2003 Bordeaux: The Vintage That Proved Me Wrong

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 2, 2026
I was in Bordeaux during the extraordinary 2003 heatwave, and at the time I wasn't convinced many of these wines would age particularly well.
More than twenty years later, some have proved me completely wrong. …
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA retrospective review of the 2003 Bordeaux vintage, once doubted due to extreme summer heat and drought. After 23 years, the speaker finds that the best wines from the northern Médoc have aged with remarkable grace, evolving from ripe and powerful youths into elegant, balanced, and magnificent mature wines.
I was in Bordeaux during the scorching summer of 2003 and at the time I wasn't convinced these
wines would age particularly well. More than 20 years later some of them have proved me
completely wrong. I have been collecting Bordeaux for over three decades, tasting wines from
imprimer through their youth and eventually into full maturity. Along the way I have had plenty
of successes and inevitably a few disappointments. But few vintages have surprised me quite like
2003. The heat that summer was extraordinary. I still remember being in the medoc and feeling
just how extreme the conditions were. The wines that followed were ripe, powerful and sometimes
unusually rich. At the time I questioned whether that style would have the freshness and balance
to survive for decades. Some didn't. But the best wines from the north and medoc have developed
with remarkable grace. And today at more than 20 years of age several are not merely surviving.
They are magnificent. In this video I am revisiting five 2003 Bordeaux that I have bought imprimer
in spring 2004 and have followed ever since. These are wines I genuinely love. But as always
enjoying a wine and wanting to buy it again at today's price are two very different things. So I
will tell you how each has evolved, what surprised me most and which 2003s I would actually put my
into again today. And before we begin, while you are still discovering your preferences,
buy three or six bottles rather than a full case of 12. A cellar should evolve alongside your taste.
The 2003 Bordeaux Vintage. First a few words about the vintage. 2003 was one of the most extreme
growing seasons Bordeaux had experienced in modern times. The summer heat wave was brutal.
The drought accelerated the entire growing cycle. Harvest arrived unusually early and many younger
vines struggled badly in bait water starved soils. The resulting wines could be exotic,
dense and unusually high in alcohol. But the vintage wasn't equally successful everywhere.
The northern Medoc performed particularly well. Pauillac and Saint-Esteve benefited from their
gravel soils, deeper reserves of moisture and in some cases the cooling influence of the Giron
estuary. Those conditions helped preserve freshness and produce some remarkably structured
Cabernet Sauvignon. The right bank was much more uneven. Pomerol and other clay heavy areas often
struggled under the extreme heat and drought and the results varied considerably from estate to
estate. That distinction matters because more than 20 years later many of the wines that have surprised
me most come from exactly those northern Medoc terroirs that handle the heat best. And that's
where we will begin. Saint-Julien, Château du Creux-Beaucaillou, 2003. The heart of the Creux-Beaucaillou's
vineyard covers around 55 hectares of gravelly soils over limestone close to the Giron. The
estate takes its name from the extraordinary multicolored quartz and flint pebbles found
throughout the vineyard. The Beaucaillou are beautiful stones. The vineyard is planted
predominantly to Cabernet Sauvignon with Merlot making up most of the balance. The nose is complex
and mature, combining dark fruit with tobacco, leather, spice, forest flora notes and delicate
florals. The palate is plush yet beautifully composed with blackcurrant, plum and fig,
supported by spice, persistent minerality, polished acidity and fine-grained tannins.
At 23 years old, what impresses me most is the wine's composure. The exuberance of youth has
faded, but in its place is something far more elegant. It remains lush and generous, but there
is an unexpected freshness underneath that keeps the wine alive. It's less flamboyant than many of
the vintages that followed, but no less distinguished. For me, this is mature du Creux-Beaucaillou at its
most graceful. The blend is 80% Cabernet Sauvignon and 20% Merlot. I bought it en primeur in spring 2004
for approximately 105 US dollars. Today, it sells for around 230 dollars. Would I buy it again?
Probably not. Not because the wine disappoints me, but at around 240 US dollars, I much prefer
the 2015. And as you will see later, there is another 2003 at roughly the same price I would
choose first. Pauillac Chateau Lafitte-Fortune 2003. Lafitte's 112 hectare vineyard lies at the northern
end of Pauillac, on deep gravel, over marl and limestone. Its name is believed to be derived from
expression for a mound or small hill. The estate's reputation has traveled far beyond France for
centuries. As early as 1732 and 1733, British Prime Minister Sir Robert Walpole was famously
ordering a barrel of Lafitte every three months. The nose is refined and deeply expressive,
combining dark fruit with cedar, tobacco, graphite, and dry flowers. The palate is broad and verity,
with blackcurrant, blackberry, and dry fruit layered over cocoa, licorice, and savory notes,
all supported by fine tannins and balanced acidity. This is where 2003 begins to challenge
every assumption I originally had about the vintage. Today, Lafitte is drinking at the
remarkable stage. There is opulence, certainly, but also extraordinary finesse. The wine remains
fresh, vibrant, and almost improbably youthful for such a hot vintage. It feels as though time
has barely touched it. The blend is 86% Cabernet Sauvignon, 9% Merlot, 3% Cabernet Franc,
and 2% Petit Badot. I bought it en primeur in 2004 for approximately 650 US dollars. Today,
it's around 1,200 dollars. Would I buy it again at that price? No. For around 1,150 dollars,
I would rather buy the 2005. Or staying within 2003, I would put my money into the next wine
instead. Boyac, Château Latour, 2003. Château Latour has remained within the same broad line
of connected family ownership for around three centuries. The estate owes much of its early
reputation to the Marquis de Ségur and his descendants before being revitalized by British
investors in 1963. François Pinot acquired Latour in 1993, beginning another important chapter
in the estate's history. The vineyard was fully converted to organic farming in 2015,
with biodynamic practices now used across much of the history of Clos. The nose is powerful
and complex, combining dark berries with smoke, cinderwood, leather, spice,
graphite, and floral notes. The palate is vibrant, yet remarkably polished, layering black fruit,
mocha, truffle, and spice over verity tannins, fresh acidity, and a mineral structure that
carries into an extraordinarily long finish. For me, this is one of the defining wines of the
vintage. It has the density you would expect from 2003, but almost none of the heaviness I feared
when these wines were young. Instead, Latour feels powerful and weightless at the same time.
The fruit is brooding, the structure is taut, the tannins are extraordinarily fine,
and after more than 20 years, every element remains beautifully proportioned. If I had to
choose the most compete wine of the vintage, this would be very difficult to beat. The blend is 81%
Cabernet Sauvignon, 18% Malot, and 1% Petit Vadot. I bought it en primeur in 2004 for approximately
500 US dollars. Today, it sells for around 970 dollars. Would I buy it again? Yes. If my budget
allowed it, I would happily buy another bottle. It's expensive, but unlike several other wines at
this level, I still believe the experience justifies the price. Coyac Chateau Pichon Comtesse, 2003.
The historic Pichon estate was divided in 1850, creating what would become Pichon Comtesse
Édouard May acquired the estate in 1926, but it was his daughter, May-Éliane de Lengsa, who took
over in 1978, who truly shaped its modern identity. Since the Rousseau family acquired the property
in 2007, Pichon Comtesse has returned firmly to the highest ranks of the Médoc. The nose is lifted
and expressive, combining ripe red and dark berries with tobacco, leather, warm spice,
and earthy notes. The palate is succulent and concentrated, layering raspberry, black cherry,
and dried fruit with chocolate, truffle, and spice over seamless acidity and resolved tannins.
This is another wine that has aged far better than I initially expected. At 23 years old,
it has developed a beautiful combination of richness and poise. There's plenty of
concentration, but the wine no longer feels driven by power. Instead, it has become graceful,
balanced, and remarkably selective. For me, it's one of the great successes of Northern Médoc in
2003. The blend is 65% Cabernet Sauvignon, 31% Malot, and 4% Petit Vadou. I bought it en primeur
in spring 2004 for approximately $100. Today, it sells for around $215. Would I buy it again?
Again, probably not. At around $245, I would much rather buy the 2015. And if I wanted a mature
2003 at roughly this price, I would buy the next one instead. Saint-Esteve, Chateau Montrose, 2003.
Founded in 1815, Chateau Montrose was acquired by the Charmelus family in 1896 and remained under
their stewardship for more than a century before being sold to the Breed brothers in 2006. Its 95
hectare vineyard forms a single block overlooking the Giron estuary, planted on gravel and gnash
stones over clay and limestone. The name Montrose comes from the pinkish heather that once covered
these slopes. And in 2003, that terroir mattered enormously. The estate's moisture-retaining clay
and the cooling influence of the estuary helped Montrose cope with the extreme heat
better than many properties elsewhere in Bordeaux. The nose is deep and savory,
combining dark fruit with mocha, cedar, tobacco, graphite, and roasted herbs. The palate is dense,
yet beautifully silky, layering blackberry, cassis, and plum with cocoa, coffee, spice, and licorice
over bright acidity and verity tannins and a firm mineral core. This may be the wine that surprised
me most. At 23 years old, the 2003 Montrose is still incredibly alive. The youthful power
is certainly there, but it has been tempered by freshness and extraordinary balance. There is
muscle, there is depth, but there is also energy. And unlike many wines from hot vintages,
it doesn't feel tired or heavy, quite the opposite. It still seems to have years ahead of it. For me,
this is not simply one of the best wines of 2003. It's one of the most thrilling mature Bordeaux
I have tasted from this period. The blend is 62% Cabernet Sauvignon, 34% Malot, 3%
Cabernet Franc, and 1% Petit Verdot. I bought it en primeur in spring 2004 for approximately
65 US dollars. Today, it sells for around 235 dollars. Would I buy it again? Absolutely.
In fact, at today's prices, this may be the easiest decision in the entire tasting.
My verdict. Looking back, 2003 taught me something I didn't fully appreciate
when I first tasted these wines. Extreme vintages don't necessarily age in predictable ways.
I was there during that extraordinary summer. I felt the heat. And when the wines were young,
I questioned whether some of them had the freshness and balance to survive for decades.
Twenty-three years later, the best northern Médoc wines have proved those doubts wrong.
Ducruz-Moucaillou has become beautifully elegant. Lafite remains astonishingly youthful.
Pichon-Comtesse has developed remarkable grace. Latour is still monumental. And Montrose
may be the greatest surprise of them all. But as always, loving a wine doesn't automatically mean
I would buy it again at today's price. For Ducruz-Moucaillou, I would rather buy the 2015.
For Lafite, I would rather buy the 2005. For Pichon-Comtesse, again, I would rather buy the
2015. That leaves two wines, Latour and Montrose. If money were no object, I would happily buy the
2003 Latour again. For me, it is perhaps the most complete wine of the vintage. But if I were looking
at the relationship between quality, maturity, and price, Montrose would be my purchase. I paid
around 65 US dollars for it en primaire. Today, it's approximately 235 dollars. That's a considerable
increase. But even at today's price, I still think the wine delivers extraordinary value for what is
now a mature, world-class Bordeaux. And perhaps that's the greatest surprise of 2003. Not simply
that these wines survived, but that some of them became far better than I ever expected. After more
than 30 years of collecting Bordeaux, I have learned to be careful about predicting exactly
how a wine will age. Some vintages that look destined for greatness disappoint. Others quietly
prove you wrong. For me, 2003 belongs firmly in the second category. I began with doubts. 23 years
later, I have nothing but admiration for the best wines. And if I were buying again today, I would
happily make room for Latour. But for my own money, Montrose is the bottle I would bring back
into the cellar first. If you have been drinking 2003 Bordeaux recently, I would love to know which
wine has surprised you most, and whether the vintage has aged better than you expected. You
will find more of my cellar insights and tasting notes on Instagram. Massive thanks for watching
today, and I will see you in the next one.
