In this episode of The Heart of Taoism, journey to the mist-covered slopes of Mount Zhongnan and the ancient Louguan Temple, where the wisdom of the Tao Te Ching first took shape.
Discover the legendary meeting between Lao-tzu and Confucius, two of China's greatest philosophers, whose contrasting visions for restoring order would shape Chinese civilization for more than two thousand years. While Confucius sought harmony through rites, morality, and social hierarchy, Lao-tzu advocated following the natural order of the Tao, like water flowing effortlessly through the world.
The episode traces the profound influence of Taoism on Confucian thought, from the debates at the Jixia Academy to the writings of Han Fei, whose interpretations helped transform the Tao Te Ching into the "Classic of Classics." Against the backdrop of the Warring States period and the rise of the Qin Empire, the enduring philosophy of the Tao survived political upheaval and cultural catastrophe to become an inseparable part of Chinese identity.
Featuring the sacred landscapes of Mount Zhongnan and the historic Louguan Taoist Temple, this episode explores how the teachings of Lao-tzu transcended dynasties and continue to inspire humanity's search for harmony between nature, society, and the self.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores the historical and philosophical intersection of Taoism and Confucianism, beginning with the legendary meeting between Lao Tzu and Confucius. It traces how these two divergent views on social order and nature eventually integrated, the subsequent influence on scholars like Xunzi and Han Fei, and the resilience of the *Tao Te Ching* through the Qin Dynasty's censorship.
The rainy season comes in summer to Mount Zhongnan.
Limpid creeks snake through the valley down to the Weishui River
at the mountain's northern foot.
Rising before dawn, Lao Tzu watched the flowing stream
and recalled his dialogue with a young man.
The world is like silk, not willing to change.
I don't know where the river goes,
and I don't know where life should be.
People change from young to old,
just as the world changes from spring to summer to autumn to winter.
This is the law of nature. Why should we be sad?
The young man was none other than Confucius,
whose courtesy name was Zhongni.
Why don't you learn the virtue of water?
What is the virtue of water?
It shines like water.
Water is good at everything,
except what everyone else does.
This is the virtue of the world.
In the spring of 524 B.C., Confucius was 27 years old.
He went to Luoyi, capital of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty,
to study the governance and morality of deceased emperors
and visit Lao Tzu for the same purpose,
which was his most important mission in the city.
The two most prestigious ideological torchbearers in Chinese history
met in the sacrificial hall on the imperial palace grounds.
Confucius was deeply impressed by the rites unique to the Zhou Dynasty.
He vowed to restore them,
and took this as his contribution to a world mired in chaos.
Confucius and Lao Tzu, the founders of Confucianism,
shared the same feeling,
that the world was mired in chaos,
but the reason was different.
Confucius believed that the destruction of the rites
was the main reason,
so he believed that if the rites were restored,
the society would return to its original state.
According to the records of the Grand Historian,
Biography of Confucius by Sima Qian,
Lao Tzu admonished Confucius,
I heard that those who are good at business
keep their goods hidden,
and don't let others see them.
Although they are rich,
they seem to have nothing.
High-ranking gentlemen
are often as ignorant as a fool,
with no way out.
But nowadays,
the rites are getting worse and worse.
Only when a large number of scholars stand up
to restore the rites,
so that people can understand the will of the people,
can the world be at peace.
If the rites are restored,
the world will be at peace.
If they are not restored,
the world will be at peace.
Confucius' teaching is that
one should not rely on oneself.
Confucius emphasized the importance of hierarchy.
He believed that
only when individuals and the whole society
strictly followed the hierarchy,
would the society be at peace.
Once the hierarchy is disturbed,
the society will be disturbed.
Confucius was full of confidence in his own ideas.
He didn't give up his ambition
in spite of Lao Tzu's admonitions.
Three months were spent to study Zhou rites.
Teacher and students subsequently parted ways.
I heard that
rich people
give money to others.
I am neither rich nor poor.
I have no money for you.
I only have a few words
to give you as a farewell gift.
In today's world,
the reason why people who are smart and insightful
are destined to die
is because they like to ridicule other people's shortcomings.
As a son,
don't think you are so brilliant.
As a minister,
don't think you are so great.
I hope you can remember this.
Confucius departed lowly,
excited yet frustrated.
Lao Tzu perceived his disciple
would have a tumultuous future.
In 516 B.C.,
when Lao Tzu was riding the Tao Te Ching on Mount Zhongnan,
Confucius was riding in a horse-drawn carriage
on his way to Qi State.
There he would preach his statecraft
to Duke Jing, ruler of the Qi State.
Confucius met Duke Jing in Linzi.
The duke asked Confucius about his view on governance,
and Confucius said this,
If sons behave filially,
fathers paternally,
kings royally,
and subjects loyally,
all would be well with the world.
However, the duke did not listen to him
and had a wild ambition of conquering other states.
This was Confucius' future setback.
Confucius sighed when leaving Linzi.
The great way has disappeared.
This showed his yearning for Lao Tzu's sage advice.
Confucius commented on Lao Tzu in his old age.
I know birds can fly,
fish can swim,
and beasts can run.
Catch those that run with nets,
fish those that can swim,
and shoot those that can fly.
As for dragons,
I shall never know how they remain in the sky.
When I saw Lao Tzu,
he was like a dragon.
China entered the Warring States period
around the 5th century B.C.
Weak dukedoms gradually perished,
and the remaining seven powers
began to fight with one another.
In this troubled time,
Confucianism gradually developed and expanded
with disciples and followers across the country.
Confucius' writings and sayings
were regarded as classics by the public.
Confucianism never stopped drawing reference from Taoism.
In 290 B.C.,
a fierce debate took place
in the Jixia Academy in Linzi,
capital of the Qi State.
The debate raged between Meng Ke,
a scholar from the Lu State,
later known as Mencius,
and Xun Kuang,
a young scholar from the Zhao State,
also known as Xunzi.
Both were Confucian disciples.
They debated on how Confucianism
should learn from Taoism
under the title of
Man Proposes, God Disposes.
From Confucius to Mencius,
both have mysterious moral qualities.
Xunzi, on the other hand,
was restored to a natural state.
This kind of resource
was clearly influenced by Taoism.
In the debate,
Xun Kuang refuted Meng Ke's theory
based on humanity
by virtue of his deep understanding of Taoism.
His view won favor
from the ruler of the Qi State
and various other assembled scholars
and helped him emerge as the victor.
Before this, he was a nobody,
but his victory in the debate
raised his profile as a scholar.
What's most important was the result.
Confucianism would absorb Taoism
in a comprehensive way.
After the debate,
Confucianism and Taoism
became integrated,
the former being imprinted
with the marks of the latter.
In the pre-Qing era,
Xun Kuang was the first
to introduce Taoism to the general public.
if Taoism and Confucianism
were to be integrated,
would not be the same.
In the pre-Qing era,
Xun Kuang was the first
to introduce Taoism to the general public.
However,
it was his most outstanding disciple,
Han Fei,
who wrote books on Laozi.
Han Fei was a political philosopher.
In 234 BC,
he was asked by the Han king
to go to Qin
and resolve the situation
through diplomacy.
His classmate, Li Si,
told the Qin king
that Han Fei couldn't be trusted
and was more a threat
than an asset to the kingdom.
Han was then imprisoned.
Li Si was then
the Qin minister of justice.
He was notorious
for his cunning behavior.
One day,
he showed up
and told Han Fei
he could obtain the king's pardon
as long as he could produce
some philosophical treaties
on the governance of country.
Being somewhat naive,
Han Fei was taken in by the idea.
In the dark prison,
he wrote several wonderful discourses
that have gone down in history.
The most famous of them are
Understanding Laozi
and Interpreting Laozi.
The book Laozi wrote
was titled after his name
in the pre-Qin era.
When Taoism was founded
in the Eastern Han dynasty,
the book was renamed
Tao Te Ching.
Understanding Laozi
and Interpreting Laozi
were the first books
written about the classic Tao Te Ching.
Han Fei wrote the two articles
on the profound connotations
of Tao Te Ching
by way of a fable.
It's used to explain
the philosophy,
misery, happiness
is to be found by its side.
Happiness,
misery lurks beneath it.
Who knows what either
will come to in the end.
However,
this misery, happiness philosophy
exemplified its correctness
in Han Fei.
When Li Si read
Han Fei's articles,
he felt a chill run down his spine.
He feared Han Fei
would be given a position
higher than him by the king,
so he decided to kill him.
Autumn night in 233 B.C.,
Li Si offered Han Fei
a glass of poisoned wine
in the king's name.
Thus, the last philosopher
of the Warring States period
was murdered.
Han Fei's death was a tragedy.
It was also the final elegy
for a turbulent era.
Ying Zheng,
the ruler of Qin State,
eventually unified all of China
in 221 B.C.
During the Qin Dynasty,
the emperor enjoyed a position
higher than God,
and his will became
the exclusive norm
all of his subjects
had to observe.
Any idea to challenge
his authority
was considered heresy.
In 213 B.C.,
an imperial edict was issued
from the palace in Xianyang,
and a cultural catastrophe
erupted in China.
According to an order
from Emperor Qin Shi Huang,
except for agricultural books,
almanacs,
historical records
from the Qin Dynasty,
and certain books on legalism,
the books from all other
schools of thought
were to be burned,
and 461 Confucian scholars
would be executed.
The proverbial gate
to ideological freedom,
once opened by scholars,
was now closed.
Gone were the days
when a debate of ideas
was condoned.
Emperor Qin Shi Huang
was notorious in history,
but he didn't burn
the Tao Te Ching.
Why was that?
The classic,
written on bamboo slips,
had become an inalienable part
of the Chinese identity,
which nothing could erase.
This is today's
Loquan Taoist Temple
on Mount Zhongnan.
Laozi was said
to have lectured here.
In the olden days,
the rule was for a scholar
to lecture on a high platform.
Yin Shi built a high platform
on a small hill
about 1,000 meters south
of Loquan Temple for Laozi.
This was the first time
Laozi lectured on Taoist concepts.
Although no records exist
detailing what Laozi lectured on,
one can imagine
how his lectures
echoed across
the mist-enveloped mountain.
Laozi's lectures
on the 590-meter high mountain
made Loquan Temple
the place to study
Taoist philosophy.
This is how Loquan
became known to the world.