REPLAY: Canadian PM Carney Speaks With Reporters at United Nations Meeting

Live News Network
1.4K followers
112 Video Views·Sep 22, 2026
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney speaks with reporters on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly on Sept. 22.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCanada advocates for \"values-based realism,\" blending human rights and sustainability with pragmatic, calibrated alliances. The strategy focuses on shifting from idealistic multilateralism to flexible, problem-solving coalitions to address climate change, AI, and global security, while simultaneously investing in domestic infrastructure and strategic trade to enhance national sovereignty.
Listen, good afternoon. Thank you for taking the time, thank you for being here.
At an important time for the international system, and the world by extension,
you know, one of the shared challenges today is that we have a multilateral system
that if it fails to reflect the realities of the time, won't stand the test of that time.
But at the same time, the need for multilateral cooperation is very much alive.
The post-war world is ending, but the underlying logic of that post-war world
that justified multilateral cooperation is more compelling than ever.
Climate emergency is intensifying. AI advancing faster than our capacity to control it.
Pandemics spreading across continents in weeks.
Financial shocks can disrupt markets and economies in hours.
Armed conflicts destabilizing entire regions, forcing millions to flee from their homes.
Global checkpoints paralyzing supply chains.
And no country, no one country, no matter how powerful, can manage these challenges alone.
Cooperation, therefore, is not an act of idealism. It is a practical necessity.
And the question is not whether multilateralism can survive,
but how it must evolve to meet the challenges of the moment.
This is, in many respects, a time that comes once or twice every century.
A moment in which our collective prosperity is defined by what we choose to build and how we build it.
So what comes ahead, it's not wishful multilateralism, which defends only the status quo,
nor a cold realpolitik that dismantles the status quo altogether.
And the alternative that Canada and many others are pursuing is values-based realism.
An approach that's both principled and pragmatic.
Principled in the commitment to the fundamental values of freedom, human rights, human dignity, sustainability, solidarity.
Pragmatic in recognizing that not every partner will share all of those values.
Put simply, we're in a position where we need to pursue calibrated alliances,
integrating deeply with those countries who share our values,
remaining open-eyed with those who do not.
It means actively, actively taking on the world as it is, not passively waiting for a world we wish to be.
It means engaging with the reality that progress can sometimes be incremental and that interests often diverge.
It requires focusing our efforts to work together where and with those where we are aligned
and where we can make the greatest impact.
Progress can be signaled through monologue, only achieved through dialogue and action.
And we're demonstrating aspects of this focus this week at the 81st session of the UN General Assembly.
Le Canada croit à la coopération. Dans un monde fragmenté, la coopération n'est pas une idéale, c'est une nécessité.
Il y a cinq jours, à Strasbourg, j'ai présenté les arguments du Canada en faveur d'une alliance pour l'avenir avec l'Union européenne.
Une alliance suffisamment ouverte pour que d'autres puissent s'y joindre.
Notre objectif n'est pas l'autosuffisance, c'est la résilience collective.
C'est dans ce même esprit que nous avons lancé la coalition partenaire pour le Montréalisme.
Ce n'est pas une autre bloc ou une autre bureaucratie.
C'est un nouveau forum qui fait le point entre les institutions universelles,
les coalitions pratiques et les capacités qui existent au-delà du gouvernement.
Il permettra de bâtir la confiance, de réunir ceux qui sont prêts à agir
et d'accélérer le développement de solutions promoteuses qui pourraient ultimement
et en tout légitimité être déployées à plus grande échelle.
Différemment, le Canada sait que l'action internationale n'a pas besoin d'unanimité.
Les Etats avec des intérêts communs peuvent avancer les priorités communes auxquelles d'autres peuvent s'y joindre
si la valeur devient plus évidente.
Le succès est le succès, juste comme la virtu est la virtu.
Ce soir, en partenariat avec les premiers ministres du Royaume-Uni,
le président de la France et le secrétaire général,
I will co-host a meeting on two-state solution and the implementation of Security Council Resolution 2803 in Gaza.
Immense human suffering continues.
Next door, Israelis continue to live with existential threats from Hamas and from Iran and its proxies.
A long-held international consensus for a two-state solution,
a consensus held by every one of my predecessors since the formation of this organization.
That long-held consensus will mean nothing if these conditions continue,
and so Canada is doing what it can to help change the trajectory.
To that end is one part.
I'm announcing $100 million in international assistance for Palestine,
$80 million of which is for humanitarian aid to alleviate immediate human suffering
and $20 million to support peace and security capacity building,
including our leadership of police training in the West Bank.
Canada and our partners recognize the direct threat to peace
posed by the Israeli government's endorsement of the E1 settlement scheme.
And with reluctance, we have announced our intention to bring forward trade restrictions
targeting goods produced in those illegal Israeli settlements.
This is a pragmatic, practical action that works towards the preservation of the possibility
of a two-state solution and ultimately a durable peace for Israelis and Palestinians.
Canada believes in sustainable development.
It also believes that we have a responsibility to protect our common heritage.
As co-chair of the Ocean Eyes Alliance,
I have joined the President of the European Commission
to guide our partners around a clearer and more common vision of the oceans on which we all depend.
It is essential to make the seas safer, to ensure the sustainability of the ocean economy
and to preserve the stability of the climate.
We cannot protect what we cannot observe.
This is why Canada is investing $80 million to strengthen global ocean observation.
This is also why we have just ratified the High Sea Treaty
to ensure the protection of international waters that cover almost half of the planet.
Next year, Canada will host the Conference of our Oceans,
which will bring together governments, indigenous leaders, scientists and coastal communities
around the same objective of moving from ambition to action
to protect our oceans and ensure their durability.
Our partners are working with Canada because Canada is predictable, reliable and principled
in a world that is anything but.
We are applying our principles in groups, sometimes small,
with groups formed around problems rather than geography or size.
This variable geometry not as an alternative to multilateralism but as an instrument of it.
In short, building trust, improving what works with those who are ready to act now
and bringing it back to the multilateral system to be strengthened, to be broadened and to be scaled.
The real choice is not between trying to preserve an international order established after the Second World War
or abandoning it.
As the sixth largest donor to the UN and a values-based realist,
Canada will continue to work in all fora to advance and to deliver for our citizens
the dignity, peace, sustainability and prosperity that they deserve.
And with that, I'd be pleased to take your questions.
Hello, Mr. Carney, Laurence Martin from Radio-Canada.
Donald Trump said today in his speech that he was thinking of destroying Iran and the Iranian regime.
In the very spirit of the UN, which is an institution whose mandate is to maintain peace,
what are your thoughts on that?
My first thought is that the Iranian threat is one of the biggest threats in the world today.
For example, there is still an existential threat to Israel posed by Iran and its allies.
It still exists.
It's not acceptable, and it will never be acceptable, that Iran has a nuclear strike force.
What is important is to try to work in a way consistent with international law in order to resolve this situation.
There is a war going on right now, that's clear.
And Canada is trying to work with regional partners, with the United States, with European leaders,
in order to create conditions for a ceasefire.
That's not the case right now.
The situation is very serious right now.
And we will continue to try to assist in a more peaceful solution.
But do you think that Mr. Trump is going too far when he says that his dream is to destroy Iran?
Do you think it helps the peace process?
There is a war right now.
Hi Prime Minister, Tom Carey from CBC.
I'd like to ask you a domestic question first on Bill C-39.
The Assembly of First Nations is warning that it could impact Indigenous rights.
UNIFOR is saying it could infringe on the right to strike.
I'd like to get your response to that.
I'd also like to ask you specifically, part of what the bill does, as I understand it,
is it removes a sunset clause that was in Bill C-5.
That would have limited a minister's extraordinary powers for approving a given project.
Why did you think it was necessary to get rid of that sunset clause?
Let's go back to first principles, and then I'll answer your questions, Tom.
The government was elected on a very clear mandate, which is to build Canada strong.
We used to build in this country.
Well, we used to build in Canada.
I'm representing this room as Canada.
We used to build in Canada.
We used to build big.
We used to build in a way that brought the whole country forward.
And we used to build strategic infrastructure.
So St. Lawrence Seaway, the original building of the ports.
Of course, you can go all the way back to Confederation, just after Confederation,
and the Canadian Pacific Railway as examples.
Decade after decade, year after year, we built less.
We added more and more restrictions, effective restrictions.
Well-meaning, but effective restrictions on building.
Duplication, parallel processes, enormous cost,
and effectively became ineffective in terms of our capital investment.
We identified that issue at a time of great risk for our country
when our sovereignty was threatened and, to some degree, continues to be threatened.
We're very clear that we will focus on what we can control.
And first and foremost, controlling is to build at home, build Canada strong,
build in a way that builds for all.
Now, building for all means several things.
It means building in partnership with labor, in solidarity with labor.
That's why we have Team Canada Strong.
That's why we're building apprenticeships.
It means building inclusively with indigenous people in all aspects of building.
Consultation at the start, partnership throughout, including, in many cases, ownership and other positions,
and building where we can as much as possible sustainably,
so taking into account environmental impacts, environmental results, in all aspects of building.
None of that is about time.
The problem is about time.
In fact, time in our country became such an issue that it helped us stop building.
It meant that we stopped building.
That's not good for Canadian independence.
It's not good for Canadian workers.
It means fewer jobs.
It means more expensive life for Canadian families.
It means fewer opportunities for our children.
This government was elected to turn that around.
The first thing we did was to focus on, as you referenced in so-called default, what's called Bill C-5,
is on nation-building projects, projects that have huge cross-Canada impacts,
so key port infrastructure, Contre-Coeur, which is now under construction,
Mackenzie Valley Highway, something that has existed my entire life
but is only now being built because of this government, because of C-5,
clean electricity grids, northern B.C., north coast transmission line, which is now being built,
now shovels in the ground, so unlocking that.
Now, in that process, for those, it's very clear in the bill,
the consultation process to designate something as those rules applying
and then the conditions associated with the project as it's actually built.
One example of those conditions is indigenous, I'll say it, participation.
It can be ownership.
It can be in the building.
It can be in the operating.
It can be other aspects, community infrastructure, other things.
Those conditions, environmental conditions would be another example,
labor conditions, another example.
What we're finding with 27 initiatives that have the potential to catalyze 200 billion of investment
and 300,000 jobs, 300,000 jobs in Canada, over 300,000, that's working.
Initiatives are coming.
The focus is there.
You saw the other side of the equation.
Forget about foreign investors and international investors at the investment summit last week.
Canadian financial institutions put up more than $400 billion for additional Canadian investment,
new Canadian investment.
So that process is working.
So we see a value.
Parliament will decide.
We see a value in making that permanent.
Now let's go to the specifics around Bill C-39, which is in the same spirit, which is decision delayed is a project denied.
If you're going to say no to a project decided within a year, one project, one review, one year,
it's making the federal government decisions much more efficient.
A lead decider, a lead regulator, not multiple ones that decide after each other,
that ask for different information or the same information but won't use it.
I mean this is literally what happens.
I use the example of, Minister McKinnon might have used this example,
but one of the things that struck me when I came into government was Lake Magantic, which was a disaster.
I mean this is a tragedy.
And 13 years later, it's just been approved, the bypass.
That's not building.
That's not protecting Canadians.
That's not serving Canadians.
And that's what this bill is designed to do.
And last point, consistent with building in solidarity with workers, it absolutely reinforces the right to strike.
And alongside that, the responsibility of employers and unions, not employers, to negotiate in good faith.
And it creates transparency around those negotiating processes.
In the most strategic parts of our economy, the railroads, the ports, the airlines,
that there is transparency around it and there's real guardrails.
Because we know, workers know as well, that the best deals are struck at the bargaining table.
So we want people at the bargaining table in these strategic sectors.
And we want to build Canada strong.
That's what Canadians elected us for.
And that's what we look to do.
Thank you.
If I could just ask on a different topic, on the summit today, on the UN General Assembly,
we heard two very different messages today from the outgoing Secretary General and from U.S. President Donald Trump.
So I'm wondering, when you hear António Guterres talking about rule of law and reining in AI,
and you hear Donald Trump saying the opposite, I'm wondering which side,
who's winning this argument right now when you speak to other global leaders?
Well, I think I would start with speaking with citizens and their concerns, their very real concerns.
I would then go to speaking with those who are running the Frontier Labs
and their real and fully informed concerns about the risks around AI and a fully deregulated,
which is what the system effectively we have now, development of AI.
I would go to this Canadian press conference.
I'll go to resident expertise in Canada, Joshua Bengio, Law Zero,
the true understanding of how it's possible to have safety protocols that are consistent with building AI out to serve our citizens.
I mean, the tremendous promise of AI.
And the two go together.
Maybe I'm a prisoner of my past here, but the financial sector is an incredibly powerful tool.
It brings great prosperity.
But without regulation, it consistently, episodically will bring depressions and crisis.
So two things are true at the same time.
These are different risks in AI, but the analogy holds.
And I would say that it is the view, I think, I would say, of many citizens in terms of the concerns here,
of those who are closest to the technology, they share those concerns.
I mean, you had in quick succession, Dario Amedai, Sam Altman, Elon Musk, asking for some form of oversight.
And it is, in my experience, and the conversations I've had in recent weeks,
also the view of a number of world leaders, and I share those views.
Kelly Malone in the back of the room from the Canadian press.
European leaders are increasingly raising the alarm about the prospect Russia may attack NATO countries helping Ukraine.
What's your assessment of the potential risk based on intelligence you have available and the conversations you've had with allies?
And have you responded by giving instructions within government to prepare for potential new or imminent threats against Canada?
The threat level from Russia has been so-called hybrid threats, has been high for a period of time.
Appropriate instructions were given, have been given, and are still offerable.
We're in complete and open conversation with our European allies, our Five Eyes partners, about those threats.
We have extreme vigilance and we'll continue to do the case.
I'm not going to comment on day-to-day ships at that time.
In French, there are serious threats coming from Russia in terms of NATO members' assets.
And for a long time, there have been recommendations, orders, in fact, to have vigilance for the forces,
and I use the word the forces, the civil force, the Canadian forces, to protect Canadian assets, NATO assets.
I'm not talking about changes in the level of threats coming from Russia day by day.
But are you concerned about any potential links to extremist ideas within the military?
I'm not going to comment on any aspect of that situation beyond to express again the gratitude,
and the gratitude to Constable Jeff Smith for his heroic actions.
Other Constable involved in those heroic actions, the best wishes for his recovery are solidarity with his family,
his friends, his colleagues, the members of the Sons of Jacob community,
the broad members, of course, those who were there on the holiest night of the Jewish calendar,
but also more broadly, and the community as a whole of Belvoir.
We stand absolutely in solidarity.
We stand against all manifestations of hate against communities and condemn this violence,
and no effort will be spared from the federal government perspective and also local law enforcement
in the investigation and prosecution of if there is additional aspects that need to be taken.
Thank you.
Good afternoon, Prime Minister. Jerry Sherry, CTV News.
You had several bilateral meetings today,
but have you had a chance to speak to U.S. President Donald Trump since being in New York,
or any member of the U.S. administration?
I find that when you have 160 leaders come to New York,
that it's most valuable to meet those who you don't normally see.
That's what I did last year at the General Assembly,
and that's what I always intended to do here.
I'd like to talk to you on potash.
The President said recently that he'd consider getting potash from Belarus.
Today, in speaking with President Zelensky, he said he'd like to get it cheaper,
but will continue to buy it from Canada.
What do you make of it, and what's your message to people in the industry in Canada that may be concerned?
First, my message to the Canadian potash industry is one of admiration.
Canada supplies 40% of the world's potash.
It is an incredible strength of our economy.
There's continual innovation.
Currently, the Janssen mine is under construction.
It's, I believe, the largest – I'll qualify it – one of the largest potash mines in the world.
So, incredibly productive, and a real Canadian strength.
In demand, absolutely around the world, because guess what?
Canada is a reliable, cost-competitive supplier.
I'll go back to earlier questions about our supply chain legislation, this Bill C-39.
Part of that is planning for the future, so that we can continue to have the capacity to be a reliable supplier.
We supply 80% of – 75%, I think, of U.S. consumption of potash on time, most cost-effective.
We'll continue to do it, and I'd go further.
I think that there is a real opportunity, if we so choose,
and it's one of many, many opportunities that Canada and the United States have
to cooperate and to become fertilizer independent.
So, not just potash, but across all ammonia and other fertilizers.
That would be good for Canadian farmers.
It would be great for American farmers.
And it's an opportunity we're prepared to explore.
Thank you.
Oh, I'm sorry.
I'll try and do rapid-fire.
Hi, Prime Minister.
Mackenzie Gray with Global News.
I just want to go back to something you said to Tom earlier,
that you have a very clear mandate, which is to build.
I went back and looked at your platform today on some of the big things
that you have been proposing over the last few days,
things like joining the European Union as an associate member,
things like privatizing airports, things like some of the labor changes in there.
These were not things that were discussed during the election.
Do you think you have a mandate to move forward with those key things
that you've been proposing over the last few days?
The short answer is yes.
We have a mandate to build Canada strong, to diversify our partnerships,
to make Canada stronger, more independent, more resilient.
All of those aspects are doing so.
The House of Commons passed Budget 2025.
It explicitly said in Budget 2025 we're going to look at ownership options for airports.
The House of Commons passed the relevant components of the spring update,
where we, again, made clear that we were looking for the options there.
And developing an alliance for the future with the European Union,
which is based on Canada becoming more solid,
building on our strengths from critical minerals to energy to space-based technologies,
being truly sovereign in a variety of technologies, that's good for Canada.
That makes us stronger.
That will create opportunities for Canadians,
create huge opportunities for young Canadians.
So, yes, it's absolutely on.
And all of these cases, in all of these cases, to be clear,
Parliament, there's a reason why we send MPs to Parliament.
Things change over the life of a Parliament,
the four-year life of a, at least, theoretical life of a Parliament.
Things change.
And we expect our MPs, myself included, to react to those events,
to work together in the best interests of the country,
to vote with their conscience and decide.
So these decisions will be subject to parliamentary approval.
Four-year theoretical life of a Parliament.
Well, I mean, four years is, that's the fixed election date gives you four years.
I mean, I'm just observing that.
It's not nothing.
But can we have the other questions in time?
Yeah.
Est-ce qu'on peut finir des questions en bas?
Hi, Prime Minister.
Chris Rennes, CBC.
Just a question.
With President Xi meeting President Trump,
the White House and President Trump has been very critical of Canada
re-establishing commercial ties with China and so on.
What do you make of the meeting this week?
And I'm just looking for your thoughts, please.
Well, the United States has far deeper cooperation with China than Canada does.
The United States has far deeper cooperation today
in some of the most important strategic technologies on the planet with China
than Canada does.
That's an observation.
Thank you.
Rachel Haynes from CTV News.
I'll just follow up on my colleague Chris.
As you're talking about President Xi coming,
I'd like to also talk about our ties with India.
When will Prime Minister Modi be coming to Canada
and how close are we to a free trade deal with India?
Thank you.
We are making good progress in our trade negotiations with India.
It is an exceptionally important relationship on many, many levels,
people-to-people levels, security levels, and also trade and economic.
Our commitment to each other, Prime Minister Modi and myself,
last year at the G20 was to look to conclude negotiations by the G20 this year.
G20, from memory, is the middle of December, 14th, 15th of December.
I believe that India has – I believe India just confirmed
that the Prime Minister will be visiting Canada around that time.
The precise date isn't out, but I very much look forward to hosting him.
Yes.
Yes, okay.
We have a lot of elections in Canada,
and we have received a mandate to build a stronger, more independent, more resilient Canada.
We want to diversify our partnerships globally.
As you know, we have signed 20 economic security partnerships.
We will continue with India, with NASA, and with the European Union.
It's an alliance, it's different, but deep down there is a commercial aspect,
and deep down there is an aspect that will make Canada more sovereign, more independent,
more prosperous, more sustainable, I believe.
But we'll see, okay?
Parliament is an example.
And as far as projects in Canada are concerned, infrastructure,
yes, we talked about all of that during the campaign.
You were there every day, building a stronger Canada.
Okay, what do we have to build?
Okay?
In Canada, we were used to building.
And the Canadians, the Canadians have decided,
the elected government that will build a country.
And even in the partials, we just had partials in Quebec,
in Ontario, in Columbia, in British Columbia.
Every year, more than 50% of the votes in each partial
for a government that will build a stronger Canada.
Final point.
We have MPs in Parliament for reasons.
We have to vote for things.
Budgets.
Initiatives were in the budget, the budget of 2025.
For example, airports.
I have another meeting, sorry.
And then there will be a vote in the future for the European Union.
There is a job for MPs.
We have to work.
And we have to understand that we are in a situation with great challenges
and with great opportunities.
We have to seize the opportunities now.
We have to change.
We have to strengthen.
We have a strategy that, in my opinion,
has already made our country stronger.
But we have just started.
So we have to strengthen the strategy.
We are doing it with C39.
We are doing it with possible partnerships,
possible alliances with the European Union.
We are going to do it with the agreement with Lannes.
We have to continue.
Okay.
Thank you very much.
Thank you, Madam.
