2011 Bordeaux: The Vintage I Regret Buying En Primeur

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
Oct 3, 2026
I bought several 2011 Bordeaux wines en primeur when they were released in 2012. Looking back more than a decade later, 2011 is probably the Bordeaux vintage I most wish I had approached differently.
…
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker reflects on the 2011 Bordeaux vintage, noting that while many wines have evolved beautifully, they were often poor financial purchases due to high initial pricing and a challenging growing season. Through a review of four specific bottles, the speaker argues that the true value of a wine is measured by the pleasure it brings at the table rather than its market appreciation.
Of all the Bordeaux vintages I have bought en primeur over the past 30 years,
2011 is probably the one I most wish I had skipped.
That's not because the wines are bad.
In fact, some of them are drinking beautifully today.
The problem is that a good wine doesn't necessarily make a good purchase.
And 2011 taught me that lesson particularly well.
Wine collecting has something in common with investing.
Eventually, you find out whether you bought well.
But there is one important difference.
I don't buy wine to sell it.
I buy it to drink with family and friends.
So my return isn't measured only in dollars.
It's measured in enjoyment.
And of course, when a bottle appreciates significantly, that's always satisfying.
But I would still rather open it around a happy table than sell it for a profit.
Looking back at 2011, I made purchases that worked.
Financially, others that didn't.
And several wines that have given me far more pleasure than their prices would suggest.
There are four 2011s in my cellar I genuinely enjoy.
But if I were buying them again at today's prices, I would only repurchase one.
And interestingly, it's a bottle that has delivered almost no financial return at all.
In this video, I will revisit four of my favorite 2011 bottles,
explain what they have become after more than a decade in the cellar,
compare what I paid with what they cost today,
and tell you why only one of them would earn another place in my cellar.
And before we begin, while you are still discovering your preferences,
buy three or six bottles rather than a full case of 12.
A cellar should evolve alongside your taste.
First, a few words about 2011.
The vintage arrived at perhaps the worst possible moment.
Bordeaux had just produced two extraordinary vintages in 2009 and 2010.
Collectors had bought heavily, sellers were full, enthusiasm was exhausted.
And after two years of increasingly ambitious pricing, the market was ready for correction.
Unfortunately, the growing season didn't make things any easier.
2011 was a challenging year, marked by unusual weather
and uneven ripening across the region.
Pomerol, however, was one of the clear exceptions.
The right bank's clay-rich soils handled the difficult conditions
better than much of the left bank.
Why Merlot's earlier ripening allowed estates to harvest healthy ripe fruit
before autumn rains and rot became more problematic.
Cabernet Franc also performed particularly well in 2011,
bringing freshness, aromatic complexity, and structure to the best wines.
That helps explain why Pomerol produced some of the vintage's most convincing successes
and why three of the four wines I'm revisiting today come from there.
The resulting wines could be firm, austere, and difficult to read in their youth.
The Oprymo campaign never really stood a chance.
Prices did come down from the extraordinary levels of 2009 and 2010,
but in my view, not enough.
At the time, I still bought several wines.
Looking back, I wish I had been considerably more selective.
But something interesting has happened.
After spending years with a reputation for being tough and unyielding,
many of the better 2011s have finally begun to open.
The tannins have softened, the fruit has emerged,
and some wines are now drinking far better than I expected when they were young.
If 2011 isn't quite a graceful swan,
it has certainly shed much of the ugly duckling reputation that followed it at release.
The question is no longer whether these wines can be enjoyable.
They can.
The more interesting question is, would I buy them again today?
Let's start in Pauillac.
Pauillac, Chateau Pontécané, 2011.
Founded in 1725, Chateau Pontécané entered a new era
after the Tesseron family acquired their estate in 1975.
A major turning point came under Alfred Tesseron,
who converted the 81-hectare vineyard to biodynamic and organic farming,
making Pontécané the first major classified growth in Bordeaux to fully embrace this philosophy.
Today, under Justine Tesseron, the estate remains one of Bordeaux's leading biodynamic producers
and consistently performs well beyond its fifth-world classification.
The nose is complex, expressive, combining ripe red dark berries
with cedar, tobacco, earthy notes, and violets.
The palate is sleek and energetic, with generous berry fruit, chocolate, and spice,
supported by bright acidity, polished tannins, and a long, savory finish.
What I particularly enjoy today is the wine's energy.
It's more taut than broad.
But the mid-palate is beginning to soften beautifully,
giving the wine a creamier, more relaxed texture than it showed in its youth.
For me, this remains one of the strongest left-bank wines of 2011.
It's ready to enjoy now, yet has enough integrated structure to continue eating comfortably.
The blend is 60% Cabernet Sauvignon, 35% Merlot, 4% Cabernet Franc,
and 1% Petit Vadeau.
I bought the 2011 Emprimeur in spring 2012 for around 95 US dollars.
Today, it sells for approximately 115 dollars.
So, would I buy it again?
No.
Not because the wine disappoints me.
Quite the opposite.
But the 2012 and 2014 Pontécanées are both currently around 120 dollars,
and I regard them as superior choices for almost exactly the same money.
I would buy one of those instead.
And that's one of the lessons 2011 taught me.
Liking a wine doesn't automatically make it the best wine to buy.
Pomerol, Château La Corséante, 2011
Next is La Corséante.
Located on Pomerol's eastern plateau, beside L'Hérengie and close to Cheval Blanc,
the estate sits on blue clay and sandy gravel with iron-rich subsoil.
Named after Catherine Conséant, who purchased the property in the 1730s,
La Corséante has remained in the same family since 1871.
Since 2015, it has been led by winemaker Marielle Cazot.
The nose is elegant and fragrant, combining rye black fruit with graphite,
incense, earthy notes, and delicate violets and peonies.
The palate is seamless and silky, layering blackberry, blueberry, and cherry with cocoa,
dried herbs, and earthy minerality over fine acidity and soft, powdery tannins.
The wine has now shed much of its tightness it carried in youth.
Today, it offers beautiful balance, polished texture,
and the kind of understated elegance that makes La Corséante so appealing.
It doesn't have the soaring finesse or complexity of the greatest vintages,
but given the difficulties of 2011, I think it's a remarkable achievement.
And importantly, it's a very enjoyable wine to drink while the outstanding
2015 and 2016 vintages continue moving towards their prime.
The blend is 82% Merlot and 18% Caminé Franc, aged in 65% New Oak.
I bought this 2011 Au Primer for approximately 95 US dollars.
Today, it's around 190 dollars.
So, financially, this has been the strongest performer of the four wines in this video.
My bottle has roughly doubled in value.
Will I buy it again?
No.
At today's prices, I would much rather buy the 2014 La Corséante, which is currently at 175 US dollars.
Or as you will see later, there is another 2011 Pomerol I would choose at around 145 US dollars.
This is where wine collecting becomes interesting.
On paper, doubling your money looks like a wonderful result.
But if I was standing in a wine shop today,
with 190 US dollars in my hand, I wouldn't spend it on this bottle.
Pomerol Chateau L'Evangine, 2011
Our third wine is Chateau L'Evangine.
Founded in 1741, the estate took its current name in 1862.
The Rothschild family of Lafitte acquired it in 1919 and took full control in 1999.
Its 22 hectare vineyard sits on the edge of the Pommon Plateau, bordering Petrus and Cheval Blanc.
The nose is inviting and generous, combining rye black fruit and plum,
with spice, violets, and earthy complexity.
The palate is rich and polished, layering cherry, blackcurrant, fig, chocolate, truffle,
and licorice over lively acidity and rounded tannins that lead to a long, supple finish.
This is a substantial wine.
There is plenty of richness and concentration,
yet a cool freshness underneath keeps everything composed.
It doesn't have the layered profundity of the great 2009 or 2010 vintages,
but neither does it feel like a consolation prize.
It has real presence, more structure than you initially expect,
and after more than a decade in bottle, it has evolved into a very satisfying Pomerol.
The blend is 94% Merlot and 6% Cabernet Franc.
I bought it en Primeur in spring 2012 for around $135.
Today, the 2011 sells for approximately $200.
The problem is that both the 2012 and 2014 are currently available at around $180.
Would I buy the 2011 again?
Again, no.
At today's prices, I would rather put my money into the 2014
or into the final wine of this video.
Because, unlike the three bottles we have seen so far,
this is the one 2011 I would actually repurchase.
Pomerol Chateau L'Eglise Clinée, 2011
Among Pomerol's great estates,
few winemakers left a stronger impression on me than the late Denis Giraudoux.
After taking control of L'Eglise Clinée in 1983,
he transformed this tiny 5.5 hectare estate into one of the appellation's finest properties.
His wines were unmistakably Pomerol, rich and expressive,
but rarely pushed into the overripe or heavily oak style that became fashionable elsewhere.
The nose is refined and expressive,
combining ripe red and dark fruit with coffee, cocoa, warm spice, fresh stone,
and delicate floral notes.
The palate is rich, yet precise,
layering blackberry, raspberry, and plum with chocolate, licorice, and spice,
of a bright acidity, fine structure, and a cool, fresh finish.
What makes this wine stand apart is its balance.
2011 can often feel firm.
This doesn't.
It's full-bodied and richly textured,
but there is a sense of freshness and control that prevents the wine from becoming heavy.
It has depth.
It has intensity.
But it also has poise.
For me, Denis Giraudoux produced one of the most compelling right-bank wines of the entire vintage.
The blend is 90% Merlot and 10% Cabernet Franc.
I bought the 2011 En Primeur in spring 2012 for around $140.
Today, it's worth approximately $145.
Think about it.
More than a decade of cellaring and almost no financial appreciation whatsoever.
Meanwhile, the 2012 sells for around $260.
The 2014 is around $205.
So, if I judge this purely as an investment, the 2011 would look rather disappointing.
But would I buy it again?
Absolutely.
In fact, of these four wines, it's the only one I would repurchase today.
Not because it made me money.
It didn't.
But because of the treasure it has brought every time I have opened a bottle with friends and family.
And ultimately, that's the return I care about most.
My verdict.
Looking back, 2011 remains a vintage.
I wish I had bought much more selectively.
Pont des Canets has become a very enjoyable wine.
But at today's prices, I would rather buy the 2012 or 2014.
La Corcellane has roughly doubled in value.
But I would still choose the 2014 instead.
L'Evolgine has appreciated significantly too.
Yet again, I think the 2014 offers the better purchase today.
And then, there is L'Église Clinée.
I paid approximately $140.
More than a decade later, it's worth around $145.
Financially, hardly a spectacular investment.
And yet, it's the only one of these four wines I would happily buy again.
That probably tells you everything you need to know about how I judge my cellar.
After more than 30 years of collecting,
I have learned that the bottle that makes you the most money
isn't necessarily the bottle that gives you the greatest value.
La Corcellane delivered the best financial return.
L'Église Clinée delivered the return I actually wanted.
Pleasure around the table.
With friends.
With family.
And bottles worth remembering long after the price has been forgotten.
So, yes, 2011 is still a vintage.
I wish I had approached more cautiously.
But I don't regret every bottle.
Because sometimes, the most useful lessons in collecting
come from the decisions you wouldn't make twice.
And sometimes, the bottle that's barely appreciated at all
is the one you most want to buy again.
For me, that's Château L'Église Clinée 2011.
If you bought Bordeaux en Primeur in 2011,
I would love to know whether you feel the same way about the vintage today.
And which bottles surprised you most.
You will find more of my cellar insights and tasting notes on Instagram.
Massive thanks for watching today.
And I will see you in the next one.
