Our understanding of ancient Greek warfare has been hampered by irreconcilable visions of the mechanics of hoplite combat. I have made use of a combination of experimental archaeology, the physics of weapons use and movement in crowds, and the biology of group behaviors in humans, to present an evolution of hoplite warfare from the Archaic to the Classical period. This view attempts to satisfy as much as possible the disparate opinions of modern scholars on elements of combat such as the level of training and drill required, the spacing of men in battle, and the concerted push of othismos. My reading of Tyrtaios suggests that the Archaic Greeks fought in shield-walls, where hoplites opened battle by throwing spears, backed by a mass of missile troops akin to those seen in а late Roman shield-wall as well as in Saxon and Norse formations. The missile component of this blended formation failed to meet the challenge of the Achaemenid barricades of large shields backed by numerous and powerful archers. As a result of the experience of the Persian wars, hoplites changed their tactics, foregoing missile combat for a charge from long range and severing the mass of light troops from their formations. At the battle of Plataia, we see not only the clash of Greek and Achaemenid shield-walls, but the bloody birth of the classical phalanx. Paul Bardunias applies principles of entomological swarm behavior and self-organization to analyze the coordination and tactics of hoplite warfare.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
An entomologist applies biological self-organization and experimental reenactment to analyze ancient Greek hoplite warfare. By testing physics and formation density, the speaker challenges historical theories on the phalanx charge, the mechanics of *othismos* (mass pushing), and the strategic evolution from defensive shield walls to high-momentum charges to counter missile threats.
So today I'm going to be talking about a lot of things, but I'm going to end up talking about
shield walls and classes. As Janice just said, by training, I'm an entomologist. My PhD is in
entomology, and I study swarm behavior in insects. And what that is, is that's any kind of behavior
that derives from large groups working together, for instance, building a giant termite mound or
defending the colony, finding food. And what I do for a living is I take a lot of the algorithms we
derive from insects, and I help people who are trying to make swarms of robots come up with
ways to make their robots work. When we look at these swarms, one of the things you'll see is
they can be highly, highly coordinated. And this coordination system here, for instance,
a murmuration of starlings. And the manner in which they're moving would be the envy of any
cavalry officer, right? The manner in which they're coordinated is called self-organization.
And self-organization is a system whereby individuals react to local conditions,
the conditions right around you. No one knows what's happening in the system. So if I'm a
termite, I'm reacting to the termite next to me or the dirt in front of me. I have no idea what's
going on around me. And I don't know the overall state of the system. So if I'm building a mound
with the termite, I don't have any idea what the actual mound looks like. I just know what's
happening around me. And interestingly, that is what we see with hoplite warfare. We're specifically
told by Thucydides that each man hardly knows anything except what's occurring around himself
to himself. And this is interesting to me because it's an intersection of the possibility for this
self-organization with hoplite warfare. And you can see in the bottom here, this is one of the few
human examples that everyone has seen before of self-organization. This is a wave going around
a football stadium. And as you know, because you've probably done this, you don't actually
monitor the wave going around the stadium. You just stand up when the guy next to you stands up.
So this is an example of self-organization. Well, can we apply these concepts to warfare
in human swarms? And that's really what I want to do. I want to be able to derive
information for you guys by applying these concepts. So what can we learn from this type
of experimentation? Well, I'm not a historian. I'm an experimental biologist. So from my point
of view, what I want to provide historians is context to understand the things that they're
seeing. And this, I think, is something that's been sorely missing in many places because,
as we've just talked about, we don't know exactly what things look like. We don't have
perfect firsthand accounts sometimes. But we may be able to reconstruct some of this.
So we can provide some context, for instance, for how weapons and armor fit, how they feel.
We can provide context for how human bodies move when they're outfitted. We can provide
context for how weapons are used. And we can provide context, and hopefully I'll show you
some of this, for how masses of combatants move, how they coordinate their motion. There's a caution
in this. Experimentation, experiential narrative like this cannot tell us how something is done.
I always stress this. It only suggests possibilities. But most importantly, it provides a context
for the creation of new ideas on how things are done. Well, what can we do? Well, we can help
explain things we see in art. For instance, it's commonly seen this helmet is up on the head like
this. And many people have opined that this is just an artistic means of showing the face. But
this is literally the first thing you do if you're a hoplite wearing a helmet and you're hot. You pull
that helmet off your face. Same thing with the armor. We see this armor in this characteristic
pose constantly. This is the way you wear your armor when you're at ease. You don't really have
a place to put it down, but you want to get everything opened up so your body veers out.
And as you can see, we all do this when we're reenacting. We can attempt to reconstruct
weapons use. And in this, we're aided by more modern weapon styles. Like, for instance, the
Philippine Moros, the Moro people of the Philippine have the most Aspis-looking shield I have ever
seen on the planet other than the Aspis. And we can look at the way they use that shield and spear.
And then there are, back in the Renaissance, we have the Bolognese masters Marozzo and Manciolino
who both advocated the use of a double grip shield and spear. And we see what they did. But of
course, those are separate systems. They're only analogies. And we have to sort of merge them with
what we see through the artwork. And it's a beautiful statuette up there from the Louvre
where you see the positions of two hoplites fighting a duel. We can also do weapons testing.
So you can see, for instance, if you ask the question, can I put a dory through multiple
layers of blue linen? Yes, the answer is you can. Can I do it through leather and linen? Sure,
we can actually do it through bronze. So the short answer with weapons testing with the spear
is that the spear goes through anything that a man could have worn on a hoplite battlefield.
Does it go through easily? Not always. You have to have a clean strike. Most of the strikes in
combat were probably not clean, full-strength strikes, but depth. But this will show you an
example of what you can do in testing. The best way to use the scientific method here for me,
I think, is to undergo falsification. So rather than say, hey, you can do this because I can do
it in hoplite gear, so surely they did that, which is a mistake. It's a rabbit hole to fall
down into. Better is to take statements that other people made because those statements are
essentially making the same mistake. So if you take a statement somebody else made, you can try
to falsify it. And if you can't falsify it, then it's abort for the statement. If you can falsify
it, well then, obviously, that brings the question against validity. The problem with this, of course,
is that there's the garbage in, garbage out concept. All testing is built on assumptions,
and they're only as good as that foundation. So common assumptions of modern testing is that
we're actually using accurate reproductions of technology. This will vary, of course,
in terms of how much work you put into it to make them that accurate. The other thing is that we
assume that human subjects will respond in a similar manner physically, emotionally, and
as ancient people. Now, physically, obviously, we're generally tend to be larger. It's hard to
assess the emotional and mental impact. But overall, I think it's close enough that you can
do a lot of falsification. Here's an example of falsification. So there are many that say that
hoplites can't charge fast and dense rates. So here you can get a bunch of hoplites together.
You can put them in dense ranks and make them run. It's probably over 100 meters we ran here.
And you can see that staying together in dense ranks is not very difficult.
Here we have a statement, for instance. This was made by Luganbill. The charge made a literal
clash of lines inevitable, since rapidly advancing heavily armed formations of hoplites would have to
halt abruptly in its track to avoid a collision. So here we're saying that if you have men moving
in formation, they can't stop abruptly. And that's something, of course, we can falsify.
And this gives you an example of how sometimes you have fortuitous accidents in this testing.
For this hoplite here in the front, who tripped over a sandal, who may or may not be me,
fell down in the middle of the charge. And as you see, everyone stopped rapidly. There was no,
there was never a time when men behind him were going to pile up and fall over and things like
that. Hoplites can stop relatively rapidly. The trick is you have to know how to charge.
And that's the kind of thing that we learn through this reenactment. If you charge so that
you're practically leaning on the guys back in front of you, then you're more likely to trip.
But they almost surely didn't charge that way. We instead leave a gap between the lines of maybe six
feet. And then just as you don't crash into a car every time you come to a red light, as you see
the red lights on the back of the car and stop, these hoplites are able to judge the speed of
the hoplite in front of them and stop in time, and they don't just pile up and crash.
Now, I guess if I were, oh, let me, I'll show you this. I'm sorry. Another question that arises,
we just talked about it, is the frontage. So how much space does each hoplite take up in the line,
right? So the sort of orthodox view on this is that there are tightly packed hoplites somewhere
between 60 and 90 centimeters. These are at 90 right now on the left because their shields are
just touching, whereas if they were overlapped to a large degree, that could be as small as 60
centimeters. On the other side, the so-called heretics, led by van Vries here, decided that
they needed more room to fight than this. This in some ways comes from some of the Roman,
the writings of Polybius on Romans and how much frontage they required. But if you put this to
test, and we did, the answer is pretty clear that you don't need much space at all. So the
men who were set up at 180 centimeters, not only lost these battles, they lost them rapidly.
And the reasons become quite clear. So at 60 centimeters of frontage for these men here in
full protective gear, you're still able to use your spear just fine. The spear as a weapon really
only needs to go forward and back. So you're not hampered in any way. And then the problem is that
you're stuck fighting multiple opponents on the other line if you are at this wider spacing and
you allow for more angles of impact because you're not protected at all by the men standing next to
you. You're not shaded by them and you're not protected by their spears, more importantly,
which would get in the way and hinder strikes. Probably the most contentious issue that I could
bring up and we could test would be aethysmos. So aethysmos is this mass pushing that is thought
to either occur or not occur. And if we look at the orthodox position on this, in battle,
the opposing balance is charged while hundreds of meters apart. They crash directly into each
other. They would get maybe one good thrust of the spear before they slammed into each other
and their momentum from the charge added force to their pushing to one side. On the opposite side,
this was essentially dismissed. And they say when battle came to close quarters, men didn't
pack together, but they fought with these wide gaps, which I just showed you are probably unlikely.
And this allowed complex weapon play, which as I just showed you, you don't really need much
room for complex weapon play. The battle was decided through spear and sword. Any notion
of pushing was figured. Well, here's an example of how we can find a happy medium in a question
like this through testing. So for instance, we look at the classic explanation of aethysmos.
This comes from Grundy back in 48. And he describes them coming into contact,
the first instance smashing into each other with the momentum from that run. And then it
becomes a giant rugby game where everybody's pushing. And this led to some issues on the
other side. This clearly doesn't completely fit the narrative that we're reading. So it's been
modified a little bit and sort of tweaked by many of the people who still believe in this sort of
literal pushing. But the objections that we can come up with through experimentation are that
this momentum concept does not actually hold true. So having momentum from a charge does not actually
help you in the push, because what matters in the push is how tightly packed you are.
That's really all that matters. So if you run as a large group of far distance and try to smash
into another, let's say a formed line, you cannot break that line. You can literally hold up any
number of men charging at you with at least four ranks of men. This is what we've discovered. So
if you have four, sometimes three ranks of men, you can charge them with any number of ranks of
men and they will just absorb the charge. And the same reason why you can get hit with a beanbag
and it doesn't hurt, but if you got hit with a rock of the same mass, it would hurt, is because
that charge is diffuse when it hits. So whatever momentum individuals have is spent hitting the
wall, and then once they're stopped, their body actually becomes something resisting the momentum
of those individuals behind them. So the charge as the entree into a fismos really doesn't hold up
by experimentation. Also, spear strikes delivered at sort of a couched, you know, underarm strike
like a lancer, like a horseless lancer, are surprisingly weak. They're much, much weaker
than just a regular overhand strike, even a standing overhand strike. So this part of it
probably needs to be re-evaluated. The a fismos as reverse tug-of-war concept is one that's there,
and then this was when people were trying to grasp how you push a fismos. Well, one obvious
thing where people seem to struggle against each other is a tug-of-war. So you can imagine if you
look at this, if you sort of change the directionality, that standing like this and,
you know, leaning into each other like this could generate force. The problem is with a tug-of-war,
you're using that rope, and this changes everything, because the inflexible rope is
what's transferring force. So if you actually try to push this way, you run into some real problems,
because hoplites cannot transfer maximum force in this stance, and this stance can't even be
maintained as pressure increases. So that may seem contradictory, but essentially what happens is
if you try to push in this stance, you will get crushed forward as more and more force comes in,
and you'll find your chest crushed into your shield. Or, as happened to Ajani once,
you might find your butt sitting in your shield if you get forced the other way. So this is actually
a really dangerous way to try to push in a crowd. What we came up with is a concept of essentially
a thysmosis crowd disaster, and this may seem similar to the rugby scheme, but it's actually
quite different, and the implications are different. So, for instance, this is a crowd disaster in
Dusseldorf, and many people were crushed to death. They were asphyxiated, and the pressure on their
bodies, especially on their diaphragms, wouldn't allow them to breathe. And obviously these people
have no armor or shields, but even if they had flat shields, they would still be squished together
like this, and unable to breathe. And interestingly, one of the places we see a number of
writers use the term of thysmos and related terms is when describing crowds moving through gates,
just like this. So even to the ancients, this concept of a thysmos was something that could
occur in a crowd disaster. The concept of a thysmos as crowd disaster being weaponized is
actually not something that was only known to the ancients. This little picture here, unfortunately,
is a timely photograph because this is the Euromaidan in 2014, and here we had riot police
pushing into crowds, essentially forming a sort of low power of thysmos to force their way into
these crowded situations, and the protesters resisted by linking arms. The level of force
generated in a crowd like this, of course, is limited because everybody's vulnerable to
asphyxiation. I took this sort of almost like a personal challenge. This was a great statement.
It's by Goldworthy in his 97 paper on thysmos. It said, should it be proved that a thysmos really
was a contest of mass shoving, then this conclusion would gain importance outside of
that contest in Greek history. It would be necessary to explain how Greeks were able to
fight this way and why they did. And I think I have the answer, and that is Greeks have a rather
particular shield. The shape of the shield is atypical, and it's not something really seen
directly modeled in other cultures. If we look at the position that you would stand in while you're
spear fencing on the left there, you can see that your shield is up in front of you, the shields
could be overlapping, fighting over the top of your shield. When we move into a thysmos, the shield
comes back against the chest, and because you're in this crowd, you're crushed into this position
anyway. You can't not form this position. So you get crushed into this position, but because the shield
covers you from the upper chest down to the thigh, it spans over your diaphragm. Because it spans over
your diaphragm, you can stand like this for extended periods of time and not suffocate.
And so this essentially becomes almost like a life preserver that protects you against asphyxiation.
And here's another quote I can falsify because it was directed at me, and this was by
Chris Matthews, Matthew and his Storm of Spears. Contrary to Barnier's conclusions, the bulk of the
aspens would make it impossible for the members of a phalanx to crowd each other. Both the shield and
the individual would be unlikely to withstand such pressure. And this was a secondary challenge
now to actually test this. So luckily we were able to. In 2015, at the Archeon Romana reenactment
event at Marathon in Greece, I was there with Giannis and a lot of other reenactors, and we
affixed a force meter to a tree, which couldn't be pushed back obviously, and then we had men
line up in file and push against this force meter. And if we had lines of up to 10 or 12,
we had multiple lines of seven, and in one of the bouts of multiple lines of seven,
we achieved our maximum force, which was 368 kilopons of force, or about 811 pounds on your
back, for about 3,690 meters of force. And if we look at the graph of this force, this is now not
maximum force, this is the average force transfer over about a minute period of time. Basically,
how long it took my scale to stabilize, but it was about a minute. And what we see here is a
clear trend in that the top line, the darker line, is this crowd-like pushing that I had to do.
And you can see that the amount of force added by each new man decreases. What that means is
there's inefficiency in pushing through a line of men. And you can sort of make up deflection points,
like around four is your sort of basic, where your line is first starting to change its slope,
and then somewhere around eight, it starts to plateau. If we continue this out to about,
maybe, let's say, 1216, we might have seen a true plateau where the new men adding less than,
let's say, five pounds per man. And this explains why, at a battle like Lutra, you could have
a giant mass of 50 Thebans fighting 12 Spartans in file, and you could actually have a valid battle,
because above a certain point, you're not adding that much more force to the push.
Remember, this force is being added by people who are essentially standing and leaning on
each other. It's not a muscular pushing force, because you're stood up in the crowd. You can't
really push as much as just lean against the person in front of you. And this concept of this
plateau, I think, clearly explains why we see somewhat parity between Theban and Spartan forces,
even though it also explains why the Thebans eventually won, and that is the numerous ranks
behind those first 1216 ranks essentially act as a wall. So it might be easier for the Spartans to
push back the 16 ranks, but once they start to push them back, they meld with the rest of the
crowd, and you end up with a huge mass that they're forcing against. So over time, it would
be the equivalent of the Spartans trying to push uphill. Eventually, they're worn down. It does,
I think, explain why we see these super deep balances. Well, I had some people tell me,
you're pushing against a tree. Maybe that can't happen in real life. So I was lucky enough again
to get together with a group in 2019, the Western Martial Arts Workshop in Racine, Wisconsin,
and we were able to get a bunch of people together. Now, these, unfortunately, don't
have proper asperities, but they do have a slightly smaller, still convex rotella,
and we were here able to generate a maximum around 675 pounds of force, 306 kilopods of force.
I think the difference has more to do actually with our shields than with our men,
because one of the things that happened is the asperity is so nice. It fits right on your
shoulder and on your thigh, neither of which can be squished. So you could stand there for
long periods of time without vismos, and we did. It's not a big deal at all. The shields are
creaking and stuff, but no shields were ever broken and no men were ever hurt when we did this.
Here, it's a little bit different because these smaller rotellas are cut into your
abdomen. So you can still breathe, but they literally squish your abdomen. You feel your
blood pressure rise. So I think a lot of us sort of pulled out of the push here a little earlier.
We could probably have done higher proper speeds here. All right, I promised you shield walls,
so I want to talk a little bit about shield walls and how everything I just described to you sort of
comes together to show what may have happened to you. I had a paper a couple years back that I
defined the functions of shield walls, and there are three major functions that shield walls can
do. They can act as a barricade behind which other troops can throw or shoot missiles. They can act
as a bastion from which troops can run out and attack and then run back behind, or they can
physically just move forward and attack, and that's what I defined as a bludgeon function.
If we look at this barricade function, we see this is primarily what's happening in, for instance,
ancient Assyria. With the Achaemenids, we see the same thing. These large walls of shields
that are sometimes even stood up on kickstands behind which people are shooting arrows,
but we also see this in other places. For instance, I think the Orarchians at the same
time are doing this. They have this weird shield with a strap that would allow them to hold it up
for a long period of time, and then we have the Hoplites. The Hoplites have a special shield too.
This corpax, one of the things it does, probably the thing it does the best and the reason I think
it was designed, is because it allows you to stand for a long time with that shield on your shoulder
and, or I shouldn't say on your shoulder, in front of you. I wanted to point out that, in fact,
it doesn't actually rest on your shoulder. You can rest it on your shoulder, but you don't actually
have to hang it from your arm like this for a long period of time. If we examine that famous
quote from Tyrtaeus, and he says, and he light-armed, crouch ye on either hand beneath the shield and
fling your great hurlstones or throw against them your smooth javelins in your place beside the men
of heavier armament. If we read that not as them infiltrating between the ranks all the way to the
front line, which they could do, but it makes a lot more sense, to me at least, if what we're looking
at here is one of these same barrier type or barricade type shield walls where you have your
richer, heavier armed men up front and you have your poorer men behind. That's a standard warband
model you'll see, you know, in many cultures. If we just look at it as that, then really the
hoplites are no different than all of these other Near Eastern people. They're essentially using the
same tactics. It's slightly different because we know, for instance, these early hoplites all
threw spears too, so they were essentially part of the missile component of this
barricade as well, and that's possible. And then it could spall off and, you know, hoplites could
charge off and fight and then run back into the mass too. These early sort of primitive shield walls are
very versatile. If we look at some other examples of later barricade shield walls, we have the Roman
folk come here on the left, which is described in excellent detail in Maurice's Strategicon,
and he specifically tells you that you form up in this multi-tiered formation here with superimposed
shields if your men aren't armored and don't have greaves. And that, I think, is a key because the
hoplites, at least the front rank, probably did have greaves, right? So you can see why hoplites can
form a shield wall like this that's still relatively invulnerable to missiles coming to
protect lighter troops behind them, even without this sort of multi-superimposed shield wall that
they had later. The other place you see a sort of primitive shield wall like this, which does a lot
of these different functions, is amongst the Saxons, their skill wall or board wheel, and the Norse and
And here is a perfect example off the Bayou Tapestry, where you can see that you have men in
some form of a shield wall, and maybe it overlaps, maybe it doesn't, that's debatable, but they seem
to be throwing spears themselves, and behind them are at least one archer and a man throwing an axe
here, right? And there are men holding extra spears. So this is essentially a missile firing
and protecting formation, which is what I define as a barricade function. If we look at the
comparative range of missiles, though, between the Acmenids and the Greeks, we have a huge disparity.
That is, the Acmenids have an advanced system of archery, where they're shooting in, if not volleys,
just massed archery, and their bows are very good, so they have a rather far-reaching archery.
The Greeks, on the other hand, at this point, if they were even backed by archers, would have been
backed by archers using self-bolts, so they would have had a much more limited range, and of course
if they were using heavy rocks and or javelins, that would be less so. Slings, on the other hand,
could range pretty far, but obviously that was not the major component of the
silo behind these Greeks, if they formed, as I suggest. So we see a problem, and that disparity
in missile component of their shield walls, I think, plays out in the introduction of two
things in the late 6th century. One is the shield apron, and that is a leather or textile
sheet that hangs off the shield to help protect the legs.
And we see this probably first in Ionia, and this is a plasminian sarcophagus. The date is unclear,
but it could be as early as 510, and here you can clearly see this shield apron, and this actually
works fairly well. We've tested this, and it does actually stop missiles, especially missiles that
are sort of spent in that range. The other thing that we see coming in the 65th Olympiad, 520,
is the haplitodromos, which is the run in armor. And now, so on the left, we have a means of
standing in this line still and engaging in this missile duel, but I think we're seeing a trend
here with this haplitodromos, that at least they're giving some thought to the fact that
running through this missile range may be a better option. And you can see here, for instance,
if you have a comparative range of missiles and you're wildly outranged, the best thing you can
do, of course, is run in and get close to your opponents. And then when you get close to your
opponents, you're actually beneath the range of their arrows, because one of the problems with
it has to be shot at a parabolic curve. So if you're going to shoot over your front ranks,
you have a dead zone right in front of those front ranks that you can't reach.
And the only way you could reach them would be to sort of step up and aim over the shoulders or
heads of the men in front of you, and clearly all of the ranks can't do that. So at best,
you'd be getting one rank of archers shooting at you once you get past that range at which the
last volleys are most effective. So there's a lot of pressure for top lights to do this.
And this has been suggested by Prince and others that this is one of the reasons we see these long
runs begin at Marathon. And I think this played out in real time at Plataea, where you have the
men standing under missile fire until one motivated Tajian takes off, and then they all go.
And once they get to this range, they're much more protected from missile fire. But one thing
that happens when you are running like this through the beaten zone of granite missiles
is you no longer need your own missile because it's useless. So Prince had suggested that they
essentially rearmed all of their light troops as heavier troops to take advantage of this.
That is a possibility. But I think one of the other problems that we see here for Greek history is
that they abandon their light troops because essentially there's a contract in this kind of
shield wall where I'm protecting you behind me, and you have to protect me from the enemy missiles.
And this represents a failure of some sort of a social contract between the heavies and the
lights. And I'm not going to go too far into that, but I think maybe keep that in mind when we're
trying to understand how the Greeks would later treat light troops, is that when they needed the
most in a sense here, they were essentially failed by their own light troops. One thing that happens
is when your own light troops are trying to fight behind you, you cannot be too deep. So as long as
you were in a shield wall that required you to be in front of and protecting and screening light
troops, you probably only could get to about eight ranks deep, which is what we're told by
Sputnik. Xenophon also makes mention of the fact that missile troops being behind ranks of their
own men greatly hampers them. And one of the reasons for this is you can imagine if each man
only occupied a meter of space, let's say, well then your own missile troops are eight meters
behind your leading element. So he's obviously not well protected. So I'm going to end on this and
just mention that I think what we're seeing on the field of Plataea is a situation where you have
a sort of mixed shield wall. One of the functions of it is a barricade. Encountering a shield wall
which has become greatly tailored towards this barricade style fighting in the Persians. And then
the answer to that was essentially not to make a better barricade, but to move the whole concept
of Greek combat more towards that bludgeon phase. And I think that's where we see the major change
before and after the Persian Wars is they will essentially abandon that integral component of
missile troops in favor of this charge and this flat out bludgeoning. Now I should point out that
in a mixed hoplite phalanx, going all the way back to the archaic, they didn't just throw things over
the top of their ranks and throw spears at each other. They always ended in some kind of a bludgeon
match. But here we see it becoming essentially the primary function. Thank you guys.