Curious whether sand or gravel is better for your freshwater aquarium? In this video, we test five popular aquarium substrate combinations over two weeks to compare their effects on water quality, clarity, and overall performance. We walk through the full setup, track changes in nitrite, nitrate, and pH, and offer observations about beginner aqua-plant growth and more.
We used different mixes of sand and gravel, we also included aquatic plants like Ludwigia, Duckweed, and Pearl Weed to observe how they interact with each substrate.To keep things realistic, we added Ramshorn Snails and Bladder Snails as the tank inhabitants. The experiment is ongoing, as aquarium science continues to evolve.
Whether you're starting a new tank or upgrading your substrate, this aquarium substrate test will help you decide what's best for your fish and plants.
00:00 Introduction 00:37 Substrate Setup 02:36 Plant Choices 04:14 Animal Choices 04:38 Experiment Overview at the Start 05:07 Results After One Week 07:03 Water Testing After One Week 08:34 Results After Two Weeks and Final Thoughts
Hello everyone.
Welcome back to another episode of The Natural Aquarium.
This is Ryan here on Father Fish, and today I'm running an experiment just like every
other science teacher out there, except this one's my own experiment.
It's not for the kids.
It's for myself.
And I was wondering, hey, what happens if you try different types of aquarium substrates?
Hmm.
You curious?
Here we go.
To begin our experiment, I went and I bought six one-gallon jars at the Lovely Store.
Made of glass, completely inert, super easy for a wonderful experiment.
They won't interfere with anything.
We have a lovely potting mix, some organic ones, pool filter sand, and aquarium gravel
as our substrates.
Pool filter sand I happen to love because it doesn't create as much dust as a play sand
would.
And we're using my lovely red cup measuring method.
Two cups into each of these things.
And here's the gravel.
Gotta make sure you get the two cups of that stuff.
And man, I'm so glad that I don't use gravel in the bottom of my aquariums anymore because
you'll see why later.
It creates some problems.
And for our soil, again, same kind of deal.
We get the one to two ratio.
So we got our one cup of soil, then we've got our two cups of gravel, and there's another
one that's not pictured here with two cups of sand on top.
And now for the water.
Straight out of the tap.
Of course, we treat it.
I didn't show that part here.
End up getting the water, and here's our control.
Just pure water in there.
And there is our lovely sand only one.
Unfortunately, I goofed up a little bit on this one, and so it ends up being a little
bit cloudy, but that goes down after just a day.
Here's our soil and sand.
Perfected my method.
No cloudiness on that one.
And then, of course, we move on to our lovely gravels.
Same method, same water, all coming from that same bucket, and again, this is just treated
tap water.
Oh yeah, look at that wonderful camera shot right there, folks.
And if you're wondering what my tap water looks like, well, here it is on your lovely
run-of-the-mill aquarium test strip.
You can see the GH is quite high, KH is also kind of up there, and as far as our pH goes,
we're somewhere around 7.5.
And on to plants.
I picked Lubwigia because I knew that this one could do well immersed, and so I wanted
to see what it would do if it reaches the top of the water.
And after that, I went in and I got me some lovely floaters.
Those are ones that are easy to check.
It's giant duckweed.
And I've got myself some Limnophila, also another one that I'm quite familiar with.
And again, the whole idea here is that I'm choosing plants that I know what they will
do under different conditions, so I can kind of suss out what's going on with the water.
And finally, everybody's favorite, pearlweed.
Pearlweed, very versatile plant, very easy to grow.
And here they all are laid out.
I made sure to get ones that were all about even length, had the same features, like not
having any roots on the sides, things like that.
And then it was time to put them in, and here is why I hate gravel.
Oh yeah, look at that.
Those plants, they just, they stay down so well, don't they?
Ugh.
And I did have to go and put the Lydwigia back in because it came out again.
And here we are, gravel round two.
I got a little bit better at it as we went.
And then finally, everybody's channel favorite here, sand.
I mean, look at that.
They just go right in.
They stay right in.
Ah.
Lovely sand.
I might be a little biased.
And then finally, the easiest one, the control, dunk.
We went with the most humane stocking.
We've got ram's horn snails, and we've also included some bladder snails.
I swapped that big guy out for a smaller one, about the same size as the others.
Plunk them all in, pretty easy.
And then also to make sure that everything gets some gas exchange, we put a little bit
of foam on the top of each one of the jar lids.
And now we wait.
Here's what they look like when they start it.
These jars will receive about three hours of sunlight at the end of the day from the
hours of about 3 to 4 p.m. to about 7 p.m. during the summer month of July in Southern
California.
One week later.
And now the fun part, the reveal after one week.
Here you go, side by side, before on the left, after on the right.
You notice there's some changes in these.
Some have fared better than others, some are definitely colored a little differently now.
Let's take a look at each one individually here.
Here's our control.
Control, uh, didn't do so hot on the limnophila part right there.
Not looking so good.
Ludwigia's doing fine, some roots come in, and you can tell the lovely pearlweed's been
growing a little bit.
Duckweed's fine too.
Moving on, we've got just sand, just sand.
Everything looks relatively happy except for, again, that limnophila down there.
Not quite as green as it could be, a little bit more white.
Then we get over to soil and sand, uh, pearlweed's growing, ludwigia's growing, limnophila still
looks a little wanting, uh, duckweed is doing fairly well here.
Overall, pretty good health.
Then we got to the biggest visual change, the gravel and soil one.
So pearlweed's growing, our ludwigia is growing, you can see it's putting off roots into the
water as well.
And the thing you can't see here is that the pearlweed is also putting off some small roots
into the water column here, which is obviously where there is probably a good chunk of nutrients
hanging out.
And here's the gravel only one, and everybody's looking a little bit sad in there except for
the ludwigia's doing quite well.
And for some reason the top of that pearlweed actually came off and you can see it floating
right next to the duckweed here.
And test strip time!
Here's our gravel only one.
Gravel only, give it that one-two little swirl, put it on, and well, things did not really
change much.
Arguably the pH looks a little bit lower than when it started.
Could be an error though, these test strips are known for that, not very precise.
Here's our gravel and soil, and hey, look, much the same.
Note that there's no change in our nitrates and nitrites here on our lovely test strips
at all.
And here's our soil and sand, and don't worry if I'm going a little fast on these and there's
a little bit of high speed motion going on, I have the comparison for you just after all
of this.
And here is sand up next.
And again, another little swirl, check out the strip, and again, not much of a change
going on there.
And then finally, we'll move on to our control here, and again, same process, swirl and twirl,
here we go, and yeah, not much change.
So here they all are, side by side, pause it if you like, check them all out, analyze,
have fun.
Here we are at the end, what did we learn?
Just water.
Not much growth.
Yeah, there's a bunch of roots going on, those plants are trying to find enough nutrients
to, you know, do their thing, but aside from that, they're pretty much just in maintenance
mode, and the Limnophila is not looking pretty good either.
Okay, moving on to our ones that are just sand and just gravel here.
Just sand and just gravel, they're actually pretty similar, there's, again, not all that
much going on, we can see some rooting action from the Ludwigia, there's not much going
on as far as our Pearlweed, it's trying to grow a little bit, there is some new sprigs
on there, the Limnophila, I got a little bit of new growth going on there, and up in the
top, not so much going on either, and then finally, the ones that you can visually see
how to change, especially this guy right here, this was our lovely soil and gravel mixture,
this one, wow, the watercolor has truly changed there, and then also I can tell that there's
a lovely film going on the top, and, well, the Limnophila's grown fairly well, our Pearlweed
here has put down a lot of roots, and same thing with our lovely Ludwigia, they're both
putting roots out, and they are obviously having a great time, they're the ones where
the Pearlweed has definitely grown the longest, and same deal right up here, our Pearlweed
has grown right up to the top, looks like Limnophila's doing alright, and the water
is a little bit yellow compared to the clear ones that don't have any soil, and that's
of course because those lovely tannic and humic substances that are down here in our
soil layer are taking their time coming up through the very small pores in between our
sand pieces, whereas down here it was almost instantaneous as far as getting lovely tannins
and humans into the water because they just got right through that gravel because there's
a whole lot more space in those particles.
So there you have it, all the substrates, we're gonna keep this one going, if I have
any great things to share I'll go ahead and do that, but if you were wondering what it
looks like if you started an aquarium, and well, these are only one gallons, but if you
started in an aquarium here with these different types of setups, what you might expect after
a week, in fact we're almost up on two weeks on this point, it's taking me a long time
to edit, but you know, that's that.
So hope you enjoyed this lovely episode of The Natural Aquarium here on Father Fish,
I'm Ryan, your lovely host, and oh, no, the most important part, don't forget, we need
to have a like, and a, oh, comment, hey, what kinds of things have you done for experiments,
I mean, come on, you gotta share the data out there, folks, and then finally, if you're
not subscribed, maybe hit that subscribe button, join us, oh, speaking of joining us, don't
forget to jump onto our lovely Discord or our Facebook group and check out all the wonderful
resources and fun time that's going on there.
So we'll see you all next time, thank you.