The Birth of China - Hunters on the Yellow River (20000 BCE to 7000 BCE)

Ancient Asia - China
17 followers
Beijing. For centuries this city has acted as China's capital and today over 20 million people
live within its boundaries. Throughout the country's final two imperial dynasties,
the Ming and the Qing, China's emperors would call it home, alternating their residence between
the sprawling estate of lakes and gardens known as the Summer Palace and the vast complex known
today as the Forbidden City. During their reigns these men would style themselves as
universal sovereigns, entitled to dominion of the known world through their possession of the
Mandate of Heaven. Their regime followed a blueprint that was already more than a thousand
years old, where the rulership of China was passed from dynasty to dynasty with only the
occasional hiatus. But for all its longevity and claimed grandeur, the imperial system was not to
last. After a series of defeats by European powers in the late 19th century, the prestige of the Qing
dynasty collapsed and the period of attempted reform that followed failed to arrest its decline.
In 1911, public discontent with the imperial system led to the outbreak of the Xinhai Revolution
and the next year saw the abdication of the last emperor, a boy then only six years old.
In the years that followed, other men would attempt to restore the Qing monarchy
or even to claim their throne for themselves, but none would succeed.
And for more than a hundred years, the sons of heaven who ruled China for more than two
millennia have been no more. Today their secluded residences and museums open to the public,
and now ordinary citizens tread every day on ground where only a select few once stood.
The end of the imperial system represented a decisive break with the past.
For over 2,000 years, China was ruled by an emperor who with one notable exception was a man,
imbued in theory with absolute power. In practice, the authority exercised by a given ruler would
vary, and at times this title would be disputed between multiple claimants and dynasties,
some of whose rule was limited to only small portions of China. The more powerful of these
emperors would leave an indelible footprint on Chinese society, and the centuries-long
rule of dynasties such as the Han and the Tang are often described as golden periods in Chinese
history. It is unsurprising then that in the West knowledge of China's ancient history is almost
entirely concerned with its imperial rulers, and often focuses on the imposing structures
that they erected. Foremost amongst these are the iconic Great Wall of China, which stretches
throughout much of the country's northern reaches, the mausoleum of its first emperor and its buried
army of terracotta warriors, and the imposing palace complex of the Forbidden City, which
served as the winter residence of China's elite for half a millennium. Outside of these structures,
other famous periods of Chinese history include the Mongol-led Yuan Dynasty, best known for its
founder Kublai Khan, and the long period of warfare between the competing dynasties of Cao Wei,
Xu Han and Dong Wu, that would later be glamorised in the Ming literary classic
of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. But as famous and long-lasting as China's imperial
system was, a question that is rarely asked is how exactly did it come to be? Indeed it has long
been understood by historians and archaeologists that by the time the first imperial dynasty rose
to power in the late 3rd century BCE, Chinese civilisation was already over a millennium old,
and that many of the institutions and customs of the centuries ahead originated in this period.
Even more obscure is the period that preceded it, that came before the emergence of the region's
first written script, and our understanding of which depends entirely on the archaeological
record. It is in this oft-neglected dream time that the deities and culture heroes of Chinese
myth are said to have walked the earth, such as the gods Nu Wa and Fu Xi, the Yellow Emperor
Huan Di, and the other divine and semi-divine figures known collectively as the Three Sovereigns
and Five Emperors. In works such as the Bamboo Annals and the Records of the Grand Historian,
we are told that this period culminated in the founding of China's first dynasty,
the semi-mythical Xia, whose claimed transfer of power to the Shang dynasty formed the ideological
basis for dynastic succession in the millennia ahead. On a surer footing, we know from the
archaeological record that this period saw the emergence of China's first complex societies,
the development of which is inexorably tied to their slow adoption of agriculture
and sedentary living. More than any others in Chinese history, it is these millennia that are
marked by dramatic changes in climate, technology, and the lifestyle of its peoples, who slowly
transitioned from the hunter-gatherer lifestyle that had marked humanity up until this point,
to complex societies reliant on domesticated plants and animals for survival. And around
the beginning of the 2nd millennium BCE, these developments would culminate in the appearance
of some of the earliest states in world history. In this series, we will attempt to fill in this
neglected period of China's history. To do so, we will begin by examining the archaeological
record of Chinese prehistory, tracing the origins of its earliest complex societies,
beginning with the hunter-gatherer communities that flourished after the end of the last ice age.
From here, we will follow their slow evolution into early farming settlements,
marked by increasing size, social complexity, and the appearance of a visible elite.
In later millennia, we will see the slow emergence of metalworking, an event that
overlapped with the development of the region's first true urban centres and kingdoms.
In later episodes, we will also take some time to discuss China's traditional body of history,
examining the Chinese people's own understanding of their past, and whether any parallels can be
made between the archaeological record and the claimed histories of the early societies of the
Yellow River Valley. Finally, we will conclude by examining the rise of China's first rulers,
which culminated in the establishment of the Qin Dynasty,
whose imperial model of rule would set the example for all others to follow.
In our first episode, we will explore the lifestyles of China's final hunter-gatherer
societies, amongst whom we will see early signs of sedentary living and plant and animal
domestication. Before we do so, however, we should note that during this series,
we will be largely focusing on societal developments in Eastern China,
particularly on the territory of what in the West is sometimes termed China proper.
This is not to diminish the development of complex societies in the other regions that
comprise the modern People's Republic, but is simply because the territory of the earliest
Chinese dynasties was largely restricted to this region. Indeed, it is in this comparatively
low-lying area of plains and hills that we see the emergence of some of China's earliest
agricultural societies, many of which were concentrated around its major river valleys,
the Huanghu, or Yellow River, in northern China, the Yangtze in southwestern and eastern-central
China, and to a lesser extent the Chucheng, or Pearl River, far to the south. When it comes
to today's episode, however, all of this lies far in the future. Instead, we must cast our minds
back over 20,000 years into the past, to the height of the last Ice Age. Around 20,000 BCE,
the climate of China was a far cry from that of today. Around this time, the Earth was in a period
known as the Last Glacial Maximum, and on average the world would have been both cooler and more
arid than it is today. With large amounts of water locked up in the ice caps and glaciers,
the average sea level was some 130 metres lower than it is today, and the now-submerged Yellow
Sea plain would have been exposed as far east as the Korean Peninsula, and as far south as the
Ryukyu Islands. In the north, the average temperature would have been between 6-9 degrees
lower than today. Permafrost levels would have extended as far south as Beijing, as well as
throughout the western Qinling Mountains and the neighbouring Tibetan Plateau, and there is little
evidence of human occupation above these points. The result is that during this time, the climate
around the Yellow River Valley would have largely consisted of arid desert or semi-arid steppe and
populated at the most by a small amount of broadleaf trees.
Further south, the drop in temperature would have been less dramatic, perhaps around 4-5 degrees,
and the lower-lying land along the Yangtze Basin would have been largely dominated by wild grasses.
By the time of the Last Glacial Maximum, we are halfway through a period known as the Upper
Paleolithic, which in this region is held to date from approximately 35,000 to 7,000 BCE.
Exactly when or how modern humans first arrived in Southeast Asia remains a subject of debate
amongst archaeologists, but it is likely that by 20,000 BCE they would already have been present
in the region for tens of thousands of years. From examining the small number of sites that
have been uncovered dating from this period, we can tell that the peoples of Upper Paleolithic
China appear to have pursued a hunter-gatherer lifestyle similar to those of peoples elsewhere
in Eurasia, remaining in one location only as long as the local resources allowed.
There is also widespread evidence that they used common tool production methods for the period,
such as striking flake tools from a central stone core to make choppers and scrapers,
and from around 43,000 BCE a type of long flake tool known as blades also became popular throughout
northern China. It is likely that many of these tools were in turn attached to wooden or bone
handles to facilitate their use as cutting implements, or were fixed to shafts to allow
them to serve as projectile weapons such as spears or bows. There is also evidence that
these peoples commonly made tools out of both bone and antler, and the presence of needles and
awls at these sites suggest that their occupants wore tailored clothing suited to the colder
environment. In terms of social structure, currently it is thought that these early
hunter-gatherer groups were largely egalitarian, and there are also signs that these people were
already practicing their own forms of artistic expression. Evidence for this has been found at
sites such as Shui Dong Gou in the Ningxia Autonomous Area, which according to Carbon 14
dating was likely occupied around 36,000 BCE. Here an inscribed pebble bearing a number of
linear markings has been found that were likely made by a stone implement. A more elaborate
carving has also been found on a piece of antler at the cave site of Long Gu in Hubei province,
dating from approximately 11,000 BCE. This item contains a series of incised wavy lines that
appear to have been originally filled with red ochre, along with a complex interlaced design
and rectangular pattern that are without parallel elsewhere in the period. Alongside these simple
carvings, there is also evidence that at least some of these peoples were decorating themselves
with ornaments made from bone and shell. A most elaborate example of these were found in the
upper caves of the Choukou Dian complex in Beijing. Here what is interpreted as a burial area
containing the remains of eight people has been found, coated in red ochre, alongside which were
found large amounts of animal teeth, bones and shells. Many of these items show signs of drill
holes and perforations, which would have allowed them to be hung as pendants, necklaces and
bracelets, or possibly sewn onto clothing as decoration. And in addition to their decorative
qualities, the presence of these shells at a site so far inland also demonstrates that some form of
long-range trade network was operating in the region, with precious items likely being passed
from one community to another until they had travelled vast distances from the coast. When it
comes to habitation sites in China, dating from the second half of the Upper Paleolithic, our
knowledge is currently limited to only a few places. This is unsurprising, as it is thought
that at this time its inhabitants would largely have been mobile hunter-gatherers, whose temporary
dwelling places would have left only a limited trace on their environment. We do however know
of a number of sites throughout northern and southern China that give us some insights into
these communities. From the evidence gathered at these locations, we can tell that peoples in
these two regions were already employing their own specialised methods to survive in their
respective ecosystems. In northern China, much of our knowledge of the late Paleolithic comes from
four major clusters of sites, Xiechuan, Shizhoutan, and Longwangchang in Shanxi province, and Hutouliang
in Hubei province. With the exception of Shizhoutan, which shows evidence of much longer
occupation, these clusters largely date from between 20,000 to 13,000 BCE, and each consist
of a dozen or more seasonal campsites. From the remains found at these sites, we can tell that
their occupants would have lived a highly mobile forager lifestyle, regularly shifting their place
of residence whenever resources grew scarce. To make the most of their colder environment,
these peoples appear to have hunted a broad spectrum of local animal life, including species
such as wild pig, antelope, deer, ox, turtles, rats, fish, buffalo, and even ostrich. This hunting
would in turn have been aided by their adoption of a new type of tool that may have been designed
for the colder environment. In addition to other common Paleolithic tools, such as large plates
and heavy duty axes, adzers, and whetstones, these communities also appear to have made ample
use of a technology known as microblades. As their name suggests, these versatile tools
consist of small blades that are more than twice as long as they are wide, and which can be inserted
into cleft handles to make composite points, cutting edges, and barbs. The earliest known
examples have been found at the site of Xia Ma Bei, dating from approximately 40,000 years ago,
but it is thought that these tools only became a major feature of Paleolithic communities in
northern China between roughly 18,000 to 14,000 BCE. Compared to larger flakes and blades,
it has been argued that these composite tools would have been both more durable and quicker
to replace, and the pebbles and stone cores from which they were struck may have been more portable
than those required for other tools. These features would have made them highly attractive
to a mobile hunter-gatherer, as they would have allowed their owners to patrol a greater hunting
range without being tied to specific sources of toolmaking materials. In addition to this tool
usage, it is at a number of these sites that we also see some of our earliest known evidence
for widespread exploitation of plant resources in the region. To demonstrate this, let us examine
one of these site clusters in a little more detail. At Shizuotan, some 25 residential sites
have been found, situated alongside the Chianshui River, a tributary of the larger Yellow River,
some of which appear to have only been occupied for short periods. The earliest of these sites
dates from roughly 19,000 BCE, and from its remains we can tell that the people here were
largely subsisting on a diet of antelope, wild pig, deer, ox, and rat. Alongside the microblade
tools of the time, this site is also marked by the presence of a small number of grinding slabs
and hand stones. Analysis of the residues taken from the surfaces of these items has found that
they were used to grind a wide range of plants, including acorns, beans, tubers, and the seeds
of wild grasses, which would have resulted in a rough form of flour that could be used to make
simple foodstuffs. Interestingly, these grasses may have included the wild ancestors of both
foxtail and broomcorn millets, the domesticated forms of which would go on to be a major foodstuff
for agricultural communities along the Yellow River basin in the millennia ahead. Similar
grindstones have also been found at Longwangchang and Xiechuan, and analysis of glosses found on
plates retrieved from the latter indicates that they may have been used as crude sickles to reap
the seeds of wild grasses. We will discuss the implications of these activities on plant
domestication soon. For the moment, however, we can say that we now have some idea of the
lifestyles of late Paleolithic hunter-gatherers in northern China. With this accomplished,
let us turn our attention elsewhere and examine what evidence we have for Paleolithic life in
the south. In this region, we currently lack evidence for any open air sites along the lines
of those discovered in the north. Instead, most of our information on how people would have lived
here in the millennia after the end of the last glacial maximum comes from a series of seasonally
occupied cave sites that have been discovered south of the Yangtze. These include Yuchanyan
in Hunan province, Jiaotonghuan and Shanrendong in northern Guangxi province, and Dayan,
Miaoyan and Zhongpian in Guangxi province. These sites date from a number of different periods
between roughly 18,000 to 7,000 BCE and are characterised by the presence of hearths,
ash piles and burials, along with thick deposits of plants and animal remains,
and tools made from bone, stone and antler. At Yuchanyan for example, a site that was occupied
between roughly 16,000 to 12,000 BCE, there is evidence that the inhabitants were subsisting
on a broad spectrum diet of pig, deer, tortoise, fish, birds, and some 40 different species of
seeds. As with other sites, the implements found here largely consist of stone choppers and flake
tools, along with a number of items made from stone, bone and antler that may have been used
to dig soil for tubers, and a number of polished shells that may have been used as cutting blades.
Interestingly little evidence has been found at these sites for the use of stone blades and
microblades, and it has been suggested that these tools were more of an adaptation to the
resource-poor environments of the North that were unnecessary in the comparatively resource-rich
South. And it is also at these sites that we see the use of a new technology, the development of
which long predates its appearance at other early agricultural centres outside of Southeast Asia.
Pottery. The Paleolithic pottery of southern and central China is the earliest yet discovered
anywhere in the world. The oldest reliably dated examples have been found at Shanrendong Cave,
and consist of fragments that have been dated to between 18,000 to 17,000 BCE, based on
radiocarbon analysis of surrounding materials. These vessels consist of simple containers made
from clay and tempered with quartz, that would have been sculpted by hand using a rounded bottom.
Coils of clay were then built up around this, resulting in uneven walls roughly a centimetre
thick. After this the vessel would have been fired at a low temperature to produce a fragile container.
Simple pottery has also been found at many other sites dating from this period,
with their exact form and components varying between them. At Dayan pottery shards have
been discovered with walls up to 3cm thick, whilst at Yuchanyan, the fragmentary remains
of vessels dating from around 16,000 BCE have been found tempered with charcoal and sand.
Interestingly at the latter site, these shards were numerous enough that two vessels were able
to be reconstructed, one of which features a pointed bottom, along with decorative chord
marks that are a common feature of early Chinese pottery. We should also note that the use of
pottery during the late Paleolithic is not unique to southern China. A small number of pot shards
have also been found in northern China at the site of Hutou Liang, though currently its exact
function here remains uncertain. Pottery has also been found throughout other East Asian sites
dating from roughly the same period, most notably at those belonging to the incipient Jomon culture
of Japan, along with a small number of locales in the Russian Far East. The discovery of this
early pottery in East Asia initially presented a quandary for archaeologists. Since the early
20th century, models of agricultural development, most notably those championed by the influential
professor Gordon Child, held the appearance of pottery to be a defining feature of early
farming communities, where it was primarily used for storage and cooking. The discovery of pottery
amongst the Paleolithic peoples of East Asia contradicted this theory, and it is now accepted
that whilst pottery is often more abundant in early agricultural settlements, it was originally
invented by mobile hunter-gatherer communities. In terms of their function, there has currently
been little in the way of systematic studies examining how these vessels would have been used.
For the moment, however, we do have a few theories. We can tell from the presence of burn marks on the
surface of some of these fragments that they may have been used in much the same way as in later
societies, to cook simple foodstuffs. At Zhengpian for example, a major component of the inhabitants
diet was fish, shellfish and mollusks such as snails, and it is likely that these foods would
have been cooked in pots prior to their consumption. It has also been theorized that pottery may have
been involved in the processing of animal remains found at Yuchangyan, possibly being used to aid
the extraction of fatty grease and marrow from the bones of red deer. As such, it has been suggested
by professors Li Liu and Xinchan Chen in their work The Archaeology of China, that the adoption of
in this region may reflect an improved form of cooking for foods that had already been consumed
here for millennia. Alternatively, it has been suggested that this early pottery may have had
more of a social role. In support of this theory, it should be noted that the amount of pottery that
has been retrieved from these sites is somewhat small, and rather than being used as a day-to-day
item, it may instead have been produced to mark special occasions and communal feasting.
Many of these cave sites would be intermittently occupied for much of the Paleolithic,
and there is evidence that Diao Tonghuan and Zhongpiang remained occupied for millennia
afterwards. We will return to some of these sites, along with others that emerged during the later
part of this period shortly. But as we now have a fair understanding of the lifestyles of the
time has come for us to move forwards. In the final stages of the Paleolithic,
China's climate would vary dramatically. Since the end of the last glacial maximum,
its average temperature had been increasing, and between 13,000 and 10,800 BCE, China's climate
was marked by a number of warmer periods. This increased temperature resulted in a major change
in the distributions of the region's plant species, one that would have a profound effect
on its residents' lifestyles. Then, as in modern times, the East Asian seasonal monsoon would have
brought warm, moist air to China's southernmost regions, facilitating the growth of wild rice.
Unlike the other cereal crops that early agricultural societies would come to rely on
in the north, rice is effectively a marsh plant, and its growth relies more on high temperatures
and a constant supply of water rather than soil quality. This means that as the region warmed,
the range of wild rice would have expanded northwards into the Yangtze river valley,
where it would have been gathered by local hunter-gabberer groups. At Yuchanyan, the remains
of small amounts of wild rice have been found alongside early pottery and shell knives that
may have been used to harvest it. At the Aotonghuan, the amount of wild rice observed at the site
surges tenfold around 11,200 BCE, indicating that the residents of this site were likely
harvesting it to supplement their diet during this period. And whilst we lack any evidence that
this plant was being actively cultivated at this time, this simple gathering is thought by many
archaeologists to represent the earliest stages of rice domestication, a process that would continue
for millennia. Then around 10,900 BCE, the climate changed again. Much of the northern
hemisphere saw a sudden drop in temperature and a corresponding return to glacial conditions.
This event is referred to in both European and North American archaeology as the Younger Dryas,
and a similar cool period is observed throughout Southeast Asia, though its exact timeline varies
between regions. This return to cool temperatures continued for just over a millennium, during which
time China's climate may have been somewhat unstable. The range of wild rice contracted
southwards, and evidence for its consumption largely disappears from the Aotonghuan during
this period. Then after 9,600 BCE, the average temperature throughout China began to increase
again. With this warming also came an increase in rainfall, as the East Asian monsoon began to
penetrate further north once again, and much of eastern China would come to consist of swamps
and lakelands. Sea levels also rose to cover much of the previously exposed Yellow Sea plain,
potentially submerging many Paleolithic sites in the process. It is during this period of warming
that we begin to see changes in the subsistence strategies employed by China's hunter-gatherer
population. Whilst in the north the inhabitants of Shizhutan continue to display a mobile foraging
strategy similar to those of earlier Paleolithic communities, people at other sites began to remain
in the same place for longer periods of time. This can be observed at sites such as Donghuilin
and Chuanyan in northern Beijing, Nianchongtou in Hebei province, and Lijiangou in Henan province,
whilst a cave settlement dating from this period has also been found at Bianbiandong
in Shandong province. Under this approach, dubbed the collector strategy by Professor Robert
Bettinger, these communities would remain at a single residential site for an extended time,
and rather than moving on once their local resources had been exhausted,
they instead appear to have sent out small groups to collect far-off foodstuffs.
These more permanent sites are characterised by their increased size compared to those of
earlier Paleolithic communities, along with more formalised burials and an increased use of pottery.
At Donghuilin for example, a 3000m2 site has been unearthed on a mountainous river terrace
close to the Qingshui river. This site was likely inhabited somewhere between 9000-7000 BCE
and is marked by the presence of hearths and ash pits, along with a large amount of
artefacts made from bone, shell and stone. It is these finds, along with a large amount
of animal and plant remains that were found on the site, that allow us to infer that the
site was used by its inhabitants to pursue a broad spectrum strategy of hunting red deer
and wild pigs, along with gathering seafood, whilst also increasingly exploiting the local plant
foodstuffs. At the time of its initial occupation, the temperature of this region would have been
some 2-3 degrees higher than today, and the local environment would increasingly have been
dominated by a mixture of forest and grassland which would have been abundant in nuts and various
types of edible grass seeds. From residue analysis of the numerous grindstones and querns that had
been found at the site, we know that its residents were using them to process large amounts of acorns,
along with the grains of wild grasses. It has also been suggested that the initial use of
pottery in this region may have been to aid in the processing of these foodstuffs.
Whilst acorns and other nuts appear to have been widely exploited as foodstuffs,
they also contain compounds known as tannins, which are toxic to humans if consumed.
However, in some cases, these compounds can be removed simply by leaving them submerged in water
for a few days, a function for which a simple pot would have been ideal.
Once grinding was complete, these same tools could then have been used to cook the resulting
nut flour into a simple but edible gruel, one that could have been readily combined with other
foodstuffs. The extensive usage of both grindstones and pottery by these communities
has also been interpreted by archaeologists as reflecting an increasingly sedentary lifestyle,
as these heavy objects would have required greater time to produce
and would have been more difficult to transport between locations.
This tendency towards remaining in one spot for longer portions of the year has also been linked
with the increasing appearance of another tool that is thought to have been linked with increasing
investment in construction. Whilst microblades and flakes remain the dominant tools amongst
these communities, a small amount of what are termed polished or groundstone tools have also
been unearthed at a number of settlements dating from this period. Unlike flakes and blades,
which would have been shaped by simple knapping, these implements would have been further refined
by slowly rubbing them against a grindstone, resulting in a partial or fully polished surface.
Whilst this process required greater time investment, the resulting axes and adzers
would have been far more durable than flake tools, and it is thought that these tools
would have been developed to facilitate increased woodworking associated with the building of more
permanent shelters. However it should be noted that other than a small number of decayed wooden
poles found at Nanchuang Tou, no clear remains of wooden structures have been observed at any of
these sites, and even then polished stone tools are conspicuously absent from this settlement.
It is also important for us to acknowledge that polished stone tools were not an entirely new
development in the region. A stone implement matching this style was also found at the
site of Longwangchang, where it is hypothesised that it may have been used as a digging implement.
However it is from this point in the archaeological record onwards that they begin to increase in
number, and in future millennia they would eventually displace blades and microblades
as the most prominent form of stone tool. It is alongside the more sedentary features
observed at these sites that we see some of the earliest evidence for both animal and
plant domestication in China. We previously explored this process in detail in another
series on this channel, The Birth of Civilisation. To give a brief overview however, domestication
refers to the process by which wild plants and animals are selectively bred for traits
that make them more attractive for human food production and management.
In the case of plants, this process is usually achieved through selective cultivation,
where seeds with preferred traits are increasingly reared in artificial settings
such as fields. In its earliest forms, the selection may well have been unintentional,
with hunter-gatherers simply replanting the seeds they knew grew well in their local environment.
These seeds could have been marked by larger grain sizes, or may have adhered more strongly
to their stalk and thus have been easier to gather once grown. This selection process is a slow one,
and it can often continue for many millennia before recognisably domesticated plant forms emerge.
In the course of this episode, we've already seen some limited evidence in earlier Paleolithic
communities of possible plant cultivation, seen in the remains of wild rice at southern cave sites
such as Jiao Tong Huan and Shan Ren Dong, along with the potential sickle blaze discovered at
Xiatuan. Exactly when this simple cultivation progressed to more intense management in China
is currently unknown, but it is from sites dating to this period that we begin to see
the earliest evidence yet discovered for domesticated millets. At the sites of Nanchuang
Tou, which has been radiocarbon dated to between 9500 to 9000 BCE, a large number of grindstones
and mullers have been unearthed. In 2012, the surface of one set of these was microscopically
analysed, revealing the presence of over 400 starch grains, roughly 50% of which belong to
local varieties of millet. Amongst these, the remains of larger millet grains were discovered,
with features more closely resembling those of domesticated plants. In the earliest layers of
the site, these cultivated grains already make up around 45% of all starch grains present,
and over time this proportion would increase to over 50%, whilst the proportion of wild
millets fell from roughly a third to just 15%. A similar pattern of morphological changes has
also been observed in millet starch residues collected at Donghui Lin, and whilst it should
be noted that only a small number of grindstones were analysed at both sites, this study suggests
that the changes associated with domestication had likely already been occurring for a long
period of time when these sites were established. In addition to these early signs of crop
domestication, it is at Nanchuang Tou that we see what may be the earliest evidence for animal
domestication in China. This can be seen in the form of a canid skull that has been unearthed at
the site, that based on morphological changes in its mandible, likely belongs to an early domesticated
dog. It is widely agreed amongst archaeologists that the ancestor of dogs in this region is the
Mongolian or Tibetan wolf, Canis lupus chanko, but exactly when its domestication began is still
debated. The remains of canines have been found at earlier Paleolithic sites such as Hu Tou Liang,
but morphologically these still resemble those of wild wolves. What's more is that by the time of
Nanchuang Tou, we know that the dog had already been domesticated by other Eurasian peoples
several thousand years earlier, and it has been suggested that the domestication process in China
would also have begun millennia before recognisably domesticated dogs appear. Either way,
the value of dogs to human communities still reliant on the hunting of wild animals for
survival would have been obvious. Their remains would continue to increase in the archaeological
record in the millennia ahead, where they likely remained a valuable hunting partner,
and at times also seemed to have been consumed as a source of protein. Similar signs of domestication
and an increasingly sedentary way of life can be observed at communities in central and southern
China dating from this period. Whilst Yao Tong Huan and Zhong Pian show evidence of continuing
occupation during the final millennia of the Paleolithic, here our picture of life has been
aided by the discovery of the earliest known open air site in the region. Situated on a tributary of
the Qiantang river in eastern Shoucheng province, a remarkable site known as Shang Shan has been
found that stretches over some 30,000 square metres. Since the mid-2000s, excavations here
have uncovered large amounts of hearths, storage pits, organised refuse areas and possible burials.
Unlike contemporary sites in the north, this site is also marked by the remains of several
large dwelling places, which has led to it being dubbed China's first village.
These buildings likely consisted of what are known as pile structures,
long raised dwellings supported by rows of wooden posts built over an earthen foundation
with a surrounding trench. The resulting building would have enclosed a substantial area,
with one building excavated on this site measuring some 14 by 6 metres. According to radiocarbon
dating of local pottery sherds, this site was occupied between approximately 9400 to 6600 BCE.
During this time, the environment here and throughout much of southern China would have
been subtropical, and the local fauna would have been dominated by nut bearing deciduous
and evergreen trees, along with a range of non-arboreal and wetland herbs and grasses.
In its layout, this settlement displays a far greater population density than earlier
Paleolithic sites, and it is likely that it was occupied for long periods, if not year round.
As in northern China, its residents likely followed a collector subsistence strategy,
with the backbone of their diet still being supplied by hunting wild animals,
which they supplemented by consuming large amounts of nuts and other wild grasses.
Interestingly, there is also evidence that Shangshan's residents were beginning to store
less perishable foods long term, which they buried in square and circular pits dug over
half a metre into the earth. In terms of tools, this site is largely marked by a continuance of
the region's Paleolithic tradition of using chipped and flaked tools, along with a very
small proportion of polished stone tools that may reflect the increasing demand for woodworking
associated with construction of the settlement's buildings. We also see the presence of hundreds
of grindstones similar to those found at earlier sites, the surfaces of which appear to have been
used to process large amounts of acorns into simple foodstuffs. In addition, this settlement
is also marked by the presence of large amounts of pottery, the majority of which consists of
large basins, along with small numbers of bowls and plates. These simple vessels were likely
constructed using what is known as the slab modelling method, where clay sheets are layered
together into angular ceramics. Some of these basins also contain a loop fixed to their outer
surface, which may have been designed to allow them to be attached to a cord. Curiously though,
none of these vessels are known to display any signs of charring or soot marks, making their
exact relation to cooking unclear. One explanation is that instead of being placed directly over
flames, some of these large containers would instead have been filled with water,
into which heated stones were placed to boil food. Whilst it is still unproven, this theory
may be supported by the presence of large numbers of stone bowls that have also been unearthed
elsewhere on the site. It is in what may seem like a minor element of these vessels that we
also see a potential insight into early crop domestication in Southern China. As part of
their construction, these vessels would have undergone a process known as tempering, where
materials were added to the raw clay to prevent it from cracking whilst being fired. In the early
layers of Changshan, the most common material used for this was the fibrous husks of local grasses,
the majority of which came from wild rice. In addition to these husks, a number of attached
rice stalks have also been found on the surfaces of these vessels, suggesting that they were
harvested with cutting implements rather than having their seeds plucked by hand.
A recent study analysing the residue and wear patterns on flake tools found at the site has
found further support for this argument, concluding that these implements were indeed used to aid in
harvesting wild grasses. Analysis of rice remains collected from this site also concluded that they
more resemble those of domesticated rice rather than wild types, and on this basis it has been
theorised that this crop was in the process of being domesticated here in the 9th millennium BCE.
It should be said though that this claim has not gone entirely without pushback.
In particular it has been argued by some scholars that the remains found at this site,
and others dating to the period, are actually those of wild rice,
and that fully domesticated rice only emerged in the region several millennia later.
The results of this analysis have also been complicated by the extremely small number of
rice remains on which it was based. Even with these concerns however, it seems clear from
wear analysis that the inhabitants of Shangshan were actively harvesting, and possibly cultivating,
the local wild grasses, though likely only as a small portion of their diet.
Less ambiguous evidence for rice cultivation and the beginnings of domestication can also
be observed at the cave site of Diao Tong Huan during this period.
After a drop in rice remains associated with the cooler period of the Younger Dryas,
after 8000 BCE rice remains reappear here in substantial quantities, and are marked by a
mixture of wild and more domestic-like forms, the proportion of the latter of which would
only increase in future millennia. We have now come to the end of the Paleolithic.
By this point it is clear that people in this region were beginning to live in larger,
more permanently occupied settlements, and were practising a degree of early animal and
crop domestication. Whilst the microblade toolset of the north and the flake tools of the south
remain the dominant implements of the period, it is also during this time that we see the
emergence of small quantities of polished axes and adzes that would become dominant
in the millennia ahead. Pottery was also growing more widespread, and at some sites it is seen to
take on less portable forms, perhaps reflecting the less mobile nature of these communities.
But despite these developments, these peoples would have still relied upon a hunter-gatherer
lifestyle similar to that pursued in the earlier Paleolithic. Wild animals remained the staple of
their diets, and the dominant plant food exploited by these communities was still the acorn and other
varieties of nuts, rather than domesticated cereals such as millet and rice. With the
exception of Changshan, we also lack evidence for long-term dwellings at these sites, and even at
this site it is likely that the population was still relocating on either a seasonal or annual
basis. Finally, there is little evidence for any organised social elite in these settlements,
and burials found at sites such as Donghui Lin consist of simple internments of bodies placed
on their side in a flexed position, accompanied at the most by the occasional trinket. But by 7000
BCE, this way of life was drawing slowly to an end. From this point we enter a period known as
the Neolithic, or New Stone Age, an era marked in its later stages by the emergence of fully
sedentary communities that would come to rely on domesticated plants and animals for survival.
The warming trend that began around 9600 BCE would continue into the early Neolithic.
With the exception of a brief cold period around 6200 BCE, this period saw average
temperatures and rainfall rise to levels above that of modern China. It is alongside this warming
period that we begin to see hundreds of early villages appearing throughout both the Yellow
and Yangtze River valleys. In our next episode, we will examine life amongst these early Neolithic
cultures, the settlements of which are marked by growing population sizes, greater investment in
housing and agriculture, and burial of the dead in more organised cemeteries. These trends would
continue into later millennia, until eventually we see the emergence of walled agricultural
settlements, the denizens of which lived under a clear social hierarchy, and whose elites were the
recipients of elaborate burials accompanied by luxury goods. We will discuss all this and more, next time.
