Hey guys, in this video, I'm sharing my honest review of the Ritz-Carlton card after a full year of using it. We'll walk through why I decided to upgrade to the Ritz in the first place, exactly how much value I got back from the card's credits and benefits this past year, including a confession about a mistake I made with the card's biggest perk. I'll also break down why my current card setup makes it hard to get real value out of this one, and share my honest verdict on whether I'm keeping the card, canceling it, or product changing it down to something cheaper. If you've been wondering whether the Ritz-Carlton card is still worth it, how the Ritz-Carlton compares to cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve or Amex Platinum, or whether the Ritz-Carlton is actually the best hotel and lounge access card out there, this video is for you.
📚 Chapters: 00:00 The Game Plan 00:23 Why I Got It 02:06 Year-1 Value: Flight Benefits 03:16 How I Track Credits Automatically 04:36 Year-1 Value: Flight Benefits (Cont.) 06:45 Year-1 Value: Hotel Benefits 10:43 Year-1 Value: Earning Categories 11:40 Keep, Cancel, or Product Change?
The speaker provides a one-year review of the Ritz-Carlton credit card, analyzing whether its premium perks justify the annual fee. Despite benefits like airline credits and lounge access, the author concludes the card provided negative value due to their specific travel habits and the mental burden of managing too many premium accounts, leading to a decision to downgrade.
There is a lot of talk about the Ritz-Carlton card being the best hotel card out there and
even the best lounge access card after all of the nerfs that have happened over the past year or two,
but I've officially had this card for a full year and gotten to experience it
first hand obviously for that year and I have mixed feelings about it.
Today I want to walk y'all through why I got this card in the first place,
how much value it gave me in year one, and whether I plan to keep, cancel, or product change it.
So to start, why did I even get this card?
It really all started back in September of 2023 when I applied for the Marriott Boundless card.
While that card is solid, giving you Marriott Silver status and a 35,000 point free night
certificate every year to cover its $95 annual fee, I had a bigger plan for it.
At this time, I had recently gone to California to see my buddy Stan the Credit Frog, who I'm
sure a lot of you already know, had a great Marriott credit card strategy going in his own setup.
Since I didn't have another card that I was itching to go for at the time,
I thought I might as well follow his lead and start my own Marriott journey with the Boundless.
Not to mention, it also had an elevated signup bonus of 5 free nights worth up to 50,000 points
each for $5,000 spent in the first 3 months of having it, so I decided to jump on it.
Then, almost 2 years go by and I am enjoying the Boundless, but I don't necessarily feel
like it's adding a ton of value to my setup. Meanwhile, I check all of the boxes required
to be able to upgrade from the Boundless to the Ritz, those being that my card was more
than 12 months old and it had higher than a $10,000 credit limit on it. But even then,
I wasn't actually sold on the idea of the Ritz card, at least not to the degree that it seemed
that everybody else was. Heck, even in my videos back then, I mentioned how I thought the card was
overhyped. But ultimately, I obviously decided to proceed with the upgrade for 3 main reasons.
First is because I'm a YouTuber and I want to always be able to review cards from a first
person perspective, where it makes sense at least. Second, there was a lot of nervous energy about
the Ritz card soon being nerfed to the ground, so I kind of felt like it was now or never. In
hindsight, it wasn't. This card is still intact, but you know, the more experience I get with it,
the better. And third, I wanted to see if it could realistically act as my main premium travel credit
card in my setup. Now here we are, 12 months later, and it's time to see if those 3 reasons
actually paid off. To figure that out, let's get into the meat and potatoes of this video
and calculate exactly how much value I got back from the card's credits and benefits.
To set a goal here, I'm looking to get a minimum of $450 back from the card,
since that would wipe its annual fee. But in reality, I would like to get much more than
that so I'm not just breaking even and scraping by with credits to do that. And that goes for
any card by the way, not just this one. But the first place we can go, which is also the easiest
to get value back from, is the $300 airline incidental credit per calendar year. Technically,
this is only supposed to cover things like baggage fees, seat upgrades, lounge passes,
in-flight purchases, and you do have to call chase after the purchase to request reimbursement. But
from my experience using it over the last year, they've never once actually asked me what the
charge on my statement was for and they just always automatically apply whatever amount I tell
them to. And although I haven't actually done this, I would imagine that it's very easy to
use that credit for just straight up airline tickets if you really wanted to. My use case
for it has almost solely been seat upgrades for flights with really short connections that I want
to trim at the front of the plane, or for longer flights that I just want that extra legroom for.
And with that alone, I've already maxed this credit out and should easily be able to do that
again year after year if I do decide to keep it. To easily track credits just like that one,
I use today's sponsor to help me, and that is Max Rewards. Max Rewards is an all-in-one credit card
management app that allows you to track all of the important information about all of your credit
cards in one convenient interface, no matter what lender they come from. And with their free tier,
you can see all of your total reward balances, card balances, credit utilizations, bill due dates,
transactions, credit scores, and more. And you also get access to the best card tool that tells
you exactly what card to use depending on what category you're spending in, or better yet,
their exact location to take out all the guesswork. All of that is great. I've personally
paid for Max Rewards Gold for the past few years to unlock even more features, some of my favorites
being the auto-offer activation tool that's saved me hundreds of dollars over the years,
the welcome offer and retention bonus trackers, the card value tab to help me evaluate whether
or not I should be keeping or canceling cards like the one today, as well as the benefits tracker,
which I've actually recently really liked using on their new Max Rewards for desktop version,
which you should definitely check out if you haven't yet. But if you're hesitant to pay for
gold right off the bat, I don't blame you. You can try out the free version through the QR code on
screen or the link down in my description, both of which have my code Spencer attached to them.
And by doing so, you will lock in a 25% discount off of Max Rewards Gold and a 12.5% discount off
of Platinum if you ever decide to upgrade to them down the line. So definitely take them up on that.
And big thank you to Max Rewards for sponsoring this video as always, but let's jump back into it.
Sticking to the flight side of things, the most important benefit to many Brits cardholders is the
lounge access that it has. Not only does it have a Priority Pass Select membership with unlimited
visits, but it also gives Chase Sapphire lounge access for the cardholder plus two guests. And
better yet, authorized users get their own lounge access and guesting at no extra charge. Speaking
of authorized users, that in and of itself is a big benefit of this card. You get unlimited free
authorized users with it, making it technically the cheapest way to get the most lounge access
coverage for your entire family. And that's exactly what gave this card such a resurgence last year
after the Venture X had its lounge access guest policies basically neutered. But as for how that
lounge access impacts me and my travel, honestly, it doesn't. I already have the Chase Sapphire
Reserve in my setup, which nets me over $2,000 a year in value. And it gives me the exact same
thing on the lounge front with access to Chase Sapphire lounges for me and two guests and
unlimited priority pass access. The one place that it does fall really far behind, though,
is the authorized user fee, since it costs $195 per authorized user on the reserve while it is
free on the Ritz-Carlton. So that is absolutely worth considering if you need access for more
than just a couple of people. And I actually did end up taking advantage of that benefit on my Ritz
card, adding my girlfriend to it so that she has free lounge access whenever she's traveling solo
for work. However, we've just found that that's actually not really that necessary. She hasn't
used the lounge access a single time by herself, and she likely won't ever do that consistently.
So because of my Chase Sapphire Reserve, the lounge access on the Ritz, which is an absolute
game changer for some, is a moot point to me. And the only reason that I would ever actually
be able to get value from it is if I got rid of my Sapphire Reserve, which I don't currently plan
on doing. Playing a much more minor role, the Ritz also has a TSA precheck or global entry credit
every four years, which is an annualized $30 value. And that is great to have, but I actually
covered that fee for myself with my Sapphire Reserve a couple of years back and got my
girlfriend covered when I had the Venture X, so we just haven't had a need for this benefit.
But honestly, this is a great reminder that I should offer it to, you know, somebody in my
family or one of my friends to let them take advantage of it. Either way, that's not going
to actually count towards reducing my effective annual fee, and it won't likely do so in the
future either because I have other cards that will cover me and my girlfriend whenever those fees
renew. Shifting to the hotel side now, the single biggest perk that this card gives is an annual
free night certificate worth up to 85,000 points, which you can also top off with up to 25,000 more
points if you wanted to, totaling a 110,000 point per night room. This is where things get really
interesting and where I have to confess something to you guys. First, though, you need to understand
how this card is at least supposed to work. And what I mean by that is whenever you upgrade from
the boundless or whatever lower tier chase Marriott card you have to the Ritz card, you're not
supposed to get the 85,000 point free night in your first year. You generally have to wait until
after you pay your annual fee in year two. And that is a massive gripe that people have with
this card because obviously you're paying essentially $900 before you get your first
free night. Somehow, though, on complete accident, I upgraded from the boundless to the Ritz at the
perfect time, I guess right before I started my third year with the card. And for some reason,
instead of either a 35,000 point free night certificate or no free night certificate at all
being added to my account, like I expected whenever I made that upgrade, they deposited
an 85,000 point free night into my Marriott account. Theoretically, that meant that in year
one, I wouldn't have to eat any costs at all like most people do. And I could reap all of the
benefits of the card right away. But here's where the confession comes up. I unfortunately let that
free night expire. I know. I know. Throw your tomatoes at me. I deserve it. But jokes aside,
this actually confirms something that I've said about this card from the jump. If you're like me
and you normally book multi-night trips, especially if I'm going to be staying at a nice property,
like I want to enjoy it for more than one night, then the free night that comes with this card
only gets you so far. If you want to keep the rest of that stay free, you're going to be left
needing to come up with at least another 85,000 points per night on top of the one that you get
for free. And while that may be easy to do with a couple of welcome offers on Marriott cards in the
beginning, long term, that's a lot harder than it sounds with how weak the earning rates are
on Marriott's cards after accounting for the value of Marriott Bomboy points. In reality,
though, that excuse applies a lot less to me than others, since I'm fortunate to get referral
points through y'all's generous support and covering an extra couple of nights a year from
those referral points isn't a big issue for me. So in reality, I just messed up here and there's
nothing I can say about it. But whenever I try to put myself in the shoes of the average card user
who doesn't have access to those referrals, that logic is a big holdup. No matter how you feel
about what I just said, sadly, I'm going to have to put a $0 value for this in my effective annual
fee calculation, at least for year one. And while I really hope that I could find a use case for
that free night every year after this, we'll talk later about how that isn't necessarily guaranteed
and how that mistake that I just went through could easily repeat itself thanks to a big flaw
of my current credit card strategy as a whole. As for other hotel related benefits that the Ritz
card comes with, you're also going to get automatic Marriott Gold Elite status, which comes with perks
like 25% bonus points on stays, space available upgrades, late checkout, and more. And this was
actually something that we got a decent amount of value from on our trip to Italy last year,
where we got our room upgraded at the Westin Excelsior in Florence, which side note, that was
like the nicest property that we've ever stayed at. And the service was top-notch. So I would
recommend it if you have the points for it. If not, it is ridiculously expensive, but even though
it was awesome to get our room upgraded, that's not something that I would pay out of pocket for
without the card. So I wouldn't necessarily count that towards my effective annual fee calculation.
And to be honest, gold status within the US really hasn't been helpful at all. Aside from me, maybe
getting some free waters and a late checkout here and there. So while I do enjoy having it,
and I think that's part of the benefit of having a luxury card to be ultra conservative in my
valuations today, I'm going to assign a $0 value to the whole perk. Unfortunately, the same thing
applies to a few of the other core benefits of this card, like the 15 elite night credits per
year, the three Ritz Carlton club level upgrade certificates per year, and the $100 property credit
on paid stays of two plus nights at St. Regis or Ritz Carlton properties. None of those gave us
any value this year since we weren't chasing a higher status with Marriott and we didn't stay
at a Ritz Carlton hotel. And there are a lot of other smaller perks that we didn't use either,
including the JP Morgan premier concierge access, car rental status and or benefits with Avis
national and silver car and the travel and retail protections that it has as a decent infinite.
But the last major piece that I haven't gone in depth on yet that might be able to scrape us back
enough value to really justify this card is the earning categories. This card gives you a base
plus three X on dining, car rentals and airfare booked directly with the airline
and six X on Marriott hotels. Now you will probably see some reports out there telling
you that you actually get 18.5 X back on all of your Marriott purchases with this card,
but that's actually a marketing trick that basically every hotel chain likes to play.
In reality, 12.5 X worth of that actually just comes from being a Bomboy member and having gold
elite status with the card. So the base is only six X back. And while that still sounds solid at
value beating out most major credit cards out there, you have to consider that Marriott points
are generally worth a little bit less than one cent per point. So I would actually rather earn
four X chase ultimate rewards points through my Sapphire reserve on my Marriott hotel stays
instead, since I value chase points so much higher. So because of that, once again, there's
just no added value that the earning rates give me. Okay, now we've gone through everything that
this card has to offer. So let's just add it all up and see if this is a card that I should either
keep, cancel, or product change back down to something cheaper. I mean, looking at this,
I'm as surprised as you guys, but ultimately after everything that we just went through,
the only real benefit that I can point to a concrete value from is the $300 airline incidental
credit. Everything else, the lounge access, the free night certificate, gold status, club level
upgrades, property credits, earning rates, all of that landed at a $0 value for me this year,
putting me $150 in the red. That's not even close to coming out ahead, let alone just breaking even.
So does that mean that the Ritz-Carlton card is bad and that I should absolutely get rid of it?
Not necessarily. It just means that it didn't line up with my travel habits this year. But
if I look ahead, there is a real path to that effective annual fee looking a lot different.
If you really boil it down, only one thing needs to change here. I need to use the free night
certificate. Even if you value Marriott points at just 0.75 cents per point, like the points guy,
that's about $640 in value that I left on the table. So that plus the $300 airline credit
would put me way in the green. And that's before considering that I might stay at a
Ritz-Carlton where I could unlock the property credit and me potentially using the club level
upgrade certificates, which would potentially produce me a lot more value. But there's a
catch here. This would require me to actually plan around this card instead of letting it just kind
of like ride in the background. And that brings up the flaw in my strategy that I mentioned earlier.
First, I want to say that there is nothing wrong with focusing attention on a card if it's very
easy for you to do that and if it's not too much to manage. But as of right now, I have four premium
travel credit cards in my setup, the Ritz card, the Chase Sapphire Reserve, Amex Business Platinum,
and Bilt Palladium, all of which have hotel credits that I technically need to be using
to get positive value from each of those cards. The Ritz has its $85,000 point free night
certificate. The Sapphire Reserve has $500 worth of edit credits that require two, two night stays
to get full value from. The Amex Business Platinum has $600 in hotel credits split semi-annually on
top of $200 in quarterly Hilton credits. And the Palladium has $400 in hotel credits split
semi-annually once again with a two night minimum for each half. Plus I also have the IHG Premier
and Premier Business, which give me a free night certificate each. So no matter how you cut it,
that is a lot to track. And that's just on the hotel side. And even though I try to use as many
of those credits and free nights as I can, there have been plenty of times where we've taken a trip
and we've stayed at either a friend's or family member's house, or we just don't really want to
stay at a higher end property, which comes with a lot more added cost, whether that's, you know,
the parking, the food at the place, the random charges that they just seemingly like to add.
So essentially, no matter what, at least a couple of those credits or free nights are just bound to
go to waste. Be honest, though, I kind of knew this was going to happen. Going into this year,
there really weren't a ton of cards that I was excited about adding to my setup,
aside from the new built cards that we didn't know about back then. And I'm at the stage of
my game now where premium cards are really some of the only ones that intrigue me because of the
high welcome offers that they have attached. So, I mean, logically, I knew that if I kept adding
more and more of them, eventually I would get to a point where tracking all of their respective
laundry list of benefits would be too much to manage and I would have to, you know,
waste some value to keep the mental burden of managing it all down. That time just came quicker
than I thought it would. And as I look ahead, I know that I just can't justify all of these
cards long term. And when I think about which ones will make the cut, I'm honestly not too
sure that the Ritz is one of those. As I've said a few times now, as long as I have the Chase Sapphire
Reserve in my wallet, which I plan to do for the foreseeable future, I have almost no reason to
have the Ritz card. Sure, it would be great to have the free night every year, but I also don't
want to be like forced to do it. And right now I kind of feel like that's what is happening. I know,
right? Woe is me having too many benefits to use, like what a first world problem. But in our
microcosm of the internet, this kind of stuff really does matter to me. This credit card game
should not require as much time as I'm giving it to get positive value back. And you should
never change your lifestyle to fit a credit card. That's just foolish in my opinion. But I am
becoming that fool in many ways right now by forcing myself to use a free night that I obviously
don't need. I mean, Exhibit A being this past year where it just didn't come up. So with all that
said, I do think that it makes sense to probably product change this one down soon, likely all the
way to the free Marriott Bold card to save the annual fee, at least until I have more use for
the Ritz card benefits. That will not only help me get back to my roots, focusing on consolidation
and only keeping cards that give me positive value, just like I recommend you guys do, but
also it would have the side benefit of allowing me to chase a couple of signup bonuses that I can't
at the moment because of the signup bonus rules between the Chase and Amex Marriott cards, those
being the Marriott Brilliant and the supposed Marriott Brilliant Business card that we talked
about in a recent newsletter. And who knows, maybe after I get those, then I'll decide to
product change back up to the Ritz and really run this Marriott strategy how it's intended to be
run. We'll see. What do you think about that decision though? I should have a little bit of
time between this video going live and the annual fee posting. So if you think I'm making a massive
mistake, or if you think I'm making the perfect decision, just let me know down below. I want to
reiterate that this entire video is based purely on my personal use case of the card. If you didn't
get that by now, I don't know what to say, but it's very likely the case that the cons I discussed
in this video just don't apply to you. But I hope that no matter what, you were able to learn from
this one and that you'll make better decisions with your cards in the future because of it. If
you want to hear how I feel about the other 30 credit cards that I've tested over the past few
years, then go ahead and click into this video next. And as always, Odin and I really appreciate
you watching this video. If you enjoyed it, consider leaving a like, subscribing to the
channel, and checking out all the links below so that we can eat tonight. And with that said,
we'll catch you guys next time.