What was the shepherd looking at?
1 Video View·Oct 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the famous painting *Landscape with the Fall of Icarus* in Brussels, questioning its attribution to Pieter Bruegel the Elder. Through scientific analysis and a comparison with a second version of the work, the video reveals that the well-known image of total indifference to tragedy is likely a copy that altered Bruegel's original intent.
He's looking at something. There's nothing there.
This is Landscape with the Fall of Icarus.
For more than a century, it has been one of the most loved paintings in Brussels
and one of the most famous images in the world of people failing to notice a tragedy.
A boy has just fallen out of the sky.
A ploughman keeps ploughing.
A fisherman keeps fishing.
A ship sails on.
It has been reproduced in textbooks and on book covers
and it turns up in the film The Man Who Fell to Earth
as the picture a character opens a book to.
And the shepherd stares at an empty patch of air in the wrong direction.
Now look at how the museum itself presents it in its online exhibition.
Peter Brueghel the Elder.
Then the word After.
Then a question mark.
The museum is not sure Brueghel painted this.
The evidence suggests he probably didn't.
And when you find the other version of this picture,
you find out what the shepherd was looking at.
Start with what's in front of you.
In the foreground, a ploughman in a bright red shirt,
steering with one hand, face turned down to the earth.
His horse wears blinkers and follows the furrows.
Below him, the shepherd, leaning on his staff, gazing upward.
At the water's edge, a fisherman with his line out.
And on a branch just above him, a partridge.
Behind them, a great ship under full sail,
a harbour town in the haze and a sun half sunk into the horizon.
And down in the corner beside the ship,
two pale legs disappearing into the sea.
That's all you get of Icarus.
The story comes from the Roman poet Ovid.
Daedalus, the great inventor, makes wings of feathers and wax
so that he and his son can escape from Crete.
Icarus flies too high.
The wax melts and he falls into the sea.
Ovid even mentions these three men,
an angler, a shepherd, a ploughman.
But in Ovid, they look up, see the two flying figures
and stand amazed, taking them for gods.
The painting turns that upside down.
Nobody is amazed.
Almost nobody even looks.
That inversion is why the picture became famous.
In 1938, W. H. Auden stood in this museum
and wrote a poem named after it, Musée des Beaux-Arts,
about how ordinary life turns away from suffering.
In 1962, William Carlos Williams wrote another,
taking the painting's own title.
Two major poets, both writing about a bruegel.
The trouble is the bruegel part.
Peter Bruegel the Elder died in 1569.
This painting doesn't turn up anywhere in the record
for another 340 years.
For a painter this famous,
a masterpiece that leaves no trace for three centuries
is exactly the kind of thing that makes specialists nervous.
It isn't signed. It isn't dated.
It appeared on the art market in 1912
and the Brussels Museum bought it that same year.
Doubts started almost at once and they came from two directions.
The first was the painting itself.
Several specialists felt the quality was weaker
than Bruegel's certain works,
although heavy overpainting over the centuries
makes that hard to judge.
Then there were details that didn't work.
The museum's own account notes that the setting sun
doesn't match its reflection in the sea
and describes that sun as probably a later addition.
And the ship, painted with enormous care,
has rigging so lopsided that, according to the same account,
it couldn't sail as shown.
The second problem was the material.
This is oil paint on canvas.
Bruegel's surviving oil paintings are on wooden panels.
The canvases he did paint are in tempera, not oil.
So either this was an unusual exception
or it wasn't his.
That question went to the laboratory
and the laboratory has been arguing with itself ever since.
In 1963, the museum's curator, Philippe Roberts-Jones,
and the Bruegel specialist, Georges Marlier,
proposed an explanation.
Perhaps it had originally been painted on a panel
and later transferred onto canvas,
which restorers once did quite routinely.
In 1998, a team from Belgium's Royal Institute
for Cultural Heritage and Utrecht University
radiocarbon dated the canvas.
Their conclusion was blunt.
Bruegel could not have painted on it.
But a sample of blue paint had been taken
from the right-hand edge back in 1973.
In 2002, at a Bruegel symposium in Brussels,
Leopold Cockhart presented a re-examination of it
under the electron microscope.
Under the original blue, he reported a layer of chalk ground,
the kind of preparation used on wooden panels.
And inside the paint, unusually long needle-like particles
of charcoal of a kind otherwise found in the census at Bethlehem,
a Bruegel in the same museum.
If that's right, the canvas is a later support
and dating it tells you when the painting was moved,
not when it was made.
In 2006, Professor Risa of the Free University of Brussels,
writing with Roberts-Jones,
challenged the radiocarbon result on technical grounds.
Then in 2011, researchers at the Royal Institute,
Christina Currie and Dominique Allart,
presented findings from a major study of Bruegel
and his son's workshop.
The Belgian press reported their verdict as
not a Bruegel.
The remains of the original canvas, they said,
dated from around 1600.
So where does that leave it?
The museum's current summary gives the canvas a possible date
anywhere from 1555 to 1635,
notes it was re-stretched several times before 1912,
and says that no test so far has produced a consensus.
That's the kind of argument that never makes it onto the wall label,
and it's what this channel is for.
If you're enjoying this, a like helps other people find it,
and subscribing means the next painting comes to you.
Because the most revealing evidence isn't in this painting at all.
In 1935, a second landscape with the fall of Icarus
appeared on the market.
It's smaller, it's painted on wood,
it leaves out the far left and right edges of the composition.
In 1951, it was bought by the collector David Van Buren,
and it still hangs in his house in the south of Brussels,
now a museum.
At first glance, it's the same picture.
The ploughman, the shepherd, the fisherman, the ship, the legs.
Then you look up.
In this version, there is a man in the sky,
Daedalus, still flying.
Icarus has already hit the water,
and his father is still up there, wings spread.
And the shepherd is looking straight at him.
In Brussels, he stares at nothing.
In the other version, he's doing exactly what Ovid said,
watching a man fly.
And the sun isn't setting.
It's high in the sky,
where a sun that melts wax ought to be.
Before anyone concludes that this is the real Bruegel,
it isn't either.
Tree ring dating shows the wooden panel is from 1577 at the earliest.
Eight years after Bruegel died.
So there are two copies.
The question becomes which one is closer to what Bruegel actually designed.
That's where the underdrawings come in,
the sketch each painter made on the prepared surface
before any colour went on.
According to the museum's summary,
infrared examination shows the two drawings
were made by two different artists.
The Brussels drawing is functional, a layout.
The Van Buren drawing is livelier and freer.
And then there's the detail that settles part of the argument.
Certain things that are painted in the Van Buren version,
a boat in the central section,
some features on the horizon,
exist in the Brussels version only in the underdrawing.
They were drawn there and never painted,
which suggests that whoever painted the Brussels canvas
started from a design that included them and left them out.
The museum's own conclusion
is that the Van Buren version is the more faithful of the two.
Some have gone further and suggested that the missing Daedalus
and the setting sun in Brussels are the work of a later restorer.
Others think the sinking sun was a deliberate choice
to make the sun look impossibly far away.
That part is still argued.
And the original?
In 1621, an inventory of the imperial collections in Prague
lists a painting called Daedalus and Icarus.
Nobody can say whether that was one of these two or a lost Bruegel.
But it makes it likely that he did paint the subject.
Now think about what that does to the famous reading.
The ploughman still doesn't look.
The fisherman still doesn't look.
The ship still sails on.
In the museum's account,
a man's head lying in the undergrowth by the plough
has even been linked to a Flemish proverb.
No plough stops for a dying man.
The indifference is real and it's in both versions.
But in the version closest to Bruegel's design,
one person in the landscape is looking at the sky
and one person in the sky is looking down at the sea.
In Ovid, when Daedalus realises his son is gone,
he calls out his name.
Icarus, where are you?
Where should I look for you?
Then he sees the feathers on the water.
It's one of the most painful moments in the poem.
A father who has just taught his son to fly,
searching an empty sea.
Ovid adds one more detail.
As Daedalus buries his son,
a partridge watches and seems to rejoice.
The bird was once Daedalus's nephew,
a gifted boy he had pushed from a height out of jealousy
and whom the goddess of wisdom turned into a partridge to save him.
That bird sits on its branch in both versions.
In the painting everyone knows, that father has disappeared.
What's left is a shepherd staring at nothing
and a picture of a world where nobody noticed at all.
That's a powerful image.
It moved two poets.
But it may be partly the result of a copyist's choices
and perhaps a restorer's brush.
So here is what the evidence supports, as plainly as I can put it.
The design is Bruegel's.
The museum says that with confidence.
The painting in Brussels is very probably not by his hand.
The scientists still disagree about the canvas
and there is still a minority who argue
it's a transferred panel from his workshop.
But the museum itself now labels it with a question mark.
The Van Buren version is also a copy painted after his death.
And on the museum's own reading of the underdrawings
it's the closer of the two to what he designed.
In that version Daedalus is still in the sky
and the shepherd is watching him.
The setting sun in Brussels is probably a later addition.
So, one more time.
The most famous painting of the world, ignoring a tragedy
is probably a copy of a lost Bruegel.
And in the version that seems closest to his design
somebody was watching.
None of that makes the Brussels canvas less beautiful.
The composition is still one of the great ideas in European painting.
And it doesn't make Auden wrong.
His poem is about what this canvas shows
and it does show it.
It may just show it more starkly than Bruegel intended.
But the next time you see the shepherd gazing into that empty sky
you'll know he wasn't daydreaming.
There used to be someone there.
YouTube only shows you what it thinks you already follow.
So if you'd like the next painting to reach you
subscribing is the only thing that reliably makes that happen.
It takes a second and it's free.
Thank you for watching all the way through.
There's another painting everyone got wrong on screen now.

