On Monday, gold and silver did something they rarely do on the same day. Both were stretched to the bottom of their Bollinger Bands right after silver lost almost 9% in a month. I tested that exact setup back to the year 2000, and in this video I show you where it worked, where it blew up, and why the odds are now tilted. Spot gold dipped to $4,110, just under its key $4,117 line, and has closed back above it every day since.
Spot silver broke under $60 for the first time since early August, then bounced straight back to its $61.04 golden ratio. The dollar is at its high of the year, factories just reported their biggest jump in input costs since May, and the Fed is still talking about hikes. At the same time, the Treasury's bond buybacks are failing, and the Treasury just brought in Judy Shelton, a woman who has argued for years that US bonds should be payable in gold. I break down the charts, the pressure, who is still buying, and the exact levels that will tell us whether the bottom is in.
AI Generated·May contain errors
On Monday something happened on the gold chart and on the silver chart at exactly the same time.
It is a pattern I went back and tested all the way to the year 2000.
It has shown up 39 times and three months later silver was higher in 26 of them.
On average silver gained close to 6 percent.
That is about one and a half times what silver normally does in any random three month window.
Today I am going to show you exactly what this signal is,
why it just fired, where it worked, where it blew up,
and the two price levels on the chart that I think will tell us within days
whether this is the bottom or a trap.
And while all of this was happening on the charts,
something happened in Washington that almost nobody in the gold market is talking about.
A woman who has spent more than a decade arguing that the United States should issue
bonds that can be paid back in gold is now working inside the Treasury Department
as a counselor to the Treasury Secretary.
I will get to her and to why the timing matters in a few minutes.
First, where we are right now.
Today I am using spot prices, the prices you see on most dealer websites,
so everything lines up with what you see when you check your phone.
Gold is trading at $4,177.
That is down about 2.5 percent on the week and down about 6 percent from a month ago.
Silver is at $61.
Earlier today, for a moment, it traded below $60 at $59.97.
That was the first time spot silver has been under 60 since early August.
And then it bounced, straight back above $61.
That bounce, and where exactly it happened, is the whole story today.
So let me explain the signal properly, because I do not want to throw jargon at you.
On any price chart, you can draw what are called Bollinger Bands.
Think of them as a channel around the price.
The middle line is the average price of the last 20 trading days.
The upper and lower lines are drawn two standard deviations away from that average.
In plain English, the bands show you how far price normally travels from its own average.
When price touches the lower band,
it means the selling has stretched the market further than it usually goes.
Now, on its own, one metal touching its lower band does not mean much.
It happens all the time.
So I did not test that.
I tested something much more specific.
Three things, all on the same day.
Gold touches its lower band.
Silver touches its lower band.
And silver has already fallen at least 8 percent over the previous month.
That combination is rare.
Both metals stretch to the downside at once, after silver has already taken a beating.
And on Monday, the 28th of September, all three conditions were met.
Gold traded right through its lower band.
Silver did the same.
And silver was down more than 8 percent from a month earlier.
And some of the wins were enormous.
January of 2011, silver rose 76 percent in the next three months, on its way to nearly $50.
July of 2009, up 41 percent.
August of 2022, up 27.
August of 2007, up 26.
March of 2020, the COVID crash, up 20.
October of 2023, the last big one before this year, silver and gold both up 12 percent.
In June, gold made a low at $3,959.
From there, it ran all the way to $4,697 in August.
If you measure that whole move, the 78.6 percent retracement,
by the last major Fibonacci level before the June low, sits at $4,117.
On Monday, spot gold fell to $4,110, $6 below that line.
Tuesday, it held.
Wednesday, it held.
Today, it held.
If you have been following the futures line I showed you earlier this week, $4,126.51,
this is the same retracement, just measured on the spot chart.
The spot chart has slightly different highs and lows than the futures chart,
so the line lands at $4,117.
Same idea, same test, and so far, the same result.
At the same time, gold is sitting right on its lower Bollinger Band, which is at $4,131.
The Daily Relative Strength Index is at 40, turning up from its lows.
That is momentum starting to turn from very weak to just weak.
It is not a buy signal by itself, but it is the kind of shift you usually see
near a short-term low, not in the middle of a collapse.
Now silver.
Silver's summer low was $54.78 in July.
It then rallied to $71.16 in August.
The 61.8 percent retracement of that move, the golden ratio, sits at $61.04.
Look at what silver did today.
It dipped below $60, touched $59.97, which was almost exactly its lower
Bollinger Band at $60.02, and then it bounced right back up to the golden ratio.
It is sitting right at that line as I record this,
so both metals are doing the same thing at the same time.
Both stretched to their lower bands, gold refusing to close below its line,
silver bouncing straight back up to its line.
That is the signal in the title.
But the chart only tells you what is happening.
It does not tell you why.
And to understand why gold and silver are under this much pressure,
you have to look at what happened in the bond market and the dollar today.
This morning, the U.S. dollar index hit 102.19.
That is its highest level of the year.
At the same time, treasury yields jumped again.
The manufacturing survey from the Institute for Supply Management came out at 10 in the morning,
and the headline was a little soft, 54.5 against 55 expected.
But inside the report, the price is paid index,
which measures what factories are paying for their inputs, jumped from 71.1 to 77.9.
That is the highest reading since May.
Factories are telling you their costs are going up fast.
And at that exact moment, gold dropped.
Yields spiked, the dollar spiked, and gold fell about $30 in an hour.
Then, as yields came back down over the afternoon, gold climbed back up again.
On top of that, Minneapolis Fed President Neil Kashkari
said today that inflation is still too high
and that it has been elevated for more than five years.
He said he expects one more rate hike this year and another next year.
So the Fed is not done, and the market knows it.
That is the pressure, a strong dollar, rising yields,
and a Fed that is still talking about hikes.
Gold pays no interest, so every one of those makes it a little harder to hold.
That is why gold and silver have had such a rough September.
Over the past month, spot gold has fallen about 6%.
Silver has fallen more than 8%.
And yet, look at the bigger picture.
The 10-year Treasury yield just had its largest quarterly rise of this century,
from about 4.4% at the end of June to about 5.3% at the end of September.
That is the kind of move that is supposed to crush gold.
Gold still finished the third quarter higher than it started.
The pressure is real, but gold is absorbing it far better than the headlines suggest.
But now, let me show you what is happening behind the scenes,
because this is where the story gets really interesting.
For months, the U.S. Treasury has been trying to calm the bond market.
In August, it announced it would double the size of its long-term bond buybacks,
from $2 billion per operation to $4 billion.
The idea is simple.
If the Treasury buys back some of its own long-dated bonds,
there is less supply out there, and that should push yields down.
It helped for a short while.
In September, the Treasury went further and raised it to $6 billion per operation.
And the bond market sold off anyway.
Ira Jersey at Bloomberg Intelligence said they would need to really
shock and awe the market next time, maybe $10 billion or more per operation.
And Stephen Zeng at Deutsche Bank put it in a way I cannot stop thinking about.
He said it is like the Treasury created a monster that it now has to keep feeding.
Remember, there are roughly $32 trillion of Treasury securities out there.
$6 billion is a rounding error.
The Treasury is running out of easy tools.
And that is where Judy Shelton comes in.
Judy Shelton is an economist who has argued for sound money for decades.
In 2020, she was nominated to the Federal Reserve Board.
The Senate did not confirm her.
Last year, she published a book called Good as Gold.
And in mid-September,
she joined the Treasury Department as a counselor to Treasury Secretary Scott Besant.
The reason gold investors should care is one specific idea she has been pushing
since at least 2012.
She calls them Treasury trust bonds.
A government bond that, when it matures,
the holder can choose to be repaid either in dollars or in a fixed amount of gold.
Think about what that does.
The biggest fear bond buyers have right now is that
the dollar loses value over the life of the bond.
Inflation eats their return.
A bond that can be repaid in gold removes that fear.
And if you remove that fear,
buyers should accept a lower interest rate.
So, in theory, the government could borrow more cheaply by putting gold behind its promise.
Now, I want to be very clear.
There is no announcement.
There is no plan on the table that anyone has published.
She is an advisor, not the person who sets policy.
But the person the Treasury Secretary chose to bring in
at the exact moment his bond market tools are failing
is one of the people best known for linking Treasury bonds to gold.
That is not nothing.
And think about what it would mean if an idea like this ever moved forward.
Gold that backs a government bond has to be worth enough to matter.
A government that wants its gold to carry weight in the bond market
does not want that gold to be cheap.
That is my opinion, not a policy.
But it is the reason this appointment caught my attention.
And it leads to a number that I think every gold investor should know.
The United States holds about 261 million ounces of gold.
On the government's own books, that gold is still valued at $42.22 an ounce,
a price set by law in 1973.
At that price, the entire U.S. gold reserve is worth about $11 billion on paper.
At today's price, it is worth about $1.1 trillion.
$1.1 trillion.
That is roughly what the U.S. government now pays in interest on its debt every single year.
The gold has been sitting there all along.
The question that people like Judy Shelton have been asking
is whether it should start doing some work.
If you are finding this useful, hit the like button and subscribe.
It really does help the channel, and it tells me to keep doing these breakdowns every day.
Now let me show you who is still buying.
Because while prices have been falling, the money has not been leaving.
According to the World Gold Council, gold exchange traded funds took in $18 billion in August.
That was the second largest monthly inflow on record.
Europe had its biggest month ever,
and total gold held in these funds hit a record of 4,189 tons.
So in August, fund investors were piling in at close to a record pace.
We get the September numbers next week,
and that will tell us whether they held on through this pullback.
My guess is most of them did.
Central banks are still buying too.
Poland's central bank added another 7.8 tons in August, bringing its reserves to 648 tons.
Its target is 700.
Its governor, Adam Glipinski, says the purchases boost the credibility of the Polish economy.
And as I showed you earlier this week,
China's central bank has now bought gold for 22 months in a row.
Meanwhile, sentiment among traders is terrible.
Fred Hickey, who has been watching this market for decades,
pointed out that gold's daily sentiment index spent last week bouncing around the low 20s,
on a scale of 0 to 100.
That means almost nobody is bullish.
And he made a point I keep coming back to.
Asian buyers, especially in China, tend to buy heavily when gold gets near $4,000.
China is in its golden week holiday right now, the 1st through the 7th of October,
traditionally one of the biggest weeks of the year for gold jewelry.
So you have record fund holdings, central banks still buying,
and short-term traders who are about as pessimistic as they get.
That is usually what the inside of a bottom looks like.
The people with the longest time horizon are buying,
while the people with the shortest time horizon are scared.
Silver has its own story, and it is one of the strangest charts I have seen this year.
Otavio Costa, at Crescet Capital, has been tracking silver adjusted for the money supply.
Take the silver price and divide it by the total amount of money in the US economy.
When you do that, you get a much longer and cleaner picture.
And according to Costa, around the turn of the year,
silver adjusted for money supply broke out above a resistance level that
had held for more than 45 years.
Then it went from euphoria back to neglect.
And now it is pulling back toward that old resistance,
which, if the breakout was real, should act as support.
That is a classic pattern.
Breakout, pull back, test the breakout level from above.
If it holds, that is often where the next leg starts.
If it fails, the breakout was false, and the physical side has not changed.
The Silver Institute expects this to be the sixth year in a row
that the world uses more silver than it produces.
So why is silver lagging gold?
The gold to silver ratio is at 68.5, up 14% this year.
My read is that silver is being treated like a leveraged version of gold.
When the dollar is strong and yields are rising,
funds cut their most volatile positions first,
and silver is the most volatile thing in the precious metals space.
That is why it fell harder.
And it is also why, if the signal I showed you plays out,
silver has the most room to snap back.
There is one more number I want you to have in mind,
because it says a lot about the world we are in.
The US Strategic Petroleum Reserve, the government's emergency oil supply,
has fallen to 283.8 million barrels.
That is the lowest level since 1982.
It has fallen for 27 weeks in a row,
and another 40 million barrels are being released.
Brent crude is back around $100.
When governments are draining their emergency reserves
and still cannot hold down energy prices,
that is the kind of backdrop where real assets tend to do well over time,
even if the short term is messy.
Now, the next big test comes tomorrow.
Friday at 8.30 in the morning, New York time,
we get the September jobs report.
Economists expect about 90,000 new jobs,
after 162,000 in August,
and the unemployment rate holding at 4.1%.
If the number comes in strong,
the dollar and yields will probably push higher again,
and that would put gold's $4,110 level,
Monday's low, under real pressure.
If the number comes in weak,
it gives the Fed a reason to wait in October,
and that takes some of the pressure off the dollar and yields,
which is exactly what gold and silver need.
I know weeks like this are hard to sit through.
You see gold drop close to $150 in a day,
silver slip under 60,
and every headline sounds like the end.
But the chart is not panicking the way the headlines are,
and that difference is worth paying attention to.
So let me answer the question in the title.
Is the bottom in?
Here's how I'm going to judge it,
and I want you to have the same checklist.
For gold, the bottom is confirmed if spot gold closes back above $4,241.
That is the 61.8% level,
the one it lost on Monday.
If it can do that,
the next target is the 20-day average around $4,300.
That would tell me Monday was the low.
The bottom is not in if gold closes below $4,110.
Monday's low.
If that goes, the 78.6% level has failed,
and the next real support is the June low, around $3,960.
For silver, the bottom is confirmed if it closes above $61.04,
the golden ratio it is sitting on right now,
and then gets back above 63,
where it found support all through September.
If silver closes below $59.97.
Today's low.
The next shelf is $58.28,
and below that, the July low at $54.78.
And one more tell.
Watch the gold to silver ratio.
At real bottoms,
silver often starts outperforming gold,
and the ratio starts falling.
If the ratio rolls over from here,
while both metals hold their levels,
that would be the strongest confirmation of all.
My honest view?
The odds are tilted in favor of a low here.
The signal I showed you has worked about 7 times out of 10.
Silver bounced off its band to the exact golden ratio.
Fund holdings are at a record,
and sentiment is in the gutter.
But the dollar is at its high of the year.
The Fed is still talking about hikes,
and tomorrow's jobs number could push either way.
So I am not going to tell you the bottom is in until the chart does.
What I will tell you is that the next few days are where this gets decided,
and you now know exactly which levels to watch.
And keep an eye on Washington.
When the Treasury runs out of ways to calm its own bond market,
and the person it brings in has spent years designing bonds backed by gold,
that tells you the conversation about gold is changing at the very top,
even if the price has not caught up yet.
If this breakdown helped you,
hit subscribe and turn on notifications.
Because I will be back as soon as the jobs report lands,
with exactly where these levels stand.
And if you think this video deserves a wider audience,
hit the hype button.
It pushes the video to people who need to see it.
Take care of yourselves,
and I will see you in the next one.