An educational historical analysis hosted by Dr. David Miano examining alternative history claims regarding a terraced monument in Ahichhatra, Uttar Pradesh, India. The critique evaluates arguments presented by amateur researcher Praveen Mohan, who proposes that this structure is the oldest pyramid in the world and served as the direct inspiration for Egypt's Step Pyramid of Djoser. The presentation systematically reviews official archaeological excavation records, local oral legends tied to the Mahabharata, regional structural evolution, and material data to demonstrate how the temple actually dates to the Gupta Period around the fourth century CE.
This video critiques amateur researcher Praveen Mohan's claim that a pyramid in Ahikshatra, India, is the world's oldest and the inspiration for Egypt's Saqqara pyramid. By contrasting local legends with archaeological data, the narrator demonstrates that the structure was built significantly later than the Egyptian pyramids, likely during the Gupta period.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
If you would like to support the channel and become part of our ancient history fan community,
visit patreon.com slash world of antiquity.
Pyramids are found all over the world. No doubt you're familiar with the ones in Egypt,
especially those on the Giza Plateau. But one YouTuber draws attention to a pyramid
constructed in India and proposes that it is, in fact, the oldest pyramid in the world.
Let's look at his video together to see how strong of a case he makes for this claim.
Praveen Mohan is an independent amateur researcher interested in ancient history
and extraterrestrial theory. His YouTube channel is another one of those that
attempt to establish the existence of advanced civilization in prehistoric times.
But his videos mostly concentrate on the history of South Asia and the Americas.
He has appeared on Ancient Aliens, and his channel has over a million subscribers,
making him one of the most popular alternative history proponents on the internet.
One of his recent videos caught my eye titled World's Oldest Pyramid Found in India.
I had no idea what pyramid he was talking about, so I had to take a look.
Then I researched the topic to double check the facts.
Now I'd like to share my discoveries with you.
Do you know what is the oldest pyramid in the world?
Archaeologists will say it is the Djoser or Saqqara pyramid built about 4,600 years ago.
But what if I told you there is an even older pyramid located in India?
When I first heard this claim, I was thinking,
oh, maybe he's talking about one of the buildings from Harappa or Mohenjo-Daro,
cities of the Indus Valley civilization, the oldest known urban society
in the region of northwestern India and Pakistan.
Urbanization occurred there around 2600 BCE, making it roughly contemporary with the
construction of the Step Pyramid of Saqqara in the reign of King Djoser of Egypt.
But no, Praveen takes us to a site in north central India.
There is such a pyramid, a few centuries older than the Saqqara pyramid in Egypt,
located in the town of Bareilly in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
Let's go take a look and see what this place has to offer.
As you can see, guys, I'm in the middle of nowhere, right?
But there is that giant pyramid.
These are the ruins of ancient Ahikshatra.
What I found out is that archaeological work was done here in the 1860s,
then again in the 1940s, and in recent years by a collaborative effort between
the Archaeological Survey of India and the Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur.
Dr. Bhuwan Vikrama, the superintending archaeologist, has written about the work done there.
I will leave a link to one of his articles below for you.
Archaeological evidence indicates that this area was settled
during the time that the cities of the Indus Valley civilization were starting to go into decline.
The first people that lived here were the ones who made the type of pottery
that archaeologists call ochre-colored pottery, dating to around 2000 to 1500 BCE.
So somewhere in that 500-year span, Ahikshatra was founded.
The problem is, if this place was first settled at the earliest, in 2000 BCE,
even if the people built the pyramid as soon as they got here,
that still would put it around 600 years after the construction of Djoser's Step Pyramid at Saqqara.
There is that giant pyramid that was built before the Saqqara Pyramid in Egypt.
In most of the video he only suggests that it could be so, but here he is definite, saying
there is that giant pyramid that was built before the Saqqara Pyramid in Egypt.
Now you might be asking yourself, how does he know?
What evidence does he have that would overturn
the physical evidence the archaeologists found here?
We'll find out shortly.
So you guys can see the height of each level of the Step Pyramid, and it's at least 10 feet tall,
and there are at least five or six levels, guys.
There are at least five or six levels.
Actually, I believe, I hope you can see all the various levels of the pyramid,
but I think that there are more levels hidden, okay?
For example, look here.
So you can see that more levels are hidden there.
Archaeologists refer to this structure as Temple 1.
There's another major structure here, which is called, as you might guess, Temple 2.
Both temples were created by constructing boxes of baked bricks,
filling them with dirt, and sealing them with two or three courses of flat bricks.
This one, Temple 1, is 75 feet high, and there are five concentric platforms.
It originally had only three platforms, but the original building was expanded at some point.
A staircase goes up it on the western side, and what Praveen is pointing to
are remnants of that stairway, which approached the building from below.
It also was a later addition.
See, this is a giant rock.
It's a giant monolithic rock.
Like, look at the height of that, right?
So I'm maybe like, you know, five and three quarters, and then probably eight feet tall.
And this is why they call this place Bheem Gada or Bheem Gada,
because they think that this used to be the club or maze of a giant called Bheem.
Archaeologists believe there was even more here on the top than that.
Comparative study with a similar temple at Bitargaon
have suggested that there was a large sanctum on the summit.
Can you tell what this is?
This is a giant lingam.
This was probably at least 12 to 20 feet tall lingam that's placed on top of the pyramid.
Okay.
I'm not making this up because there are ancient texts which clearly give
how a lingam should be designed.
And this four-sided base, eight-sided middle part,
and the top cylinder is clearly described in ancient texts.
So we know that this is a lingam.
And archaeologists also confirm that this is, in fact, a giant monolithic lingam.
For those who don't know, a lingam is a symbol of the god Shiva that evokes the male sex organ.
A yoni is a symbol of the goddess Shakti that evokes the female sex organ.
But they're not associated with fertility rites, but rather with cosmic principles,
the generative power of the universe, or the male and female aspects of the universe.
They are often represented together and found on temples dedicated to Shiva.
Okay, so this is what the locals say.
Shortly after the time of Krishna, a group of Nagas came down here
and started to build the very first pyramid in the world.
This is why this place was originally called Ahi Kshetra.
The word Ahi means Naga, and the word Kshetra means
place or sometimes even temple in the ancient language of Sanskrit.
Ah, so here he begins to provide his evidence for the age of the pyramid.
It comes from local legend.
I'm sure you realize that means we're talking about an oral tradition that has
spanned centuries, or if the locals are correct, millennia.
No one can even say what the origin of this oral tradition is.
Someone in the past said it, and people started repeating it.
Mind you, I think it's always worth exploring oral stories, but in this case,
they're telling us that Nagas built the pyramid, and Nagas are mythical creatures,
semi-divine beings that are half human, half cobra.
But maybe the legend preserves a historical kernel of truth in it,
such as the part about the pyramid being built shortly after the time of Krishna.
When was that?
Well, that would be the time of a legendary conflict known as the Kurukshetra War.
Unfortunately, there's considerable disagreement as to when the war may have occurred.
Suggested dates have ranged between 5500 and 950 BCE.
Because the great Indian epic, the Mahabharata,
which recounts the story of the Kurukshetra War, mentions Ahikshatra,
it seems to me that this is the basis of the local legend.
They know their settlement is mentioned in the poem, and it would be perfectly normal
for them to then assume the pyramid was built sometime after that.
But it's all very vague on the timing.
How long exactly after the war do they think it was built?
Instead of relying on a story that has been passed down orally for many generations,
which is subject to change, embellishment, and distortion,
it seems we're on more solid ground when we rely on the evidence from the site itself.
Now, this is what's really, really interesting about this pyramid,
because it's very, very similar to the oldest, or the so-called, quote-unquote,
oldest pyramid in the world, which is considered Saqqara Pyramid in Egypt.
Because you can see the Nagas carved over the walls in the complex of the Saqqara Pyramid,
indicating that the people who built this pyramid must have migrated
and built the Saqqara Pyramid in Egypt.
Are these two pyramids really all that similar?
They look quite different to me.
But maybe I'm missing something.
Seriously, please let me know what you think in the comments below.
They're also built with different materials and with different methods.
Now, what about the Nagas?
Even though there are cobras at the Djoser Pyramid complex,
there are none at the Akshatra Pyramid.
There's the lingam representing Shiva.
Images of the river goddesses Ganga and Yamuna
were found at the entrance to the third terrace stairway.
But no Nagas.
While it's certainly true that both India and Egypt have cobra gods,
just that fact alone cannot establish that
one country got the idea of a cobra god from another country.
That's because many countries turn animals into gods.
And because we have no other evidence of people from India
migrating to Egypt prior to dynastic times.
Now you can see how this place could be the origin
of all the pyramids around the world.
Because we know that Mayas have pyramids,
Aztec built pyramids,
Egyptians obviously built pyramids,
Cambodian built pyramids.
But it's quite possible that India was the mother of all these pyramids.
As you may already know, pyramid is a very broad category of building.
It's any structure that's largest at the bottom
and whose outer surface converges to a smaller point at the top.
It can be smoothed.
It can be stepped.
It can be irregular in shape.
It's a very basic generic design.
Easy to devise by any human being at any time in history.
Give a little kid some blocks
and he will, without any knowledge of a pyramid,
likely build a step pyramid in due course.
And the pyramids Praveen refers to
are all built in very different styles
and with different materials.
To suggest that two step pyramids
could not have been thought of by two different societies
far removed from each other
is not all that different from suggesting that
two flights of stairs could not have been thought of
by two different societies far removed from each other.
Whenever you see pyramids,
you are supposed to see a square base
with a unique spout called a yoni.
But where's the yoni here?
Why is it missing?
Now, initially, I had assumed
that people have broken the yoni
and they've thrown it somewhere.
And that's quite possible.
But I've seen images
from the Remote Sensing Department of India
and it's very interesting
because the entire pyramid
has a unique spout-shaped structure at one end
indicating that could be a giant yoni.
And not only that,
believe it or not,
that same structure,
that same yoni-like structure
also exists in Saqqara.
It's interesting that Praveen
is making two incredible claims in this video.
Not only that this pyramid is older
than the Saqqara Pyramid,
but also that this pyramid
was the inspiration for the Saqqara Pyramid.
We've already seen that
they do not have similar blueprints
and that the Saqqara Pyramid
was not connected to snake worship in any way.
But what about his claim
that the yoni-like structure existed at Saqqara?
Well, here's the structure he's talking about,
which is attached to the Saqqara Pyramid.
It's the funerary temple.
It was a building.
Praveen is just showing you the outline of its shape
as seen from above,
basically a rectangle.
Here is a reconstruction of it.
And here are some examples of yonis.
How strong do you think the resemblance is?
This entire area is said to be a part
of the ancient Panchala Kingdom,
which existed at the time of Krishna
during the period of Mahabharata,
around 3100 BC.
This region originally belonged
to the ancestors of Panchali,
the wife of Arjuna and his brothers,
and also his great-great-grandfather.
So this place was originally
a part of the Panchala Kingdom.
So Praveen puts the date of the Kurukshetra War,
the time of Krishna,
at around 3100 BCE.
Let's say he's right
and the Kurukshetra War occurred at that time,
before the earliest evidence of urbanization
in all of South Asia.
Remember, archaeology indicates
the Indus Valley civilization urbanized
around 2600 BCE.
The Mahabharata does indeed say
that this place, Ahikshatra,
existed at the time of the war,
but it doesn't say anything about the pyramid.
So the Mahabharata offers zero evidence
for the date of the pyramid.
This place was inhabited all the way
until the 10th century of the Common Era,
thousands of years.
During the life of a settlement,
buildings go up, buildings come down.
The pyramid could have been built at any time
during the life of the settlement.
You see that circular structure
at the base of the pyramid?
When archaeologists excavated here in the 1940s,
they found that.
It's the remnants of an earlier building,
which the pyramid was later built on top of.
Its existence confirms that the pyramid
was not built right away.
Another building had a life here
before the pyramid did,
and the style of the earlier building
and the potsherds found within it
have indicated that it was built
during the Kushan period,
between the 1st and 4th centuries CE.
The pyramid, therefore,
had to have been constructed after that.
The archaeologists have noted
a gradual development of the art
and architecture of the city.
Based on the known evolution
of temple architectural and artistic styles
and comparison with other ancient structures,
the archaeologists have dated the pyramid
to the Gupta period.
Bhuvan Vikrama dates it specifically
to the reign of the great emperor Samudragupta,
who reigned in the 4th century CE.
So, I'm sure this comes as no surprise to you.
This is not the world's oldest pyramid.
Not even close.
Anyway, ground-penetrating radar
has revealed that there's more
to be found beneath the earth,
so there will likely be more discovery
at this fascinating site,
which will shed more light
on the development of urbanism in the area.
I look forward to that.
You might like my little e-booklet,
Why Ancient History Matters.
It's designed to persuade people
that the subject is important,
even in the modern world.
You might also wish to use it
to help spread the word,
so feel free to share it with someone you know.
It's free for anyone who wants it.
I've left a link in the description box
below the video for you to grab a copy.
Catch you later.