How to Explore Alchemical Symbolism 3

Legacy of Science
19 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 13, 2026
The last of a three part investigation of alchemical imagery by Adam McLean, the creator of the renowned alchemy website. He is well known for the hundred or so books he has published on the subject, and for his in-depth study courses.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation analyzes the shift in alchemical perception from the 19th century to today, contrasting the rise of esoteric \"metanarratives\" and psychological interpretations with the emergence of rigorous historical scholarship. It critiques how pseudoscience, Jungian psychology, and digital culture have distorted alchemy into a fictionalized spiritual tool.
In order to grasp the ways in which alchemical symbolism came to be perceived in the late 20th
century up till today, we must take a look at the reception of alchemy in the 19th through into the
20th century. We have already seen in the first of these presentations that alchemical publications
dropped almost to zero at the beginning of the 19th century. Around the turn of the 18th
into the 19th century, we find a number of enthusiasts and researchers trying to record
and preserve alchemical texts. Among these were Sigismund Backstrom, Ebenezer Sibley and Francis
Barrett. Perhaps they had some sense that interest in alchemy was waning. Many of the manuscript
transcriptions have survived. Little original material appeared in the opening decades of the
19th century. Then, in 1832, a small book was published with the title Hermes des Voisins,
Hermes Revealed. This purported to be by a French adept called Siliani. It is an account of his
search for the philosopher's stone and includes a section in the form of a conventional alchemical
allegory. In 1829, François Cambriel created a series of 19 lessons on the philosophy and practice
of alchemy. In 1843, these were published in Paris. This was a strange work in which the author
revealed himself as not possessing the secrets of alchemy, but if he were given sufficient funding,
he would be able to discover the secrets. There were a handful of other such publications,
but the momentum of writing on alchemy had entirely collapsed. This hiatus in interest
in alchemy was to change with the appearance of the books published under the name Elipas
Levi. First appeared in 1854, the Dogme de la Roche Magie, followed in 1856 by the companion volume
Rituel de la Roche Magie. Its famous opening lines were not written until 1861,
after the initial success of the first edition, presents the single essential theme of occultism
as a secret esoteric tradition that he saw as underlying many aspects of human culture.
Behind the veil of all the hieratic and mystical allegories of ancient doctrines,
behind the darkness and strange ordeals of all initiations, under the seal of all sacred
writings, in the ruins of Nineveh or Thebes, on the crumbling stones of old temples,
and on the blackened visage of the Assyrian or Egyptian Sphinx, in the monstrous or marvellous
paintings which interpret to the faithful of India the inspired pages of the Vedas,
in the cryptic emblems of our old books on alchemy, in the ceremonies practiced at reception by all
secret societies, there are found indications of a doctrine which is everywhere the same,
and everywhere carefully concealed. Levi's books were illustrated with a number of engravings,
somewhat inspired by alchemical symbolism, some of which he was undoubtedly aware. We've already
seen in the first presentation that his notorious Baphomet image was partly based on an engraving
in the works of the alchemical philosopher Heinrich Kunrat. Levi's views on an occult
secret doctrine could merely have been the isolated opinions of an eccentric individual,
however they resonated with a retreat from rationalism that was occurring within the
French intelligentsia at that time. So Levi's perspective rapidly gained traction and began
to influence many writers. Thus Levi and his followers sought to recontextualize alchemy,
among other aspects of early culture, within the idea of there being part of a hidden occult
tradition which was not accessible in the historical record. There being no historical
traces of such a secret tradition, instead this perspective rested entirely within a belief system
thus we should see this idea of an esoteric secret doctrine as a metanarrative,
a fictional account of history that nevertheless was seductive and provided simplistic answers
to complex and often difficult areas of cultural history. Such metanarratives however
corrode people's ability to see a subject such as alchemy within its proper historical context.
It was not only the French-speaking world that was embracing this emerging syncretic esoteric
philosophy, but in Britain and the USA the Theosophical Society was emerging. Its initial
aims expressed in 1875 were the study and elucidation of occultism, paralleling the views
of Levi. Later the Theosophical Society broadened its perspective, seeing all religions as having
some common basis. It blinded itself to the obvious irreconcilable differences found in
the multiplicity of belief systems it sought to unify, and so various movements budded off from
it well into the early 20th century, an obvious example being Rudolf Steiner's Christian European
Anthroposophy. Many such groups emerged, centred on individuals affecting clairvoyance,
a kind of spiritual perception that could not be challenged. From within the Theosophical Society,
Annie Besant and Leadbeater turned their clairvoyant gaze on the structural matter
and devised a book entitled Occult Chemistry, issued in 1908. This drew on the then emerging
idea of the periodic table of the elements. They also saw the structure of atoms as a complex
vortex of subtle forces. This image they clairvoyantly saw actually came from a book,
The Principles of Light and Colour, by the American Edwin Babbitt, published some 30 years earlier
in 1878. Babbitt's conception was entirely derived from his abstract theoretical ideas
on the forces within atoms and had no esoteric input, but may have drawn on the physicist
Lord Kelvin's 1867 paper on atoms as vortices of forces. Leadbeater so elaborated his picturing of
that the ideas all but collapsed under their own weight and complexity. As these theories had no
predictive power, they made little impact outside of the believers. We should consider their occult
chemistry as signifying one of the ways in which alchemy became transformed through the interaction
with modernity, the rise of pseudoscience. We still find this pseudoscience today with the idea
of ornaments, supposedly obviously rearranged monoatomic elements, and the white powdered gold
invented in the late 1970s by the American farmer David Hudson. This self-deception was to some
extent based on chemical ideas, and later sparked off a not insignificant business supplying
substances which were believed to provide healing, which then metamorphosed into superconductivity,
anti-gravity, and free energy devices. Hudson and others sought endorsement of the claims
by recontextualizing alchemy. Many similar pseudoscientific ideas have emerged,
derived from or using alchemy as a philosophical underpinning. Another shoot emerging from the
Theosophical Society was the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, established in 1888 as a secretive,
invitation-only group, partly modeled on Freemasonry, but with an hermetic charge.
Much of its inner teachings were a contextualizing of alchemical ideas within an overarching magical
structure. Part of the inner teaching involved the construction of magical diagrams,
drawing somewhat from alchemical hymns. This constituted a magical metanarrative that is
still very persuasive. Historical alchemists were rarely involved in magical practices,
though the term natural magic was sometimes used as in the writings of Delaporta.
But here it essentially means natural philosophy rather than ritual ceremonial magic,
goetic theurgy, or the summoning of spirits and similar sorcery. There were a few exceptions
who were involved both in alchemy and the ritual type of magic, the best known being Edward Kelly
during the Elizabethan period. However, during the last half-century or so,
many people have, through this metanarrative, come to view alchemists as magicians.
A whole slew of books on alchemy, using these sorts of esoteric ideas, were issued in the
drawing on similar such writings, and usually it becomes obvious that the author has not
thought it necessary or important to do any actual primary research. These authors,
and the various experts touring the lecture and weekend seminar circuits, came to construct
a new 20th century belief system under the umbrella of alchemy. This had almost nothing
to do with historical alchemy, as these writers and speakers had little interest in studying the
original writings, and instead put their energies into devising a persuasive rhetoric. This seemed
to meet a need in the interested public for a simple, easy to understand philosophy and lifestyle
that they saw as being endorsed by the alchemists of half a millennium earlier.
This constructed alchemy has now become so ingrained that it has a life of its own,
and will probably continue to develop for many more decades. Its underlying body of preconceptions
and invented history seems sufficiently coherent that it is impervious to the truths
of document-based historical research. Such metanarratives are not confined to the modern
period. A number of attempts to recontextualise alchemical ideas even occurred back in the 16th
and 17th centuries. The best known of these was that of the Rosicrucians. From about 1612,
there were circulated a number of open letters and some manifestos promoting the idea that there
existed a group of Rosicrucian adepts who held the secrets of alchemy, and even had a secret
underground vault as a base. This was such a powerful idea that it influenced many alchemical
writers through to the end of the 18th century, even being revived in the late 19th century,
and again reconstructed in the 1970s as a current in Palatinate history by the scholar Francis
Yates. Another way of looking at alchemy arose in the mid-19th century through Mary Ann Atwood's
suggestive inquiry into the Hermetic mystery. She wished to recontextualise alchemy as being
somehow involved with the personal development of the human being. Atwood was influenced by the
then current English obsession with the ideas of Mesmer, who had popularised a belief in a
non-corporeal fluid, a sort of ether that permeated all space and even entered people's bodies,
often described as animal magnetism, which can now be seen as a method of hypnotism.
Atwood wished us to see that this undetectable fluid was the primary material of the alchemists,
and the alchemists' own body was the vessel and laboratory in which alchemical transmutation
would occur. In the closing sections of her book, she states, alchemy is a universal art
of vital chemistry which, by fermenting the human spirit, purifies and finally dissolving it,
opens the elementary germ into a new life and consciousness. Her book was withdrawn and her
ideas held back from substantially influencing the way people saw alchemy until a reprint in 1918
brought this back into the public sphere. Even today her book still holds a considerable
influence upon the development of the view of alchemy as a method for inner or spiritual
development. This inner development metanarrative was to merge with and become amplified by the
relocation of Eastern meditation practices into the West and the reconstruction of Western shamanism.
A number of the major players in the Golden Dawn and its later offshoots were involved in
the translation and publication of classic Latin alchemical texts such as the Hermetic Museum,
1893, the Triumphal Chariot of Antimony of Basel Valentine, also 1893, Hermetic and Alchemical
Writings of Paracelsus, 1894, the Petrus Bonus New Pearl of Great Price, the same year, and the
Turba Philosophorum of 1896, and a number of other key works of alchemy. Thus, for the first time,
alchemical texts in English fell into the hands of general readers outside of libraries.
This openness to exploring alchemical texts resulted in the founding of the short-lived
Alchemical Society in London in November 1912, which was set up to study the works and theories
of the alchemists in all their aspects, philosophical, historical, and scientific,
and of all matters relating thereto. A number of its members were such as A. E. Waite,
who was immersed in the stream of the Golden Dawn and simultaneously responsible for translating
many of the key alchemical texts, but it primarily attracted more scholarly people,
such as the great collector John Ferguson and Stanley Redgrove, and the papers published in
its journal were primarily of a historical and scholarly nature. Later, in 1935, the Society
for the History of Alchemy and Chemistry was formed in London and began issuing its journal
Ambix, which continues to this day. This brought the study of alchemy back into the realm of exact
scholarship. From the late 1960s, the study of alchemy within the context of the history of
ideas and the history of science gained ground and a number of major scholars were able to embrace
the subject, which led to a massive PhD thesis appearing from the 1970s onwards. This scholarship
sought to find the correct context for alchemical texts, imagery, and ideas.
The emergence and consolidation of a scholarly approach to alchemy was put in danger of becoming
undermined by the seductive Jungian metanarrative, which emerged with the publication of Jung's book
Psychology and Alchemy, which, though issued in German in 1944, did not appear in English
until 1953. This was followed by his more mass-market book Man and His Symbols in 1964.
Psychology and Alchemy is probably the most influential book about alchemy in the 20th
century. It contained some 270 illustrations and his remarks and commentary seemed, at first glance,
very convincing and based on a scholarly perspective. Jung's scholarship on deeper
consideration, however, appeared to be built on a body of preconceptions that ultimately require
the reader to believe in. Jung's belief system is clearly the most persuasive of metanarratives
applied to alchemy. In a sense, Jung wrapped up the various metanarratives into his own psychological
theory. For example, Levi's devising of an esoteric secret doctrine underlying human culture
was translated into Jung's concept of a transcultural collective unconscious.
We no longer had to follow Levi and envisage secret groves, hidden ritual centres, mysterious
shrouded adepts. Instead, for Jungians, all of this lay unconsciously inside of every human being.
One of Jung's closest collaborators, Marie-Louise von Franz, said,
it is naturally very tempting to identify the hypothesis of the collective unconscious
historically and regressively with the ancient idea of an all-extensive world-soul.
In this Jungian world, no longer did we find ourselves within a historical current
rooted to our own culture, but we all contained within ourselves archetypes that transcended our
culture and time. This meant that Jungians could even seriously consider that Australian
Aboriginal myths and legends might throw some light on 17th century European alchemy,
or that we should turn to the dreams of someone of today to understand an old alchemy text.
As an example, let us consider the 2003 publication of the Jung Institute of Los Angeles.
The book starts off with a survey of the life of the 10th century Ibn Umayyad and continues by
describing a particular manuscript which contains a very interesting coloured allegorical painting,
but suddenly on page 29, the author of this book, Theodore Abt, feels it necessary to
recount a dream of some unknown modern man, indicating that it will help us understand
the symbolism of Ibn Umayyad. We seem now in the realm of a total collapse of context
and transported into an entirely ahistorical world. The Jungian metanarrative proved seductive
to the modern mind, yet corrosive of linear rational thought. To step into this metanarrative
requires abandoning any sense of historical development and an acceptance that two cultures,
totally disjoint historically and geographically, can have influenced one another. To Jungians,
this is an acceptable price to pay for their belief-driven psychological model.
From the late 1960s, a stream of books on various esoteric themes emerged,
eventually becoming a torrent. These drew on magic, astrology, Celtic and Grail myths,
a fabricated envisaging of shamanism and, of course, alchemy. These writers, for the most part,
unquestioningly accepted the Jungian metanarrative, which often served as a support for ill-conceived
research, allowing writers to draw links between ideas or traditions where there was no evidence
that any existed. This fed the proliferation of actual magical cultic groups and weekend retreats
where people were sometimes led to an encounter with what they thought to be underlying spiritual
forces or archetypes. These books were often profusely illustrated with images taken from a
but usually entirely excised from the original context, probably often chosen by picture editors
for aesthetic reasons within the book design rather than for any coherent reason. Alchemical
illustrations were thus often used purely as decorative elements. This muddling up of images
led to their often being divorced from their context. Items that were in no way alchemical
were labelled as such. In 1996, the Alexander Rube book Alchemy und Mystik was published,
quickly to be issued in English as Alchemy and Mysticism. This profusely illustrated 700-plus
page book was a vehicle for imagery and included little explanatory text. It purported to give the
overview of alchemy and mysticism, providing an hermetic museum, but it was a melange of imagery
from all sorts of sources. Even the cover of some hardback editions used an image which has nothing
to do with either mysticism or alchemy, but instead was taken from the late 15th century
untitled manuscript now called the Estée de Sphaira, which has many beautiful images of the
planets and their influence on the outer world, clearly an astrological piece. Another edition
repeats the confusion, this time using an image from the 17th century celestial cartographer
Andreas Silarius, here an astronomical work. Inside the book, in places, series of alchemical
images that were part of the same work were printed hundreds of pages apart and there was no
historical sequence. A reader without specialist knowledge was just lost in a sea of engaging
but decontextualized images. With the rise of internet image sharing sites such as Tumblr,
Pinterest and Flickr, individuals, some appearing to have no knowledge or understanding
of the material at all, put up a massive imagery under the title of alchemy or related terms.
Items from emblem books, illuminated manuscripts, even the paintings of old masters were now labelled
as alchemical. Image search engines such as that of Google further consolidated this material
and bundled it up. Someone lost any sense of where the image came from. People then raided
these image banks and chose images for use in their blogs or website pages,
often believing them to be alchemical when they have no connection whatsoever to alchemy.
They also feel free to attach their own commentary as people today, labouring under the illusions
of post-modernism applied outside its context of political history and modern media, feel that
anyone's opinion and understanding of an image, even if it is based upon a total misunderstanding
or ignorance of the material, is nevertheless valid. The understanding of alchemical symbolism
and its place in history seems entirely lost, except to the few people who have made a close
study of the subject and have at least viewed many hundreds of books and manuscripts.
Decontextualization is now almost complete and it is a hard task now for someone to find the
original context for a particular image and, in any case, few people today consider this worthwhile.
It is only when people become aware of the fictional, belief-driven nature of these many
metanarratives and the ways in which they subtly filter their perception of these images that they
can come to a real encounter with what was originally intended by the creator of an
alchemical emblem. All else is just mere storytelling. Sadly, few people are sufficiently
engaged by this imagery to wish to truly grasp it. Instead we see that, especially during the 20th
century, there has been constructed a modern idea of alchemy that has only selectively drawn
on historical alchemy. Thus has been created a sort of simplistic, cartoon-like alchemy
that the modern mind responds to and which satisfies the need in the popular mind for a way
of envisaging the subject. These three videos have been an attempt, however imperfect,
to survey the ways in which alchemical symbolism appeared in historical tradition
and the way in which our modern age has massaged and remade the subject. There seems no way back,
for most people, into a true encounter with what the alchemists were actually saying in
their texts and imagery as this requires much hard work and research and there are so many
easy-to-read books available which claim to reveal what alchemy is about. I will,
over the next few months, revisit and critique in more detail some of these metanarratives
in further audiovisuals for YouTube.
