China’s High-Speed Rail Collapse: No Pay, Female Crew Quit In Mass, Turnover Hits 50%

China Observer
822粉絲
China says its high-speed rail network now spans more than 31,000 miles, ranking first in the world. At the same time, turnover among high-speed rail attendants has remained persistently high.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT2kPBcD6tXn8TP_aV7BmgA/join
#chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
⭐You can support us at: https://donorbox.org/china-observer-supporting-independent-news
⭐For business cooperation, please contact us: [email protected]
China says its high-speed rail network now spans more than 31,000 miles,
ranking first in the world. At the same time, turnover among high-speed rail attendants has
remained persistently high. Some data show turnover rates among high-speed rail attendants
ranging from 35 to 45 percent, with some routes exceeding 50 percent. Fewer than 20 percent of
contract workers stay for three years. Recently, many former attendants have posted farewell
videos online. A railway worker who resigned said, I finally quit. Today I made an important
decision. I don't regret meeting everyone and I don't regret leaving. Goodbye to my one year and
eight months on the railway. Another person said, I never thought I would give up this quickly.
I worked for one year and seven months and now I'm getting off the train. A young woman born
after 2000 quit her job as a high-speed rail attendant and jumped into the auto parts business.
She posted a video saying she once thought she would spend her entire life wearing a uniform
and standing on high-speed rail platforms. But now she has moved into the auto parts market instead.
Many people are puzzled by this. High-speed rail attendant jobs in China are considered
stable and respectable. Workers can travel across the country regularly. So why is the
resignation rate still so high? Chinese media reported that industry insiders described the
profession this way. It looks prestigious, but the work is exhausting. The pay does not match
the effort and the future is uncertain. Analysts say the high number of resignations among female
attendants is linked to several real-world challenges. First, pay is a major issue. Most
frontline attendants are employed through labor dispatch agencies rather than as official railway
employees. Even when doing the same work, their pay can differ. With monthly salaries potentially
30-50% lower than those of permanent employees. Frontline attendants typically earn around
2,000-3,500 yuan a month. After becoming regular employees, many earn around 3,000-6,000 yuan a
month. Labor dispatch companies may also deduct management fees. After paying rent and living
expenses in major cities, many have little money left. Another reason is the demanding workload.
Female attendants often work more than 14 hours a day, spending most of the time standing or
walking more than 18 miles a day. Long periods of standing and pushing carts while bending over can
lead to occupational problems such as varicose veins, back pain, and stomach issues. In addition,
rotating shifts disrupt their body clocks for long periods. Waking up before dawn for early shifts
and finishing work late at night are common. As a result, many frontline attendants experience
insomnia, hair loss, and hormonal problems. This working environment can damage health over time.
On top of the physical demands, frontline attendants also have to deal with difficult
passengers. They're expected to keep smiling even when facing unreasonable complaints or angry
travelers. Since train cabins are monitored throughout the journey, complaints can lead
to financial penalties. For many, the mental pressure is even harder to endure than the
exhaustion. After dealing with repeated conflicts and complaints from passengers,
some attendants choose to resign. Industry insiders also said that holidays and weekends
are usually peak travel periods, which are exactly when attendants are the busiest.
As a result, they have little time to spend with family and friends, and their personal
lives are taken over by work. In addition, irregular schedules, frequent business trips,
and difficulties adjusting after pregnancy make frontline attendance jobs less friendly
for female employees. Many eventually choose to resign. Furthermore, high-speed rail attendants
currently being recruited are mostly women between the ages of 18 and 25. After becoming attendants,
their career paths are limited. From attendant to train conductor, then to team leader,
only a small number are able to reach management positions. Many female attendants also face major
life changes around the age of 30, including marriage and having children. Without clear
opportunities for promotion, some choose to leave and switch careers. Chinese affairs expert Yang
Bo said that for Chinese workers, salary is probably the biggest factor. Everyone's trying
to earn money. If the pay and benefits were good enough, these workers wouldn't leave.
Yang believes that because Chinese authorities do not allow negative portrayals of the economy,
Chinese media are unwilling to discuss the real reasons. He said the reality is that China's high
speed rail system has operated under heavy debt for years and has had to cut operating costs.
Apart from senior officials who may become wealthy through corruption, ordinary employees have little
room for wage increases. When the effort required does not match the income received, many workers
can't stay. Chinese state media has recently heavily promoted the achievements of China's
high-speed rail system, claiming that operating mileage has surpassed 31,000 miles, making it the
largest high-speed rail network in the world with more mileage than all other countries combined.
However, state media hasn't mentioned that China's high-speed rail projects continue to carry
massive debt. On June 18, 2009, China Railway Corporation, which was responsible for high-speed
rail construction and operations, was restructured into China State Railway Group. The company's
latest financial data shows that by the end of the first half of 2026, its total liabilities had
reached about US$870 billion. Although the company reported growing passenger revenue,
higher traffic volume, and total assets of about US$1.4 trillion, its debt-to-asset ratio remained
as high as 61%. As China's high-speed rail network surpassed 31,000 miles, the scale of
loss-making routes and the debt burden have continued to grow. Hong Kong newspaper Mingpao
reported in 2025, only a small number of high-speed rail lines in China are profitable.
These include the Beijing-Shanghai route, Beijing-Tianjin, Shanghai-Hangzhou, Shanghai-Nanjing,
Nanjing-Hangzhou, and Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong. Together, these routes account for only about 5%
of the country's total high-speed rail network. The state-affiliated Observer Network also reported
on May 11, 2024, that as of the end of 2023, profitable high-speed rail routes accounted
for only 6% of China's total network. The Beijing-Shanghai high-speed railway performed
exceptionally well in the first half of 2026, generating about $3 billion in revenue during
the period, with net profit attributable to shareholders reaching about $940 million.
This also highlights that a small number of highly profitable routes generate large amounts of
revenue to cover losses from more than 90% of the remaining routes. The Wall Street Journal
reported that Chinese authorities have long relied on infrastructure spending to support
economic growth. Even after China had already built much of the infrastructure it needed,
authorities did not change course. The report said this model has now become a massive money pit
and questioned whether China actually needs so many high-speed rail lines.
Chinese high-speed rail network is still expanding rapidly. Official data shows that in 2025,
China's total railway fixed-asset investment reached about $126 billion, up 6% year-on-year.
From January to August 2026, that figure totaled about $71 billion, up 1.5% year-on-year.
According to financial reports from China State Railway Group,
China's high-speed rail system recorded net losses of 55.5 billion yuan in 2020,
39.8 billion yuan in 2021, and 69.5 billion yuan in 2022. It turned a net profit of 3.3 billion
yuan in 2023, 3.8 billion yuan in 2024, and 4.3 billion yuan in 2025. In the first half of this
year, it also reported a profit of 1.85 billion yuan. However, many financial analysts point out
that even with a record profit of 4.3 billion yuan in 2025, China State Railway Group's return
on assets was only 0.04%, compared with its asset base of more than $1.4 trillion. Meanwhile,
compared with revenue of $180 billion, its net profit margin was only 0.33%.
Chinese affairs expert Yang Bo said that the current situation shows China Railway Group's
total debt has exceeded $870 billion. With annual interest payments exceeding $28 billion,
that means it has to pay around $77 million in interest every day.
He said the financial burden is enormous. China's high-speed rail system is burning money.
The whole world is laughing at China's high-speed rail, saying the more it builds,
the more money it loses. But Chinese authorities have already changed their strategy,
making people across China pay for this money-losing megaproject. Ordinary people
may not fully see it yet, but they're already starting to feel the impact.
In recent years, Chinese authorities have repeatedly emphasized expanding domestic
demand and boosting consumption. At the same time, fees in public sectors, including subway
services, water and electricity, gas, high-speed rail, and airport services, have continued to
rise. Among them, China State Railway Group has repeatedly increased ticket prices on several
popular routes, including the Beijing-Shanghai, Shanghai-Kunming, and Wuhan-Guangzhou lines.
Rising high-speed rail fares have become a trend in recent years. At the end of 2020,
China State Railway Group introduced flexible pricing on some train services.
Starting in 2021, it gradually expanded a differentiated floating pricing system for
high-speed rail tickets. From May 30, 2023, ticket prices on several routes were adjusted,
with increases of up to 20%. In June 2024, ticket prices on several major high-speed routes,
including the Wuhan-Guangzhou section, were raised by up to 20%.
On May 11, 2026, the Beijing-Shanghai high-speed rail announced that it would
adjust the published fares for trains running on the Beijing-Shanghai and Hefei-Bangbu high-speed
lines. Some fares would increase by 20%, and the highest second-class ticket price would exceed
$110. The Beijing-Shanghai high-speed rail route currently carries around 500 to 700,000 passengers
a day. According to Chinese media reports, high-speed rail tickets for the day before the
2026 National Day holiday went on sale on Sept. 16. Many passengers found that fares for Sept. 30
were noticeably higher than usual, with some trains increasing by nearly 100 yuan.
One user posted a comparison of ticket prices. On Sept. 25, a second-class ticket from Chongqing
North Station to Nanjing South Station started at 446 yuan. On Sept. 30, the same train's fare
increased to 520 yuan, making each ticket 74 yuan more expensive. In the comments, some users said
sleeper train tickets had risen by 190 yuan. Others said some routes had increased by about 25%.
Multiple high-speed rail customer service centers responded
that ticket prices are subject to flexible adjustments and are not fixed.
They said price fluctuations during holidays are normal practice.
Railway companies also said that this is not a price increase, but rather a change in discount
levels, and that the maximum listed fares have remained unchanged. Some users believe this is
clearly an attempt to take advantage of the situation and charge more. Industry insiders say
the reason China State Railway Group was able to turn losses into profits since 2023
is largely because higher ticket prices shifted more costs onto passengers.
As a major public infrastructure project built with taxpayer money,
high-speed rail has a strong public service role. However, to make its financial reports show a
turnaround, the China State Railway Group has transferred cost pressures directly to consumers.
Meanwhile, lower-income groups who rarely take high-speed rail contributed to railway
construction through taxes, but have not equally benefited from the system. However,
with China's overall economy declining in recent years and consumer downgrading continuing,
the result is, if prices go up, people simply stop using the service.
Take the Beijing-Shanghai high-speed rail route as an example. After the fare increase in May,
a second-class ticket for more than a four-hour journey approached $110. What does that mean?
During off-peak seasons, it can cost more than flying. A four-and-a-half-hour high-speed train
ride can now be more expensive than a flight that takes one hour and 40 minutes. At the same time,
China's railway authorities have introduced another measure. While high-speed rail fares
are rising, they've reduced service on conventional trains, known as the old-style green trains.
Many of these trains have already been suspended. The demand for travel has not disappeared,
but people's choices are gradually shrinking. As a result, long-distance buses, which many once
believed would disappear, have made a comeback on the streets of the Pearl River Delta.
Some routes are difficult to get prices for. According to a report from Chinese media in
July this year, a bus ticket from Zhuhai to Shenzhen costs 19.8 yuan, while high-speed
rail tickets start at 140 yuan. A bus from Guangzhou to Jiaoqing costs only 9 yuan,
roughly the price of a cup of milk tea. A bus from Guangzhou to Zhanjiang costs 80 yuan,
less than one-third of the high-speed rail fare. Some routes have seen passenger numbers surge by
400 percent, with tickets becoming difficult to buy. China built the world's largest high-speed
rail network, but now many people are turning around and taking buses instead. The message
behind this trend is significant. Some people say it's not that buses are taking away business from
high-speed rail. Rather, buses are serving the part of the market that high-speed rail has left
behind. On ordinary workdays, people post videos showing nearly empty high-speed rail carriages.
On September 12, a content creator posted a video saying that a high-speed train
in Xishuangbanna, Yunnan Province, was surprisingly empty. On September 26,
another content creator posted a video saying that ordinary people can no longer afford high-speed
rail because, while ticket prices have soared, wages have remained unchanged. The high-speed
train from Guangzhou to Zhanjiang takes only about two hours and costs more than 200 yuan.
A regular train takes five hours and costs only a few dozen yuan.
Saving more than three hours means paying an extra 200 yuan. For business executives,
those three hours could be enough to close a major deal. But for many workers,
earning 200 yuan in a day may already be difficult. Besides the price, high-speed
rail has another major drawback. High-speed rail stations are usually built in suburban areas.
For people in counties and towns, they still need to take another form of transportation to reach
the station, meaning the time saved is often limited. During this year's Mid-Autumn Festival
and National Day holiday, a huge number of Chinese travelers used high-speed rail. However,
road travel by bus and private cars still accounted for the overwhelming majority of
cross-regional travel. According to the latest official data, during the Mid-Autumn Festival
and National Day holiday period this year, China's railways were expected to take 284
million passenger trips. But official forecasts also showed that road transportation accounted
for more than 90 percent of all cross-regional passenger movement, including private car trips,
rental cars, and long-distance buses. In reality, investment in China's high-speed
rail network has often been criticized for waste over the years. Many places have built
high-speed rail stations that were later left unused. Some stations attracted too few passengers
after opening and were unable to continue operating. For example, Jiulangshan High-Speed
Railway Station in Juzhou City, Hunan Province, had a total investment of more than $17 million.
It opened in December 2016, but its daily passenger volume was sometimes only in the
single digits. The station was eventually suspended from operation in March 2022.
Chinese users questioned, how was this approved in the first place? What was the purpose of
a station in a place like this? In China, abandoned or unused high-speed rail stations
are often called ghost high-speed rail stations. And such stations can be found across the country.
For example, Zouqun East Station in Zibo, Shandong Province, was completed 17 years ago,
but has never opened and remains abandoned. It ranks among the top ghost high-speed rail stations
in China. The second place goes to Zijingshan East Station, which has been unused for 16 years.
Located in Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, the station was built as a connection between Nanjing South
Station and Xianlin Station. It was officially completed in 2010, but has never entered
operation. Number three is Jiangpu Station in Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, which has remained
unused for 15 years. There are currently at least 20 high-speed rail stations across China that have
been left unused. Tesla CEO Elon Musk publicly praised China's high-speed rail during an
interview with Chinese state broadcaster CCTV. He described his previous high-speed rail trip
from Beijing to Xian as a great experience and praised Chinese high-speed rail stations as
extremely impressive. Musk's comments, which appear to align with Beijing's positive messaging,
drew mockery from some Chinese users. Some users said, the high-speed rail station in my hometown
was built very grandly. I've taken the train there twice. The station is so big, but there's almost
no one there. I was the only person getting on and off. Who planned this project back then? Did
anyone calculate the cost? Another person said, the Communist Party is skilled at deception,
and Musk is also saying things that aren't true. One user posted, most of China's high-speed rail
lines did not need to be built. The essence of high-speed rail is using money from poorer people
to subsidize wealthier people. How many poor people regularly take high-speed rail? There's
been a huge number of duplicate and inefficient construction. Besides the high-speed rail stations,
some people have also questioned the reliability of China-produced high-speed trains.
One widely discussed fact is that in the early 2000s, Chinese authorities used the country's
huge potential high-speed rail market as leverage in negotiations. They reached technology transfer
agreements with international companies, including Japan's Kawasaki Heavy Industries,
Germany's Siemens, and France's Alstom. Among them, Kawasaki Heavy Industries provided core
technology based on the Shinkansen E2-1000 series, working with Chinese partners to produce
the CRH2 Harmony high-speed train. Under the agreement, Japanese companies provided detailed
technical drawings, manufacturing processes, and on-site guidance based on principles of
commercial trust and technological cooperation. The contracts also reportedly specified that the
imported technology was only for use within China and could not be transferred abroad or used for
But after the Chinese railway authorities and China State Railway Group obtained the technology,
they carried out large-scale reverse engineering. They dismantled Japanese train models,
conducted detailed measurements, and reproduced many parts of the designs.
With only modifications to areas such as the front end appearance and some technical details,
they later promoted the trains as independently developed products,
including the Harmony series and later the Fuxing series.
One content creator commented that using decades of research and development achievements from other
countries while minimizing the original contributor's role represents a form of
technological appropriation and damages trust in international business. However, critics argue
that even after obtaining foreign technology, the quality of some Chinese-made dupes still
failed to meet expectations. A content creator posted a video saying that after passing Tianshui
South Station in Gansu Province, a high-speed train carriage shook throughout the journey.
One user commented,
High-speed rail is suffering from serious losses and has no money for maintenance.
On top of that, Europe is no longer exporting key components to China.
It's only a matter of time before things start falling apart.
In July this year, the third phase of the Shah Alam Light Rail Transit Line,
operated by Rapid KL in Malaysia, experienced an incident during its first week of service.
The train suddenly stopped, followed by a loud cracking sound and sparks.
Passengers were eventually forced to evacuate. The incident was caused by train components
coming into contact with a power conductor. The trains involved were manufactured by a
company under China's state-owned CRRC Group. The European Commission previously pointed out
that Chinese companies often receive government subsidies from Chinese authorities. While these
allow them to lower prices and win bids, quality is not always guaranteed.
