Ireland was once known as the 'Land of Saints and Scholars', regarded as one of the most Catholic countries in the world. But over the past number of decades, the Catholic faith has declined sharply across the Emerald Isle, fueled in part by the clerical scandals.
In 2023, EWTN's Colm Flynn travelled to Ireland and asked the question, "Is Ireland still Catholic?" He examined the various reasons for the decline of the faith in Ireland and the challenges that the church faces there today. Well three years later, viewers have been emailing and messaging, pointing to other signs of hope for the "quiet revival" of the faith in Ireland.
Colm Flynn returned to Ireland and travelled across the country, meeting young people, talking to bishops, and asking the question, "Are there signs of hope for Ireland's Catholics?"
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores a \"quiet revival\" of Catholicism among Gen Z in Ireland. While traditional practice has declined, a new generation is seeking spiritual depth, tradition, and purpose. The Church is transitioning from a position of institutional power and cultural obligation toward a \"church of conviction\" driven by personal choice, lay leadership, and a commitment to purification.
In 2023, I produced a report called
Is Ireland Still Catholic?
where we looked at the decline of the faith here in Ireland
and the challenges that face the church.
After that, I received many emails and messages from people
who said that I had possibly missed something,
a quiet revival of the faith among young people
in certain parts of the country.
So, three years later, I've come back to Ireland
to look again.
Coming up, we examine some of the challenges
made in our last documentary.
We're, in a sense, an old army.
And see how the church is responding.
You know, what will we free ourselves from
to free ourselves far?
We go to Cork in the south to meet young people
who are part of a quiet group
that have restarted weekly adoration.
I think people are looking and searching for connection.
They're looking to grow deeper with their faith.
Because you're called to more,
there's something in us that I don't think we see comfort.
And we hear about how ordinary lay Catholics
are stepping forward to take on more duties in the parish.
At the beginning, you're nervous.
You don't know how it'll be received.
So, it was really new for everybody.
We learn about the reality of just how few men
are entering seminary,
but see how strong the conviction is of those who are.
I knew the beauty of the faith
and I thought to myself,
wouldn't it be lovely to bring this back?
In 2023, I stopped people on the streets of Dublin,
the capital, and asked them,
do they practice their faith?
I would consider myself a Catholic,
but I don't practice it.
I feel like I find things more important in life.
Eve, do you grow up Catholic?
I did.
Do you practice religion today?
No.
Everyone said no,
which might have given an impression
of a total lack of faith among young people.
However, this time I've travelled
to the other side of Ireland
and to the city of Galway.
It's Wednesday night and outside,
the streets are full and the bars are busy.
But inside Galway Cathedral,
it's dark with flickering candles and incense burning,
as around 60 young people have gathered to sing,
to pray and sit in silence for Eucharistic adoration.
This is the act of praying in front of the Blessed Sacrament,
which Catholics believe is the body of Jesus Christ.
And after adoration is over,
the group gather in a room at the back of the cathedral
and in real Irish style,
the tea and biscuits are in full supply.
And it gives me an opportunity to talk to some of them.
When you listen to the news
or you read the paper,
you'd be led to believe that the church,
especially among young people,
is dead in Ireland.
What say you?
I don't think it's true.
From my own experience,
I think a lot of people are more open to faith
than they would have been before.
I think there's like a void in people's lives.
And I'll often tell people I go to mass
or I pray or I'm a Christian
and they're like kind of astounded,
but they're always interested.
And I think everybody kind of tries to hide
their interest in faith and in God and all that.
They just don't have the place to share it.
You know what I mean?
What's it like being a young Catholic in Ireland today?
It's wonderful.
You know, have a little look around tonight.
You know, there's no one over the age of 35 here
and people are joyful
and they are ready and willing to represent Christ.
You know, you go around the country,
you see the fire in like certain pockets
more so than others,
but that fire is there.
And it's being lit throughout the country.
And I think it's a great time to be a Catholic.
In 2023, I stated the fact that
according to the latest census figures,
over 78% of the population still identify as Catholic.
But according to a poll by the Irish bishops,
only around 30% are practicing their faith
and attending mass.
I spoke to Father Eoghan Gorman at the time about this.
So why do you think it is that 78% of the population here
claim to be Catholic,
but when it comes to practicing, they don't?
Why do they still identify as Catholic?
Yeah, I think the research in this indicates that
Irish people are now identifying with
or living Catholicism in a different way.
I suppose the older generation would have looked at
being a Catholic as a person who
they would have went to mass,
they would have went to confession quite regularly,
they would have been to the local parish in Avina.
So it tended to be very focused on
church rituals of prayer and of sacraments.
Baptism was the first thing that made me a Christian
when I was born.
But then I was brought up in the Catholic religion
and I went to school with nuns.
The new generation of Catholics
don't necessarily identify with those rituals as strongly.
But what they do identify with is living Catholicism
in terms of social justice or social inclusion
or just having a kind of a charity towards a neighbour.
So the markers almost have changed.
Yes, they have, yeah.
As to what it means to be Catholic
for some people in this country.
This generation tends to identify more with
what we might call a horizontal
kind of living of the faith.
It's been good to other people.
Older generation, it's more that vertical dimension,
you know, it was the worship, it was the adoration.
While this is still true,
there is anecdotal evidence from across Ireland
that seems to suggest Gen Z,
people in their teens and twenties,
are starting to return to Christianity
and to some degree, the Catholic Church.
For example, more Bibles were sold last year in Ireland
than in any year since 2013.
This year, almost 130 people are preparing
in the Archdiocese of Dublin
to be baptised at Easter.
In Galway, over 800 young people
attended church on Ash Wednesday,
something that was even discussed on Reddit.
And a new report published
by the Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference
showed an increase in young people
practising their faith in 2023 and 24.
The report very interestingly does point
to some type of uptick, as they call it.
To talk about this possible quiet revival,
I sit down with Franciscan friars,
Brother Ronan Sharpley and Brother Jacopo Poserley.
Brother Ronan is from County Leitrim
and started to take his faith seriously
in his teenage years.
I ended up having to move school
when I was about 16.
And when I went to the new school,
I just started, I took another look at my life.
I wasn't happy.
And when you say you weren't happy,
why were you not happy in life?
Well, I didn't, I was following others,
really, in school.
I was trying to fit in, I suppose,
looking for affirmation.
I didn't have an anchor.
But when faith came into it,
it gave me direction.
It gave me meaning and hope.
And it also helped me decide
what I was going to do with my life.
Ronan was studying engineering,
but felt a call to serve others
in a more profound way.
He traveled to El Salvador
to do missionary work with the church.
And that's when he decided to become a friar.
And I thought to myself,
I'm really excited about what I do,
working with the poor,
with the church,
as my response to my faith,
my Catholic faith.
And that's what I wanted to keep doing.
Father Giacobbo,
you are from beautiful Italy.
Yes.
What part of Italy?
I'm from Verona,
city of love.
And your first love was for medicine.
Yes, yes.
I started attending medicine
because I wanted to become a Christian doctor.
I was inspired by my grandfather
and other figures of doctors
that I met throughout my life.
Similar to Brother Lim,
Giacobbo was passionate about his profession
and he could have helped people every single day,
but too felt called to something deeper.
And it was during a pilgrimage
that he decided to enter religious life.
There is no better or less important thing.
What is best for you
is what God asks from you.
And that was the solution to my dilemma.
Okay.
And if God asks me to become a friar,
that's all right.
That's okay.
Yeah.
In the 50s and 60s,
over 90% of the population of Ireland
attended Mass weekly.
But over the decades,
as Ireland became more prosperous and modern,
there seemed to be a rejection of Old Ireland,
of which the Church was such an integral part.
But of course,
the stories of abuse and cover-up
by some members of the Church
were hard even for the most faithful Catholics
to understand.
A damning report on child abuse in the Dublin
Archdiocese,
hundreds of victims...
This is no longer about the Church mission.
In 2024,
Archbishop of Dublin Dermot Farrell
spoke to me about the need for accountability.
It is a wound in the Church.
And that wound will only be healed
when we have full transparency,
true accountability.
That's the challenge for the Church today
because until that happens...
Is the Church ready for that challenge?
Yes.
Yeah.
Yes, we are.
We have been always encouraging people
to come forward at every opportunity
that people who have been abused come forward
and we try and have accountability
and justice for them
because that's the only way
we'll make a safer environment for our children.
Did you not think,
I want to run a million miles from this,
this is going to be terrible
to be part of the Church at this time?
Yes and no.
A part of me was excited
to realise that something is coming to an end
and it will have to be purified
and I felt I knew the beauty of the faith.
I'd seen it in El Salvador
and I'd seen little pockets of it,
what it can be like in Ireland
and I thought to myself,
wouldn't it be lovely to bring this back?
There is an optimism in the Church
from those I meet
that there are signs it is starting to come back.
But to what extent?
Well down south in Cork,
over 4,000 people took part
in the annual Corpus Christi procession in 2025,
again with many young people.
And from interviewing Gen Z members of the Church,
while they are of course
troubled by the abuse crisis of the past,
for them it's a generation removed.
It's something their parents' generation
had to go through
and now some want to see a more courageous Church.
Growing up in a smaller county,
I'm from Monaghan
there's such a lack of community.
In my last documentary,
I met two young Catholics
walking by the canal in Dublin,
Eva and Maria.
If the faith, let's say for you,
has all these incredible things
that you're talking about
and young people are smart,
they're intelligent,
why do you think so few are practising their faith
or going to mass then in Ireland?
I think they're misinformed.
I think our shepherds,
our priests are not preaching the truth.
They think they're giving people what they want
by a watered-down mass
or a shorter homily
but young people are craving the truth.
A lot of what we're finding
is they're craving tradition,
they're craving what the Church is.
It's interesting what Eva says here.
She believes young people today
are not looking for, as she calls it,
a watered-down mass or shorter homily,
that they're looking for something more challenging.
That's something I hear multiple times
travelling across Ireland
and speaking to the young believers
who practise today.
It seems the ones who are coming to the faith now
are all in.
For example, in Cork City,
in the Church of Saints Peter and Paul,
they have restarted 24-7 Eucharistic adoration.
Sheila Kelleher is the coordinator
of the youth ministry
with the Diocese of Cork and Ross.
People are looking for substance
and I know for me,
I grew up in a rural parish
near West Cork.
It's not quite West Cork.
So I grew up,
and we would have gone to mass every Sunday.
I became an altar server for my local parish,
the first girl, actually,
in my parish to altar serve.
And I did that for a number of years
but I didn't really see
many other young people around me.
So I think being given these opportunities,
I suppose I came into my faith,
well, through altar serving,
which then led a priest in my parish
invited me to go to Lourdes
as a young adult helper.
And that really changed my life.
I met my husband in Lourdes
and my faith just went deeper.
I started working for the chaplaincy in UCC
and then that led to me
working with the diocese
as the youth ministry coordinator there
for the last year.
Sheila tells me that
the number of young people
coming to their youth projects
has tripled since 2023.
PJ Cronin is another young Catholic
who comes here for weekly adoration.
There seems to be more of an openness
than I've seen in recent years
and a lot of young men,
especially returning to the faith,
which has given me a lot of hope.
Why is it, do you think,
that in particular,
young men are coming back to the faith?
Good question.
I think, I suppose,
the way society has gone
there's been a kind of...
Men have kind of reverted into themselves
because masculinity has come under attack.
You know, there's this narrative
that anything you do at all that's masculine
is toxic masculinity
and men really have found
nowhere to go with that.
They look around and
obviously, I believe, as a Catholic,
the truest answer of masculinity
is Jesus Christ
and, you know, when that's presented to you,
I don't think that can help but to change you.
And I've seen so many people
brought into the faith
just because of that,
just looking for responsibility,
looking for meaning.
I think there's something about that model
that just it's so attractive
and, you know,
even all the saints throughout history
and, of course, our Lord Himself,
you know, the servant leadership model
of giving yourself for others.
I think there's something about that
that just calls to young men
when it is presented to them fully
because it's uncomfortable
but, you know,
there's something about that that attracts people.
So they're attracted to the idea
that the church is saying,
look, this isn't going to be easy
and this isn't going to be comfortable.
This will be a challenge.
Because you're called to more,
there's something in us
that I don't think we seek comfort.
Like Pope Benedict,
you know, he said,
we're made for greatness, not comfort.
And I think there's something about that,
you know, the paradox of the cross,
the most beautiful thing you could ever look at,
but also terrifying,
you know, something that is uncomfortable
but it will make you grow,
make you better than what you are,
then that calls to them.
Sunday morning mass in Cork.
The cathedral is busy
and those attending
are mainly the older generation.
However, you have some of the young people
who are coming back.
But what type of Catholic church
are they coming back to?
Well, in 2023,
I spoke to Bishop Alphonsus Cullinan
from Waterford in Lismore
about what kind of church it was in the past.
It was a very devotional church.
I wonder how deep it was theologically.
Being a very clerical world,
that holiness was associated
with clerics and religious.
Was it too powerful?
I think so.
Yeah, I think so.
I think it was,
there was too much of an emphasis on,
there was a bad clericalism.
Those days of the church
yielding great power in Irish society are gone.
But everyone I speak to in the church now
seems to agree
that having a more humble church,
purified as we heard earlier,
is better.
This is something I asked
Bishop Fintan Gavin about,
how he sees the new church in Ireland.
I see a very vibrant, renewed church,
a church much more of conviction
where people make a decision
about being part of church.
When you say a church of conviction,
what do you mean by that?
That, I suppose,
if you look at the church in the past,
that changed very quickly.
It was very much,
there was a culture there
that supported it.
People went,
the expectation was
people would be in church on a Sunday,
people were part of it.
I think today,
there's a very, very strong culture
that doesn't support faith.
So people have to make a decision
around faith themselves.
I think the church today
is a much humbler church,
and that we're leading from gospel values
that are based on justice,
peace, love, integrity.
A church that wants to rule not with power,
but lead with the gospel message.
And that not only applies
to the church in Ireland,
but goes all the way to the top.
In 2026, history was made
when Pope Leo met
with Irish abuse survivor
David Rhine from Tipperary.
They met privately
inside the Apostolic Palace
at the Vatican for almost an hour,
where the Pope heard his story
and said sorry.
I was there to meet David
when he walked out.
His sincerity,
his empathy,
he felt my pain,
but he hasn't experienced my pain.
But he knows what pain
I have gone through in my family.
And just a lovely, lovely man.
And what an experience to have.
Wow.
I'm so glad I've done it today.
I really am so glad I've done it.
A moment of healing
in what has been a painful story.
But as Bishop Fintan Gavin said,
the church in Ireland
will be a smaller, renewed church.
The problem is smaller
means fewer priests
and less resources.
And while many people
in Ireland today
don't practice their faith,
as you heard earlier,
they still identify as Catholic
and expect to have the church
there to use when they need it
at Christmas, for weddings,
baptisms and for funerals.
And that all takes
a huge amount of resources
and time, and it's
a time of encounter.
The difficulty sometimes
is that there isn't
a conviction outside of that,
that there isn't this kind of,
you know,
part of a religious community
that gathers every Sunday
for the Sunday Eucharist,
if you like,
that we're not making disciples.
So the real,
and yet these are,
these are really important moments.
It's important to use them
as moments for evangelization,
for connection.
But they do take time and resources.
Time and resources
that are now in short supply.
And it's a problem
right across Ireland.
In Galway, I sat down
with Bishop Michael Deignan,
who told me the church
needs to make some tough decisions.
We have to leave behind
certain things
that we can't bring with us.
You know, what will we
free ourselves from
to free ourselves for?
What are we going to prioritize
instead of continually
doing the same thing
over and over again, aimlessly?
We are still using old structures.
We have lots of buildings,
lots of infrastructure
that we no longer need
and are becoming a burden upon us.
You mean like lots of parishes?
Lots of parishes,
lots of buildings.
We tend to keep the same thing
going that we always did.
Our schedules for Masses,
our parish schedules.
I don't think that's going
to last much longer.
I think we're coming near
maybe the end of that
because it's become
to a critical phase
that we just can't keep
things going the way they were.
Where do you think the church
shouldn't be using now
its limited resources
and its personnel?
I think one of the problems
in our modern world
is we're time poor
and we're so busy
with so many things.
So we need time
to spend time with people.
So I think we're going
to have to make choices.
Now I'm excited about these choices
because I think they will
bear fruit into the future.
What would something like that be?
Maybe I prioritize
when I assign priests
that I don't assign priests
to a parish
to say a morning Mass
but I assign them
maybe to the university
to accompany young people.
So how do I free up a priest
from the ministry
of the weekend Mass,
weekend work
to go and to be with the young people
at those gatherings?
That's difficult for you
to have to make that decision
saying well we have one priest
he can't be in two places at once.
Maybe of a Sunday
this parish cannot have a Mass
but here in the university
with the young people
they can have a Mass.
It's difficult isn't it?
These are some of the difficult choices
and that's why certain discernment.
Now obviously
we wouldn't be talking
about leaving people
totally devoid of the sacraments or Mass.
We'd be doing our best
but we do have to make choices
and in those cases
I think the choice would be
to accompany the youth of the Church
and to accompany
the future generations of the Church.
The lack of priests
being at a critical point
is something that some dioceses
have been responding to
in creative and bold ways.
In County Mayo for example
in the diocese of Killala
they looked at some of the roles
currently fulfilled by priests
and thought
why don't we have lay members
of the community
helping with those?
Father Michael Gilroy
is the director of the Newman Institute
in Ballina
and in 2023
they held an assembly
with members of the diocese
to see if people
would be willing to step forward.
One of the strong desires
expressed in the assembly
and through the results
was that people
were more than willing
to participate
in the pastoral life
of the diocese
at parish level
and at diocesan level.
But the one thing
that people asked for
was formation and training.
From that
the Newman Institute
developed a two and a half year program
called
Certificate in Lay Leadership,
Theology, Culture and Ministry.
Twelve modules
over two and a half years.
To all of you our graduates
I salute each
and every one of you
here this evening.
64 people graduated
from the first certificate program
more than they had expected
and one of the main ministries
these lay leaders
are now involved in
is the funeral ministry.
For example
being at the wake
the night before a funeral
to pray with the family.
Sometimes with the local priest present
but other times
on their own.
We're planning for a situation
in 5, 10, 15 years time
where we won't have
a priestly presence
in every parish
so we will depend on
our lay leaders
to celebrate
the various rituals
that are part of our funeral rites.
Evelyn Deasy
One of those graduates
is Evelyn Deasy.
You're very much working
in collaboration with the priest
that's with you
so you're co-leading
the prayers
so you would be at the funeral home
the evening before
and in some cases
then the remains
are brought to the church
and prayers are said there
we would be part of that as well.
The next day
then we're at the funeral mass
we wear the alb
on the altar
with the priest
so we're very much part
of the ceremony
that's happening there.
What kind of reaction
did you get from the people
when they saw you coming in
and reading the prayers?
They are happy
people will come up to you afterwards
and thank you personally
they appreciate your presence.
Another one of the graduates
is Marie Gilvary
Marie Gilvary
who enrolled in the
two year certificate programme
after seeing it advertised online.
This got my attention
because I saw it
probably on social media
and maybe it's the Holy Spirit at work
I don't know
but I said yes.
Almost like the Holy Spirit calling you.
Maybe it's about
I know you talk about
people getting a call
and answering yes to it
and I suppose I actually
I actually think that
that's what happened to me
and that's why I said yes.
These lay members
were already involved
in church ministries before
like the choir ministry
and Eucharistic ministers
but felt they wanted to give back
to the church
and live out their
baptismal promises even more.
But still they all admit
at first they were apprehensive
like Anita Mulligan.
I didn't have the faith myself
I said I can't be there
I can't give the support to
families that you know
that they might need
in the time of grief you know
it is a very vulnerable time
and I just thought
I didn't have the capability but.
Was it a case as well that
you know you had always thought
well we're this side of things
in the church
and the priest
and the religious
and the ordained
well they're the ones
who take care of that
was that part of it as well?
Yeah that was kind of
a daunting part of it
because I would have
been on the gallery singing
looking down on the people you know
I would never have been to the front
you know facing them
and that was the kind of daunting thing
I said I won't be able to
you know do the reading
or you know the prayers
but no.
You were reluctant initially
are you glad now that you
you got involved?
It's great actually
I'm so glad I did do it
yeah so glad I did do it.
Why do you say that?
It's very rewarding actually
it's this spiritual feeling
that you get off it
it's just it's hard to actually
you know say what it is
you know but it's just it's
when you start them prayers
and you're there
just something comes over you
you know.
They're hoping that
this greater lay involvement
could be used as a model
for other diocese in Ireland.
Bishop Francis Duffy
is the Archbishop of Tuam
and the newly appointed Bishop of Calala
and he was the one
who approved this initiative.
Has there been any resistance to it?
Yes there would be some
small amount of resistance to it
I remember talking about this
these sort of initiatives
maybe 10 years ago
and people were a bit
so no we won't have that
they want to see the priest
yeah they want to see the priest
but things have changed a lot since then
and I think there's a greater openness to that
and a welcome for it as well.
But for them has it been a case of
maybe reality bites?
It is certainly reality biting
but I think there's also a welcome
for more people being
greater involved in their local church
so I think it's a good initiative.
As a young Catholic in Ireland today
Michael how do you feel about
the state of your faith
the Catholic Church in Ireland?
I am actually really hopeful
like and I'm not just saying that
like I am really hopeful
because I believe that there
we are few in number
like the Catholics
like you know solidly in the faith
particularly young Catholics
and I think like when you look
you know into stories from the Bible
like you see how God uses
just like a remnant
like a small number of people
to actually like spearhead
this renewal of faith
or to like convert a whole
like town or village you know
so he works from a few the whole time.
Three years ago I came here
and asked the question
is Ireland still Catholic?
And as you've just seen
the answer is complicated
it's probably both yes and no
no not in the way that it used to be
but yes in a new way
smaller stronger communities of faith.
Where do you see signs of hope today Bishop
when you look around?
I see lots of signs of hope
I mean the culture within which
all of us live
but particularly our young people
is more and more challenging
what's my life for
how can I make a difference
I think that's what young people
are searching for.
I think the church in Ireland
in the future will be small
but we will be communities of faith
because we choose to be
communities of faith
not because it's what
we're to do socially.
Faith is something that
that liberates you
faith is something that
crowns everything you have
it brings a more to life.
I am convinced that that message
is as valid today in Ireland
as it ever was.