Why did Christianity spread across the Roman Empire—and why was it once considered a threat?
In this fascinating historical discussion, we explore the complex relationship between the Roman Empire and the early Christian movement. Discover why the first Christians refused to worship the emperor, how Roman authorities viewed this new faith, and what made Christianity so appealing to ordinary people despite persecution.
Learn about the social and political forces that shaped one of history's most influential religions—from the reigns of Augustus and Tiberius to Emperor Constantine's conversion and Christianity's rise as the official religion of the Roman Empire. The discussion also examines the faith's message of equality, hope, compassion, and eternal life, and why it resonated with women, slaves, and marginalized communities throughout the empire.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This discussion explores the early relationship between Christianity and the Roman Empire, detailing how a fringe movement evolved from a perceived political threat into the official state religion. It examines the social appeals of the faith and the political motivations that led Roman emperors to eventually embrace it.
Jesus was born during the rule of Emperor Augustus.
Yep. Which is kind of neat that, you know,
really influential people in the realm of political events and religious events coexisted.
What are the odds?
I mean, yeah, there's certain moments in history where just a lot of
interesting, powerful people come together and make history.
And he was crucified under Emperor Tiberius' rule.
Yep.
Why were the ideas of Jesus seen as a threat by the Emperor?
The thing that causes conflicts between the Romans and Christians is a little bit strange.
It's all with this, where the Romans had a tradition of, on the Emperor's birthday,
sort of saying a prayer, basically wishing him good luck, okay?
But technically, it's in the form of sacrificing to that part of the Emperor
that might become divine after his death.
So to the Romans, this is the equivalent of a patriotism act,
saying, you know, the Pledge of Allegiance or something to the country.
But of course, to Christians, this is worshipping another god.
And I think there's almost a failure of communication here,
that the Romans just, at least initially, didn't quite understand
this is really problematic for these people,
because they're coming from a polytheistic perspective,
where, yeah, everybody has different gods, so what?
This isn't a religious problem, this is a political one,
that why won't you wish, you know, send good wishes to the Emperor?
If you're a loyal Roman, this is something you should want to do.
And many of the early Christians, I think, would have been fine with that,
but it took the form of what they were asked to do,
was to basically worship another god.
And that was the sticking point.
And this is where I think movies have kind of warped some of our images of Roman history.
That Hollywood loves to depict very early Christians,
and I'm talking like first 200 years here after the ministry of Christ,
as, you know, a group that all the Romans were obsessed with,
that they were constantly trying to persecute and all this.
And honestly, I think the Romans, at that point,
were more just sort of indifferent or didn't know what was going on.
And if you look at some of the primary sources at that time,
I mean, there's this very famous letter by a guy named Pliny,
who was a Roman governor of a province in the east.
And he has the habit of writing letters to the Roman emperor at the time,
who was Trajan, every time he had a problem with being governor.
And so this is great.
This is the two highest governmental officials in the Roman world
sort of hammering out policy between them, right?
The emperor and one of his governors.
And so this is about 100 years, 100 AD about.
And Pliny says, hey, emperor, I had this issue.
I had these people come before me called Christians.
I don't quite know what to do with them.
What should my policy be?
And here's what I know about them.
And what he knows is almost nothing.
I mean, it's this almost comic, like, garbling.
And, you know, they have this weird thing
where they get together on some day of the week
and they sort of swear oaths to one another not to do bad stuff,
which is, of course, his garbled understanding of the Ten Commandments, you know?
And then they have breakfast together and they eat food.
And this is communion, but he doesn't get that that's what's going on.
And so he's really ignorant.
But I think that the broader point is, okay,
this is one of the best-educated, best-traveled Romans
who has the most experience in the empire, has been all over the empire.
And what does he know about Christianity?
Basically nothing.
So if one of the best-educated, most widely-traveled guys
really doesn't know much about them,
that kind of suggests that not many people did at this point in time.
At this time, it was a fringe movement that really did—
Yeah, very fringe.
I mean, it was one of, you know, hundreds of little mystery religions
the Romans sort of thought of as.
And these are, you know, religions that have some sort of revealed knowledge
and that appealed, make more personal appeals to people.
Now, stepping back from this in a broad way,
I think you can say that Christianity really was different in some ways
and had some things that maybe the Romans
should rightfully have viewed as a threat.
I mean, you know, the Romans are people very focused on this world, right?
Citizenship, what you do.
Christianity, in essence, has a focus on the next world.
So this world isn't as important as what you're setting yourself up for.
And even worse, from a Roman perspective,
I'm kind of saying, okay, if I were a Roman,
Romans are all about making distinctions between people.
Citizen, non-citizen.
Man, woman, free, slave.
Christianity comes along and says, in God's eyes, you're all equal.
Now, that's a pretty problematic idea if you're deeply invested in Roman hierarchy.
And I think it is no surprise that among the earliest converts to Christianity
are women and slaves, and in particular, female slaves.
Now, who are they?
They're the people at the rock bottom of the Roman hierarchy of status.
Which the Romans are obsessed with status.
But here's a religion that says that doesn't matter.
And in that same letter to Pliny, Pliny says, okay,
in this group of Christians I've heard about,
their leaders are two female slaves they call deaconesses.
Now, this is really early.
This is before the church exists, right?
There's no church structure yet.
And who is leading the local congregation of Christians?
Two slave women.
So that's an interesting moment.
And that's not necessarily the image we get of early Christianity.
But you can see how for people in this social structure,
that would be very appealing to them.
And in some ways, yeah, it is sort of a threat to the Roman system
because they're challenging it.
Now, the irony is, of course, 300 years after the life of Christ,
the emperor converts to Christianity.
And another 100 years later under Theodosius,
it becomes the official religion of the Roman Empire.
So all of a sudden you have this flip-flop where now the state itself
is not just converted to Christianity, but actively promoting it
and now persecuting pagans.
And the reason the emperors do that is,
one of the biggest problems for emperors at that point in time is legitimacy.
That there's tons of civil wars where
you have lots of different people saying, I'm emperor.
So lots of generals declaring themselves emperor.
Now, under a polytheistic religion,
you're all just fighting, it doesn't matter.
But if you say, there is only one god,
then if that god picks someone to be his emperor,
they're the only legitimate emperor, right?
So there is a real advantage to emperors now becoming Christian.
Because if they can say, we're now a Christian empire
and there's only one god and I'm the guy that god picked to be emperor,
that means all these other people claiming to be emperors are illegitimate.
Do you think that, or is there other factors that explain why Christianity was able to spread?
Well, I mean, that's why it's appealing to the emperors.
And we're talking here, you know, I mean, the religious answer is
people see the light, right?
It's a faith-based thing.
I'm looking at this as a historian.
So putting aside, you know, religious feeling and saying,
if I'm doing an analysis of this as a social phenomenon,
what would be appealing to people?
And there is that very compelling reason for emperors to want to go to Christianity
because it helps them with their biggest problem, which is legitimacy.
Now, if you're an ordinary person, what is the appeal of Christianity?
Well, we already looked at a couple of them.
One of them is that, you know, it promises you a reward in the afterlife.
I mean, the Roman and Greek notions of the afterlife aren't that appealing.
Either you just sort of turn into dust, or at best, you turn into this kind of ghost thing
that floats around something that looks like a Greek gymnasium,
which is like a bunch of grassy fields.
It's not so hot.
So here you're offered the idea of like, oh, you go to paradise forever.
That sounds really good.
And secondly, for a lot of people in Roman society, that notion of
here's something that says I'm valuable as a human being.
It doesn't matter whether I'm free or slave.
It doesn't matter whether I'm Roman or non-Roman.
It doesn't matter if I'm a man or woman.
Here's something that says I have equal value.
That's enormously appealing.
And finally, early Christians, I mean, they honestly, a lot of them do good works.
They take care of the sick.
They feed the poor.
I mean, if you look at Jesus in the Sermon on the Mount, that's the stuff he really hammers.
If we look at, you know, the words of Jesus when he says,
what do you do to be a Christian?
A lot of it is take care of the unfortunate.
You know, take care of people who are sick, take care of people who are starving.
And a lot of the early Christians really take that seriously.
So they are helping people out.
So that's appealing.
They're the good kind of populist, and populist messages spread.