Russia says its economy has remained remarkably resilient despite sanctions, war spending and the loss of many of its traditional Western trading relationships. But what if the official statistics aren’t telling us the full story?
In this video, I look at fascinating new research that uses NASA satellite imagery and nighttime light emissions to measure what is really happening across more than 1,000 Russian cities.
Unlike official economic statistics, satellite images can’t easily be manipulated. They provide physical evidence of how much light — and therefore potentially how much economic activity — is being generated across different parts of Russia.
And the results are striking.
The research finds a significant deterioration in nighttime light growth following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, with some of the biggest declines concentrated in western Russia and cities closest to countries such as Finland, Estonia, Poland and Belarus.
Meanwhile, areas closer to China and Georgia appear to have performed much better, potentially revealing how Russia’s economic centre of gravity has shifted as trade has been redirected away from Europe and towards alternative markets.
We’ll go through the key graphs and maps carefully, explain exactly what the data is showing, and look at why Russia’s official GDP figures may be painting a very different picture from the one visible from space.
Has Russia really shrugged off Western sanctions — or is the country becoming economically darker than the official numbers suggest?
Watch to the end for my thoughts on what this could mean for Russia’s economy, the sustainability of its wartime spending, and the longer-term consequences of the war.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi, welcome back to the channel. In today's episode I want to show you something really
interesting about the Russian economy because for the last few years we've had an enormous debate
about what's actually happening inside Russia. The official statistics tell us that Russia has
been remarkably resilient. They tell us that despite sanctions, despite losing access to many
western markets, despite hundreds of thousands of workers being pulled into the military or
leaving the country, and despite the enormous cost of fighting the war in Ukraine, Russia has
continued to grow. But there is an obvious problem. Those numbers are produced by the Kremlin,
and Russia has stopped publishing some of the statistics that it used to publish. So how can
we actually work out what's really going on? Well some economists have come up with a fascinating
solution. Don't look at Russia's spreadsheets, look at Russia from space. Because NASA satellites
have been photographing the amount of light being generated by Russian cities at night.
And when researchers analyzed what's happened to those lights before and after the invasion of
Ukraine, they discovered something rather different from the official Russian story. In fact, Russia
appears to have become measurably darker. And that could be giving us one of the clearest indications
yet of the real economic cost of the war. So in this video I'm going to show you the satellite
data. We're going to go through the graphs carefully, because some of these are quite
complicated. And we'll look at what this tells us about which parts of Russia are winning,
which parts are losing, and why the economic heartland of Russia appears to have been hit
particularly hard. But before we get into all of that, if you're enjoying these videos,
could you please give me a thumbs up? Please subscribe to the channel if you haven't done so
already. And if you have the option, if you see that funny little hype symbol, which is just
alongside from the thumbs up symbol, if you could hit that, then that would really help me with the
algorithm. It'll promote this video to more people and put a smile on my face. Okay, so let's start
with the official story. According to Russia's published statistics, the economy contracted by
only 1% in 2022, which is when the invasion of Ukraine started in February. Then it apparently
bounced back very strongly. Official figures showed that growth hit 4% in both 23 and 24,
followed by modest growth in 2025 around 1%. If you look at those numbers in isolation,
you could quite reasonably conclude that Western sanctions have failed. Russia has adapted,
trade has been redirected, government spending has increased, military production has surged,
and the Russian economy has simply shrugged off the war. But the researchers behind this new study
argue that there is a fundamental problem with taking that data at face value. Russia
has restricted the publication of economic information since the invasion. Some regional
data is now missing, some series are fragmented, and perhaps more importantly, the Russian government
has an obvious incentive to present the economy in the best possible light. A strong economy
supports the domestic narrative that Russia can continue fighting indefinitely, and it sends
exactly the same message to Ukraine and the West. So the researchers asked a very simple question.
Is there something Russia can't manipulate? And the answer is the night sky. Satellite imagery
has been used by economists for years. The basic concept is surprisingly simple. Economic activity
produces light. Factories operate, warehouses have their lights on, shopping centres give off
light when they're open, roads are busy so the lights from cars show up, offices are illuminated,
homes use electricity, and cities expand. And when economic activity increases,
the amount and intensity of artificial light at night often increases with it. It isn't a perfect
measurement of GDP, but particularly in countries where official economic statistics are unreliable
or unavailable, night-time luminosity has become a useful independent indicator of what's actually
happening on the ground. And crucially, the Russian government doesn't collect this data.
NASA does. The researchers used NASA's Black Marble Satellite project and looked at night-time
lighting across more than a thousand Russian cities. The data stretches back to 2012 and
finishes around January 2025. That's the most recent in this study. They exclude the summer
periods where necessary because parts of northern Russia don't actually become properly dark during
the summer. They have almost 24 hours of light which would obviously interfere with those
measurements. What they're interested in isn't simply whether Moscow has more lighting than a
small Siberian town. Obviously it does. They're looking at the changes. How was night-time light
growing before the invasion and what happened to that growth since? This is where the first really
interesting result appears. I'm going to put this chart on the screen now and it looks a bit
intimidating at first glance. So let me explain exactly what we're looking at. There are three
versions of essentially the same measurement. The horizontal axis along the bottom is time,
so we're moving through the years before the invasion on the left and after the invasion
on the right. The dots represent observations of changes in night-time lighting across Russian
cities. The red data is the period before the full-scale invasion. The blue data is the period
afterwards and the black line running through the data is the important bit. That is effectively
showing us the overall trend. Now look at what happens after the invasion. The direction changes.
The growth in night-time lighting weakens. There appears to be a small improvement at one point
in early 2024 but the researchers say that this recovery was temporary. The downward movement
resumes and when they actually calculate the effect statistically they estimate that at the
city level the invasion was associated with roughly a four percentage point reduction in
the growth of average night-time lighting. Now that doesn't necessarily mean Russian GDP fell by four
percent. These are not interchangeable figures. What it means is that this independent physical
proxy for economic activity experienced a significant deterioration after the invasion
and that deterioration persisted. So you've now got two very different stories. Official Russian
statistics say the economy rebounded strongly. The satellite evidence says something significant
changed for the worse. But I think the next graphic is actually even more interesting because
Russia is enormous and the economic impact of the war hasn't been evenly distributed. So let's put
this map on screen. Again it looks complicated initially but the color scheme makes it much
easier to understand. Red represents areas where night-time light growth deteriorated following the
invasion. Green represents areas that performed relatively better and the researchers show this
in three different ways. The first map looks at individual cities. The second groups those cities
into Russia's federal subjects which are basically the regions that make up the Russian federation
and the third groups them even further into Russia's larger federal districts. Now look at
the geographical pattern. Western Russia is overwhelmingly where we see the damage. You can
see red stretching across important areas in the west and northwest. But as you move south and east
you increasingly start seeing it green and that tells us something very important about how
Russia's economy has been restructured by the war. Before 2022 Western Russia had a huge geographical
advantage. It was close to Europe. It traded with Europe. Businesses were integrated into
European supply chains. Foreign companies operated in Russia. European goods moved backwards and
forwards across those borders. Then the invasion of Ukraine happened. Sanctions arrived. Companies
withdrew. Trade groups were disrupted and Russia suddenly started trying to pivot its economy
away from the west towards China and Central Asia and the Caucasus towards countries that
hadn't imposed the same sanctions. And incredibly you can effectively see that change from space.
The researchers looked specifically at Russian cities according to which international border
they were closest to and the results are fascinating. Cities close to Belarus, Ukraine,
Poland, Estonia and particularly Finland experienced statistically significant declines
in nighttime lighting growth. By contrast areas closer to China and particularly Georgia
showed significant positive effects. If you think about what that represents
Russia's economic center of gravity appears to have physically shifted. Trade that once flowed west
has increasingly been pushed south and east and that's not necessarily a sign that the sanctions
haven't worked. In some respects it would be evidence that they have. Russia has been forced
to reorganize parts of its economy because access to its traditional markets has been damaged.
There is another fascinating detail in this data. The biggest Russian cities were hit relatively
hard and so were the smallest. The researchers divided cities into four groups according to
population. The smallest quarter saw nighttime light growth fall by roughly eight percentage
points. The largest group saw a decline of around four percentage points. The middle groups did
considerably better and there are some plausible reasons for that. Very small cities often depend
heavily on one or two major employers. If those employers are affected by sanctions, labor
shortages or disrupted supply chains there may have been very little else to compensate. The biggest
cities have the opposite problem. They're highly integrated into the international economy. They
have more foreign businesses, more services, more exposure to global capital and international trade.
So sanctions and the withdrawal of western businesses can hit them disproportionately
hard as well. And that brings us to one of the most extraordinary parts of this story.
Some of the poorer regions that have supplied large numbers of soldiers to the war don't
necessarily show the same deterioration. And why is that? Well one possible explanation is money.
Russia has been paying very large recruitment bonuses. Soldiers receive wages. Families can
receive compensation following injuries or deaths of their family members. And in relatively poor
regions those payments can represent a huge injection of money into the local economy. So
economically something quite perverse can happen. A working age man leaves his community and goes
to fight. The local economy loses his labor but his household suddenly receives a very large
amount of government money. If he's killed there may be additional compensation. In the short term
those payments can actually support local spending and therefore the lights may not go out. But there
is a huge long-term problem here. When the war eventually ends the military payments will stop.
The government spending associated with the war will also fall. But someone who's been killed
doesn't return to the workforce. So some of the regions currently appearing relatively resilient
may be benefiting from something that simply isn't sustainable. And there's another obvious
question about all of this. Could the reduction in light simply be Russia deliberately turning the
lights off because of Ukrainian drone attacks? Well the researchers did consider that and they
argue that it's unlikely to explain the overall pattern in the data. Modern long-range drones and
missiles generally don't need visible city lights to find their targets. They can use GPS, inertial
navigation, terrain matching, thermal imaging and other systems. And importantly the researchers
satellite data set finished in January 25. The much wider expansion of Ukrainian long-range deep
into Russian territory came after that. So the drone attacks really picked up over the last 12
months. So while all the inevitably re-local effects, deliberate wartime blackouts don't
appear to provide convincing explanation for the national pattern. And then we come to perhaps the
most revealing comparison of all. The researchers looked at Russian official economic indicators.
Things such as building permits, fixed investment, profitable companies, employment and financial
results. And if you use some of that official Russian data you actually get a remarkably
positive picture. Construction appears strong, so does investment. Some of the figures could
almost lead you to conclude that the invasion actually improved the Russian economy. But the
satellite data is telling a very different story. And that doesn't necessarily mean every Russian
statistic is fabricated. That's not what they're trying to prove here. Government spending has
actually increased, military factories are producing enormous quantities of equipment
and Russia has redirected a lot of its trade. There's undoubtedly parts of the Russian economy
that have benefited from the switch to the wartime economy. But GDP doesn't tell you whether an
economy is becoming healthier. If the government is spending billions producing missiles that are
subsequently fired into another country and destroyed, that spending can still contribute
to an increase in GDP. If you pay enormous bonuses to recruit soldiers, that money will
flow through into the economy. If factories work around the clock, producing ammunition,
industrial production will rise. But none of that necessarily makes Russian households richer
or makes Russia more productive in the long term. This is why I think the satellite study is so
interesting, because it strips away some of the accounting and looks at physical activity. And
what it shows is not an economy that has collapsed. Russia has clearly adapted to the enormous
pressure it's under, but neither does it show an economy that has simply shrugged off everything
that's happened since 2022. Instead, we're seeing a persistent slowdown. We're seeing major
regional disruption. We see Western Russia, the most populous and economically important part of
the country, suffering disproportionately. And we see activity shifting south and east as Russia
becomes increasingly dependent on entirely different trading partnerships. In other words,
Russia hasn't escaped the economic consequences of the war. It's rearranged its economy around
them. There's a very big difference between those two things because rearranging supply chains
is expensive. Replacing Western technology is also very costly. Moving trade through third-party
countries is going to be difficult and also cost a fortune. Funding huge military salaries and
recruitment bonuses is going to take up a large part of the government's spending. Supporting
sanctioned businesses is also very costly. And maintaining an enormous military industrial
economy is costing Russia an absolute fortune. The lights visible from space don't tell us
everything about Russia, but they do provide something extremely valuable, an independent
reality check. And when the view from space and the official statistics are telling you two
different stories, I think it's worth paying very close attention to the physical evidence of the
from space. So hopefully you've found today's video useful, informative, and most importantly,
thought-provoking. If you have liked what I've said then please give me that thumbs up. Please
subscribe to the channel if you haven't done so already. If you have the option, please hit that
hype button because it will promote this video to more people. So I'd really appreciate it if you
could do that. Thank you for watching this video all the way through to the end and thank you so
much to everyone that's supporting me. If you've bought me a coffee or sent me YouTube super thanks,
thank you for that generosity. I really do appreciate it. And if you've signed up as
a patron or a member, that long-term support really does help to keep me motivated and
making as many videos as possible. So I really appreciate your support. Thank you so much
and I'll see you again on the next video.