Executed on charges of adultery and treason, Anne Boleyn has long been cast as the ambitious ‘harlot’ who seduced Henry VIII into annulling his first marriage and forcing his country into religious turmoil. But was that really the whole story?
Historians Dan Snow and Professor Suzannah Lipscomb look beyond the familiar legend to uncover a very different Anne: a woman whose ideas and influence helped change the course of England, and whose reputation may deserve to be rewritten.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores the life of Anne Boleyn, challenging her historical reputation through a newly discovered manuscript and an analysis of her formative years in France. It suggests that Anne was viewed as innocent and virtuous by the public at the time of her death, contrasting sharply with the narrative pushed by Henry VIII.
At the time of her death, and since, Anne's name has been tarnished by those charges of adultery and incest.
But was Anne Boleyn really guilty of all those alleged crimes?
One of the more reliable accounts of events surrounding Anne Boleyn's death was written by French diplomat Lancelot Ducas.
There are multiple copies around Europe.
But in 2021, an academic colleague, Professor Joanne de la Neve, discovered that one here in the National Library of France was different to all the rest.
I've seen this poem in the British Library, I've seen it printed, but I've never seen this version before.
It gets us to the moment of her death, and on the scaffold, she's speaking to the crowd.
And in the standard version of her speech, she says,
To narrate to you why I'm here would not serve you nor me either, so that's why I'm staying quiet.
But in this version of the text, there are some additional lines.
She doesn't stay quiet.
So, here we go. She says,
I want to beg you, very humbly, that you will not, on the basis of what you have seen, or on those things you have heard from others, judge my part such that it damages your confidence against me.
In other words, she's saying, don't believe the rumours, don't listen to the hype that I have done something wrong.
And then Descartes gives us the reaction of the crowd, the crowd that he himself was probably in.
Each one made judgement that her life was prudent.
This is such an exciting word to find here, because nowadays, I know we use it to mean sensible, and it doesn't really stand for much,
but in the 16th century, in the Renaissance, this is a really important word.
The ability to restrain your passions, to control yourself, it's the ultimate virtue.
To say this of Anne is to put her in that category of saintly women, to say she's completely different from the harlot, the whore that she has been painted in the trial.
And there's more.
It goes on.
So they thought that they had greatly offended in all the evil that they had thought of her.
These additional lines seem to indicate that as far as the people around her were concerned, at the time of her death, she was innocent.
This is a story that goes completely contrary to the version of events that Henry VIII and his cronies are putting out.
It's believed these lines were wiped from all other known copies, likely on the orders of Henry VIII.
This one was just out of his reach.
These missing lines fundamentally reframe the life and death of Anne Boleyn.
If she protested her innocence and those around her thought she was innocent, how is it she still wound up being executed?
To find out, we need to go back to the start.
On my way to the Loire Valley in central France.
I wonder, is there anything in the early years of Anne Boleyn's life that might help us understand her tragic end?
Anne was sent to France around the age of 14 by her father.
An ambitious member of the English gentry, he wanted Anne to get a good education and to mix with royalty.
So in 1515, Anne arrived here at the stunning Chateau du Bois.
Wow, I've been here before but this place never ceases to thrill me.
This was one of the homes of French King François I and Queen Claude.
Under their rule, France was emerging as a leading cultural and intellectual force in Europe.
The ideal place for an aspiring young woman.
Anne had secured a post as Lady-in-Waiting to Queen Claude and together they would have walked these rooms.
Pauline!
Hi Suzy, how are you?
I'm well, thank you.
I'm meeting Pauline Favreau to find out how being a Lady-in-Waiting would shape Anne's whole life.
So their daily life was indeed to be close to the Queen and so they did whatever the Queen did.
Claude valued the education of young girls.
Anne Boleyn learned how to speak French, how to dance, how to play music, how to converse as well because she had to represent her Queen.
Well, it's utterly thrilling to be in the space that Claude and Anne Boleyn were in.
Here, under Queen Claude's influence, Anne also encountered new ways of thinking about religion.
Claude is quite a pious woman, isn't she?
Yes, she prayed every day and so probably here Anne Boleyn heard about the reformist idea that was happening everywhere else in Europe.
In early 16th century France, new ideas of religious reform began to circulate.
Reformers questioned priestly authority and translated Bibles into their mother tongue so ordinary people could read it for themselves.
The idea was not to create a new church but to put the church back on track and I think that really could have an influence on her life in England.
Absolutely, so she has a sense of what it is like to be open-minded, to consider a whole range of ideas, nothing's off the table.
Of course, the court of France was more about saying your mind, you say what you want to say.
So when Anne went back to England, how do you think she had been changed by her time here in France?
I think she was really, really different than anyone else at the English court.
She had this wit, so different, she could speak, she could act and she could say no.
She was confident in herself and she learned this here at the court of France.
Anne's time in France was so formative, she realised that it was possible to be someone of faith and deeply engaged with religious ideas
and also someone who was witty, she is a great dancer and she's a very sort of sensual woman.
She could be all of these things in one.
The question is, how would this sophisticated young woman use what she'd learned back home in the English court?