
And as rigid as I sound in making these kinds of comments,
I do not believe that there are absolute rules in fish keeping.
The reality is that it's critical to be flexible.
I mean there are times when I will look at a tank and I'll do a water change.
Yep.
I've seen it with my own eyes.
And I'll do it as a kind of a quick and dirty fix
to a situation that I consider to be an emergent situation.
So can you kind of walk us how you would ascertain that?
Just what you would look for?
Just like the fish gasping or...
Lethargic fish certainly.
Okay.
Plants that are struggling.
Any kind of odor.
Anytime you have odor.
Odor in the tank?
Yeah odor and there should never be odor in a tank.
And so that's one of the primary signals is smell if it smells bad.
My first predilection will be to do a 25% water change.
Follow it up the next day by a 25% water change.
Just by smelling it?
Just by yeah if it smells bad then that means there's something rotten in it.
There's something foul.
Something is dying.
There's it's out of balance.
It's out of whack.
Now I could sit there and spend two days trying to figure out what it is.
Yeah.
Or I could simply pull 25% of the water out.
Replace it.
Which it could be another extra day.
Yeah.
To figure out what's going on.
Buy you a little more time.
Okay.
And by then it may it may resolve itself.
So the only other thing that we're going to touch on today is cleaning.