We’ve Been Wrong About the Trojan Horse
1 Video View·Sep 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the historical and literary origins of the Trojan Horse, questioning whether the legendary wooden sculpture was a literal object or a poetic misunderstanding. By analyzing ancient texts and archaeological evidence, it examines several theories regarding what the \"horse\" actually was during the fall of Troy.
The story of the Trojan War is among the oldest stories in the world.
A sprawling, fantastical tale of gods, omens, and perhaps most famously, a giant wooden horse
packed with Greek warriors. But despite its fame, historians believe this equine weapon of war
might be completely misunderstood. And that's why today we're risking the wrath of the gods
to discover what the Trojan Horse actually was.
It's pretty much impossible to discuss anything related to the Trojan War without first paying
lip service to the Iliad, an epic poem written by the Greek bard Homer. Or at least, it's credited
to Homer. Whether he actually wrote the Iliad is a bit of a mystery. In fact, we're not entirely
sure Homer ever even really existed. Many scholars believe he may be a folkloric character whose
name was derived from a society of poets known as the Homeriti. But it's also possible the stories
were purely the result of oral traditions that evolved over the course of centuries,
only to be written down sometime later. Whatever the case, the Iliad remains our chief source of
information about the Trojan War, and it says the whole thing began as a rescue mission to
retrieve the legendary Helen of Troy. Abducted from her Mycenaean homeland, the woman with the
face that launched a thousand ships sparked an unprecedented 10-year offensive against Troy,
also known as Iliad, by a coalition of Greek states. Whether this war or anything like it
ever really happened is also a mystery. The works of Homer deal with the real-world politics of the
alleged era, but they also contain Olympian deities, terrifying monsters, and some seriously
badass heroes. For example, Achilles, the mighty warrior and child of a god. In other words, Homer's
account is fantastical by design, so it's hard to say whether it's an embellished version of actual
historical events or a complete fiction. Archaeologists, always looking to be helpful,
remain split on the question. There is evidence of a real city named Troy having existed in what
is now Turkey, but there's no proof the climactic battle of legend ever occurred. Thanks, archaeologists!
Anyway, fictional or not, you might think the Iliad was at least responsible for the story
of the Trojan Horse. But much like the legend of Achilles' heel, the Iliad actually contains no
reference to the famous device. Why? Because the Iliad ends before the story reaches that point
in the war. To find Homer mentioning the Trojan Horse, you have to look to the Iliad's sequel,
The Odyssey. During the decade-long battle against Troy, the Greeks had to get down and dirty. The
city was protected by walls, built with the assistance of Poseidon, who was apparently
really good at building walls, so Troy easily deflected all attacks by their invaders. That is,
until an absolutely devious act of trickery turned the tide. At the suggestion of Odysseus,
a fairly crafty dude in any era, the Greeks secretly constructed a large wooden horse on
the shores of Troy. A band of Greek warriors then hid themselves inside its hollow body.
The horse was then pushed toward the gates of Troy and abandoned. The Trojan soldiers,
guarding that gate, watched with pride as the Greek army left its offering and then retreated
to the seas. Accepted as a gift, or perhaps a white flag, the wooden horse was then brought
into the city. Happy with their enormous, and kind of random, trophy, the Trojans then partied
hard into the night and eventually hit the hay. Once the coast was clear, the Greek soldiers
slipped out from their hiding place in the horse's belly and opened the gates of Troy from within.
Beneath the blanket of night, the invading army had returned to the shores of Troy.
And after leveling the city, the Trojan War ended and Prince's Peach, uh, I mean Helen of Troy,
was saved. Since it was the brainchild of the legendary hero Odysseus, star of the Odyssey,
it seems safe to assume the story of the Trojan horse came from that poem. But much like the
Iliad's surprising lack of wooden sculptures, the Odyssey also contains little to no mention of the
Trojan horse. In fact, there are only two lines in the epic poem referencing Odysseus' plan.
Homer's second poem is way more concerned with murderous sirens and cycloptic carnivores,
which begs the question, how exactly did the Trojan horse become so famous? Well,
we can all thank the most famous tour guide to hell for that one. Yes, before his posthumous
appearance in Dante's Inferno, the Roman poet Virgil composed an epic titled The Aeneid,
which is where we get all of the Trojan horse tropes found in the cartoons and blockbuster
films of today. It's widely assumed that Virgil's account is based on more ancient sources,
since Lost, but even if that's the case, the most famous trick the Greeks ever pulled
is mostly only remembered because of a Roman. Virgil's version of the story offers a fascinating
glimpse into ancient espionage, but it also kind of makes the Trojans look like a bunch of idiots.
Like, seriously, who would fall for that? And that's not the result of thousands of years
of hindsight because even the commentators of antiquity had trouble believing the whole Trojan
horse thing would really work. Maybe that's why it's not all that surprising that modern
scholars believe the entire concept was a misinterpretation right from the giddyup.
Barring the discovery of some mind-blowing new evidence, or time travel, there is no way of
knowing exactly what the ancient poets meant when referring to a horse at the fall of Troy.
There are, however, a few clues scattered across the history of warfare. For example,
to make a heroic dent in a legendary fortification, old-timey warriors like
Odysseus required an engine. And no, not one of the V8 variety. Before the discovery of gunpowder
and chrome, armies looking to reduce an opposing city to rubble required some good old-fashioned
wood and rope to make a siege engine, an ancient weapon that utilized primitive physics to crushing
effect, literally. In terms of pure scale, siege towers offered the most baffling visual horror
for any fresh recruit guarding their cities. Carted to the borders of battle on gargantuan
wheels, siege towers offered a distinct hide advantage for conquests. Side by side,
these towers of death could quickly overpower pretty much any army or civilization. But when
it comes to siege engines with deadly ambition, the ranged variety took aim at everything in
sight, from boulder-bearing catapults and flaming trebuchets to the unholy terror of a loaded
ballista. Ranged siege engines were some of the most devastating forms of ancient warfare,
but while it's intriguing to imagine bolts of Greek fire being leveled at terrified Trojans,
Occam's Razor suggests the siege engine engine we're looking for might actually be a simple
battering ram, named both for an ability to ram through the gates of the enemy and for the hooved
animal often adorned on its focal point. The battering ram was a deceptively simple tool,
whether literally carried and forced against its gates by crazed warriors or hoisted between
structures and swung back and forth. These siege engines were very effective when it came to ye olde
BNE. Why are we telling you this? Because even though the true nature of the Trojan horse is
still up for debate, the writer Posanias dropped this bombshell in the 2nd century that the work
of Apias was a contrivance to make a breach in the Trojan wall as known to everybody who does
not attribute utter silliness to the Phrygians. Apias, for the record, was the right-hand man of
Odysseus, the carpenter extraordinaire who built the Trojan horse, and the Phrygians were the
soldiers of Troy. So what Posanias was saying was basically, unless you think the soldiers of Troy
were a bunch of morons, the so-called Trojan horse was obviously just a name for a battering ram.
And Posanias might be right. Some ancient armies did in fact refer to battering rams as
horses. Why? Because of the horse skins wrapped around each wooden element to dull vibrations.
These hide-laden logs were also typically doused with water to prevent an enemy's flaming arrows
from setting the whole contraption on fire. Much like today's Black Hawk helicopters and military
drones with names like Raven and Puma, the urge to give weapons of war animalistic name tags
seems very ancient and entirely human. The Romans, for example, had a siege device called corvus,
which is the Latin word for crow. When it's all laid out like that, it's easy to imagine some
ancient poets heard some military types talking about the horse that breached the walls of Troy
and simply took it a little too literally. That being said, it's hard to imagine a troop of men
hiding in a battering ram. So did the poets just make that part up? Or is there perhaps
another explanation? Siege engines don't have big hollow bellies people can hide in, but ships do,
and the ships of ancient Greece might just be the answer we're looking for. We say that because
the Greeks of antiquity often referred to their ships as, wait for it, seahorses. In fact, Homer
himself, or whoever wrote it, uses the term seahorse to refer to ships on multiple occasions
over the course of the Odyssey. Equally intriguing is that when Homer very briefly describes Odysseus
and his men loading into the horse that sacks Troy, he uses pretty much the same language he
uses when he describes soldiers boarding ships. And from a literary perspective, it hasn't escaped
the attention of historians that the story of the Trojan War begins with the building of boats.
So it would be a perfect bookend to the full tale if it ended with the construction of yet another
ship or horse. Adding credence to this theory is the fact that naval archaeologists have uncovered
ancient texts and images of a Phoenician merchant ship, with the head of a horse carved into its
bow. Such carvings were said to imbue each vessel with ferocious speed, and according to ancient
texts, these ships, which were common in the first millennium, were lavishly decorated with other
horsey vibes. Similarly, ships with horsehead decorations are depicted on artifacts from the
Minoan and Mycenaean era, both common reference points for writers of epic legends. So once again,
it's possible that over centuries of oral tradition, a metaphorical name for ships got
confused with a literal interpretation, resulting in a story about a giant horse full of soldiers.
So that settles that, right? Well, not quite. Before we finish, there is one last slightly
more obscure theory lying among the rubble. Austrian historian Fritz Schockermeyer sees
the horse as a metaphor for an earth-shattering event, namely an earthquake. This theory holds
that the horse in question is actually representative of Poseidon. Most popular for
being god of the sea, this trident-wielding deity is also symbolic of horses and, oh yeah, earthquakes.
Fringe theory or not, there are some compelling arguments to support Fritz's case. For one,
although the Fall of Troy has no real documentation outside fanciful scribes like Homer and Virgil,
there is indeed archaeological evidence the city faced a disaster. During excavations in the area,
archaeologists uncovered signs of damage to the walls and, most likely, the culprit was an
earthquake. However, even if the real Troy was blown to smithereens by Mother Nature rather than
the acolytes of Zeus, most scholars reject the earthquake theory as it relates to the horse story.
Why? Because while it's entirely possible the walls were damaged by the movement of tectonic plates,
Poseidon was the least likely Olympian to tear down the Trojans. We say that because
Poseidon is actually credited with building the walls of Troy, so it's hard to imagine
him putting tridents through his own drywall. But nice try anyway, Fritz!
Considering the vast strangeness of ancient mythology, there is, of course, the possibility
that the Trojan horse isn't based on anything real and is simply a literary device, from the
wings used by Icarus to fly just a little too close to the sun, to Adamant, the impenetrably
hard substance shamelessly ripped off by Marvel Comics. Myths are full of science-fiction-style
contraptions and materials that could never have plausibly existed. That said, it would seem that
either siege engines or ship decorations are the answer. Wrapped in the words of a poet,
these military devices took on a life of their own. Oral traditions battered down the battering
ram truth behind the Trojan horse and entire cultures forgot their pet names for boats.
Whatever the case may be, the Trojan horse now survives as a metaphor, a warning about gullibility
that refers to the tactic of tricking targets into letting an enemy sneak into a safe zone.
In that sense, the horse is a reminder that non-threatening exteriors can become a token of
fear. And fear we must, for as Virgil himself wrote in the Aeneid,
I fear the Greeks even when bearing gifts.

