What’s Going On With PFF???
2 Video Views·Sep 21, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Normally each week I put together a video and I tweet out the highest graded Jets players by
Pro Football Focus, by PFF, and I don't think I'm going to do that this week. It's a nuanced
conversation and I've long been a defender of PFF and we can get into the specifics of
why I might be changing my tune on that. But the sticking point for me this week
was David Bailey's grade and the nonsensical process that PFF seems to have taken
because it just does not make any sense. Let's talk about it.
Originally PFF gave David Bailey a 57.0 PFF grade for his week two performance against the Packers
and that was largely because of his coverage grade which was in the 40s. It was the lowest
on the entire Jets roster and that was basically because of one play where he dropped back into
coverage and essentially was responsible for trying to defend a Christian Watson crosser
that went for 20 yards and that was a very difficult situation to put Bailey in.
But because of that one play he had a coverage grade in the 40s and his overall grade dropped
to a 57, but that's been changed. I was as great as of Monday morning and then I checked back a
couple of hours and I was surprised to see that David Bailey now has an 82.8 PFF grade, which is
I believe among the highest of all defensive linemen, all interior and edge players in the
entire NFL in week two. In fact, his coverage grade, which again was previously in the 40s
as the lowest on the Jets roster is now a 92.3, which makes him the highest graded coverage
rusher in the NFL in week two. How did that happen? Bailey only played five coverage snaps,
so this is a very small sample size, but you'd probably think with this large of a change in his
grade, probably PFF went back and said, Oh, actually he did allow another catch. Like maybe
he was in a situation in zone coverage where PFF previously didn't think that he was responsible
for allowing that catch. And now they do. Nope, nothing changed there. He still has allowed one
catch for 20 yards on one target, nothing with his stats. Essentially multiple evaluators,
obviously a PFF, if they're real humans, even doing this at this point, looked at that David
Bailey play. And one of them thought it was bad enough that he was the worst graded coverage
player on the Jets. And the other thought it was good enough that he was the best graded coverage
edge rusher in the NFL. That large of a discrepancy is why his grade went from a 57 to an 83.
Listen, I have long been a PFF defender. While their grades have always been kind of hit or miss
and subjective at the end of the day, I still think their statistical database is one of the
best in the business. Specifically, I think their coverage stats are the best of any site
out there, but their grades are becoming increasingly unusable and nonsensical.
Look, I know it's not Jets related, but Dallas Turner of the Minnesota Vikings had 11 pressures,
two sacks, two QB hits and seven hurries in week two. Do you notice PFF grade was
a 48.8 and you're like, Oh, maybe it's his run defense. Nope. Pass rush grade 51.3. I mean,
what are we doing? I don't know what's going on over there at PFF. I know they've let a lot of
talented people go and I don't want to jump to conclusions, but it does feel like their grades
have become increasingly unreliable and inconsistent and nonsensical. And the David
Bailey thing just jumped the shark for me because how does something like that even happen?

