In some ways, the FOX X-Men movies were ahead of their time. A team up superhero movie in a time where superhero movies weren’t all that common laid the groundwork for this franchise, but also opened the doors for other Superhero franchises as well. And while the Fox X-Men movies had their fair share of successes like X2 and Days of Future Past, there’s no denying that at some point, the MCU came along and surpassed what Fox had achieved. Now at what point they surpassed the FOX movies can be debated, but today we’re talking about the end of the Fox X-Men movies, and that’s of course Dark Phoenix.
Become a member of the Channel! / @thethriftytypewriter
Join My Discord! / discord
DISCLAIMER: There was NO AI used in the creation of this video. All Music is from Artlist.io The recording is my actual voice, not an AI. I wrote the script of each and every video on this channel I made the thumbnail and applied a filter over the characters to give them a unique look. Editing was done by myself on Premiere Pro If you don't believe me, feel free to check out my older videos from before AI even existed and see for yourself. #movie#review
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video analyzes the production failures and critical reception of *Dark Phoenix*, the final film in Fox's X-Men series. It examines how script overhauls, the Disney-Fox merger, and rushed reshoots led to a disjointed narrative, while acknowledging specific strengths in the soundtrack and character portrayals.
In some ways, the Fox X-Men movies were ahead of their time. A team-up superhero movie in a time
where superhero movies weren't all that common laid the groundwork for this franchise, but also
opened the doors for other superhero franchises as well. And while the Fox X-Men movies had their
fair share of successes like X2 and Days of Future Past, there's no denying that at some point the
MCU came along and surpassed what Fox had achieved. Now at what point they surpassed the Fox
movies can be debated, but today we're talking about the end of the Fox X-Men movies, and that's
of course Dark Phoenix. Now we're all aware of the reception towards this movie, but I do think that
there's a fascinating history behind it. Why it turned out the way it did, what the original
script was going to be like, and really how this movie was dead before it even released. So that's
really what I'm going to talk about in this video along with some things about the movie that
I actually kind of liked. Because this movie does a few things right, but that also might just be the
X-Men fan in me. So if you enjoyed the video make sure to like and subscribe for more stuff like
this, check out my other X-Men videos, and of course let me know which X-Men movie you want
me to cover next. So let's get into the bitter end of Fox's X-Men with Dark Phoenix.
When this movie was first announced, I was excited for it. Sure, Apocalypse was a bit of a letdown
after Days of Future Past, but I was intrigued to see them pick it back up and really start
focusing on this X-Men team moving forward. But then things changed pretty drastically. Dark Phoenix
was intended to be the start of a new trilogy focusing on the next generation of X-Men. Charles
and Eric would now take a back seat after their trilogy was completed. In fact, Magneto and Mystique
were originally not supposed to appear in the film at all until heavy script rewrites were done
by writer-director Simon Kinberg. The original Dark Phoenix movie wasn't actually just one movie,
it was two movies. Not a lot is known about what Dark Phoenix Part 2 would have been like,
but during the rewriting process, the characters of Mystique and Magneto were written in,
which itself was a huge gamble considering the contracts for Michael Fassbender, Jennifer
Lawrence, Nicholas Holt, and James McAvoy were all up after Apocalypse, but they wrote the script
with these actors in mind, and luckily, they all returned for one final film. It was also during
this rewriting process that the script changed from being focused on the next generation of X-Men,
which would have included a younger Rogue appearing, Olivia Munn reprising her role as
Psylocke, as well as much heavier involvement from characters like Storm, Quicksilver, and
Nightcrawler, to instead being focused on closing the character arcs from the characters set up in
first class. Due to the lackluster box office performance of X-Men Apocalypse, this film
wasn't given as high of a budget, leaving things like characters being cut, a whole second part
being scrapped, but things like this happen, you know, they finalize the script, they shot the
movie, so it should be smooth sailing from this point on, right? While filming was completed in
October of 2017, it was announced in December of 2017 that Disney would be buying Fox, putting the
film in jeopardy, even though it had already been shot. But director Simon Kinberg continued on,
put together a cut of the film for test audiences, and those test audiences hated the movie so much
that the entirety of the third act had to be reshot. In the original version, an alien armada
would have attacked New York City, forcing the X-Men to work together to protect the city from
an army of Skrulls invading, with many Skrulls already having infiltrated the UN when Professor
X and Scott went there to warn them of the invasion. The X-Men themselves would have different
ideas on how to handle Gene and the Skrull invasion, leaving the movie off with the X-Men
divided, and Gene having sacrificed herself, similar to the theatrical version. Yes, you heard
me correctly, the original threat of Dark Phoenix, the aliens involved in this movie, were the
Skrulls. But because Captain Marvel had already used the Skrulls in a film that would release
before Dark Phoenix, the entirety of the film's plot had to be rewritten and re-edited to feature
the DiBari instead. But the Skrulls in Captain Marvel weren't the only thing that forced Dark
Phoenix to change. Originally, Gene's powers would have looked similar to how they looked
in X-Men Apocalypse, with a more fiery glow, but this too looked very similar to Captain Marvel's
powers. So, in post-production, the Phoenix force was changed to something more cosmic,
which honestly, I actually think looks a bit cooler anyways. But since this ending was so
poorly received, the entirety of the third act was re-shot, and this train sequence took its place.
The budget for the reshoots was considerably smaller, and since these reshoots took place
in late 2018, the Fox and Disney merger was going through, so really all the actors returned,
everybody that was working on this movie returned, without even knowing where this movie would
end up, if it was actually going to be made, or if it was just going to be shelved entirely.
They were making a movie for a studio that no longer existed, with a budget and priorities
that were clearly elsewhere, and you can really see that reflected in the performances and the
writing of the third act. But alright, you know, re-writes took place, reshoots took place,
but now we're good to go, we're good to release the film now, finally, right?
Well, the film was now firmly under Disney control, and by the time all the layoffs got
sorted out and actual marketing got involved, there was two months before the release of the
movie, and typically marketing for a big budget superhero movie starts around 10 months before
the film releases. Disney also slated the movie to arrive in theaters in June of 2019, about a
month after Avengers Endgame released. So we got the conclusion to both Fox's X-Men and the Infinity
Saga of the MCU in the same year, about a month apart. One of them went on to become the second
highest grossing movie of all time, and another one had such a drastic second week drop off that
it was out of most theaters in America by its third weekend. So in short, everything that
possibly could have gone wrong with this movie went wrong. A lower budget, script re-writes,
massive reshoots, a studio buyout, and this affected everything from the makeup of Mystique
to Ty Sheridan just using a muscle suit instead of working out, to the absolutely god-awful X-Men
uniforms. Now, there's a lot to be said about this movie and the things it did wrong. I could talk
about the lifeless performances, the rehashed storylines, the ex-women, but after learning
about how much of a shitshow this production really was, I'm just gonna highlight a few of
the things in this movie that I actually liked, or I guess wanted to like. Starting off, we got
this poster, which is bar none one of the coolest teaser posters for a movie I've ever seen. This is
still, regardless of the movie itself, a really cool poster. But every time I watch this movie,
I feel like I start to see more and more what they were going for, what they were trying to achieve,
and honestly, I do see the vision. And I do feel like in some other universe out there,
if this movie was given bigger priority, if some of the things that happened during production
didn't happen, this could have been a really good X-Men movie. After the world-ending stakes
of Apocalypse, Dark Phoenix wanted to reel it back in and tell a more grounded and personal story.
They wanted to center the stakes around the characters and their dynamics with one another,
but this being an adaptation of the Phoenix storyline and being centered on Gene,
doesn't work all that well when this is only the second time we've seen this version of the
character. In my Apocalypse video, I said that that film tried to do way too many things at once.
Dark Phoenix doesn't have that same problem, but we also don't care enough about the relationship
between Gene and Scott for this to take center stage. The Phoenix storyline, while it's lower
stakes for the world, it's basically the highest amount of stakes you could possibly have for the
X-Men team themselves and their relationships with one another. We've never seen Scott and
Quicksilver have a conversation. We don't know if Storm and Gene are even friends.
The Scott and Gene relationship only works as well as it does because we know that these two
are supposed to be a couple, and even then, it's not very strong. Fox's rush to get to the Phoenix
storyline has been a detriment to its franchise two times, and I just hope that the MCU learns
from this moving forward. Now, I know I talked about the budget for this movie being cut short,
but to be quite honest, I think that the CGI in this movie looks better than it did in X-Men
Apocalypse. In fact, I think a lot of this movie was saved, as much as it was, in post-production.
This movie is darker, just overall lighting-wise, and CGI looks better in the dark, so that could
certainly be a part of it, but if I had to highlight one aspect about this movie's post-production
above everything else, it would be Hans Zimmer's absolutely incredible soundtrack. And I'm not
saying that in a sarcastic way by any means, I do think that this is probably Hans Zimmer's
underrated work. The soundtrack alone makes this movie rewatchable, and this is not the first time
he's done this. Hans Zimmer can turn a 5 out of 10 movie into a 7 out of 10 just from his soundtrack
alone. There's not only one soundtrack, but two of them, and this album, from what I can tell,
was probably the original soundtrack of the movie, but they made him change this along with all the
other rewrites and reshoots. And speaking of experimental, this movie very much feels like
an experiment. The tone is drastically different from the previous X-Men movies, it's far darker
and more emotional, whether that emotion resonates with you or not is where I feel a large part of
this movie failed, but this feels purposeful and stylistic, it doesn't feel like Man of Steel or
the Amazing Spider-Man which are trying to be darker movies because of the Dark Knight. Do I
think this is what people really wanted out of an X-Men movie? No, I don't, but like I said earlier,
I see the vision and I actually kind of like that vision too. The first 20 minutes of this movie
always catches me off guard because the first 20 minutes are really good. Seeing the world
cheer for the X-Men when they go on a mission shows just how far mutants in this world have
really come from the earlier installments. Having an actual established team, regardless of the
roster, regardless of the costumes, is really great. A mission in space is incredibly cool
and it's uncharted territory for the movies. There's a lot to like in the first act of this
movie, even just seeing the school as a school and all the moments that come with that is a
great sequence, but slowly these moments start to fade as the movie goes on. The X-Women line
serves more as a way to divide people and stir up unwarranted controversy than it does to serve
the story. Raven's death being a catalyst for the X-Men to split and reintroduce Magneto in the
story actually works for the character arcs of everybody involved, but also just kind of feels
like Jennifer Lawrence was done playing the character if her light blue makeup wasn't an
indication already. This does bring some genuine emotional scenes that I personally bought into,
particularly the ones between Charles and Hank. You can see where Hank and to a lesser extent
Magneto are coming from and this definitely increases the personal stakes of the movie.
Sophie Turner also turns in a pretty great performance as Jean and more specifically
the Phoenix in this film. I think she's appropriately menacing and sympathetic at the
same time, especially when she returns to see her father who she thought had been dead,
but in reality he just didn't want her anymore. That's an incredibly haunting and emotional
revelation for Jean and I think it definitely furthers her descent into the Phoenix in an
appropriate way. A lot of the emotional beats of this movie are well written and placed,
I just don't think the actual character connection is there for a lot of people,
particularly when it comes to Jean. Another big complaint about this movie comes from the
characterization of Charles, but I honestly think that this movie has one of Charles' best character
arcs that we've seen from a Fox X-Men movie. This movie presents Charles as a flawed man who has
become more obsessed with keeping the peace rather than doing what's best for his students
and those he cares about. He learns over the course of the movie that this was wrong,
that his actions have caused massive consequences for those he cares about,
and if the alternative is just having James McAvoy sit there and be like,
hey, good job everyone, I'm proud of you, but you still have a lot to learn,
like a lot of his comic book counterparts, then I'll take this version of Charles over that
any day of the week. Surprisingly, I have the opposite opinion of Eric in this movie. This
does feel like a script that Magneto just didn't have to be in. Having him be a peaceful man who
gets filled with hatred over the death of a loved one so he returns to be evil only to join the side
of the X-Men at the end of the day is not only a character arc we've seen from him before,
but it's the exact same character arc he had in the last movie. The Skrulls, I mean the Dabari,
have a really great horror-filled introduction, but after that, all of these actors give some of
the most lifeless performances I've ever seen. Now, that was probably a deliberate choice by
the director or the actors, but it doesn't make for a very exciting performance or villain.
Jessica Chastain is an amazing actress, but she's not great in this movie,
and apparently she hates superhero movies and took a big risk accepting this one,
so that's unfortunate. The entire third act with the train delivers some cool moments,
but I feel like you can literally see that everyone is just mentally checked out for the
remainder of the movie, which was all during reshoots anyway during a time that they weren't
sure if this movie was even going to be released. Everything happens incredibly fast, Charles'
character arc, Hank forgiving him over Raven's death, Magneto switching to working with the X-Men
again, Jean's sacrifice, all of this only ever feels half-earned, and that's coming from a
massive X-Men fan who gives a lot of passes to the Fox movies. I do ultimately wish we could have
seen the original third act and the fight in New York City. I know test audiences didn't like it,
but test audiences have been wrong on numerous occasions in the past. The fact that this is
kind of where the Fox universe ends is pretty depressing. I guess technically the ending is
the future that we see in Days of Future Past, or I guess the future in Logan depending on which
timeline theory you believe, so the movies after this would have brought Jean back and brought
everybody up to speed. The ending of this movie also kind of harkens back to that a bit, but this
is such an incredibly low note for this franchise to end on. Yes, the film is stylistically bleak and
darker, but it doesn't even wrap everything up into a nice bow, even with all those extra reshoots.
The fact that this is the last we see of Charles and Eric from McAvoy and Fassbender will forever
leave a sour taste in my mouth. I suppose the MCU gave the Fox X-Men a more proper conclusion
with Deadpool and Wolverine with the end credits, but they were kind of the ones who made the
headstone for the Fox X-Men in the first place. It's like the killer giving the eulogy at the
funeral. Now, was there a lot of places to go from here? Not really, but also absolutely. Jean survives,
but we never got to see that happen. Seeing as how the MCU is going younger with the X-Men anyways,
part of me wonders what could have been if they had just continued on with this cast.
The Marvel was on top of the world at the time they got Fox, the MCU reigned supreme, and now
their X-Men castings and bringing back of the Fox X-Men feels like an attempt to win fans back over.
Dark Phoenix was an absolute mess of a movie. Maybe it always would have been, even if they got
the massive budget for a two-parter film, setting this up as the first installment of a new trilogy,
giving the other X-Men bigger roles, and while I probably like this movie more than
90% of you watching, I still think it's a bleak end for a franchise that had its ups and downs
but also did far more for the superhero genre than people give it credit for. I'd give Dark Phoenix a
6.4 out of 10. I can only hope the next time I talk about the Phoenix Saga, it won't be for such
dark reasons. Oh wait a minute, I still haven't talked about The Last Stand.
What are your thoughts on Dark Phoenix and the Fox X-Men movies as a whole? If you enjoyed the
video, make sure to leave a like and subscribe for more videos like this. Special thanks to all my
channel members and Patreon supporters, you guys are the best, and I'll see you all in the next one.