This video analyzes the engineering challenges of the Starship HLS (Human Landing System), focusing on the critical need for stability during lunar landing, the complexities of crew egress via a lunar elevator, and the overall mission architecture required to establish a sustainable human presence on the Moon.
Starship is not ready to land on the Moon, and landing legs are a huge problem.
If you look at the Starship concepts released over the years,
you'll find numerous different landing leg designs,
yet SpaceX has never officially confirmed any of them as the final configuration.
But the more difficult the problem, the more interesting it becomes.
Recently, a new landing leg concept was revealed.
Although it wasn't created by SpaceX itself,
the design is particularly interesting because it could potentially fit the requirements of Starship HLS.
Before we get into that design, though,
you need to understand why landing legs have become such a difficult problem for SpaceX and Elon Musk.
Or, to put it another way, how do you keep a spacecraft standing upright
when it's roughly 50 meters tall, carrying hundreds of tons of hardware and landing on an uneven surface?
The basic physics is straightforward.
When engineers think about landing stability, three factors matter most.
How far the landing feet extend from the vehicle's centerline, where the center of gravity sits,
and how many points are supporting the vehicle.
Think about standing on your own feet.
If you bring your feet close together, it becomes much easier to lose your balance.
Spread them apart, and you create a much wider support footprint.
The same principle applies to Starship.
But Starship HLS has a major disadvantage compared with the Apollo Lunar Module – its enormous height.
A vehicle this tall naturally creates a much more demanding stability problem,
especially when the center of gravity remains relatively high above the lunar surface.
And some early Starship HLS concepts have shown landing legs that appear relatively short
compared with the overall height of the spacecraft.
That matters because the Moon doesn't provide a perfectly prepared landing pad.
A slope, a rock beneath one foot, or simply one leg touching down slightly higher than the others
could introduce a significant tilt at exactly the moment when Starship needs to remain stable.
That's why, if landing for Apollo simply meant touching down on the Moon,
then for Starship, landing also means making sure the spacecraft doesn't tip over once it gets there.
To ensure this, countless renders and discussions about Starship's landing legs have continued to circulate,
far beyond what anyone might have imagined, turning the subject into a never-ending hot topic within the space community.
Recently, another render showing a possible Starship landing leg design
was released by an ex-user and 3D artist named 3D Daniel,
and it offers a genuinely fresh and different concept.
Thanks to Daniel for sharing these images and videos.
Although this render is still purely speculative,
it could point to a very different solution to Starship's stability problem.
The concept appears to show a more sophisticated mechanical landing system
attached to the lower section of Starship's cylindrical body.
Instead of simply extending a long, rigid leg from the vehicle,
the design appears to use two long black struts running in parallel,
resembling hydraulic pistons or structural actuators.
These struts would extend downward and outward during deployment,
while an internal framework provides additional support and mechanical connections.
When stowed, much of the mechanism appears to be protected by a streamlined fairing
that sits tightly against the spacecraft's body.
At the bottom, the system appears to use a hinged footpad
that can rotate slightly to make better contact with the lunar surface.
Although SpaceX has not publicly confirmed what the final Starship HLS landing leg design will look like,
if a system like this were eventually developed, it could offer an interesting solution
because it addresses one of Starship's most obvious challenges—stability.
And the basic idea is simple.
The farther the landing feet are from the vehicle's centerline,
the wider the support footprint becomes.
A wider stance allows the spacecraft to tolerate greater surface slopes
and reduces the risk of tipping when one foot touches down higher than another.
So why not simply make the legs extremely long?
Because every extra meter of landing leg structure comes with a price.
Longer legs require more structural material.
They have to withstand greater loads at their attachment points,
need stronger deployment mechanisms,
and may require additional actuators, joints, plumbing, or other hardware.
This creates one of the most important engineering tradeoffs in the entire landing system—
more stability versus more mass.
SpaceX, therefore, doesn't simply need the biggest landing legs possible.
It needs the lightest system that can still provide enough stability
under realistic lunar landing conditions.
The goal, then, isn't to build a landing leg that can survive every imaginable situation.
It's to design an entire landing system capable of remaining stable across thousands
or potentially millions of different combinations of terrain,
touchdown conditions, vehicle mass, and landing dynamics.
And that is why Starship's landing legs are much more than just four pieces of metal
holding the vehicle up.
They are part of the system that determines whether a 50-meter-tall spacecraft
can actually stay standing on the Moon.
But even if SpaceX solves the landing problem,
Starship still has another challenge waiting immediately after touchdown.
And this is where Starship's enormous size
becomes a completely different kind of engineering challenge.
At roughly 50 meters tall, the crew compartment and airlock
are positioned high above the lunar surface,
which means astronauts can't simply open a hatch and step onto the Moon.
They need a way down.
That's why Starship HLS includes something that sounds almost strange on a spacecraft
– a lunar elevator.
The concept uses a platform, or basket,
that moves along rails mounted to the outside of the vehicle.
After the astronauts exit through the airlock,
they can step onto the platform and ride it down toward the surface.
Once it reaches the bottom, a deployable ramp allows the crew
to move from the elevator onto the lunar terrain.
The same system can potentially transport scientific equipment, tools,
and other cargo between the spacecraft and the surface.
But building an elevator on Earth is one thing.
Building one on the Moon is something else entirely.
Every moving component – joint, rail, and actuator –
has to keep working in an environment where there is essentially no room
for a mechanic to come along and fix it.
And that creates another problem.
What happens if the elevator fails?
NASA's Office of Inspector General has raised concerns
that the current design does not provide an alternative method for astronauts
to enter or exit the vehicle if the elevator becomes unavailable.
That effectively makes the elevator a potential single point of failure
in the crew access system.
And on the Moon, that's a serious issue.
But the elevator is only one part of the architecture.
Before astronauts can even reach the lunar surface,
Starship HLS has to meet Orion in lunar orbit.
The two spacecraft must dock,
allowing the astronauts to transfer safely from Orion into Starship.
Once the astronauts enter Starship, however,
the spacecraft becomes much more than a vehicle
for getting them from orbit to the Moon.
It has to keep them alive.
And that changes the way we should think about Starship HLS.
At this point, it starts looking less like a rocket
and more like a temporary lunar space station,
one that has to launch from Earth,
cross hundreds of thousands of kilometers of space,
land on the Moon, support astronauts on the surface,
and then get them safely back to lunar orbit.
So, the landing legs may be what keeps Starship standing.
But everything above those legs has to turn that enormous vehicle
into an actual place where humans can live and work on another world.
So, how does a 50-meter-tall Starship actually get from Earth to the Moon?
The surprising answer is that the Moon is almost the easy part.
The really complicated journey begins much earlier, in Earth orbit.
First, a super-heavy booster launches Starship HLS into orbit.
But unlike a conventional spacecraft,
HLS doesn't simply point toward the Moon and leave.
It has to wait for fuel.
Multiple tanker Starships rendezvous with HLS in orbit
and transfer additional methane and liquid oxygen.
Once sufficiently fueled, HLS performs a burn
that sends it away from Earth and toward the Moon,
eventually entering near-rectilinear halo orbit, or NRHO.
Starship gets there first.
Then, NASA sends the astronauts.
Travel toward the Moon and rendezvous with the waiting Starship HLS.
After Orion docks with HLS, the crew divides.
Two astronauts transfer into Starship.
The other two remain aboard Orion.
Finally, HLS undocks.
And now comes the moment everything else has been building toward.
Starship begins its descent toward the lunar south pole.
There is no runway, no landing tower,
and no traditional cockpit where an astronaut simply looks through a window
and manually flies the vehicle toward the ground.
Instead, this enormous spacecraft has to combine its propulsion system
with navigation computers, cameras, radar, LIDAR,
and hazard detection systems to find a suitable landing area
and guide itself safely toward the surface.
But touchdown isn't the end of the mission.
It's where the real work begins.
The platform travels down the outside of Starship,
carrying astronauts and equipment toward the ground.
Under the mission architecture described here,
the astronauts could spend roughly six to seven days on the lunar surface.
But eventually, they have to leave.
Starship fires its engines again and lifts off from the Moon,
returning to lunar orbit and eventually rendezvousing with Orion in NRHO.
The astronauts transfer back into Orion,
bringing their lunar samples and scientific results with them.
Orion then begins the journey back to Earth.
And Starship?
It stays behind in lunar space.
That detail leads to a much bigger question.
What happens after the astronauts leave?
Because if Starship HLS only delivers a few astronauts to the Moon and brings them back,
then we've built an extraordinarily capable transportation system
for what is ultimately a short visit.
But the larger vision goes beyond simply visiting.
The crewed Starship helps people reach the Moon.
A cargo Starship could help people stay there.
Unlike the crewed HLS,
a cargo Starship wouldn't need to dedicate valuable space and mass
to crew cabins, sleeping quarters, life support equipment,
or other systems required to keep astronauts alive.
One cargo mission wouldn't create a lunar base.
But a sequence of large deliveries could gradually transform a landing site
into something much more permanent.
And that's the bigger promise of Starship.
The crewed version answers one question.
How do we get people to the Moon?
The cargo version asks something much bigger.
How do we give them everything they need to stay?
Because landing humans on the Moon would be an extraordinary achievement.
But delivering the infrastructure that allows them to return, work,
conduct science, and eventually build something permanent
could be the real beginning of the next era of lunar exploration.
That's everything for today's episode.
If you want to take a deeper look at what the inside of Starship HLS could look like
and how the first Starship missions to the Moon could unfold,
make sure to subscribe to the channel
so you don't miss the analysis and insights you won't hear anywhere else.