Eating at Graciela. The BEST New Steakhouse in NYC

Xuka
10 followers
1 Video View·Sep 29, 2026
I eat at and review Graciela which is located in the West Village of New York City. Graciela is an Argentinean steakhouse and fine dining restaurant from Pablo Rivero, who’s the same restaurateur behind the legendary Don Julio in Buenos Aires, which has been ranked as the world’s best steakhouse. Graciela is Rivero’s first restaurant outside of Argentina and it already has become a popular spot in NYC.
Graciela is currently the most talked about and hyped up steakhouse in New York City.
The restaurant stems from the legendary Don Julio in Argentina which has been ranked as the greatest
steakhouse in the world. Without question I just had to give Graciela a try and my goodness I was
impressed. Today I'm here in New York City at Washington Square Park and it is a pleasant
evening indeed and I just had dinner at the hottest steakhouse in the city right now.
I am talking about Graciela. It's an Argentinian steakhouse and it comes from the same restauranteur
behind the world's greatest steakhouse Don Julio in Buenos Aires. Now I had such an amazing time
when I traveled to Argentina a few years ago but my one regret was not going to Don Julio.
I of course tried to get a reservation but I had no luck in that regard. However I could have shown
up as a walk-in and that's part of the fun too because you wait there, you're given a glass of
wine, it's supposedly a fun time. However I chose to do other things and I deeply regret that. Well
to an extent because I still had an amazing time and plus I ate a ton of steak. In fact I ate so
much meat during that trip that the one food I wanted most when I came home was believe it or not
I'm not kidding a salad. Yeah Argentina is an incredible country but maybe not the best place
if you're a vegetarian. I do hope to return there one day especially to dine at Don Julio. However
when I heard about Graciela opening up and their connection to Don Julio well I got excited. In
fact out of the many steakhouses that have been opening up in New York City Graciela was the one
that I was looking forward to dining at the most. However a lot of other people apparently have had
the same idea because getting a reservation at Graciela is quite the challenge. Plus right now
the restaurant doesn't seem to offer reservations for single diners like me. Although I've noticed
that the place has a bar so I thought I'd try my luck as a walk-in. Fortunately luck was shining
upon me tonight so with that being said this was my dinner at Graciela. Graciela is located in the
west village of New York City and opened its doors in July of 2026. The restaurant is the product of
the acclaimed Argentinian restaurateur Pablo Rivera who is most well known for his legendary
Buenos Aires steakhouse Don Julio. The establishment has been ranked as the world's best steakhouse
and has been awarded a Michelin star. As a result expectations were high for Graciela which is in
fact Rivera's first restaurant outside of Argentina. Now I was incredibly excited to dine at Graciela
but I still wasn't sure if they would have space for me. Nevertheless I stepped inside when they
Right away I was given a glass of sparkling lemonade before I even found out if I was able
to have dinner at the restaurant. Fortunately there was a spot open at the bar because that
lemonade would have been pretty awkward to drink had space not been available. Feeling grateful
to have been seated I took in the atmosphere. Graciela is a fairly sizable restaurant that
spread out over multiple areas. Where I was situated I had a decent view of the open kitchen
which contains a massive grill that stretches to over 10 feet in length. There was also another
dining room on the opposite end of Graciela that I barely saw. In total the restaurant can
accommodate 120 diners but that sort of becomes a problem when it comes to the amount of washrooms
in the establishment. Basically I waited a bit longer than I would have liked to use one of the
bathrooms but really that wasn't much of a big deal. Overall I really liked the interior of
Graciela and I particularly appreciated the restaurant's custom knives. They not only looked
and felt incredible they added a level of character to Graciela that made it feel even
more special. Then I began to explore the menu. While most may head straight to the steak selection
Graciela is so much more than just about beef. The menu is filled with Argentinian classics and
believe it or not there's a good variety of vegetables on offer. In fact I think that if
you're a vegetarian you won't be disappointed. Next I checked out the beverage selection. Graciela
has a nice variety of wines by the glass with a number of the offerings hailing from Argentina.
The restaurant also offers a list of intriguing cocktails which I've heard good things about.
In fact I was seated right next to the service station where I got to view many of the cocktails
before they were taken out to diners and they looked great. For that night however I got wine.
First though I turned my attention to the sparkling lemonade I received when I arrived.
That was a fantastic drink. It was so refreshing and perfectly balanced. I think it's a great touch
that the restaurant hands those out to all customers the moment they step through the door.
Right off the bat it sets a great tone of hospitality and generosity towards diners.
Although I can't say that I got the most generous pour when it came to my glass of wine. I decided
to go with the 2023 Bodega No Mia Alisa which is a Malbec from Patagonia. The wine was very
pleasant. It's medium bodied and I found that it paired well with a variety of food. While I do
wish that I got more wine with that pour sometimes the shape of the glass makes it appear that there
is less there than there actually is. Next I turned my attention to the bread which is
complimentary. It was paired with olive oil and lemon along with a few olives.
When I pulled apart that bread it was steaming hot but most importantly I found it to be delicious.
The bread had a nice crust and was actually a bit heavier and a bit more dense than I expected
it to be but it was a delight. Plus that olive oil was on the mark. I didn't have a very long wait
until I was presented with my appetizers and I got two of them. First I turned my attention to
the empanada which was filled with corn and cheese. On every level that empanada was fantastic.
It was perfectly fried with a nice crisp and flavorful shell. The filling of the corn and
cheese proved to be both comforting and delicious. Back in Argentina I ate a great many empanadas but
I must say the one I had at Graciela proved to be better than them all. Now I was tempted to get
the Osobuco empanada but my server recommended the one with corn as she said it would pair nicely
with the other dish I got and she was certainly right. For my second appetizer I chose a dish
that's rapidly becoming a signature of the restaurant, the tomato. It's simply a sliced
heirloom tomato in a yascua sauce. Yascua is basically a spicy tomato and chili hot sauce.
Although Argentina doesn't really do much in terms of spice to me that sauce was incredibly
mild but combined with the tomato it was delicious. After one bite I fully understood the hype behind
that dish. The tomato was so fresh vibrant and juicy. Paired with the tasty sauce there was a
light richness and a satisfying but subtle tingle of spice. Plus I also used some of the bread to
up that sauce and it paired nicely as well. Overall that was a simple dish but it was done
so remarkably well. While I was enjoying that course I was reminded of another straightforward
tomato dish at another New York steakhouse. I'm talking about Peter Luger's sliced tomatoes and
onions with Luger's own sauce. In my opinion that is one of the most boring dishes out there.
Graciela on the other hand does it right. After finishing it was on to the main event but before
my steak arrived I was given another beautiful custom knife. Once again details like that are
something that I really appreciate. Soon enough however I was presented with my steak and it was
a beautiful sight. I went with the Ojo de Bife which is a 16 ounce center cut ribeye from Argentina.
In fact that was one of only two cuts on the menu sourced from Argentina with the rest acquired
from within the U.S. First off the aroma coming from that steak was marvelous and I couldn't wait
to dig in. Now the beef arrives pre-sliced but the pieces of meat were still fairly large and thus
required more cutting. After slicing off a bite and giving it a try I was transported to heaven.
That was a phenomenal steak. The meat had the most spectacular flavor and believe it or not
it wasn't even dry aged. The flavor instead comes from the live fire cooking over charcoal
on Graciela's massive grill and the quality of the beef itself. First off that ribeye was cooked
perfectly. It was right on the money of what a medium rare steak should look and feel like. The
grill marks on the beef were no doubt attractive and the tenderness of the cut was fantastic.
Now it wasn't quite as tender as the T-bone I had from the legendary La Brigada in Buenos Aires.
That steak was so tender it was able to be sliced with a spoon.
The tenderness of Graciela's ribeye on the other hand was still on the mark for me. The steak was
also seasoned just right although the restaurant pairs all of their steaks with a few condiments
which include a flaky sea salt. I at least tried the steak with some of the salt and it was very
delicious but for me it didn't need it. I did however appreciate the two kinds of chimichurri
the restaurant provided. One was a fresh chimichurri and the other was an aged chimichurri. Both were
very tasty and complemented the steak well. Although like I said the steak was so delicious
on its own that it didn't need anything more. Still I did like adding both of the chimichurris
to the steak every few bites to keep things interesting and to reduce palate fatigue.
What also helped in that regard was my side dish of pimentos. The colorful plate contained
charcoal roasted and marinated peppers. Those pimentos proved to be very tasty. First off
they were perfectly cooked. Those peppers were light and tender and went down easy.
Their flavor was delightful as the pimentos maintained a light sweetness that paired
perfectly with my steak. Overall I was thoroughly enjoying that dinner. From the warm atmosphere,
kind hospitality and excellent food everything was clicking at Graciela. Not to mention the fact
I did feel a bit of nostalgia for my time in Argentina but all good things come to an end.
Thankfully I still had dessert to look forward to. Graciela has a decent dessert menu. There was a
good variety of ice cream on offer but ultimately what caught my attention was the flan. Now I did
think it took a little too long to reach me but that wasn't much of a big deal. Plus the restaurant
generously gave me a scoop of ice cream to pair with the flan which I was very grateful for.
Unfortunately I didn't catch what flavor of ice cream that was but I did find it to be very tasty
and of great quality. Plus it paired nicely with the flan and speaking of the flan it was crafted
with free-range eggs and was accompanied by a serving of whipped cream and dulce de leche.
I first tried the flan just on its own and all I can say is wow I was blown away. That was the best
flan that I've ever had. The texture was perfect. The creation had a pleasing jiggle to it and my
spoon just glided right through it. That flan was so ridiculously smooth. Adding the whipped cream
and dulce de leche to it took it to another level as well as providing even more pleasing flavor
notes to the dessert. To sum it up I truly had a great experience at Graciela. Now New York City
is filled with a countless number of steakhouses but with Graciela's Argentinian flair it stands
out in the best possible way and is a welcome addition to the city's culinary landscape.
After finishing it was time for the bill which totaled to $197.08 but with my tip I spent a bit
over $233. Now that set me back a lot more than any meal I had in Argentina but I was satisfied.
Now that was one fine meal. In fact that was the greatest steak meal I've had so far this year.
That ribeye was perfection. In fact that was probably the best piece of beef that I had
all year. Now having said that I loved all the other food I had tonight. I mean the restaurant
may get most of the hype for their steak but in reality it's an all-around fine dining Argentinian
establishment. I mean that tomato dish was perfect, that empanada was perfect, and that flan
was heavenly. Although I wish I had gotten more wine that pour frankly felt a bit stingy. Still
that's pretty much my only complaint because it was overall an excellent experience. Plus I got
some of those nostalgic feels from my time in Argentina. However the one thing that was so
unlike Argentina was the price. But it is what it is. This is the United States, one of the most
expensive countries in the world, and this is New York City, one of the most expensive cities in the
world. Now having said that the restaurant's prices are sort of similar to other establishments
within the area. Plus since I had such a great time at the restaurant I didn't even really mind
spending that much because this is what I live for. I got phenomenal steak and really phenomenal
food in general. I couldn't be happier. No, I think I'd actually be happier with a little more
wine. That was the only thing. Regardless, Gra Cielo lived up to the hype for me. It's a phenomenal
steakhouse, a phenomenal restaurant, and one that I will definitely be returning to.
