Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/vujbgh • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% (up to $250) off ⮕ https://www.cbac.com/ramsey - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries. ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get started today with Churchill Mortgage. Equal Housing Lender • NMLS ID 1591 • NMLSConsumerAccess.org ⮕ http://ChurchillMortgage.com/RamseyOffer ⮕ Churchill Certified Homebuyer program is available for qualifying borrowers and select loan types only. Ramsey Audience offer of up to a $500 credit applied at closing toward fees incurred for appraisals for a limited time and may be discontinued without notice. - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe. ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance or call 1-800-356-4282 for your free instant quote today. ⮕ https://www.zander.com/
A recently widowed woman with a $7 million investment portfolio and $8 million net worth seeks a second opinion after her financial advisor suggested she grow her portfolio further before buying a $75,000 show horse. The hosts conclude that she can easily afford the purchase and the $45,000 annual upkeep given her high annual returns.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
I want to buy a horse and my financial advisor told me I need to grow my investment portfolio
a little bit more before I can afford it and I feel like I can afford it so I wanted to just
get a second opinion from you all. Okay what's the size of your investment portfolio? The size
of the horse? I don't know why. Yeah okay. Big horse, small horse, Caroline? It's a quarter
horse. It's going to be a show horse, a reigning show horse. That's big here in Texas and so
reigning is a thing here, is a type of horseback riding but anyway it'll be a show horse
and my investment portfolio to answer your question is seven million dollars.
My net worth is eight million and your screener asked me how much I've been earning on that
and I actually went I told them about 14% but I went and looked it up and it's 16.47% that I've
earned year over year. That would be bright. Okay and how much is this reigning quarter horse?
Yeah so it's going to be somewhere around 75,000. It might be more, it might be less.
I don't know why your financial advisor even gets a vote.
You're a lady that has seven, eight million dollars and she wants to spend 75,000.
Well thank you for that and here's the thing, it's ongoing upkeep and the reason he gets a vote
is I trust him and I ask him the question so I mean I rang his bell and asked him.
How much is the upkeep yearly? The answer is he wouldn't do it if it was him but the answer is
not you can't afford it. You can afford it. Now if you're not a horse person you might not view
this as wise but you're a horse person and it's where you want to burn some money. You're getting
ready to put 150,000 in the middle of the floor and burn it. That's right, that's exactly right.
But if you got seven million dollars you can do that. It doesn't matter yeah. How much is it a
year Caroline with everything? Boarding, grooming, like yeah it's at least 45,000 a year if everything
goes right. When did ever anything go right? Yeah it's 45,000 a year. What are you, are you working?
Are you retired? No I'm not working. I am a young retiree. I'm 54 years old and so I need my
investment portfolio to last for the rest of my life. Don't have kids, don't have a husband.
If your investment portfolio makes 10 percent a year you make 700,000 a year. Okay. Right. So I
should be able to afford a horse right? Yeah. But um yeah just remember just remember though
when it comes to horses it's like a lot of things. It's like my cars and my guns and some other
things. The first one is the gateway drug. Oh yes I've had this is this is going to be a problem.
It's going to get worse. Yes yeah they're like potatoes. I'm a recent widow and so uh my husband
always worked and had a big job and so we were able to afford horses and it was fine because
he had an income but now I don't have. You have a $700,000 annual income. Right other than that
other than that. What's your, do you, what's your uh house situation Carolyn? Do you own your house
or are you still paying on the mortgage? I still have a $140,000 mortgage um and I need it takes
me about because that's what my husband did. My recently departed husband we had a very low at
less than two percent interest rate so he was just like let's just pay it off you know over 15
years. No. That kind of thing um so I might pay off my house. I know. Yeah I would pay off your
house and because you want the horse you should buy the horse you can afford it. I just want you
to I buy some things that are absolutely um everyone buys some things that are absolutely
ridiculous meaning that we just take the money and burn it in the middle of the floor it's just a
it's ridiculous consumption right we all do and the only question is does it harm your life
when you do that? Okay. That's the question. And this does not harm your life $150,000
75 for the horse and the next two years of upkeep gets you to 150 real quick right
um burning $150,000 in your fireplace tonight your life would not change one ounce. Okay. And
$45,000 a year for the upkeep ongoing doesn't change $700,000 a year coming in. I think if
I think in the future I would want my financial advisor to phrase differently so I don't fire him
he should say he should say you can afford to do this but you need to understand that you are
completely burning this money in the middle of the floor if you understand that and you feel like
you're going to be okay mathematically you're going to be okay but the but you can't you can't
do this 10 times you can do it once we don't go to a million five we're not going to a million five
on this yeah I want to keep it going a year over you know what I mean I want to keep it no I'm
saying probably four to six years I'm going to buy another horse and retire the other one and
well if you live on considerably less than $700,000 and you end up with $14 million
and you want to buy another horse then I think you'll be fine okay yeah but just some of my
portfolio is in you know IRAs like about half of it's in an IRA that I can't really touch yeah but
it's growing at that rate is my point you are not going backward you're going forward yeah and that's
seven years from now it will have doubled if it's continuing at 10% or greater and so you're
seven will be 14 seven years from now if you're earning 10 or greater and you have been so you've
got a good portfolio um and so the you know the question is if I if I if you booked a $200,000
four seasons or Ritz private jet around the world which is actually available for about that
it would be the same thing I'm going to travel around the world for the next six months by
private jet and I'm going to book it through four seasons or Ritz they both have it okay
and it'd be the same exact thing you're just burning the money yeah but that's triple what
she's paying for the no she's 200,000 I said and she's paying 150 over yeah I mean she's
gonna pay uh she's gonna pay 75 and then she's got two years of upkeep she's gonna have 150 200
in the source in a heartbeat yeah so and ongoing the upkeep is 45 yeah yeah yeah yeah and so all
that's safe but if you have seven million dollars and you want to go on a $200,000 trip you can do
that yes yes that's my point yep now would your financial advisor agree with that obviously he
wouldn't you know but he doesn't hers you mean he her financial yeah yeah he doesn't get a vote
on that stuff you know he just is there to help me understand the math and you know you know let's
couch this decision looking at what it does to the arithmetic does this harm my life I wonder why he
would tell her well I'll give you let's give him the benefit of the doubt for a second yeah okay
I'll be nice he might be her husband just passed away he's been coaching both of them for years
he might be afraid she's buying this out of grief and he might be trying to protect her
as a widow for a large purchase from making a large purchase um while you know and uh because
maybe she if her husband was here maybe they wouldn't have done this purchase or whatever he
may be kind of standing in there trying to love her well right that may be what it is but yeah but
um but that's a different thing than to say you can't afford it and you need your portfolio to
that sounds parental and you're not my parent you're my financial advisor yeah yep and so um
you don't folks the relationship you always want with your financial advisor is not parental
it's teacher so it's like I worry about you if you're going to spend two million dollars and
you've got seven I think that's unwise I think you're going to make some I think you're going
to regret that and here's why here's how that destroys your nest egg and messes with it but um
but you also could say to her instead of saying you can't afford it you know hey you just lost
so and so you know a year and a half two years ago and make sure you're not doing this from a
place of grief you're not medicating the grief somehow yeah yeah and I'm worried about you and
I care about you that would be an okay position right that's a brotherly position rather than a
yes than a parental position well glad Caroline called when George Camel wasn't on because he'd
he has he's on all the I think he would even tell Caroline she can buy the horse he would but he
would he would he would be because he's on all the he'd be under the desk he's under the he's on the
hate list of all the horse people websites create your free every dollar budget today
the simplest way to budget for your life