The UK is Collapsing (And It Can't Stop It)

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financement
~ TIMESTAMPS ~
0:00 – Is the UK Falling Apart?
0:39 – UK vs Britain Explained!
03:27 – The £45B Money Trap
05:11 – Brexit Broke the Union
06:47 – The Irish Sea Border Crisis
09:05 – Why Wales is Walking Away
12:02 – A Shocking Political Shift!
13:45 – "Westminster is Finished"
15:20 – PM Denies the Vote!
17:45 – The Silent Breakup Begins
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe United Kingdom is facing significant instability as Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland increasingly seek independence. Driven by stagnant economic growth, the fallout from Brexit, and deteriorating public services, the traditional financial bonds that held the Union together are weakening, leading to a coordinated challenge against Westminster's authority.
The United Kingdom is beginning to fray at the seams.
Frustration with the government in Westminster is building day after day
and just recently four prominent political leaders met in a hotel in Wales and told
the British government to prepare for the UK to break apart in time.
Scotland's First Minister John Swinney, First Minister of Wales Rhiannap Jorwath,
First Minister of Northern Ireland Michelle O'Neill and Mary Lou Macdonald, the President
of Ireland's Sinn Féin party, all signed a historic Memorandum of Understanding that declared
Westminster's time is coming to an end. It appears that Scotland, Wales and Northern
Ireland are now uniting in their efforts to leave the Union.
Now, the UK isn't held together by brotherly love and sentiment.
It's endured because there's long been an economic bargain keeping the whole thing together.
Share a market, pool resources, redistribute money around the Kingdom
and make staying in the Union more attractive than leaving it.
The problem is that, well, that bargain isn't looking very attractive these days.
Growth is stagnant, public services are deteriorating
and nationalist politics are gaining ground by the day.
Many of the political compromises that were supposed to hold the UK together
are now starting to pull it further apart.
So, is Old Britannia destined to break up?
My name is Guy and this is the Finance Bureau.
First, let's begin by clarifying something that people often get confused about.
When we say the United Kingdom or UK, what we mean is the country that comprises
England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
Now, in the past, each of those was a separate, independent country,
with the exception of Northern Ireland, which was just one of the counties of Ireland,
called Ulster, in case you were wondering.
Now, Wales and England were united as one country in the 16th century,
not that many Welsh people were particularly happy about it, but hey.
Then, in 1707, the Act of Union joined England and Wales,
with Scotland, into a single state called Great Britain.
Now, whenever we say Britain, Great Britain, or indeed the British Isles,
what we actually mean is the landmass that's shared by England, Wales and Scotland.
Confused? I don't blame you.
But wait, there's more.
In 1800, Britain was joined with the Kingdom of Ireland,
again, not something a lot of Irish people were overjoyed about,
to form the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland.
And then, in 1922, the Irish Free State was created,
which made most of Ireland an independent country,
except for the northern part, which remained part of what was now called
the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland,
which, you'll be relieved to hear, is how it's remained ever since.
OK, history lesson over.
Now, the United Kingdom is, ultimately, an economic arrangement.
In 2024-2025, the block grants going out from the Treasury
ran to roughly £45bn for Scotland,
£20bn for Wales, and £18bn for Northern Ireland.
Those grants are set by the Barnett formula,
and the effect of it is that public spending per head is simply higher outside England.
Scotland spends around £22.2k per person against a UK average of £19.5k.
That's a premium of £2.7k ahead, or about 14%.
Wales is at £15.6k per person, around 12% above the UK average.
And Northern Ireland runs the largest gap of all,
with public sector spending making up more than half of regional output.
Scotland's notional deficit for 2025-2026
came in at around £25.3bn, or 10.9% of its GDP against a UK figure of 4.2%.
And, as you might recall, that's a bigger hole than the entire Welsh block grant.
And this dynamic has been going on for a very long time,
which gave Westminster a pretty simple answer to the independence question
any time it popped up. Leaving would make you poorer.
Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland receive more in public spending than they raise in tax,
and walking away means putting that support at risk.
Now, it was a powerful argument because independence could always be presented
as the bigger gamble, that countries would probably be much worse off on their own.
But then, the UK held a referendum of its own.
In June 2016, the UK held its Brexit vote on whether or not to leave the European Union.
And suddenly, two parts of the UK were being taken out of the EU, despite voting to stay in it.
The UK overall voted to leave by 51.9% to 48.1%.
However, Scotland voted to remain by 62% to 38%, and every single one of its 32 council areas
returned a remain majority. Northern Ireland voted remain by 55.8% to 44.2%.
But of course, both countries were taken out of the EU anyway, because they're part of the UK.
And I'm not looking to discuss here whether Brexit was a good idea or not,
because that is a Pandora's box that I'd rather not open today, thanks all the same.
But the point is what Brexit demonstrated about how the union works.
If the UK as a whole votes one way, then even the parts of it that didn't go with the majority
still have to fall into line. And after Brexit, every argument with Westminster
gave the independence movements outside of England more ammunition.
And nowhere did that become more obvious than in Northern Ireland.
There was no hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
People and goods could cross freely without checkpoints.
Now, I won't dive into Irish history here, but the long and the short of it is
that putting up another hard border just was not going to fly.
So, avoiding a hard border after Brexit meant putting checks on goods somewhere else,
and they ended up between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK across the Irish Sea.
Northern Ireland stayed inside the UK constitutionally,
while staying aligned with EU single market rules for goods.
And in case you're not familiar with how that plays out commercially, well, it's pretty simple.
Selling east into Great Britain now involves friction and paperwork.
Selling south into the Irish Republic does not.
And companies have responded to that in the way you might expect.
Trade into Northern Ireland from the Republic grew 5% year-on-year in 2025,
to 5.4 billion euros.
And North-South trade has been outgrowing the traditional East-West corridor with Great Britain
ever since the Windsor Framework settled the rules.
So, the economy of the island integrated,
while the constitutional link stayed formally untouched.
And that's important because Sinn Féin, a political party whose central goal
is to take Northern Ireland out of the UK and reunite it with the Republic,
now holds Northern Ireland's First Minister's office.
So, for the first time, that office is held by a party that wants a united Ireland,
rather than one committed to keeping Northern Ireland part of the UK.
And as businesses on both sides of the border become more closely connected,
Sinn Féin has a stronger economic argument to put alongside its political one.
The UK still holds together on the map,
but Northern Ireland's businesses have more and more reasons to look south rather than east.
And if you want to understand how political shifts like these affect the global economy,
then you've got a reason to subscribe to the Finance Bureau newsletter.
It's completely free and each week we break down the biggest stories
and what they mean for your portfolio.
So, just click the link in the description or scan this QR code on your screen to get started.
Okay, back to a rather delicate United Kingdom.
Because the Irish sea border was at least a decision that somebody made.
What happened in Wales, though, was just neglect.
Now, Wales was supposed to be the settled nation,
too small, too dependent, with no case to make for leaving the UK.
And it even voted in favour of Brexit in 2016, with 52.5% voting to leave the EU.
So it doesn't have Scotland or Northern Ireland's argument that Brexit was imposed against its will.
Although many argue that the figure was distorted by English people living in Wales
voting for Brexit rather than actual Welsh people.
But again, a Pandora's box.
Today, what Wales has instead is an economy that has fallen badly behind.
Economic output per person is only around three quarters of the UK average.
In some of the old industrial valleys, it's much lower still.
By 2024, Welsh GDP per person was still more than £1,100 below where it had been before the pandemic.
And the employment rate sits at 71.4% compared with 75.1% across the UK,
a gap that has widened over the last year.
Around 26% of the Welsh workforce is employed in the public sector against 18% UK-wide.
And 32% of Welsh children live in relative income poverty,
around 210,000 children, the highest rate of any of the four nations.
And then there's Port Talbot.
Its last blast furnace shut down in September 2024,
ending more than a century of traditional primary steelmaking at the site,
not to mention making 2,800 people redundant.
The replacement electric arc furnace cost £1.25 billion,
with £500 million of UK government money behind it.
And it won't be running until late 2027.
So that's three whole years between the old industry disappearing and the replacement arriving.
And that helps explain why the argument in Wales has started to shift.
For a century it was, we can't afford to leave.
Now it's, what exactly are we getting for staying?
Because there's no actual reason to stay dependent if the relationship stops delivering.
And in May this year, Wales answered that question.
In the first election to the expanded 96-seat Senate, Plaid Cymru took 43 seats,
Reform UK took 34 and Welsh Labour took just nine, ending close to a century of dominance.
And First Minister Eluned Morgan lost her own seat.
Rhun ap Iorwen became Wales' first pro-independence First Minister at the head of a minority government.
On the same day in Scotland, the Scottish National Party, or SNP,
won a fifth consecutive term with 58 of 129 seats.
And together with the Greens, the pro-independence benches came to 73
members of the Scottish Parliament, or MSPs,
the largest such majority in the history of the devolved Parliament.
Then the Scottish Parliament voted 72 to 55 to demand what's known as a Section 30 order,
essentially permission from Westminster to hold another independence referendum.
And in August, the Scottish Government published a draft independence referendum bill
with the question already written and the date left blank.
Meanwhile, in Belfast, Michelle O'Neill remained First Minister,
with Sinn Fein pushing for a referendum on whether Northern Ireland should leave the UK
and join a united Ireland by 2030.
All of which brings us back to that hotel in Wales.
The memorandum the four leaders signed that day contained this line,
We recognise that our parties have different constitutional positions
and that each nation will determine its own future in its own way and in its own time.
And then this one,
Westminster's time is coming to an end.
Scotland's John Swinney said UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham
would go down in history as the final Prime Minister of the United Kingdom.
Bold call.
So, three separate grievances, which London had typically managed one at a time,
came as a single joint demand.
Now, to be fair, there is a strong argument that all this is a lot less dramatic than it looks.
The pact isn't legally binding and support for independence in each of these countries
is still very much a mixed bag.
Scotland is close.
It actually held an independence referendum in 2014,
which saw just over 55% of voters in favour of remaining part of the UK.
Wales, meanwhile, is nowhere near a majority on independence.
Northern Ireland's reunification support is still well short of one too,
though shifting demographics may change that in the years ahead.
And in every case, actually holding a vote is much harder than simply demanding one.
But at the same time, the nationalists don't need to win a referendum yet.
The question is whether anybody in London can give them a reason not to try.
Andy Burnham became Prime Minister back in July.
He holds the title Minister for the Union.
And on his first official visit to Northern Ireland in August,
he said a reunification referendum was off the table.
He wrote to John Swinney to say a second Scottish referendum was off limits
before the next general election.
And when he appeared to soften that position in Parliament in early September,
his office walked it back within hours.
Now, Swinney's response was that refusing under these conditions is,
quote, legally unreasonable.
But Westminster's answer is still basically no.
However, that's harder to sell when the economic case for staying together is getting weaker.
Throughout its history, the Union could point to money, stability and support from the centre.
Now, money is tight, growth is weak and those arguments
just don't carry the same weight as they used to.
UK GDP grew 1.6% year on year in July.
Inflation was running at 3.1% in August.
Unemployment at 4.9%.
And sterling is down about 1.8% against the dollar over the past year.
Now, you can't buy much favour at 1.6% growth.
And borrowing more and more to fund something that doesn't work
is making less and less sense to many people.
The problem is that a lot of the Union's economic case
rests on Westminster continuing to send money out to the nations,
as I touched on at the start of this video.
But if the UK is struggling to grow and already borrowing heavily,
that becomes a much harder argument to sustain.
Which means this isn't just a political argument anymore.
It feeds directly into taxes, borrowing and the value of the pound.
And as it happens, there is in fact a useful precedent
for how this actually unfolds.
And it's on the island of Ireland.
In 1998, when the peace deal that largely ended decades of violence
in Northern Ireland was signed,
cross-border trade was worth somewhere around 2 billion euros a year.
It's now around 17 billion euros.
That's nearly an eightfold increase,
and it didn't require a vote or a constitutional moment.
That's a key detail because Northern Ireland
didn't become more connected to the Republic
through one dramatic political event.
It happened gradually as businesses traded more across the border,
supply chains became more integrated,
and the economic relationship deepened over time.
And that's the bigger risk for the UK as a whole.
Scotland and Wales don't need to vote to leave tomorrow
for the union to weaken still further.
More people feel that decisions made closer to home
work better than decisions made in London,
and that sets things in motion.
That's what makes the meeting in Wales between the leaders so important.
It was three nationalist movements openly coordinating against Westminster
while the UK government's answer was basically
that none of this was even up for discussion.
But just saying no to independence doesn't give people a reason to stay.
The UK may hold together for some time to come,
but if the economic case for the union keeps getting weaker
while nationalist parties keep building their own political and economic ties,
then the breakup may begin long before any referendum.
But look, that is just one Englishman's opinion.
What do you think?
Is the end of the United Kingdom nigh,
or are the four nations better together?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments down below.
And as bad as things might be in the UK right now,
the US isn't exactly in great shape either,
and you can check out our video on that right over here.
Okay, as always, thank you very much for watching,
and I will see you in the next one.
This is Guy, signing off.
