When talking about historical fiction films, historians and history buffs use the same two words over and over again: accuracy and authenticity. The first refers to strict adherence to historical fashion, customs, and events. The second is a little more nebulous, and refers more to how a historical movie "feels." I would use a more specific word: immersion. To me, a period piece succeeds if it's well made enough to – with a little imagination – transport you to a different time. In this video essay, I recommend ten movies that, in my opinion, accomplish just that.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
A filmmaker and history enthusiast explores the distinction between material accuracy and emotional immersion in cinema. By analyzing a diverse selection of historical films and series, the speaker argues that artistic choices, visual storytelling, and a commitment to the \"spirit\" of an era are more effective at transporting an audience than mere factual correctness.
Generally, the more you learn about history, the less you'll enjoy watching historical
movies.
I used to love watching big Hollywood historical epics when I was a kid.
They set fire to my imagination and encouraged me to learn more about the past.
Nowadays, revisiting those movies that I loved as a child is often a frustrating experience
because I find myself endlessly distracted by little anachronisms and inaccuracies.
When historians and history nerds talk about historical movies, they often frame the conversation
in terms of accuracy and authenticity.
By accuracy, they mean the physical culture, or, in cinematic terms, the production design.
The hair, makeup, props, costumes, and sets.
What they mean by authenticity is a little less well-defined, but usually it refers to
how the movie feels.
Does it capture the spirit of the time period?
Do you feel like you're being transported to another world?
If that sounds a little mystical, nebulous, and subjective, you're right.
It is.
I would use a different word to describe that feeling.
Immersion.
Even if a movie isn't technically accurate, I feel like it deserves praise if it's sufficiently
immersive.
It succeeds if you can watch it, even as a jaded history nerd, and be swept up in the
story and buy into the illusion that it's presenting without constantly going,
Uh, that button's not quite right.
Sword's way too late for the period.
That accent's all over the place.
Gah!
I'm a filmmaker and a history buff, so I feel like I've got a foot in both camps here.
And my useless film school education has given me enough technical knowledge about filmmaking
to articulate what makes a movie more or less immersive.
In my opinion, it has much less to do with material culture, though that is important,
and much more to do with artistic choices and the tools of visual storytelling.
So here's my list of the Top 10 Most Immersive Historical Movies of All Time.
Number 4 may surprise you!
10.
Andrei Rublev
It's kind of hard to overstate how good this movie is.
Andrei Rublev, directed by Andrei Tarkovsky, tells the story of the life of an icon painter
in 15th century Russia.
The narrative is broken up into chapters, with years or even decades passing between
these key events.
What sets Andrei Rublev apart from most medieval movies is that it doesn't focus on
badass battles or the rise and fall of nations or great heroes.
At its core, it's a quite simple story about an artist searching for meaning in a chaotic
and meaningless world.
This was a struggle that Tarkovsky understood only too well, as a devoutly Christian filmmaker
working in the atheistic Soviet Union.
Many of Tarkovsky's movies were cut down by government censors.
So when Andrei Rublev's artistic ambitions are derailed by the whims of the nobility,
you get the sense that Tarkovsky is commenting on much more than just the politics of the
15th century.
Faith is a huge theme in this film, as it is in most of Tarkovsky's stuff.
But I don't think he ever made a more Christian movie than this.
Andrei Rublev is obsessed with the biggest questions of that religion.
He wrestles with them.
He has all sorts of angst about them.
And unlike the faith-based American movies of today, Andrei Rublev doesn't pretend
to have any answers.
It approaches the subject with much more intelligence and much more nuance.
Because Christianity was such an enormous part of life in Medieval Europe, I always
prefer Medieval movies that are directed by devout Christians.
For me, it offers more of a glimpse into the mindset of the people of the time, and makes
the whole viewing experience much more authentic.
Andrei Rublev is not for everybody.
A lot of viewers are going to be put off by its leisurely pace and its episodic plot.
But I think it's one of the most beautiful historical movies I've ever seen.
9. Das Boot
Imagine that you're living for months on end in a 200-foot-long iron coffin with 56
of the most annoying roommates in the world, with a really good chance that you could die
horribly at any moment.
And you thought quarantine was bad.
This movie manages to be both a super-believable portrayal of daily life on a U-boat and a
surreal nightmarish descent into hell at the same time.
When we first meet our characters, they're clean-shaven and immaculately groomed.
But over the course of their war patrol in the Battle of the Atlantic, their beards grow
out, their hair gets long and greasy, bags appear under their eyes, they're pale, malnourished
skeletons by the end.
The makeup and costuming feel so real, you can almost smell the B.O.
But what throws me into this world most are actually the rare scenes when the crew of
U-96 leave their boat and re-emerge into the land of the living.
My favorite scene in the movie is when the officers are invited into the luxurious German
merchant ship that's docked off the coast of Spain.
Some Nazis show up and greet them—in the traditional way, of course—and give them
all sorts of champagne and cookies and ask them to tell all of their great heroic stories.
This scene always felt very relatable to me and reminded me of some experiences from my
own life, though obviously my experiences are a thousand times less intense than those
of the crew of a U-boat.
So I'm really into backpacking.
Nothing I love more than going out for a few weeks into the woods, walking up mountains
10-12 hours a day.
And on a big hike, your standard of hygiene just plummets.
It goes way down.
You're used to gobbling up Pop-Tarts, you're constantly hungry, flies crawling on your
asshole when you're taking a dump in the woods is like no big deal after a few days.
It's an absolutely beautiful experience.
But when you return to your normal life—and this has happened to me every time—you find
that it's really hard to talk about your experiences with someone who hasn't shared it.
And I've talked to veteran friends who've told me they had very similar feelings when
they came back from Iraq and Afghanistan.
And again, I'm not trying to say I understand the horrors of war just because I've been
on some long-ass section hikes, but I just love the way that Das Boot presents that disconnect
between this ragged U-boat crew that's been to hell and back and the pampered, plump landlubbers
that they're supposedly fighting for.
It just rings true.
And that's what storytelling should be at the end of the day—truth under imaginary
circumstances.
8.
The Lighthouse
In my opinion, Robert Eggers is the best director of historical fiction work in today.
His awesome first movie, The Witch, very nearly made it onto this list, and it's the best
depiction of 17th century New England that's ever been done on film.
So far.
Fuckin' comin' for you, Rob.
But as good as The Witch is, The Lighthouse is a hundred times better, set on an island
off the coast of Maine in the 1890s.
It's an amazing depiction of the superstitious seafaring culture of 19th century New England.
The Lighthouse has received some much-deserved praise for the authenticity and poetry of
its dialogue, much of which was taken directly from 19th century Yankee novel literature.
But I think what makes this film truly immersive, at least for me, is the cinematography.
It was shot on 35mm black and white film, using a narrow 1.19.1 aspect ratio.
The cameras were equipped with antique lenses from the 1930s, as well as a custom-made color
filter that evoked the crusty, high-contrast look of 19th century photography.
To evoke this time, you know, one thing that would really help is this orthochromatic look,
you know, so the film would see blue and green and ultraviolet, and that's it.
So the film is insensitive to red, of course red is a predominant color and skin tone,
so your skin tones get really dark, and any fluctuation would be very pronounced, you know,
like blemishes, you know, any little blood vessels, whatever, get really dark,
because those would be more red, therefore darker.
Most movies these days are shot on digital cameras, which can achieve a very high exposure.
But back in the old film days, and especially with the old-fashioned film used on The Lighthouse,
they needed to have a powerful array of lights in order to illuminate this properly.
And that's a look that you really can't fake on digital, no matter how low you go.
In a recent episode of the show Outlander, there was a flashback scene in a silent film aesthetic,
but at least to me, it's very obviously shot on digital, using modern lenses,
with color correction and antique-looking scratches and grain added in post.
And it's just not nearly as cool.
We were all nervous, talked to the director once again, Stephen Wolfensohn directed this,
we want you to film it in a silent picture way,
but we also want you to film it, you know, in a more conventional way, just in case.
Pussies.
Oh, don't be such an old bitch!
7. Ran.
The title translates to chaos, or turmoil, and it's an extremely apt one.
Ran was the last epic of legendary director Akira Kurosawa,
based loosely on Shakespeare's King Lear, and it is beyond awesome.
As with Andre Rublev, it's a slow burn, but I promise, if you let yourself get into it,
you will love every square inch of this film.
It's just amazing scene after amazing scene, with top-notch acting and writing.
Ran might be the most authentic portrayal of court intrigue that I've ever seen in a movie.
Lords go mad with power, family members turn on each other ruthlessly,
and creepy courtiers scheme in the shadows, but there's nothing sexy about it.
There are no pithy Lannisters with quippy comebacks.
Instead, there's strict deference to authority,
an absolute adherence to samurai ethics, and good old-fashioned Japanese court tradition.
Plus, there's a power-hungry queen who makes Cersei look like Sir Pounce.
Seriously, this lady is terrifying.
The violence is super gnarly, and the battle scenes are glorious.
Rewatching this, I felt like a total idiot for not including it in my old video about battle scenes,
because the big fights in this are absolutely terrific.
And nobody did arrows better than Kurosawa.
Like, this guy will shoot arrows at his actors and not give a ----.
But everything I've said could honestly apply to all of Kurosawa's other samurai movies.
They're all amazing.
I mean, there's not a bad apple in the bunch.
But those movies were in black and white.
And I think what makes Ran really immersive is the fact that it's in color.
Today, we take color for granted, but in the 20th century,
filmmakers who began their careers working in black and white used color in really interesting ways.
It was just another tool in their toolbox.
Again, look at this siege and how Kurosawa uses color here.
We have this black sand landscape, smoke spiraling all around,
looking like a sinister alien planet,
contrasted with these bright yellows and reds that make for an incredibly striking image.
Personally, I'm kind of sick of medieval movies that look all dour and desaturated.
It's overdone.
Every medieval movie these days is brown and blue.
They look like a plastic bag full of dog ----.
Who's that then?
I don't know.
Must be a king.
Why?
He hasn't got ---- all over him.
And it's not historically authentic.
Whether in feudal Japan or medieval Europe,
all sorts of times and places in the past, people dressed colorfully.
Even New England Puritans were known to wear bright red and bright green on occasion.
I'd like to see that sort of thing make more of an appearance in movies.
It's more authentic and, more importantly, it's prettier to look at.
6. Master and Commander
This movie is the definition of class.
On paper, Master and Commander is a movie you've seen before.
British dudes on a boat, pretty much.
But it's never been done so well.
It doesn't hurt that it's based on some of the finest historical fiction ever written.
And I will never not be mad that this film doesn't have at least 10 sequels.
What really makes this film immersive for me is the acting.
I don't think Russell Crowe has ever done a better performance.
It's understated.
He doesn't have any big crying scenes.
You know, he doesn't even raise his voice all that much.
But he's completely convincing as the charismatic and capable Captain Jack Aubrey.
His foil is, of course, Paul Bettany, who plays physician and naturalist Stephen Maturin.
They're the classic odd couple.
Sailor and scientist.
Jock and nerd.
They couldn't be more different.
And yet they share a heartfelt and touching friendship.
Their performances are completely rooted in the time period.
These are upper-class Napoleonic-era naval nautical gentlemen, after all.
And a stiff upper lip is compulsory.
A lot of lead actors in historical movies make the mistake of modernizing their performances.
They make them feel much more contemporary.
I guess to make the characters more relatable or something.
But I don't think that approach works.
And I think that Master and Commander proves that you don't need to make your
main characters feel modern in order for your audience to fall in love with them.
Crowe and Bettany disappear into their roles, as do all the other actors.
And there are some big names in this movie.
I mean, maybe not A-listers, but character actors you've seen a thousand times in other things.
****, Pippin is in this movie.
But I don't see Pippin.
Nor do I see Maximus Decimus Meridius
or the weird alien thing that Paul Bettany plays in the Marvel films.
I see the crew of the HMS Surprise.
Do you not know that in the service, one must always choose the lesser of two weevils?
5. HBO's Rome
Yes, I know it's a TV show and not a movie,
but Rome is just too ******* good not to include here.
It's an enormous two-season epic that follows two commoners
as they get swept up in the intrigue and skullduggery of the fall of the Roman Republic.
The show has stellar writing, casting, and performances,
but the unsung hero is the production design.
The costumes and sets are a conscious departure
from the marbleized version of ancient Rome that we're used to seeing in so many Hollywood epics.
Instead of a spotless white marble city filled with stoic old men,
this Rome is -----stained, grimy, dirty, bursting with color and with life.
And that's much more historically authentic.
Ancient Rome had more in common with Bourbon Street than with the National Mall.
For the show, the art department built a gigantic five-acre city set
at Cinecittà Studios in Rome,
at that time the biggest set in the world.
Though the main cast was largely British, the extras were almost all local Italians,
which make the backgrounds of scenes feel even more real.
The costumes were made entirely of period-direct fabrics and metals.
Linen, wool, silk, brass, and iron.
You might not have noticed it, but your brain did.
The only thing that's obviously inauthentic about Rome
is the fact that the characters are speaking English.
Personally, I prefer the Mel Gibson approach to period language,
but it's important to understand that The Passion and Apocalypto
were relatively cheap films paid for largely out of Mel Gibson's own pocket.
Realistically, if you want somebody to give you a hundred million dollars
to make a historical epic, it's got to be in English.
Despite that, the dialogue of Rome is incredibly immersive.
From its curse words...
A who but a son of dick gives you the right to make such judgment!
...to the complete lack of anachronistic phrases and idioms,
it's easy to imagine that you're watching this show with a babblefish stuck in your ear.
Everything else about it, the weird Roman customs, the dirty sex,
the casual violence, really transports you to this lost world.
The gods have abandoned Rome.
If Mars were watching, he would not allow such a disgrace.
Or maybe he was having a crap and missed it!
Speaking of Apocalypto...
4. Apocalypto.
Bet you didn't expect a Mel Gibson film to appear on this list.
But I think Apocalypto is a perfect example of how accuracy and immersion
can be two completely separate things.
This movie is utterly unique and extremely well made,
though anthropologists have noted inconsistencies in the actors' accents.
Gibson's ballsy decision to have the dialogue spoken entirely in Yucatec Maya
makes this over-the-top chase movie feel more grounded and real
than pretty much every other historical movie out there.
To a non-Maya speaker, that is.
If you do speak Maya, then don't bother yourself with this movie.
Unless you want to laugh at it.
With the exception of a few veteran character actors,
most of the cast of Apocalypto had never been on camera before in their lives,
including the lead actor, Rudy Youngblood.
That is, again, a super risky, ballsy choice.
And all these non-actors delivered pretty effective and memorable performances.
Getting a good performance out of a non-actor is one of the hardest things a director can do,
but when it's done right, it can add a certain rawness and realism to a film
that Juilliard graduates can rarely match.
But it ain't easy.
I can tell you from experience that most of the time it blows up in your face.
And it takes a truly manic crazy man to make that work.
The sets and costumes are absolutely beautiful and insanely detailed.
The sequence where the Hulkane warriors lead their captives into the city,
passing fields afflicted by pestilence and a populace on the verge of starvation,
is some of the most superb world-building I've ever seen.
And within the city itself, elaborate production design is complemented by the
The chase in Apocalypto's third act might be the best work Mel Gibson has ever done.
The camera is always moving.
The cinematographer utilized cutting-edge crane technology to
hurl the camera at breakneck speeds through real jungle,
achieving some super dynamic and creative shots that really heighten the suspense.
All this makes for some seriously thrilling historical fiction.
You buy into the world of this story from the very first frame.
And that's an amazing technical achievement,
especially considering that among historians and anthropologists,
this film is universally reviled.
Yeah, even taking into account artistic license,
Apocalypto is a piss-poor representation of Mayan civilization.
But in terms of audience immersion, it's almost unmatched.
There's a need for so much gruesome graphic violence.
Why not let us imagine a little bit?
Because it's so much fun, Jan! Get it!
Quest for Fire is set 80,000 years ago,
before humans knew how to make fire and could only take it from nature.
When one tribe of early humans comes under attack by weird savage ape-men,
they lose their only source of fire.
So they send three of their young warriors out to find some.
The survival of the tribe at stake.
Unlike Apocalypto, which bizarrely manages to be immersive,
despite an almost complete disregard for history,
Quest for Fire demonstrates just how much a commitment
to painstaking accuracy can do for a film.
While much of the science the movie is based on is now dated,
director Jean-Jacques Annot hired a dream team of anthropologists and experts
to help craft as authentic a portrayal of early humans as possible.
In the DVD commentary,
that literally no normal person would ever notice or care about.
That's my kind of director.
Anthony Burgess, the author of 2001 A Space Odyssey,
was brought on to construct a plausible prehistoric language for the characters to speak.
Yeah, you heard me right.
The only dialogue in this film is spoken in a made-up caveman language,
without subtitles.
And it is the most awesome ---- ever.
And yet, the plot isn't hard to follow.
You understand exactly what's going on at all times,
despite the fact that you don't understand a goddamn word of what anybody's saying.
Because so much of communication is non-verbal,
a body language of gestures and postures was also developed,
based on customs of modern-day hunter-gatherers
and the behavior of primates like chimpanzees and bonobos.
The makeup and costumes are stunning and completely transform the actors.
Except, of course, for Ron Perlman.
They really didn't have to change his appearance at all.
What also does wonders for immersion are the inhospitable and beautiful locations.
Quest for Fire shot across three continents,
in some of the most rugged places in the world.
We shot three weeks in Scotland,
where it was anywhere from 25 degrees Fahrenheit to about 40 degrees Fahrenheit,
barefoot up to about here, up to the midsection.
And there were no tricks.
We were walking on cold rock, sometimes frozen heather,
climbing trees in the cold weather and stuff.
All for the authenticity of the ruggedness of the elements that these people faced.
Now we're in Africa and we actually sometimes walk on land that's so hot
that you get blisters on your feet when you finish a take,
which is no more than 30 seconds sometimes.
It's incredibly difficult.
I'm truly baffled why this movie isn't regarded as the classic of historical fiction that it is.
And of all the movies on this list, this one might be my personal favorite.
Two, Come and See.
Come and See is quite simply the best war movie ever made.
It follows a Belarusian teenager who joins a partisan group
during the Nazi occupation of the Soviet Union.
And it all goes downhill from there.
Honestly, the less said about the plot of this film, the better.
You can't really explain this movie.
You just have to experience it.
There are lots of movies that emphasize the tragedy and brutality of war,
but it's never been done so unflinchingly, so unapologetically.
It's harrowing, haunting, and at times extremely hard to watch.
Come and See exudes evil with every frame and it just fills you with unspeakable dread.
And as I've said before, that's how every war movie should feel.
War doesn't look like this.
It looks like this.
This movie is so disturbing that I'm not even going to show you clips from the worst bits.
And I know you think you're a tough guy because you've seen Cannibal Holocaust,
but it's different when you know that what you're watching
is an unexaggerated depiction of actual events.
Let's not mince words here.
The Wehrmacht burned, murdered, and raped their way across Eastern Europe.
They killed 13 million Russian civilians.
Approximately 1 million women gave birth to children that resulted from rape.
Many of those women, by the way, were then murdered under Nazi anti-miscegenation laws.
And that's just the big historical picture.
On the sort of micro level,
countless other millions had their lives completely destroyed.
Countless other millions were brutalized and traumatized.
Countless other millions lost loved ones in the most unimaginably cruel ways.
From our safe, comfortable 21st century existence,
it's almost impossible to imagine the level of suffering
the Nazis inflicted during their invasion of the Soviet Union.
But Come and See gives us a pretty good idea.
1. Barry Lyndon
It's hard to beat Kubrick, man.
If Barry Lyndon isn't a perfect historical movie, then it's pretty damn close.
Everything about it, the dialogue, the humor, the narrative flow,
feels like it was plucked right out of the 18th century.
If camera and sound equipment existed in 1765,
this is exactly the sort of movie that people of that time would make.
Almost every frame feels like an 18th century painting.
And to achieve the look they wanted,
Kubrick's crew had to come up with lighting and camera techniques
that had never before been done.
Most of Barry Lyndon was illuminated using natural light,
and when it wasn't available, the effect of natural light was carefully mimicked.
Many of the night interiors were lit entirely by candles,
which again, is no small feat when shooting on film.
Famously, the only way that cinematographer John Alcott was able to achieve this effect
was to use an extremely fast aperture lens
developed by NASA to photograph the dark side of the moon.
The characters of Barry Lyndon are men and women of their time,
and very few of them are actually likable.
Barry himself is opportunistic, misogynistic, hot-headed, adulterous.
Dude's a total prick, and that is so refreshing to see in a period piece.
The fact is, almost every person watching this video
would never in a million years be able to honestly befriend
anybody born before the Industrial Revolution.
Harp on all you want about the good old days,
and how life was so much simpler then,
and how much you'd love to fight in the American Revolution or whatever.
If you could go back in time and meet your six-times-great-grandfather,
he'd think that you're lazy, effeminate, and insufferable.
Even this guy would think that you're womanly.
I mean, he would definitely think that if you are, in fact, a woman,
but let's face it, it's always the boys who say that stupid ----, you know.
I wish I could have fought in the Civil War.
No, you don't. **** you.
You're a candy ass. Shut up and sit down.
Barry Lyndon isn't likable, but he is relatable.
Kubrick had enough confidence in his script and vision
to allow our common humanity with these historical people to speak for itself.
We may have nothing in common with them.
Their world may be alien to our own,
but we don't need to modernize them to empathize with them.
The human condition is universal.
Well, I hope you enjoyed that glorified list of movie recommendations.
I don't know if you've noticed recently, but this channel's kind of been blowing up.
Like, three weeks ago, I had 5,000 subscribers.
And it was actually around then, around the time that I made that Witcher 3 spoof video.
And I was talking to my girlfriend, and I was saying, like,
I don't know, babe.
Like, this is, this YouTube thing, it's just such a time and money pit.
And I love my audience, but not enough people are really watching to make this viable.
You know, just not a good productive use of my limited time on this planet, right?
And she said, no, no, you gotta stick with it.
Your stuff's really good.
You know, it's only a matter of time before all that hard work pays off.
And now, thanks to my generous patrons.
Oh, there they are.
I actually am making enough money on YouTube now to pay my rent.
Which is nuts.
It's a huge deal for me.
And the possibility that sometime, hopefully soon, I'll be able to make this into a full-time job
is, I mean, that's not crazy now.
You know, it's kind of sort of a tangible thing that, like, may very well happen.
So, I mean, that's awesome.
And there's a lot of people who helped me, like, along the way.
And who encouraged me.
But, babe, you're definitely the sexiest.
And I can't thank you enough.
Yes, even sexier than Brandon.
I love you, sweetie.