Did a plane really hit the Pentagon on September 11th — or was it a missile?
In this highlight from The Brief, retired Lieutenant General David Deptula, who was inside the Pentagon on 9/11 just two corridors from the impact site, responds to one of the most persistent conspiracy theories about the September 11th attacks.
Deptula explains why the missile theory does not fit the evidence: American Airlines Flight 77 departed Dulles, was hijacked, was tracked by air-traffic and radar records, had passengers who communicated from the plane, left wreckage and flight-recorder data, and resulted in victims whose remains were identified through forensic methods. Shabbos also asks Deptula about Donald Rumsfeld’s September 10th statement regarding $2.3 trillion in Pentagon transactions. Deptula explains why that claim referred to unsupported accounting entries and audit trails — not missing cash — and why the idea that 9/11 was staged to cover it up does not fit the facts
I think one of the most bizarre, frankly, conspiracies is that the Pentagon itself was
not hit by a plane, but actually a missile.
And there was no plane at all.
There was no Flight 77.
And for you and I, we might say that that's absurd, but as I said, there's a significant
amount of the populace, at least on social media, who really swear by this theory.
So how would you respond to those who suggest there was no plane, but it was actually a
missile?
Let me answer that from two perspectives and kind of take a mature approach to this, not
an emotional one.
First, I was there.
I mean, I was two quarters away when the Pentagon was struck.
Now, I want to be precise.
I did not personally see the airplane hit the Pentagon, so I'm not going to claim that
I did.
But the idea that a missile hit the Pentagon instead of American Airlines Flight 77 is
simply inconsistent with an enormous body of physical, forensic, eyewitness and investigative
evidence.
I mean, we know that Flight 77 departed Dulles Airport that morning.
We know who was aborted.
We know it was hijacked.
There were communications from people aboard the aircraft.
There were witnesses who saw the airplane approaching the Pentagon.
Aircraft wreckage was recovered inside and around the building.
The flight data recorder was recovered from inside the Pentagon, and it provided the altitude,
the speed, heading, and timing information.
And remains of the people aboard the aircraft were recovered and identified through forensic
methods, including DNA.
The FBI conducted the largest investigation in its history into the 9-11 attacks and concluded
that American Airlines Flight 77 was hijacked by five terrorists and crashed into the Pentagon.
Sixty-four people aboard the aircraft and 125 people inside the Pentagon were killed.
So when somebody says, you know, where's the evidence that an airplane hit the Pentagon?
My response is, the evidence isn't one photograph or one eyewitness.
It's the convergence of radar, air traffic records, witnesses, aircraft wreckage, flight
recorder data, forensic identification of the victims, the known history of the flight,
and the physical damage to the building.
All of those independent lines of evidence point to the same conclusion, and that's that
American Airlines Flight 77 hit the Pentagon on September 11, 2001.
So I just have to ask one last question on that note, which again, I wish I didn't, but
I think it's really important for our viewers to hear it from someone who was there.
On September 10th of 2001, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld was giving a press conference.
You can watch it.
It's still on the internet today on C-SPAN, and he talks about this untraceable $2.3 trillion
that the Pentagon has lost track of.
And a lot of internet conspiracy theorists, they'll look at that and say, well, the timing
has to be something more than just coincidental.
You're talking about the loss of trillions of dollars, and then no one remembers it because
the next day, coincidentally, there's this terrorist attack.
So again, I just think it's important to hear it from you.
How would you respond to those who say, well, the timing here is just too odd to merely
be random?
Well, that claim takes a real Pentagon accounting problem and turns it into something that it
was not.
Secretary Rumsfeld did refer on September 10th to roughly $2.3 trillion in transactions
that couldn't be adequately tracked through the Defense Department's antiquated financial
system.
But that did not mean that $2.3 trillion in cash had disappeared.
I mean, the underlying Inspector General work dealt with fiscal year 1999 financial statements.
The department had processed trillions of dollars in accounting entries, and approximately
$2.3 trillion of those entries did not have adequate documentation or audit trails to
support them.
Now, that's a serious accounting and financial management failure.
But it's very different from saying somebody misplaced or stole $2.3 trillion.
Here's another important point.
This was not revealed for the first time on September 10th, 2001.
The underlying problems had already been documented publicly in Defense Department Inspector General
work and discussed in Congress well before 9-11.
So the notion that the attacks somehow occurred the next day to cover up $2.3 trillion in
missing money simply does not fit the facts.
Thanks for watching this week's episode.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments below, and also tell us what topics you want
to see covered, whether it's immigration, tariffs.
We have great episodes coming up, and we'll see you next week on The Brief.