The Brutal Training That Made Renaissance Artists So Good

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
22 Video Views·Sep 18, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Imagine stepping into a renaissance workshop so good that it regularly turned aspiring
apprentices into geniuses like Albrecht Dürer, Da Vinci or Michelangelo. Imagine the smell of
mixing pigment with oil, the sound of hammers and chisels and the aura of creativity hanging
in the air. What was it about the apprenticeship training system that made artists so good
that we still admire them today? Of course they were talented, but after three weeks of researching
I found something that went far beyond talent strategies or even training methods. So let's
unravel it all and start with one of the greatest artists of all time. Let's take a look at
Michelangelo. His father Ludovico came from minor nobility and considered working with your hands
as something for the lower classes. When his son kept sneaking off to copy paintings in churches
instead of studying grammar, Ludovico was furious. Sometimes it was so bad he even beat his son.
However, Michelangelo felt this inner calling and kept drawing anyway. Eventually his father
gave up the fight. In April of 1488, Ludovico signed his 13-year-old son into a three-year
contract with Domenico Ghirlandaio, one of the most sought-after fresco masters in Florence.
Ghirlandaio would pay 24 gold florins spread across three years, six in year one, eight in
year two and ten in year three. On top of that it was custom to provide housing and food. Back in
those days students were being paid to learn from the greatest masters on earth while getting housing
and food for free. Today students pay six figures for the privilege of becoming employable. Imagine
being part of Ghirlandaio's workshop for a moment. Ghirlandaio wasn't running a school,
he was running a business. Every morning you subconsciously absorb Ghirlandaio's morning
routine. You eat together with your fellow apprentices, the same diet your healthy master
is eating. As the day went on you watch him prize a commission, you watch him pray, you watch him
negotiate with a church official who demands a discount in the name of God. You overhear the
conversation when a patron tries to dictate which pigment to use. A patron who doesn't know anything
about color theory but knows that ultramarine costs four times more than the alternative.
In other words, you learn without anyone formally training you. No art school today teaches you the
business side of the arts. They don't teach you how to sit in front of a buyer and close. And to
be fair with you, the artist formula, a business course I released a couple of years ago to provide
the first real complete business manual for artists, the same problem exists. You kind of
only get the theory. In an ideal scenario you would actually sit next to me or even better
sit next to Ghirlandaio and see him close a deal in front of your eyes. But all this doesn't even
account for the true genius of this system. Within the system the master you are working under
actually wants you to succeed because his name is on the line. If you produce bad work it's
partially his brand that will suffer. This created a system no modern school has been
able to replicate. The person teaching you has a direct financial incentive to make sure you
actually became good. So the apprentice model is hitting it in all levels and we haven't even
started yet. Throughout this video I will give points for the apprenticeship model or the modern
schooling system but in this case one point goes to the apprenticeship model. Let's go to the first
year of your apprenticeship training system where you, the apprentice, will do something that looks
harmless at first but could quite literally kill you and end your career on the spot. Before you
touch the brush to anything that mattered you spend months grinding stone and mineral into
powder fine enough to bind with oil. One of the most common pigments in the entire renaissance
palette was lead white. It made the most luminous highlights any painter could produce. It was also
pure poison. It caused crippling stomach pain, tremors and sometimes forms of insanity. And people
were aware of this during the renaissance period. In fact the earliest depictions of various diseases
linked to lead white go back over 2200 years. Nicander of Colophon specifically described
acute poisoning from lead white around 250 BC. This means that it took governments 2200 years
to ban lead white which is impressive considering that normally they discover new ways to regulate
your life much faster. The point for health and safety goes to the modern education system. Now
imagine yourself covered in cloth to avoid breathing in the fine dust as you are grinding
the paint. Besides grinding paint you're preparing canvases. Building frames for paintings that will
be studied for hundreds of years. You're making brushes by hand. Selecting the best hairs for the
best brushes and binding them like your life depends on it. And in doing so fighting the
satisfying urge to lick your brush to a point because you remember the dust can be deadly. Now
what happens during these months? What's the impact of this low-level labor while you develop a love
for the materials that is unparalleled? The richest painters today don't know how to make a brush or
grind paint to perfection. In many cases they lack the foundational love that comes from this
apprenticeship model. And unlike popular belief there is something that comes with adding more
love to an object that cannot be replicated by machines. Another point for the apprenticeship
model. So lead poisoning was one way the training could cost you your life but it wasn't the only
one. The next danger came from the person that was standing right next to you. Zanini's
El libro del arte is one of the most respected sources for training your craft at the time. He
encourages apprentices to work first with silver point before they go to charcoal or graphite. Now
it's much harder to erase silver point which forces the artists to develop a level of confidence they
otherwise wouldn't develop. Great example of this is Albrecht Durer's self-portrait. A portrait he
made at the age of 13. Look at the expression on his face. With just a few lines he's able to capture
a level of innocence that's astonishing. I don't think I need to explain why this adds another
point to the apprenticeship model. After working with silver point you would move to graphite
charcoal. At first you would focus on copying the master you're working under for a couple of months.
Then you go out of the workshop and copy other masters in churches, chapels and private
collections. Zanini encourages apprentices to focus on a handful of masters and copy as much
of their work as possible instead of trying to copy from as many masters as possible because
this gives you a deeper understanding of their style. Now in order to understand how competitive
this landscape is let's take a look at how Michelangelo got his flat deformed nose. Arguably
one of the most famous noses in art history. By his mid-teens Michelangelo had left Ghirlandaio's
workshop and was training in the sculpture garden of Lorenzo de' Medici. Walking in the sculpture
garden Michelangelo felt like he was one of the chosen ones. Working alongside a ferociously
competitive circle of Florence's most gifted teenagers. One of them was an older sculptor
One morning the two of them walked together to the Brancacci chapel inside the church of
Santa Maria del Carmini to copy Masaccio's frescoes. This looked like an ordinary day
except it wasn't. When they arrived they sat next to a couple of other apprentices who were all in
full concentration drawing the frescoes. Michelangelo wanted to keep it all joyful and so he did what he
always did. He started mocking some of the fellow apprentices in a funny teasing way while they are
concentratedly drawing. This was a very fun way but not everyone saw it that way. On this particular
afternoon the teasing pushed Torrigiano past his limits. He later said I clenched my fist and gave
Michelangelo such a blow on the nose that I felt bone and cartilage go down like biscuits beneath
my knuckles. Michelangelo fell on the ground unconscious. When he woke up he felt the pain
throughout his entire face. He couldn't believe it went this far and with nothing better to do
he started overthinking the entire scenario. Would his nose ever heal? What will people say?
How am I going to explain this in the future? Michelangelo didn't know yet that he would carry
a flattened crooked nose for the rest of his life. A story we still talk about hundreds of years later.
Michelangelo never saw Torrigiano again because by the time he woke up Torrigiano already
fled Florence terrified of what the Medici would do to whoever had disfigured his favorite student.
He spent the rest of his career bouncing between Rome, England and Spain. A genuinely talented
sculptor who never did learn to control his temper. And it finally caught up with him in Seville
where after a dispute about a payment for a statue he'd carved he smashed the piece in a rage.
The Spanish inquisition arrested him for sacrilege and he died in a cell largely forgotten. Now on top
of the competition among the apprentices there was also a level of nepotism that made it even harder.
The master had an incentive to make sure almost none of the apprentices actually became masters
themselves because that would increase the competition too much. On top of that sometimes
they would promote their own offspring or children of friends. If you think about this is actually a
positive because sometimes it results in a higher quality master as well as a supply that is in line
with the demand. In other words during the renaissance artists didn't starve the way they do
in the 21st century. Another point for the apprenticeship model. However there's one element
to modern life that is truly inspirational and not pointing it out would be dishonest. When Dürer
made his self-portrait at the age of 13 it sat in the family's private collection and after changing
some hands for 431 years it became part of the state's ownership. But it would take 481 years
for the museum it was housed in to open to the public. 481 years before the public laid eyes
on a drawing I showed earlier. Today if you compare it a 13 year old can make a video about
the drawing they made and within minutes reach tens of thousands of people. The liberation that
this brings for the apprentice or student to gain mass adoption without having funding without having
backing from patrons is truly mesmerizing. And needless to say anyone who wants to learn this
skill can buy my course. However be warned the algorithm in its current state is a meritocracy
but a meritocracy where the best marketers win instead of the best artists. And algorithm changes
are technically speaking possible that would change this but they're not on the horizon.
So this adds a point for the modern education system. But besides social media the modern
education system runs on artificial deadlines that are made up. Renaissance had a different
way to create urgency. One that wasn't artificial at all and arguably much better. In the fourth
stage apprentices would be encouraged to go beyond drawing and train in multiple media.
Sculpting in stone and metal, painting in oil, fresco painting, painting with tempera, engraving,
mosaic and goldsmithing. The idea of someone who becomes an expert painter and only trains
the art of painting is a recent invention. During the renaissance artists were inspired by the idea
of the homo universalis. The idea that the perfect man should be able to do many things.
This concept was popularized by Leon Battista Alberti who was a walking example of it. He was
architect, painter, poet, linguist, mathematician, musician and according to the legend in extremely
healthy physical condition since he could jump over a man's head with his feet together. The
most famous example of the homo universalis is of course Leonardo da Vinci. Training people to
become experts in a variety of disciplines in just a couple of years is truly mesmerizing and
deserves another point for the apprenticeship model. But why is the homo universalis approach
so powerful? How is it able to create geniuses so consistently? Let's say you don't want to
become a fresco painter but you are forced to learn it anyway. What happens? Fresco painting
has a unique training element to it. Every day a new section of fresh wet plaster would be applied
to the wall. This plaster would dry in about eight to nine hours which meant that you had
to make sure the painting was finished in a very short timeline. On top of that it required a great
deal of memory as well because before the plaster went on you would sketch the underdrawing on the
wall then the plaster would go over it completely covering the underdrawing meaning you would
partially paint from memory. And if for some reason you make a mistake the entire thing would
need to be scrapped off and you would start all over costing the workshop lots of money. In other
words each medium forces you to learn skills that you would otherwise not learn. Skills that you can
then use when working in your preferred medium. One point added to the apprenticeship model but it
becomes even more strange. During this stage they also train on live models where they will gain
even more speed. Most of the times one of the apprentices would awkwardly stand in as a live
model for that specific day. During the early renaissance female models were very rare which is
why most of the female figures in study drawings and paintings have a bit of a male vibe to it.
If you look for example at the Libyan Saebol in the Sistine Chapel by Michelangelo you see
that she has a very masculine back with quite a lot of muscle mass for a woman. If i would show
you the preparatory drawings for this figure without any context most of you would simply
think that this is a man. And we see this over and over again in the work of renaissance artists.
If you look at the sculptures in the Medici Chapel done by Michelangelo you see that the woman on the
right has quite a muscular shoulder for a woman. After many years of weight training myself my
shoulder doesn't look that different from the female shoulder in this sculpture. So i guess
this adds one point to the modern education system where students have access to unlimited
female models in all sorts of positions that you can dream of on the internet for free.
In the next stage things are going to become wild. During my research i found something that looks almost
made up until you see the finished painting. In stage five you'll finally be working on real
paintings that are commissioned by powerful people. One of those commissions is the Baptism
of Christ given to Andrea del Verrocchio, the teacher of the one and only Leonardo da Vinci.
For this particular piece he asked da Vinci to paint the angel on the left holding the rope.
Da Vinci is thrilled. Technically speaking da Vinci was already registered with the painters guild
since 1472 and he could receive his own commissions for his own workshop. But nobody was giving him
any and after a while da Vinci felt doubt creeping in. So this was an opportunity for da Vinci to
prove his skill to the world. There was just one problem. As an apprentice one of the key rules
is to not outshine the master. The finished work needs to look like it's painted by one artist
namely the master. And so Leonardo has to paint but not paint too well. Now imagine a workshop
with assistants preparing the canvas, grinding the paint. Everyone kind of knows that da Vinci has
more in him and there's a tension in da Vinci's heart. Something tells him to not hold back. The
final work can be watched today in the Uffizi and the tension from that workshop is still visible
in the painting. Compare the angel on the left holding the rope to the main characters in the
painting and ask yourself which of the figures feels most beautiful and most alive. According to
Giorgio Vasari writing decades later the angel came out so luminous, so alive next to Verrocchio's
more traditional figures that the contrast embarrassed the master in front of his own
workshop. So the story goes that Verrocchio put down his brush that day and never picked it up
again. Being able to paint on artworks that actually sold in the marketplace is something
the modern education system doesn't have. So another point goes to the apprenticeship model.
Now there's one problem with this video so far. If you would have hypothetically speaking the talent
that Leonardo da Vinci has and you would do everything the renaissance artists did, everything
I outlined so far, your artistic skill wouldn't even come close to da Vinci's or Michelangelo's
because there is something missing and it's arguably the most important ingredient of them all.
The missing ingredient is best understood if we look at making art from the eyes of the
renaissance artists themselves. What is practicing your drawing skill really? From our 21st century
perspective it looks like they are training their skill to become better at drawing obviously but
from their perspective this is only 20% of the equation. They believe the most important part
of drawing various religious figures and scenes from the bible is developing their relationship
with God. Michelangelo was extremely devout. We know this from the day-to-day practice of his time
as well as his poetry that survived. His poems are literally prayers. His contemporaries called
him il divino or the divine one. He attended the sermons of Savonarola. Vasari records that on one
of the feast days 48 artists gathered in the chapel to celebrate mass. The agnus bell would
three times a day and artists would go into prayer. If you want to understand the artistic
practice of the renaissance artists you have to understand their relationship with God because
according to those renaissance artists this relationship is the most important ingredient
for their artistic success. Renaissance artists are spiritually developed beings. They literally
hear God speaking to them. They literally ask God for guidance. They literally make art in order to
strengthen their relationship with God. They didn't search for the proof of God through the words in
the bible because they didn't have to. On top of that many of them couldn't even read the bible in
the first place but again they didn't have to because they experienced God through them. The
result they got from that experience was the proof they needed. Most of you who are watching
hundreds of years after these renaissance artists lived are non-believers and as a non-believer
it's hard to understand this because nobody explained it to you properly. So let's think
this through. How does believing or non-believing influence your artistic development? Stay with me
for a moment because this is very very important. Imagine that you can ask God anything in prayer
and get responses that are of a much higher intellectual quality than your own prefrontal
cortex or any book you've ever read. Imagine for a moment that this is real so that there's no doubt
in your mind that God is in fact speaking to you. In that case you obviously want to utilize this
communication line. Now imagine that besides prayer, meditation, living righteously, drawing
becomes strengthening that bond so that you can tap into the highest form of wisdom known to man.
How would your practice transform? Would you take it more seriously and would you subsequently
become better at it? And that is exactly what happened here. Now this sounds very abstract in
the eyes of a non-believer. Luckily there is a way for you to see whether or not this is true.
There is a way for you to know if talking to God is real. Sadly it will require you to meditate
and pray on a daily basis for a couple of years. Either way let me know what you think about this
in the comments. Is it possible that declaring God is dead as Nietzsche prophesied brought with it
the absolute collapse of western society or is something else happening entirely? Now this brings
us to an interesting score because God's collaboration adds 100 points to the apprenticeship
model. So after six stages the unbiased score is a perfectly reasonable 107 vs 3. Can modern
education still catch up? It's time to go to the seventh stage. In this stage you become the master
and you get your own commissions. But this stage isn't as easy as it looks. After all Da Vinci
created the Mona Lisa, the most famous painting in the world, but he also gave up in this stage
and never finished the three commissions he got. Needless to say Da Vinci would have probably
benefited from my free newsletter where I explain the business side of the art in the 21st century.
For this video however we have to give you a complete run through on what it takes to
actually become a master during the renaissance. We are not going to do that predominantly because
I already did in a video called the dark world of Michelangelo how he made millions. That said
get out of here.
