Was the Trojan War real? Did the Greeks dig ditches? Why did the Greeks fight the Persians?
Ancient Greek historian Roel Konijnendijk Answers Google’s Most Popular Questions About Ancient Greek Warfare.
00:00 Intro 00:46 Who did the Greeks fight? 01:47 How did the Greeks fight? 02:59 What weapons did the Greeks fight with? 04:25 Did the Greeks fight on chariots? 05:08 Did the Greeks have cavalries? 06:51 Did the Greeks have navies? 08:24 Did the Greeks do sieges? 09:46 Did the Greeks dig ditches? 10:47 Who was the best Greek warrior? 12:05 Was the Trojan War real? 14:04 Who started the trojan war? 15:34 Who was Helen of troy? 16:15 Did the gods fight in the trojan war? 17:02 Which heroes fought in the trojan war? 18:21 What was the trojan horse? 19:16 Who won the trojan war? 20:20 Why was the Trojan war important? 21:28 Why did the Greeks fight the Persians? 23:09 Where was the Persian war? 24:59 Who won the Persian war? 26:50 Why was the Persian war important? 28:26 Did the Spartans fight the Athenians? 28:58 Why was it called the Peloponnesian war? 29:50 Who won the Peloponnesian war? 31:51 What happened after the Peloponnesian war?
You can now become a History Hit member right here on YouTube! Join for access to a new exclusive documentary every week, and access to over 160+ of our documentaries presented by world renowned historians like Dan Snow, Eleanor Janega, Tristan Hughes, Mary Beard, Matt Lewis and more. Get an exclusive release every week by signing up here: https://bit.ly/45Y4Oyg
#expertreacts#ancientwarfare#ditches R. Gand, an ancient historian from Oxford, explores the realities of warfare in ancient Greece. They answer frequent questions regarding tactics, the
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Historian Roel Groenendijk examines the evolution of ancient Greek warfare, from the legendary Trojan War to the historical Greco-Persian and Peloponnesian conflicts. He analyzes the transition from small-scale raids to complex campaigns, the development of naval and cavalry power, and how these military struggles shaped Greek identity and political structures.
Whew, kind of a big question.
Which heroes fought in the Trojan War?
Um, there's...
It's a bit of a list.
Famously, they were pretty bad at it at first,
but they quickly learned.
I wonder if this question is meant for me.
Did the Greeks have navies?
Yes, they did.
In fact, earlier than they did, cavalry.
Hello, everyone.
My name is Roel Groenendijk.
I'm an ancient historian at Lincoln College,
University of Oxford,
and I'm here to answer frequently asked questions
about my field, ancient Greek warfare.
First, I'm going to answer some general questions,
and then we're going to go into a few more specific
questions about the Trojan War,
about the Persian Wars,
Peloponnesian War, and some other conflicts.
And hopefully we'll have some interesting things to say.
Who did the Greeks fight?
Everyone.
I mean, basically everyone they could find.
And if they couldn't find you,
they would give it a good go looking for you.
Greeks in this period, in ancient times,
thought of war as pretty normal.
It was quite a big part of their lives
to jump to warfare as a way to resolve conflicts
between themselves and other communities.
So they often fought wars with their neighbors
over perceived slights, over injustice,
over territorial disputes,
over questions of honor, legitimacy,
breaking of the rules, whatever else.
And so warfare was quite a common thing for them.
But they also fought wars against non-Greeks around them.
So they fought wars against the Thracians
and the Etruscans and the Carthaginians
and the Persians, of course,
and peoples of North Africa.
Everywhere they encountered people,
either because they were themselves
trying to carve out territory
or because those peoples either wanted them gone
or had their own expansionist designs in mind.
So who did the Greeks fight?
Yes, basically everyone in the world.
Next question.
How did the Greeks fight?
That's kind of a big question.
I spend a lot of time studying this.
They have very limited means of mustering military force
because they don't have a lot of money.
They have small populations.
Most of their population can't leave home
for any length of time
without crashing the economy, essentially.
So how did the Greeks fight?
Well, in really quite modest ways most of the time.
A lot of their early wars were essentially border raids.
Later on, they do start mustering large citizen armies,
but those armies are just composed of regular citizens
and they can't leave home for very long.
Only a few states had the means to do things
like build elaborate fortifications
or put together war fleets.
And it's only later when these states grow richer
and more populous and more powerful
that they start to have overseas campaigning,
overseas conquests, prolonged campaigns
like sieges and things like that.
So how did the Greeks fight?
Initially, in very basic ways.
And then later on, their warfare becomes more and more complex
and they start to be able to take on
bigger and bigger opponents.
And this obviously culminates in the end
with Alexander the Great uniting the Greek world
and taking on the Persian Empire.
What weapons did the Greeks fight with?
They would use spears and swords, javelins, bows, slings,
all the kind of weapons that you find
on a pre-modern battlefield.
The average Greek warrior perhaps,
you know, just numerically speaking,
was a light-armed warrior who fought with a rock
perhaps that he found on the battlefield
if there was nothing else,
but otherwise with some javelins,
with a bow and arrow or with sling stones.
If he had a bit more money to equip himself
because the state was not paying for any of his equipment,
he had to afford it for himself.
If he had the money, he might buy some body armor,
he might buy a long thrusting spear and a shield
and then fight that way.
In that style of fighting,
short swords were also prominent secondary weapons.
Early in the 4th century BC,
they developed a totally new kind of weapon
which can throw projectiles at much greater range
than anything else and larger projectiles
than a human being can project.
But this is something that develops first in that period
and initially, I mean,
these weapons are really quite modest.
We should imagine them as sort of large bolt shooters.
And it takes a while for that to really develop a presence
within Greek warfare.
And then, of course, the other weapon they fight with
is warships which are themselves kind of a weapon.
Their main warship, the trireme,
is itself essentially a floating ram.
It has a very large crew of rowers
to allow that ship to get stuck into other ships,
to ram them and hopefully either sink or disable them.
So that is itself kind of also a weapon,
but fundamentally that is the full range
of what the Greeks would use.
Next question, did the Greeks fight on chariots?
That's an interesting question, actually.
Chariots appear in Homer.
So in the Iliad, there are warriors fighting in chariots.
They jump off them to fight
and then they jump back on to get away.
So they don't really fight in chariots,
but they use them as something that's been described
as like battlefield taxis essentially.
They use them to get around quickly.
And historians are divided over
whether that's a real practice,
maybe from the early archaic period.
So from the eighth or seventh century BC,
that they really did this.
Or whether this is essentially something
that the poet doesn't quite understand,
it's fantasy or it's something
that maybe is reflecting a bad memory,
a badly preserved memory of earlier times,
the Bronze Age when this kind of chariot
would be more common.
Next question, did the Greeks have cavalries?
Yes, they did.
This is something that's sometimes considered
to be like un-Greek or alien to the Greek world
because we have some battles like in the Persian wars
where the Greeks don't seem to have
any men fighting on horseback.
And the assumption has long been
that this is because horses just don't feature
very much in Greek warfare.
But the fact is that shortly after the Persian wars,
you get very prominent accounts
of the capabilities of cavalry from Thessaly,
from Boeotia, from Asia Minor,
from other parts of the Greek world.
And it's spreading from there
until towards the middle of the fourth century,
about a century after the Persian wars,
it seems like every Greek state worth its salt
will have some cavalry of their own.
So this is something that is emerging
in the period of the Persian wars.
It's not quite developed yet,
but soon after that, it becomes very normal.
And this cavalry has a very important role
to play in Greek warfare.
There are a lot of different roles
that cavalry is especially suited for,
protecting farmlands, harrying the enemy,
keeping them together, keeping them in place,
maintaining, fighting their scouts,
fighting their outriders,
preventing them from plundering,
but also for instance, fighting in battles,
being this mobile force that can intervene where needed
and often actually deciding the outcome of pitched battles.
Cavalry is a huge part of Greek warfare.
And towards the end of the classical period,
they actually become such a big feature of it
that when Alexander the Great musters his army
to cross into Asia, to attack the Persian empire,
there are more Greek horsemen in his army
than Macedonian and Thracian horsemen put together.
There's a huge element of his force
that is Greek cavalry,
because the Greeks have so many of these horsemen
ready for battle.
Did the Greeks have navies?
Yes, they did.
In fact, earlier than they did,
cavalry, as we've just discussed,
I mean, they had navies
at least from the late sixth century onwards
and probably later.
And some of their most famous exploits in war
are thanks to their large fleets of warships.
The Greeks lived by the sea.
Naval connections and trade
were extremely important to them.
And of course, they realized early on
that if you could dominate those,
if you could secure and protect those sea lanes,
then it would give you a special amount of power.
Your influence over, for instance, island states
would be absolute
because no one could get to those states
without your permission, without your say-so.
So Greeks start developing this idea of naval power,
thalassocracy, rule of the sea quite early on.
And by the time of the Persian wars,
you have different states already vying for naval power.
Aegina, Athens, Samos are all noted naval powers.
Many of those are conquered by the Persians
and used to build a fleet to send against Greece.
But it is the Athenian-led or the Spartan-led
but mostly Athenian fleet of the coalition
against the Persians
that wins the great victory at Salamis
that actually drives off the Persian fleet
and more or less turns the tide of the Persian wars.
So from then on, the Athenian navy
becomes this huge factor in the Aegean.
They end up projecting their power
into the Black Sea, into the Eastern Mediterranean,
into Sicily, everywhere else.
Athenian naval power becomes one of the driving forces
of the history of the 5th century.
Next question.
Did the Greeks do sieges?
Again, famously, they were pretty bad at it at first,
but they quickly learned.
So initially in Greek history,
sieges don't really seem to happen.
Sometimes cities are taken by surprise.
Sometimes cities are quickly overrun.
But you don't really get good stories
of prolonged operations against a fortified settlement.
The story of the Trojan War is kind of exceptional
because we hear of this 10-year war against the city.
But when you read Homer,
you realize that the way it's described
is not actually a siege.
The Greeks are just kind of sitting outside of that city
and they have battles in the plain
between the city and the Greek camp.
So it's really not a siege
in the way that we understand it
with engines going up to the walls
and people being starved out.
And in fact, it's only decided
because of this famous trick of the Trojan Wars.
And the reason for that, I mean, I've already mentioned,
these Greek states have very limited means.
Keeping an army in the field is very expensive.
It's very difficult.
It requires a lot of logistical know-how
to be able to get supplies to them
and to be able to keep these men in operational activity
when they're not tending to their fields
and their shops and whatever else they have at home.
So they are out of your economy.
You're projecting them out into the world
and using them for a military campaign.
It's very difficult for a small community to sustain that.
So initially, Greek sieges, they have to be very limited.
If they're not over quickly, they don't happen at all.
Did the Greeks dig ditches?
I wonder if this question is meant for me.
Surprisingly, not that much.
Much to my disappointment, obviously.
But the Greeks sometimes would try and reinforce a settlement
with a ditch, for instance,
on a side of the walls that was facing a plain.
If it's easy to approach, you dig a ditch in front of that
and you'll be much safer.
It becomes more difficult for an enemy with engines
or ladders to approach your walls.
But generally speaking, Greek fortified settlements and forts
were placed in easily defensible positions.
So for instance, on hilltops, on mountainsides,
or on sort of promontories sticking out into the sea.
So most of these Greek positions rely on natural defenses,
which are reinforced by building walls,
reinforced with towers and parapets
and all sorts of things,
but fundamentally don't rely on earthworks
in the same way that fortifications do in places
where the land is more flat
and where it's easier to construct those.
Next question.
Who was the best Greek warrior?
Canonically, Achilles.
He's famously described as best of the Greeks
and legendarily the best warrior among the Greeks
in the Trojan War story.
Historically, there's much less interest
in this kind of question.
There isn't so much a sense
that individual warriors make or break
the fate of campaigns.
And so there isn't as much of a sense
that individuals should be considered
the best of the Greeks
and should be honored accordingly.
You get a couple of battles
in which Herodotus, who is a historian,
he is still describing for us
who was awarded within the Greek army
with the prize for valor.
We hear of Sophanes among the Athenians
and also Pythias, an Agonitian marine
who fought so nobly
during the battle of Artemision
against the Persians
or some of the actions before that,
that the Persians actually captured him
and took care of him and treated his wounds
so that they could have him fighting on their side
since his ship had been captured.
So there was some understanding
that some of these warriors
had done sort of great things
and that they deserve to be honored for it.
But when we hear about
what those things actually are,
I mean, there's very little detail.
I mean, this is really just about
the basic level of valorous conduct,
just being willing to stand and fight
and face the enemy
even at the expense of your own life.
Next question, was the Trojan War real?
Kind of a big question.
There's a couple of different things
to distinguish here.
One thing is that the story that we know
comes primarily from the Homeric epic poems.
These are tales that were written down
around the year maybe 700 BC,
maybe a little later.
They're the earliest sources
written in the Greek alphabet
that survived down to our time.
The time in which they believe
the Trojan War took place
conforms more or less if we squint
to the very end of the Bronze Age in Greece
when Mycenae was a very powerful kingdom
and when one of the layers
of the ancient city of Troy was destroyed.
And so it's been incredibly tempting
for many historians to say
that these things are not coincidence,
that there was a real Trojan War
at the end of the Bronze Age
and that when Homer or when the poet
putting together the epics
referred to this war
as happening in the heroic past,
they were actually referring to
the traces of a real memory
of a historical event.
And some people are very optimistic about this.
They say we have plenty of evidence
from Hittite sources and from archaeology
to attest that there was a real Trojan War.
Others are much more cautious
and say we really cannot say
even if we have these pieces
whether this is in any sense
the Trojan War that is described by Homer
or whether any of the characters
or any of the events that were described
in the epic cycle
have any relation to real history.
I am myself on the skeptical camp.
I don't think the Trojan War
ever actually happened.
What we're dealing with
is an epic poem about a story
that fits very nicely
within the world of early archaic Greece
in terms of how societies are organized,
how they're run,
what the concerns of the individual people are,
where they're based and what they do
and what kind of equipment they carry.
This is an early archaic Greek world.
That's what's being described to us
and that's why these poems are interesting.
Next question.
Who started the Trojan War?
Different accounts of that.
It's a story that goes further and further back.
There's always a first cause for everything.
According to the sources on the Trojan War,
so the epic cycle,
the first instigator was Zeus
who wanted to trigger it.
So he sent Eris, the goddess of strife,
to a wedding party
to essentially provoke a fight
between different goddesses
about who was the most beautiful
which they submitted for arbitration to Paris,
who was a Trojan,
who didn't know at the time
he was a Trojan prince.
He gave the apple,
gave the prize,
gave the title of the most beautiful to Aphrodite
in exchange for the promise
that Helen,
the most beautiful woman in the world,
fall in love with him.
But Helen was already married to Menelaus,
the king of Sparta,
or rather Helen of Sparta
was already married to Menelaus
who was therefore king of Sparta.
And so when she fell in love with Paris,
he abducted her and took her to Troy
which then triggered the Trojan War.
Now this is, you know,
it's a complicated story,
it has many different phases and episodes.
This is basically the way that it's understood.
Herodotus, in the beginning of his history,
tries to tie this Trojan War
into a wider narrative of conflict
between Asia and Europe.
And this kind of reflects something
about the way the Greeks
talked about this in the 5th century.
So he says that it goes even further back than that,
that there were other occasions
where mythical figures like Io
had been stolen by other people.
So earlier peoples had stolen,
you know, women from Asia
or women from Europe
and taken them with them.
And this created this sort of
prolonged series of tit for tat.
Who was Helen of Troy?
Helen of Sparta, rather,
was the daughter of a,
well, the daughter of Zeus, technically.
And she was eventually married off to Menelaus
who was one of the Atreides,
so one of the brothers, the sons of Atreus.
So that was a big event.
There were many suitors to Helen's hand
because as a daughter of Zeus,
she was reputed to be
the most beautiful woman in the world.
And at the end of that,
her choice for Menelaus,
all the other suitors were made to swear a pact,
were made to swear an oath
that they would defend the sanctity of this marriage
between Helen and Menelaus,
which is what is activated
when Helen is abducted from Sparta
and the Trojan War begins, essentially.
Next question.
Did the gods fight in the Trojan War?
According to the story, they absolutely did.
In fact, they caused it.
And they chose sides in it.
So several different gods have their favorites.
Athena is very much on the Greek side.
Hera, along with Hera as well, of course,
because Paris chose against her.
Aphrodite is very much on the Trojan side
because Paris chose her.
And there are other gods involved as well.
Poseidon, Ares, Apollo, they all play their part.
But various others are there
to protect their own offspring, for instance,
or to put their finger on the scales.
At one point, Zeus wants to save his son Sarpedon
and is told off by Hera
because if he started doing it,
all the other gods would want to do that too,
like save their children from death in battle.
So that kind of thing is absolutely,
it's a huge factor in the story that was told,
the poem that was written about the Trojan War.
Which heroes fought in the Trojan War?
It's a bit of a list.
It's got a huge cast of characters.
In fact, there's almost an exhaustible supply of heroes,
especially when you have heroes going on a rampage,
going on what's called Aristeia,
so an act of a series of glorious deeds.
They seem to be killing heroes left and right
that are all named.
They get a name and a patronym.
Sometimes they get an epithet
or they get some kind of detail about their backstory,
about their looks, their skills, their origins, their family.
You get all sorts of details about these heroes.
There's an absolutely vast cast of characters
associated with the Trojan War in the epic poems.
Only a handful of those are famous enough
to now feature in a lot of stories and versions of this.
You have your Achilles, Odysseus, Agamemnon,
Aias, Ajax, the two different Ajaxes,
actually, because there are several.
On the Trojan side, of course, Hector, Paris, Aeneas.
But when you then later read the rest of the story,
you find that there's an enormous number
of additional heroes below the level
of these absolute top leaders.
In terms of which heroes fought in the Trojan War,
the list is literally endless,
because as soon as Homer or whoever else,
another poet, needs another character,
a named character to get involved in a debate or a fight,
they can just generate more.
There seems to be an absolutely inexhaustible list of them.
What was the Trojan horse?
It's an interesting question.
At its most basic level, the Trojan horse
was the trick that either Apeas or Odysseus
used to try and infiltrate Troy.
So they built a horse.
They left it behind on the beach.
They pretended to flee, the Greeks.
The Trojans decided that the Greeks had left,
that they'd won the war.
They took the horse with them as a trophy into the walls.
Supposedly, they even had to break down some of their walls
to make room for it, because the horse was so big.
They brought it into the walls, and they celebrated,
and they got drunk, and they fell asleep.
At that point, the Greeks, who had hidden themselves away
inside the horse, came out, opened the gates
to the Greeks, who had returned quietly,
and that was how the city fell.
So the Trojan horse is a famous metaphorical symbol still
of the idea of infiltrating in secret.
You are able to come in with something else that was invited,
and the people who are doing it don't realize
that you're in that horse.
Who won the Trojan War?
The Greeks.
Agamemnon.
Menelaus.
He got his wife back.
That's who he was fighting for.
Fundamentally, this is the end of the Trojan Wars,
that Troy is destroyed.
It is sacked thoroughly by the Greeks.
The city is burned down, and supposedly, everybody dies,
except for those who get away.
Peoples, not just the Romans, who famously did this
with Aeneas, but many, many peoples around the world
have claimed to be the last surviving Trojans
who fled and resettled somewhere else.
Germanic tribes did this in Roman times,
and many other peoples have claimed
to be the Trojans who got away from the destruction
of the city.
But the Greeks, thanks to the Trojan horse trick,
they absolutely win.
They achieve their aim.
They destroy the city.
They kill Priam and his family.
They enslave most of the women they capture,
which leads to many tragic stories after that,
when the horrible fate of these women is considered.
And it leads into other stories, such as the Odyssey,
as the Greek heroes try to get home.
Next question, why was the Trojan War important?
I mean, so we can't talk about it historically.
It's a little bit difficult, because there's just no way
to prove that this actually happened.
If it did actually happen, then the only outcome
was that the city of Troy was burned down
and later resettled.
But in terms of literature and culture,
we can say the Trojan War is important,
because it is the story for the Greeks.
This is absolutely the story they all know,
the story they all tell.
This is something that binds the Greeks together culturally.
And so the Trojan War is an enormously important story,
and especially Homer, especially the Iliad and the Odyssey,
are just absolute cornerstones of Greek culture.
And they see them, in fact, they see Homer
as this unimaginable sage who is both the first historian
and the first tactician and the greatest poet.
And they think of him as basically being
the pinnacle of all their learning,
the one who gave the example for every possible thing
that you could want to know about the world.
So for them, this is essentially the start
and the foundation of all knowledge
is to learn your Homer.
And they all know it.
They can all quote it.
They can all recite it at each other.
This is the text that absolutely everyone knows.
Within that world, there is no text more important
than the Homeric epic.
Why did the Greeks fight the Persians?
The Persian Empire emerges very suddenly
in the middle of the 6th century BC.
And then at that point, it's basically everybody's problem.
So the Persians continue to expand
for a long period of time.
They successfully subject the entire Middle East,
Iran, parts of Central Asia, what is today Turkey and Egypt.
They spread out over all these regions.
And the Greek world, which doesn't necessarily
overlap just with the modern state of Greece,
is essentially next in their path.
So they conquer parts of the Greek world
early on in their conquest in the 540s BC.
And that part of the Greek world rebels in 499 BC.
So that's called the Ionian Revolt
because of the revolt of a couple of city-states
around Ionia, which is this part of the coast
of what is now Turkey.
People who are leading that rebellion
go to the mainland Greeks and ask for help.
Most of the Greeks turn them down.
But the Athenians and the Eretrians
say, yes, we'll support you.
They briefly do.
They don't achieve very much.
But at that point, the Persians become
aware of the existence of these other Greek states.
And the story that we are told is that from that moment,
it was clear that that was going to be their next target.
So why did the Greeks fight the Persians?
Either because the Persians just continue
to expand continuously throughout the first half
century of their existence as an empire.
And so Greece is just next in their path.
And it was inevitable.
But according to the Greeks, it's
also because, according to the Greeks themselves,
it's also because the Greeks more or less provoked them.
So there are different stories in which they essentially
either harm, or slight, or dishonor,
or destroy parts of Persian land,
forced temples, et cetera, and that the Persians think
it is vengeance is due, essentially.
So that is why the Greeks fight the Persians.
Next question, where was the Persian War?
The Persian War is presumably.
Initially, all of this fighting happens
in what is now Western Turkey.
So there is a couple of different campaigns
to subdue the rebellious Greeks, which
the Persians do quite handily.
I mean, it takes them a few years.
But they win all their battles.
They win all their sieges, which they're
much more capable of doing than the Greeks themselves,
because of the resources and experience they've built up.
And so the Persians initially re-establish their control
over Asia Minor, over what is now Turkey.
But then they cross over into Europe.
Now, they've already done that briefly previously.
So they've subjected Thrace, and Macedon,
and some other regions.
But they never turned against the mainland Greek world.
So now, at this point, first, Darius
has his generals advance across the Aegean.
So they go island to island into the west.
They take a number of these islands, Euboea, Naxos.
And then they land in Attica, near Athens.
But that's where they are defeated,
the Battle of Marathon, which is a marathon away from Athens,
literally, 42 kilometers.
That's where that first big encounter happened.
And that's where the Greeks learned, oh, you can win this.
That's interesting.
One decade later, Xerxes, who has succeeded Darius,
his father, invades again with a big royal army.
He crosses into Europe across the Hellespont.
He advances first west and then south into mainland Greece.
And the campaigns of that war are essentially
fought around central Greece.
So we're talking about Thermopylae,
which is just north of modern Theba.
And then south of there, south to the southwest of that,
Plataea is where the decisive land battle is fought.
Naval battles happen sort of just to the east
in the coastal regions, first at Artemision,
and then at Salamis, south of Athens.
That's where the big battles are fought.
Next question, who won the Persian War?
Depends on how long you put your time brackets.
Always fun.
Initially, the Persian invasions were thwarted.
The Battle of Marathon cements the fact
that Darius can advance no further west.
So his campaign was a big success up to the point
where he landed on the mainland,
but that's where he was stopped.
Then Xerxes' army and fleet are essentially
destroyed by the Greeks.
So that the big events of 480 to 479
is that this Persian invasion force is wiped out.
And that puts a stop to Persian expansion permanently.
In fact, they never resume any expansion towards the west
except that they continue to try and assert
their control over the west, which also involves
kind of relationships of vassalage
with the Greek state.
So they no longer try to outright conquer them,
but they try to throw their weight around
to make sure that these Greeks can't
form a threat to Persia or infringe
on the Persian ability to rule over Asia Minor,
what is now Turkey.
So when you're talking about who won the Persian Wars,
I mean, fundamentally, it is the Athenians or the Greeks,
more generally, the Greek alliance that wins.
But in the long run, the Persians do manage
to claw back control over the regions
that they were pushed out of.
And eventually even get to a position
where they more or less get to decide policy
between the Greek states just by saying,
whoever is doing anything that we don't like,
we are going to support their enemies.
And they support their enemies with money and ships,
which are the kind of things that most of these Greek states
struggle to afford.
And it allows them to wage war on a much higher level
and maintain empires at the kind of scale that they want.
And so they end up really wanting Persian support,
really vying for Persian support,
and in the process,
kind of submitting themselves to a world
that is dominated by Persians.
Why was the Persian War important?
Again, in terms of modern scholars have argued a lot
about whether it actually matters
that the Persians were defeated.
In an institutional sense,
the argument that this was somehow hugely important
for the Greeks has been debunked to some extent
by people who point out that the Greeks
living under the Persian yoke already in Asia Minor
get to live more or less the way they want.
And in fact, even according to Herodotus,
get to have things like democratic forms of government,
as long as they do the bidding of the Persian king.
So culturally, it may not have been that important
that they were able to avoid subjection to the Persians.
It may not have meant that Greek culture was preserved
or the products of Greek political
and cultural and literary life were allowed to flourish.
A lot of that stuff may well have happened
under Persian rule,
just as much as it did after the victory.
However, there is a way in which this victory
was very important to the Greeks
in the sense that it really galvanized
their understanding of themselves as a culture
that's quite apart from the Persians.
So they start to think of themselves
much more strongly as Greeks,
Greeks against the world,
Greeks against the East.
And they start to think of that status
as that identity as something worth celebrating.
And that in itself may well have been
one of the instigators
of a lot of the cultural production that follows.
A lot of the kind of things that they start making
and doing, creating and imagining
comes out of this understanding
that they are something special in the world
because they were able to stop Persian expansion
where all the other peoples
around the Eastern Mediterranean
and the Middle East had failed to do so.
Did the Spartans fight the Athenians?
Yes, many times.
There are at least five wars
throughout the classical period.
So we have the so-called First Peloponnesian War,
the Archidamian War,
the Ionian-Decalayan War
and the Corinthian War and the Boeotian War.
So there are many different wars
in which the Spartans fight the Athenians
for a period of about 90 years,
which is sometimes grouped together
and called something like the hegemonic wars.
So it's the wars over hegemony of the Greek world.
So they are vying for partial or total control
over the Greeks as the leading state
within that community of smaller states.
Why was it called the Peloponnesian War?
It's an excellent question.
Actually, there were different names for this war.
The Peloponnesian War is ancient as a name, as a label,
but there were different names for this war
that already existed in ancient times.
So the reason we call it the Peloponnesian War
is primarily because we tend to look at it
through the eyes of an Athenian source, Thucydides
and his successor as a historian, Xenophon,
who were both Athenian.
So they are talking about the war of the Peloponnesians
against Athens.
So that's why it's called the Peloponnesian War.
But of course, for them, as Thucydides himself says,
it was the Athenian War.
How long did the Peloponnesian War last?
The thing is actually it breaks down
into two wars.
The first one is about 10 years.
Then there's about seven years of peace
in which various campaigns were waged,
including the Athenian expedition against Sicily.
And then there's another period of 10 years of war,
which is a much more all-out conflict.
Who won the Peloponnesian War?
Sparta.
Surprise, upset.
Everybody thought, actually, that they would win.
Not necessarily because they were the better warriors
or because they had the larger army,
but because they were taking the war to Attica.
They were invading Attica every year.
And it was generally thought in the Greek world
that the Athenians wouldn't be able to stand this
for very long.
Their resources would run out.
They would run out of food and money,
and so they eventually would have to surrender.
But they didn't.
For a long time, they fought on.
And this is something that surprised a lot of Greeks
and actually made them think that,
oh, this is not going the way that we thought.
It seems like their resources are greater
than any other state that has existed
within this Greek world.
And as a result, they're able to sustain warfare,
even if they are kind of taking more of the losses
than their enemies, they're able to keep going.
So this war had kind of an unusual course,
and the Greeks themselves were quite baffled
by what was going on.
And the only reason the Spartans are eventually able to win
is because they get the support of the Persians.
So first of all, it's because the Athenians
make some terrible mistakes.
They lose half their fleet in Sicily,
but they're able to bounce back from that
and actually cling on to a lot of the power
that they'd established in the Aegean,
which is, again, something that really impressed
other Greeks and made them wonder
if the power of Athens would ever actually be humbled.
But once the Spartans managed to make an agreement
with Persia to finance naval warfare,
the Spartans were able to challenge the Athenians at sea,
and that proves to be decisive.
Now, I say that proves to be decisive.
It doesn't immediately prove to be decisive.
The Spartans actually lose their entire fleet twice over,
but ultimately they are able to wear the Athenians down
simply because the Athenian resources
are constantly dwindling
as they have to support this war alone,
whereas the Spartans, every time something goes wrong,
they call Mr. Great King of Persia and say,
could we have some more money, please?
And all their losses are made good.
Next question.
What happened after the Peloponnesian War?
Kind of a long story.
I mean, all of history, technically.
Immediately after the Persian War
is that obviously Athens had to surrender its empire.
So the empire was dissolved.
Their fleet was scrapped.
Their walls were torn down.
The long walls are the walls of Piraeus, their harbor.
And Athens was made a subject ally of the Spartans.
So they had to do the Spartans' bidding.
And for a little while they do.
But soon discontent with Spartan overlordship
starts to take hold not only in Athens, but also elsewhere.
So there are other states as well
that no longer enjoy existing in a world
in which Sparta at this point has unrivaled hegemony.
They completely call the shots around the Greek world.
They're not happy about that
because they're constantly being made to fight wars
against people who they have no particular quarrel with.
They're constantly being made to campaign
in all sorts of places
that they don't want to have anything to do with.
And they're unhappy with the outcome
of the Peloponnesian War in general.
They don't think they got their share of the spoils
or their share of the benefits
for fighting that war on the Spartan side.
And so a lot of their Spartan allies become disaffected
and the Athenians joined that camp.
And in 395 BC, so only nine years
after the end of the Peloponnesian War,
these states band together and declare war on Sparta again.
That triggers the Corinthian War,
which is a whole other story.
But the fundamental point is
that the Peloponnesian War doesn't settle the business
of who should be in charge of the Greek world.
So the questions that we've covered here
really only discuss a couple of the most famous wars.
There are many others that continue into the fourth century.
And the big one, of course,
is first the subjection of the Greek world to Macedon,
which happened under Philip II,
and then the great conquest of his son,
Alexander the Great.
I haven't covered that in detail.
There will be another video coming up here on History Hit.
And if you enjoy that, please look out for it.
And thanks very much for watching.