There are suburbs in Utah where people are paying a premium for a story that stopped being true about four years ago. And there are suburbs in this state almost nobody outside of Utah has heard of, where you can buy the exact same lifestyle for a whole lot less money.
Today I am naming both. The five most underrated suburbs in Utah, the five most overrated. And I want to be clear about what overrated means before we start, because I am going to get comments about this. Overrated does not mean bad. Every single place on the second half of this list is a genuinely nice place with genuinely happy people living in it, and I have clients I care about in all five. Overrated means the gap between what people believe they are buying and what they are actually paying for has gotten too wide. That is a math problem, not an insult. Coming from the top Utah real estate agent, Scott Steele, the best realtor in Utah to help you find the best places to live in Utah based on your pros and cons of living in Utah.
Real estate expert Scott Steele analyzes the Utah housing market, distinguishing between \"overrated\" areas where prices exceed utility and \"underrated\" gems offering similar lifestyles for less. He encourages buyers to prioritize structural integrity and actual geography over zip code reputation and aesthetic staging to find genuine value.
There are suburbs in Utah where people are paying a premium for a story that stopped
being true about four years ago.
And there are suburbs in this state almost nobody else outside of Utah has even heard
of where you can buy the exact same lifestyle for a whole lot less money.
And today I'm naming both the five most underrated suburbs in Utah and the five most overrated
as well.
And I want to be clear about what overrated means before we even start because I'm going
to get comments about this.
First, overrated does not mean bad.
Every single place on the second half of this list is a genuinely nice place with genuinely
happy people living within it.
And I have clients that I care about in all five.
Overrated means the gap between what people believe they're buying and what they are actually
paying for has gotten a little too wide.
That is the math problem.
It's not an insult.
And here's why I'm making this.
There is an enormous amount of information out there about where to live in Utah.
A lot of it is really confusing.
Some of it is three years stale and a good chunk of it was written by somebody who happens
to have a house for sale in the exact neighborhood that they are recommending.
So I put this together to make it simpler and to say the parts most people in my business
will not say on camera.
For each of these 10, I will give you what is actually there, the honest trade-offs and
who it is right for and who it is wrong for because none of these places are good or bad
in a vacuum.
They are good or bad for a specific person with a specific commute and a specific budget
with a specific lifestyle.
And my job for the next half hour is to help you figure out which of those people you are.
And I will tell you right now, the most overrated one is Last.
It is the one that I expect to catch the most heat for.
And it is a place that I love and sell real estate in every single month.
That is what makes it worth saying out loud.
So stick around for that last one.
Let me show you what is really going on out there in Utah.
And real quick.
So you know who's talking.
I'm Scott Steele and I lead the Steele Group here in Utah.
And I spend my weeks and days helping people navigate exactly this decision.
Folks coming from California, from Texas, the Pacific Northwest, the East Coast, all
over the country, plus plenty of locals moving from one part of the state to another.
And before real estate, I spent years in construction.
So I tend to look at a place a little differently than most real estate agents do.
I'm not just looking at the drone shots or the finished basement or the beautiful listing
photos.
I'm thinking about what is behind those walls.
How are those systems really working?
Where the water comes from and where the traffic actually goes at five o'clock.
That shows up in all 10 of these.
Here's what I believe.
And it runs underneath the whole video.
In Utah right now, price and value have come apart in specific places.
There are areas where the hype arrived before the infrastructure did.
And the price followed the hype instead of the reality.
And there are areas sitting on genuinely great geography that nobody even talks about.
So the price never caught up.
Both of those gaps are temporary and both are worth real money to you if you can see
them first.
The five most underrated, a couple of which relocators do not even scroll far enough to
find.
Then I flip it and give you the five most overrated in ascending order, ending with
the one that is going to light up the comments.
And watch for something as we go, because it is not an accident.
Almost every overrated place on my list has an underrated one sitting practically next
door to it.
The same mountains, the same access, wildly different prices.
Once you see that pattern, you cannot unsee it.
All right, grab something to write on.
Number one on the underrated list is a place that you have absolutely driven through and
never once considered.
Number one is Sandy.
And I already know some of you just made a face.
That is exactly why it is on this list.
Look at Sandy on a map instead of in your head.
It sits directly between Cottonwood Heights and Draper, two of the most talked about and
most expensive suburbs in Salt Lake County with nearly identical geography to both.
From the east benches above Wasatch Boulevard, you are 10 to 15 minutes from the mouth of
Little Cottonwood Canyon, worst case.
Now, that is the same Alta and Snowbird access that people pay a serious premium for one
city to the north.
You have Dimpledale, a massive open space canyon running right through the middle of
the city with miles of trails within it.
And I would bet most people watching who do not live in Sandy have never even heard of
it.
Bell Canyon straight up off of the benches, Alta View Hospital, the shops at Southtown
Tracks and easy access to both I-15 and 9400 South and the MLS Soccer Stadium, everything
that Sandy provides.
And the lots are real lots.
This was built in an era where you still got a yard with the purchase of a home.
Now here's the problem.
Sandy has an image problem, not a fundamentals problem, and the image problems take a long
time to fix.
It reads as generic and the State Street and 700 East corridors are busy and not pretty.
The housing stock is mostly 1970s through 1980s or 90s.
And for me, that is the whole conversation.
That age means furnaces and water heaters are at the end of their useful life.
Aluminum branch wiring in some specific areas in some specific neighborhoods, polybutylene
supply lines and others, clay and cast iron laterals on the older streets, early aluminum
windows.
None of it is a deal breaker.
All of it is money and you want that number before you write the offer, not after.
The other thing is that Sandy is big and uneven.
A home on the bench east of Wasatch Boulevard and a home on the far west side are completely
different purchases at completely different prices in totally different cities, even though
it technically is.
So an average home price in Sandy on a website is telling you almost nothing at all.
So who is Sandy for?
The buyer who wants Canyon access, a serious trail system, a hospital and real shopping
nearby, and actual square footage on an actual lot.
And who does not want to pay the Cottonwood Heights or Draper premium for functionally
the same position on the map.
You buy location and structure, then put your money into the house instead of into the reputation
of the zip code.
If you need new construction or an address that impresses people at dinner, this might
not be it.
Although there are areas that do impress.
Absolutely.
If you want the most access per dollar in Salt Lake County, Sandy is quietly the best
value in the valley.
If you ask me now, hold that idea, paying for access instead of paying for a name, because
number two takes it about 35 miles to the north to a place that most people move here.
Never scroll far enough to even see.
Okay, quick thing before number two, somewhere in this video, I'm going to name your city
and you are either going to nod or you're going to be furious with me.
Either way, put it in the comments.
Tell me which one I got wrong and why or tell me the suburb that you want me to judge next.
I read these comments and they decide what videos I make next.
Half of the videos on this channel exist because somebody argued with me in the comment section
or left a really thoughtful comment.
So, pile on, and if this is already useful, hit that subscribe button so you catch the
deep dives as I do them one by one.
Okay, moving on, number two.
Okay, the number two most underrated suburb or area in the state of Utah is Ogden, 35
miles north of Salt Lake City, and I would guess most people relocating to this state
never scroll that far up the map.
Their loss can be your gain.
Start with the town.
Historic 25th Street is one of the best preserved downtown blocks in Utah with real food and
music scene.
With a real food and music scene, not a manufactured one.
The East Bench sits directly under Mount Ogden with trails coming off the back of neighborhoods
so you walk out your door and you are on the dirt.
Ogden Canyon puts you about 15 minutes from Pineview and the Ogden Valley, and from there
you have Snow Basin, which hosted the Olympic downhill event, Powder Mountain, one of the
largest skiable acreages in the country and in the middle of a very, very private expansion
right now, and Nordic Valley, three resorts inside about 45 minutes.
Frontrunner runs from Ogden straight into downtown Salt Lake City, so a Salt Lake City
job is possible without ever driving I-15.
Weber State and the hospital systems are large, stable employment anchors, and the historic
housing is real architecture, brick, craftsmen, Victorian, detail that you cannot buy at any
price right now.
Now, here's the flip side.
There are three honest things.
One, it is a commute if your work is in Salt Lake City.
Call it 40 to 45, maybe 50 minutes in the car depending on the hour, and Frontrunner
is excellent, but you are on its schedule, not yours.
If you have young kids and daycare pickup, run that math before you fall in love.
Number two, the housing is genuinely older, and old in Ogden means the whole list.
Now, there are beautiful new suburbs to the west of Ogden.
We can talk about that in other videos, so you have options in both directions.
But Ogden means the whole list here, settled foundations, knob and tube remnants, galvanized
supply lines, clay laterals, and unreinforced masonry in some neighborhoods, which matters
more than most of the country because we sit on the Wasatch Fault.
I love these homes.
I also walk through them completely differently than a 2005 build.
And then number three, and people get this wrong, the Ogden Valley side, Eden and Huntsville
up and around Powder Mountain and Pineview Reservoir is no longer the bargain.
The value is in the city and on the bench down near Ogden, not up in the canyon.
So who is Ogden for?
The remote worker, the family that skis a lot and refuses to pay Cottonwood Heights
or Park City prices to do it.
Anybody who wants real architecture and immediate mountain access and is willing to be 35 miles
north of Salt Lake City.
Dollar for dollar.
It is the best mountain access in Utah and it is not particularly close.
If you have to be in a downtown Salt Lake City office at eight o'clock every morning,
this might not be your answer and I will not pretend otherwise.
That is the north end.
Next, I'm taking you to the far other end of the Wasatch Front to a town that has held
onto something almost nobody down there has managed to keep.
But first, one quick pause because it changes how useful the rest of this video is to you.
Let me actually stop and introduce myself properly since you have stuck with me this
far and we're about to get into the good stuff.
I'm Scott Steele and I lead the Steele Group here in Utah and my team and I would love
to be your real estate resource of choice.
We help people just like you every single day with real buyers, real sellers across
and all throughout the state of Utah.
So when I tell you that a suburb is underpriced or overpriced, that is not coming from a blog
post or a national ranking.
It is coming from being on those streets every single day, every single week, writing offers
at those numbers.
And because I came out of construction before I ever sold a home, I'm usually the guy that
people bring along to figure out whether a home or a whole area is as good as it looks
once you get past the staging and the photos.
And stay with me too, because there is a problem that a lot of you watching have and have not
yet realized.
And I'll get to that at the end of the video.
And here's something that will help you if you are taking this comparison seriously.
Picking between these areas is not about the vibe.
It is property tax differences, county to county.
It is secondary water versus culinary water, which trips up almost every out-of-state buyer
that I work with.
It is school district boundaries.
It is which commute corridor you're going to sit in every single morning along the Wasatch
Front.
I put all of that into a free Utah relocation guide that lays it out side by side.
It is the exact resource that I send all of my own relocation clients before their first
visit.
The link for that is in the description below.
It is free.
It's an app that you can download and save on the home screen of your phone, just like
any other app.
And if you are comparing the 10 places in this video, it will save you an enormous amount
of guessing.
All right, moving on.
Number three, and this one is for the people who want land.
All right, number three is Salem, down in the south end of Utah County, past Spanish
Fork, sitting under Loefer Mountain.
Well, Salem is the answer to a question that a lot of people ask me and then get talked
out of, which is whether you can still get real land at a normal person's price along
the Wasatch Front.
In the north end of Utah County, honestly, it might be a no.
Down here in the southern half, yes, Salem still has bigger lots.
It still has horse property.
It still has water shares attached to some parcels.
And it has grown without erasing what it was.
Salem Pond sits right in the middle of town with a park and a trail around it, which is
a genuinely lovely anchor.
You are about 10 minutes from Spanish Fork, 25 minutes from Provo, and right where the
canyon country starts at the south end of the valley.
So if your picture of Utah involves a garden, a shop, maybe some animals, and a mountain
out the kitchen window, this is one of the last places that picture is still affordable.
And next, we're going to talk about four things and take the first one seriously.
One is distance is the entire conversation.
Salem to downtown Salt Lake City is roughly an hour to an hour and 10 minutes, each way
in normal conditions.
And worse, when the weather turns.
If that is your commute, you will hate your life within a year.
I've watched it happen over and over.
Number two, amenities are thin by design.
Your grocery run and your big box shopping are in Spanish Fork or Payson, which is a
10 to 15 minute drive.
That is the trade that you make for the quiet.
Number three, water.
And this is the big one.
This is exactly the geography where secondary water, pressurized irrigation, water shares,
and irrigation company rules matter the most.
I have watched out of state buyers close on an acre without water and only later find
out what they actually bought and what they are allowed to do with it.
Have somebody read the water before you write the offer, not during the due diligence.
Number four, air quality during winter inversion events down here is real and you should look
at it with real information rather than discovering it in January or February.
So who is Salem for?
The buyer who wants land, space, and a small town at a real price break from the north
end of the county or up in Salt Lake City, and whose job is either in the south end of
the valley or does not care where they live at all.
For remote workers especially, this is one of the best trades available in Utah right
now.
If you are commuting north every single day, maybe cross it off.
If you are not, it is a completely different life than what the same money buys you 30
minutes up the freeway.
Okay, now stay in Utah County with me because number four is a city that everybody in this
state has an opinion about, and I think almost all of those opinions are about 15 years out
of date.
All right, the number four most underrated city in the state of Utah is Provo.
And I know, everybody treats Provo as the college town that you drive through on the
way to something newer.
Go look at what is actually there right now.
In fact, Provo was just named as the best run city in the entire country.
If you start downtown on Center Street because it has quietly turned into one of the more
interesting downtowns in the state, there are something like 79 restaurants down there
and essentially everyone is locally owned because the historic buildings favor independent
operators over chains.
That is not an accident.
It is a structure and it is why the place has character that you cannot manufacture
in a new development.
You have the Covey Center for the Arts, the Convention Center, hotels, the rooftop concert
series in the summer.
Then the geography.
Provo Canyon is right there.
Bridal Veil Falls, the Provo River, Sundance right up the road and Rock Canyon going straight
up off of the bench with an excellent trail system.
Then the jobs, which is what people miss completely.
BYU, the hospital corridor, new skin and a tech economy that no longer stops at the
point of the mountain.
And the housing.
The historic neighborhoods near downtown have real architecture and character.
Brick bungalows, deep lots, mature trees, streets that took 90 years to look like that.
Now here's the flip side.
Here's where you need a local and I mean that more in Provo than anywhere else in this
video.
Number one, the student housing dynamic is real and it is intensely geographic.
There are blocks near campus and along certain corridors that are heavily rental and turn
over every single fall.
In historic neighborhoods, three streets away that are completely different in character
and in how they hold value.
In Provo, the gap between a great buy and a frustrating one can be 100 yards apart and
a website average for Provo is not just useless, it is misleading.
Number two, parking, traffic and the rhythm of a university calendar are part of the deal
in Provo.
Number three, the historic core runs 1920s to 1950s so foundations, old wiring and additions
built across decades and not always with a permit, which is exactly what I go looking
for.
Number four, downtown Salt Lake City is 40 to 50 minutes away so this is not a Salt Lake
City commuter play.
Now so who is Provo for?
The buyer who wants a real downtown that they can walk to, a real canyon out the back door,
real architecture and an actual employment base at a price well under what the north
end of the county charges for a new house on a small lot with no trees.
Everybody buying new construction 20 or 30 minutes north of Provo is literally driving
past it.
If you want a quiet cul-de-sac and a three-car garage with no students within a mile, it
is not for you.
But historic Provo is the most underappreciated address in Utah County and I do not think
it's even close.
Which brings me to number five, the last of the underrated and the one I'm most excited
to tell you about.
It is the only place on this list where you are not just buying a discount, you are buying
in front of something and it sets up the final pick of this entire video.
So pay attention.
Okay, number five on this list of underrated is the Jordanelle area east of Park City.
This includes hideout, the Mayflower side, the benches around the reservoir, about 15
minutes east of Park City on the US 40 side.
It is the most interesting thing happening in Utah real estate right now that most people
still have not caught up to.
Now Deer Valley is building an entirely new front door to the resort on that side of the
mountain as well.
The East Village expansion with new lifts, a full resort base village with hotels and
restaurants and retail and branded residential going in around it, including a four seasons
project along with Marcella and Cormont.
That is not a rumor and it is not a rendering on a website.
It is actively under construction right now as you can see in the drone footage that I
have here.
And here is the piece that almost nobody has processed.
The Jordanelle Parkway now connects US 40 directly to that base area, which means a
lot of people coming from Salt Lake can get to that skiing without ever touching Park
City traffic.
And in some conditions, get there faster than people going in the front door.
On top of that, you have the reservoir itself, boating, paddling, the state park and big
open water views looking back at the Wasatch, which is a view Park City proper simply does
not have.
Now, let me be honest about the risk because the whole thesis is that you are early and
early cuts both ways.
Number one, a real amount of what makes this area work is still under construction and
construction schedules move.
You buy the promise and you own the timeline.
Number two, services on that side are still thin compared to Park City.
Groceries, schools, medical, restaurants, you will be driving in for just a little while
yet.
However, the hospital is just down the road.
And then number three, and here's where my hand is up as a construction guy, a lot of
the product out there is new attached and branded residential, which means HOAs, dues,
transfer fees, and resort community assessments.
Those numbers are not small and they are not always obvious.
Read every line before you fall in love, not after.
Number four, the Wasatch County and Summit County line runs right through this area and
taxes, rules, and services differ on either side of it.
So know exactly which county your parcel sits within.
And five, much of the ownership out there is a second home ownership.
So it is quiet in the shoulder seasons and nightly rental rules, very community, community
and change over time.
So who's the Jordan L area for the buyer who wants Deer Valley access without paying for
a park city address and who has the patience and the stomach to be a little bit early.
If that is you, this is the most compelling value in the Wasatch back right now, in my
opinion, and it is the only place on my underrated list where the upside is not just a discount.
It is a development that you can watch getting built in front of your eyes.
If you need everything finished and convenient on day one, wait just three years and pay
a little bit more.
That is a legitimate choice as well.
And hold on to Jordan L because in about 12 minutes, I'm going to tell you why a very
specific handful of streets, 15 minutes west of here is in my opinion, the single most
overrated place to buy in Utah.
Those two things are directly connected.
Okay, that is the five nobody talks about.
Now we flip it.
And this is the half where I make some people mad one more time.
So nobody quotes me out of context.
Overrated does not mean bad.
Every one of these next five is genuinely nice and full of genuinely happy people.
And I sell real estate in every single one of them.
Overrated means the price got ahead of the reality and somebody is paying for a story
instead of a house ascending order.
So the fifth one is the one that I feel the strongest about.
And number one is three miles from a place I just called one of the most underrated in
the state.
That is not a coincidence.
Okay, number one on the overrated list is vineyard.
Let me give it real credit first because on paper, it is one of the most exciting things
being built in this state.
Vineyard has been one of the fastest growing cities in Utah for years built out on the
old Geneva steel ground on the Utah Lakeshore in Utah County, Utah City is a 700 acre master
plan district designed by actual urban planners with five districts, more than 50 acres of
parks and something like 17 million square feet of mixed use at full build out waterfront
park, a racket club, new restaurants, a walkable core, a front runner station right there.
Somebody sat down and designed a genuine city and I like the ambition a lot.
So why is it even on this list?
Three reasons.
First and biggest is supply.
When you buy into an area with years of new construction still coming, you're not just
competing with other resale homes when you go to sell, you are competing with the builders
next phase and the builder can do things that you as a seller cannot buy down the rate throw
in the finishes carry the incentive that is the single most underappreciated resale risk
in Utah right now.
And it is the conversation I keep having with sellers who bought new three years ago and
are surprised.
Second, you are living in a construction zone for quite a while.
700 acres is a decade plus story and the rendering show you year 12, not year two.
And third, the lake, Utah Lake is shallow and warm and it gets algae blooms advisories
in the summertime oftentimes and it is a real amenity, but it is not the lake that most
out of state buyers picture when they hear the word waterfront.
So who is Vineyard actually right for somebody who wants walkable brand new transit connected
living and who plans to stay seven to 10 years so the build out works for them instead of
against them.
If you are still there when it is finished, you will do great and you will have watched
a real city get built around you.
Who it is wrong for is anybody who might need to sell in two to four years and anybody who
thinks they are buying waterfront the way that word works, where they came from.
And here is what bothers me the most.
Provo is right there three miles away, finished with a real downtown, real trees, real Canyon
access and a price that in a lot of cases is not higher.
And it's not just rental properties and I think that's the biggest play here.
Most of what is coming in Utah city will be rentals.
Go drive both on the same afternoon before you decide for yourself.
Okay.
Number two is where I lose some of you because it is where a whole lot of you are currently
under contract.
Let me show you the math.
Okay.
Number two is Eagle mountain and most of this applies to its neighbor Saratoga Springs as
well.
So if you're out there, this one is for you as well.
The fair version first Eagle mountain is one of the fastest growing cities in the entire
state.
And it will be for the next decade or two.
For understandable reasons, you get more house for the money than almost anywhere along the
Wasatch front.
It is a new construction zone.
There are young families everywhere that are lake and mountain views.
And there is a real promise that the jobs are moving West towards you.
Now on the flip side, the commute math is the entire story.
So let me do it out loud.
Getting out of Northwest Utah County at seven 30 in the morning means Redwood road or pioneer
crossing or the new 2100 North expressway that's being built SR 73 and all three feed
the same I 15 and point of the mountain funnel that everybody else in two counties is already
sitting in.
Now, the state has committed serious money to fixing this and I want to be fair about
it.
Roughly $1.4 billion converting 2100 North and Lehigh into a freeway between Mountain
View corridor and I 15 starting this year, they already have this under construction
pioneer crossing flex lanes, extending Mountain View corridor south to SR 73.
Starting in 2027, converting the quarry right of a highway to a freeway in the future starting
maybe next year.
That is genuinely great news out there.
But read the dates, those things get better over the next several years and decade.
And you are commuting tomorrow morning.
And here's what nobody says out loud relief projects that make an area more accessible
also invite more growth into it.
And so some of that relief gets absorbed by the next wave of rooftops.
Northwest Utah County is exactly where secondary water water shares and pressurized irrigation
rules matter the most and out of state buyers consistently misunderstand what they are buying
and what it costs to keep a lawn alive out there.
Third, the price per square foot trap a bigger house 25 miles out is not a better deal if
it costs you 90 minutes per day.
90 minutes a day is about 375 hours per year.
That is 940 hour workweek sitting in a car every year forever.
Price that out.
So here is the fair verdict.
If you work from home permanently, or your job is genuinely on the west side of Utah
County, Eagle Mountain is legitimately great and you should look at it really hard.
If there is any chance of an in office job up in Sully County, go drive that commute
at 715 in the morning on a Tuesday in February before you sign a single thing and hit the
commute on the way home as well.
It is not overrated as a place to live.
It is overrated as a commute assumption.
And if what you actually wanted was land and quiet and space, go back and look at Salem
because that is the honest version of what a lot of people think they are buying out
here.
Okay, number three is going to surprise the locals watching this because it is a place
that everybody around here has been quietly recommending for about five years.
And I think the reason people recommend it stopped being true.
Okay, number three is bountiful.
And this is the pick I went back and forth on the longest because I like bountiful.
Here's the fair version and it is really strong bountiful sits up on the Davis bench and on
a map it is 10 to 15 minutes away from downtown Salt Lake City closer than most of the south
end of the Salt Lake Valley mature neighborhoods with real trees enormous west facing views
out over the valley and the Great Salt Lake Mueller Park and the canyon trails right behind
you and established Main Street with a real small town core and three separate ways to
go south I 15 Legacy Parkway and front runner for years.
The recommendation has been if the Salt Lake East Bench is out of reach, go north to bountiful
and get the same thing for less.
And for years, that was excellent advice.
But here's why I do not think it is anymore.
First, the commute is not the number of people quote 10 to 15 minutes is a Sunday number.
The I 15 pinch at the Davis County and Salt Lake County line is one of the more reliable
bottlenecks in the entire Wasatch Front at rush hour and on a normal weekday morning,
you are not doing 15 minutes, you're doing maybe 25 to 30 and maybe sometimes even more.
But legacy helps front runner genuinely helps but the number that sells the house and the
number that you live are two different numbers and almost nobody drives it before they buy
go drive it at 745 in the morning and again at 5pm second, be honest about the corridor.
The refinery complex sits right along I 15 through the south end of Davis County.
It is visible depending on the day and the wind it is noticeable and it smells sometimes
as well.
And it is a legitimate consideration that essentially never comes up in a listing.
And the Great Salt Lake dust question during low water periods is a live conversation in
that specific geography.
I'm not telling you what to conclude about either one.
I am telling you to look at real information before you commit instead of hearing about
it from a neighbor in month number two.
Third, this is where my construction background gets loud.
Bountiful bench homes are largely 1950s through 1970s on cut and fill hillside lots.
That means retaining walls somebody built decades ago that are now your problem drainage
coming off of the hillside that has to go somewhere slope and soil questions that matter
far more here than on a flat valley lot and steep driveways that are charming in July
and a chore in January plus the useful vintage list of original mechanicals and old laterals.
I would not buy on that bench without somebody looking hard at the walls, the grating and
where the water goes in a heavy spring melt fourth, the price Bountiful got discovered
as the affordable alternative to Salt Lake City East bench and the price moved to reflect
that the bottleneck did not move and the housing did not get younger.
The discount that made it its value play earlier on has narrowed quite a bit and the recommendation
never updated.
So who's Bountiful right for?
Somebody whose work is in North Salt Lake or in Davis County or it's genuinely going
to ride front runner every day and is happy about it and who wants that big bench view
with a canyon out the back door.
For that person, it is terrific and it always will be.
Who it is wrong for is the buyer who got sold a 15 minute commute and is going to spend
the next 10 years sitting at that County line.
And here's the line I would leave you with.
If you've already accepted that you're going to commute and you are going to be on front
runner anyways, stay on that train another 20 minutes and go look at Ogden.
The same commuter rail, a real historic downtown, three ski resorts and a very different price.
Okay, number four on the list is where I have to publicly disagree with myself on camera
about a video that I've already made in the past.
Let me explain.
Okay, number four is sugar house and I have to do something uncomfortable here, so let
me just do it.
I made a video on this channel about the seven best neighborhoods in Utah and sugar house
was first on the list.
I stand by everything that I said about the neighborhood.
It is one of the oldest established parts of Salt Lake City.
The tree line streets and the brick bungalows are beautiful.
The walkable business district is real and it is really amazing.
The S line connects you into the transit system.
Sugar house park is a fantastic anchor.
You are minutes from downtown Salt Lake City and the university of Utah and you are still
about 20 minutes away from the mouth of the Cottonwood canyons.
The lifestyle is real.
I have not changed my mind about the neighborhood.
What I am calling overrated is what people are being asked to pay for it right now and
specifically what most of them are actually getting three things.
First, the honest question almost nobody asked themselves, you are paying a walkability premium.
Are you going to walk?
Not in the fantasy, in your actual life.
In the last month, how many times did you leave the car parked and go somewhere on foot?
If the honest answer is a few times per year, you are paying a real premium for an amenity
that you're never going to cash in and that is the exact definition of overrated to me.
The people who use sugar house get every dollar back.
The people who love the idea of it do not.
Second, the product does not always match the number.
A lot of that classic housing is small by modern standards on very small lots, one bathroom,
a low headroom basement, a detached single garage that's falling apart or no garage
at all and no off-street parking in many places and you are paying more per square foot than
a bench home twice the size and here's the construction list for that as well because
this is where I earn my keep.
Nob and tomb remnants, galvanized supply lines, undersized panels, single pane windows and
clay sewer laterals running under a 90-year-old tree canopy.
That last one is not theoretical.
In a neighborhood with trees that old, lateral repairs are a recurring line item every single
time, not a one-time surprise and a lot of those basements got finished by somebody with
no permit and no egress windows.
Renovating a 1920s bungalow to modern expectations in this labor market is not a $60,000 project
and people walk in assuming that it is.
Third, the neighborhood that you tour is not the neighborhood in five years.
Sugarhouse is redeveloping really fast and the mid-rise projects around the business
district mean traffic, parking pressure and construction on those blocks for a while.
That is not a criticism of the plan.
Denser housing near transit is how a city should grow.
I actually love it.
It is just a heads up that you are buying into a place actively changing shape right
now.
So who should buy in Sugarhouse?
The person who is genuinely going to live on foot.
If you will walk to dinner three nights a week, ride the S line, use the park almost
every day, and you actively want a smaller, older, character full house, buy it today
and you will be happy for 20 or 30 years.
And I genuinely mean that.
Who should not buy it is the person who loves the idea of walkability, is going to drive
everywhere anyways, and needs four bedrooms and a garage.
That buyer is paying an enormous premium for a story.
And if what you actually want is a walkable downtown with real character and it does not
have to be Salt Lake City, go back and look at Provost Center Street and 25th Street in
Ogden.
Same idea, real history, and a price difference that will genuinely shock you.
Which brings me to number five.
This is the one I've been building up to all video.
The one I expect to catch the most heat for, and it is a place that I love.
I sell in every single month and would happily own in myself.
Let me explain exactly what I mean because the details matter here more than anywhere
else.
Number five, the most overrated place to buy in the state of Utah is Old Town in Park City.
Not Park City, Old Town specifically.
That distinction is the entire segment here.
So stay with me.
Old Town, it's full due first because it deserves it.
Old Town is the soul of Park City, historic main street, the mining era cabins and Victorians
stacked up on those hillside streets.
Walk out your door to dinner, walk to the lift, Sundance happening in your block in
January, well at least up until this year.
And on a summer evening, there is not a better street in this entire state.
It is irreplaceable and I understand why people fall in love with it because I have to as
well.
And Park City overall is one of the great mountain towns in North America.
Four real seasons, about 40 minutes from an international airport, two world-class ski
resorts with Deer Valley's expansion transforming the East side right now.
I love selling in Park City and I will keep doing it enthusiastically for the rest of
my career.
But Old Town is the one place in Utah where the postcard and the ownership experience
are the furthest apart that I've ever seen.
And this is the part that almost nobody says on camera.
Start with the houses because this is my whole background.
A lot of those hundred plus year old mining cabins and many were built fast and cheap
as temporary housing for miners.
That is not a knock.
That is literally what they were for.
A century later on a steep hillside lot, that means original foundations or post and pier
that have been shimmed and jacked and reworked across a hundred years.
Structural work done in eras with completely different standards, additions built on top
of additions, insulation, retrofitted piece mill, wherever somebody could reach and freeze
thaw and roof snow loads working on all of it every single winter.
A properly renovated Old Town cabin is a spectacular thing to own and incredibly expensive.
An unrenovated one is a multi-year project in one of the most expensive and most constrained
construction labor markets in the entire country.
And because you are in a historic district, you do not simply get to do whatever you want
with it.
I have watched people fall in love with a cabin in July, get their first real bid in
October and go very quiet.
Second parking and access.
Old Town streets are narrow and steep and a lot of these places have no garage and no
off street parking in January.
That is not charming.
It is a daily logistics problem and challenge and getting a contractor or a delivery truck
up there midwinter is genuinely difficult, which is part of why the work costs what
it costs.
Third, you are buying a home inside an event venue.
Main Street's calendar is full of things from the holidays to the seasons, race weekends,
summer festivals, visiting that is absolutely wonderful.
Living on top of it is a different experience and you should go stand there during peak
season before you buy, not after.
Fourth, a lot of Old Town buyers underwrite the purchase with nightly rental income.
Those rules change, the competition is fierce and the operating costs on a 100 year old
home at 7,000 feet are always higher than the spreadsheet says.
If the deal only works with the rental income, the deal does not work.
Put it together because this is the actual argument.
You are paying close to the highest price per square foot in the entire state of Utah
for the oldest, hardest to park, hardest to maintain, hardest to renovate housing stock
in the entire state.
That combination is why it is my number one.
Not because Old Town is not wonderful and charming, because that gap between what people
believe they are buying and what they are signing up for is the widest on this entire
list by a large margin.
So who should own an Old Town?
The buyer who wants that walk to Main Street life, who has already bought the renovated
version instead of the project, who has budgeted maintenance as a permanent annual line item
rather than a one-time event, and for whom that address genuinely is the entire point.
That person is going to be thrilled and I will happily help them find the right house
because when it is right, it is some of the best real estate in the entire state.
But if that is not you, and for most people it is not, buy the mountain instead of the
museum.
And here's where it all comes back around.
15 minutes to the east, on the Jordanelle side, Deer Valley is building an entirely
new front door to that same mountain.
New construction, actual parking, a driveway that you can get a plow into, systems built
this decade, and a price that is not paying a hundred years of history tax.
Same mountains, different math.
That is the whole lesson of this video and it is why Old Town closes the list.
Now, Old Town also works incredibly well for those looking for a really expensive project
to build one of the most custom homes they can in such a unique place.
Those two buyers really do well in Park City, Old Town.
All right, let me pull all 10 back together because the list is not the point, the pattern
is the point.
First, underrated.
Sandy, because it is the same map position as its expensive neighbors without the premium.
Ogden, because it is the best mountain access per dollar in the state if you can live 35
miles to the north.
Salem, because it is one of the last places you can still buy real land at a normal price.
Provo, because it has a real downtown, a real canyon, and real jobs, and everybody is driving
past it to buy new construction with no trees.
And finally, the Jordanelle area, because you can still get in front of what Deer Valley
is building over there.
Five most overrated.
Vineyard, because you will be competing with the builders next phase for a decade or more.
Eagle Mountain, because the roads are coming, but you are commuting tomorrow morning.
Bountiful, because the recommendation never got updated for the bottleneck of the price.
Sugarhouse, because most people paying that walkability premium are never going to walk
at all.
And Old Town in Park City, because it is the most beautiful and most expensive way to buy
the hardest house in the state of Utah to own.
And here's the pattern underneath all 10.
In Utah right now, you are usually not paying for mountains, or trails, or good schools,
or a short commute.
Those things are available in a lot of other places.
You are paying for how many other people already know about it.
Find the place where the geography is great, and the story has not been told just yet,
and you will have found yourself that value that you might be looking for.
So here's where I would go next, depending on where you are in all of this.
If you are still comparing, sitting there with two or three of these on a short list,
trying to figure out how they actually stack up on the things that matter.
The property taxes, county by county, the water situation, the school boundaries, the
real commute corridors, grab that free Utah relocation guide that I mentioned earlier.
You can download it, save it to your phone as an app on your home screen.
It's a wonderful tool that help people every single day.
Make sure that you download that first.
Next, subscribe to the channel for more videos just like this.
And if you're further along, if you want a straight answer about which of these 10 actually
fits your budget, and your commute, and your family, and your lifestyle, and your timeline,
just reach out to me.
Let's start the conversation.
My contact information is in the description below.
We can book a call and go from there and make sure that we make this move as smooth as possible
for you.
And if you're looking to learn more about life in Utah, check out these videos next,
and I'll see you in the next video.