House Appropriations Committee Holds Oversight Hearing on Economy Act

Live News Network
1.4K followers
3 Video Views·Sep 15, 2026
The House Appropriations Committee’s Subcommittee on Financial Services and General Government holds a hearing titled “Oversight Hearing—The Economy Act” at 10 a.m. ET on Sept. 15.
Witnesses:
Shirley Jones, managing associate general counsel, U.S. Government Accountability OfficeDominick Fiorentino, analyst in government organization and management, Congressional Research Service
AI Generated·May contain errors
I now recognize myself for an opening statement. I'd like to welcome both of our witnesses here
today and for taking the time to be here. Today's oversight hearing is intended to help us better
understand the origins of the and the use of the Economy Act since its enactment. The policy
behind the Economy Act is simple. It allows government agencies to acquire goods or services
from other agencies. An agency can utilize the Economy Act when funds are available.
Another agency can fill the order and the head of the agency decides the goods cannot be provided
as conveniently or cheaply by a commercial enterprise. The Economy Act provides powerful
flexibility that allows government agencies to take advantage of another agency's expertise,
potentially saving taxpayer money and leading to better policy outcomes. These transactions
occur all over government for a variety of purposes and there are substantial benefits.
It is important for Congress to understand how these agreements work and whether the Act can
and should be strengthened. We are always encouraged by ways to save the government
money and to utilize the federal government's vast resources to be more efficient. From an
appropriation standpoint, Economy Act transactions are being used and impact current agency operations
and funding levels. As policymakers, we need to understand the Economy Act's limitations and its
strengths so that Congress can ensure that the Economy Act is effective. We want to make sure
that we support agencies that are undertaking additional work under the Economy Act. I look
forward to learning more from our experts here today and I now recognize the Ranking Member,
Mr. Hoyer, for his opening statement. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I'm
pleased that we're having hearings. I'm pleased we're having a hearing on the Economy Act.
While nearing a century old and as relevant today as it has ever been,
while its original attempt was to help the federal government economize
and become more efficient, it is now increasingly being used, in my view,
as a loophole to get around Congress's authority over appropriations. It has become a tool of
executive overreach, exploited in ways Congress never intended. A prime example has been the
administration's attempt to purge the federal workforce through DOJ. The Trump administration
used the Economy Act to move funds from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to pay
DOJ employees. Another example is the Department of Education, which has used the Economy Act to
outsource critical department-specific functions to other departments and agencies. The Economy
Act does not authorize such transfers or functions, only transfer of funds under very limited,
specific circumstances, which shows, Mr. Chairman, that the Economy Act is being misused and
misappropriated. As an institution, Congress cannot and should not allow it to be exploited in such a
way as to circumvent our power of the purse and seize control over key aspects of the appropriations
process. No administration should be able to use an efficiency statute as a taxpayer's fund should
be spent. We cannot and must not allow the executive branch to make congressional restrictions
or directions disappear by routing other than the original recipient of funds.
This is especially serious given the current administration's rampant disregard for law
and constitutional norms and its track record of seeking any and every loophole possible
through which they can make an end run around Congress. This is the unitary presidency that
folks speak so often about. I'm looking forward to hearing from our expert witnesses today.
I hope they can help us shed some light for ourselves to engage in actions that undermine
our system of checks and balances, and I hope I'll be hearing your observations on that specific
issue. I hope we will take away from today's hearing both a greater understanding of the
problem and a determination to fix it. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I yield back the balance
of my time. Thank you very much, Mr. Hoyer. Today, we welcome the testimony of Dominic Fiorentino,
Analyst in Government Organization and Management, Congressional Research Service,
and Shirley Jones, Managing Associate General Counsel, U.S. Government Accountability Office.
Without objection, your written testimonies will be entered into the record. With that in mind,
we ask you to please summarize your opening statement in five minutes or less. Mr. Fiorentino,
you are now recognized. Good morning, Chairman Joyce, Ranking Member Hoyer,
and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on the Economy Act.
I will summarize my written statement with the following brief remarks.
The Economy Act authorizes an agency to either place an order for goods or services
provided directly from another agency or to use another agency's contracts or contracting
operations. The agency ordering the goods or services is the requesting agency, and the agency
providing the goods or services is the servicing agency. The Economy Act applies when no other
specific statutory authority is available. Legislation to provide generally applicable
interagency transaction authority was introduced in 1930 as a legislative package to reduce
government spending during the Great Depression. Contemporaneous committee reports stated that the
intent of this provision was to help agencies save money by relying on existing agency contracts
and generate economies of scale by reducing redundant activities.
The Economy Act provided for unassisted acquisitions, which authorizes an agency to
use another agency's existing contracts. In 1940, this provision was amended to allow certain
defense agencies to perform assisted acquisitions, such as awarding and administering a contract on
another agency's behalf. In 1980, the Assisted Acquisition Authority was expanded to all agencies.
The Economy Act has also been amended. In the early 1990s, reported misuse of contracting
authority under the Economy Act led Congress to pass provisions that required updates to the
Federal Acquisition Regulation, or the FAR. Economy Act agreements are subject to the FAR
when the transaction results in one agency using another agency's procurement contract
or contracting operations. The FAR updates included a requirement that the servicing agency
either have an existing contract for the good or service or be better qualified to administer the
contract on the requesting agency's behalf. In 2008, Congress directed another FAR update
to require assisted acquisitions to include a written agreement assigning responsibility for
contract administration and management. Agency use of the Economy Act is subject to the following
statutory conditions. The requesting agency must have the funds available. The order must be in
best interest of the United States. The servicing agency must be able to provide the goods or
services. And the goods or services must be available more conveniently or cheaply than
for a private contractor. Economy Act transactions are typically documented in the form of an
interagency agreement. Economy Act orders subject to the FAR must also be supported by a determination
and findings document. The interagency agreements and determination and findings documents are
internal to the agency and are not always made publicly available. The Economy Act does not
define the variety of goods and services that it authorizes agencies to provide. Examples of
categories of work performed under the Economy Act include interagency acquisitions, detailing
personnel, property management, and other services. There is no publicly available government-wide
data on agency use of the Economy Act, nor is there a government-wide requirement that agencies
regularly report on their use of the Economy Act to Congress. Given concerns over agency use of the
Economy Act, Congress may consider options that would limit the use of these transactions or
create new reporting requirements. Congress may consider instituting a requirement making all
Economy Act transactions subject to limitations or notification requirements similar to reprogrammings
or transfer of funds, limiting the use of the Economy Act above a certain threshold,
requiring agencies to affirmatively provide interagency agreements to Congress, or requiring
the establishment of these options against the value of current agency flexibilities.
This concludes my brief remarks. Thank you for the opportunity.
Good morning, Chairman Joyce, Ranking Member Hoyer, and members of the subcommittee. Thank you
for the opportunity to discuss the Economy Act and its legal requirements. My written testimony
submitted for the record starts with the history of the enactment of the Economy Act in 1932.
I'd like to start my oral statement by discussing why this topic still matters and why
continued congressional oversight is still important. In fact, this topic is so important
that it spent several years on GAO's high-risk list from 2005 to 2013. Because interagency
transactions require that statutory requirements are met, we were particularly concerned with the
lack of data on these contracts, unclear lines of accountability between customer and servicing
agencies, and the potential for the provision of out-of-scope work. In our 2013 report,
we removed it from the high-risk list based on the progress made by agencies at that time in
addressing previously identified deficiencies and steps taken to address the need for better data,
among other efforts. Congressional oversight was noted as being vital in addressing the issues.
That oversight continues to be particularly important for Economy Act transactions,
which have requirements that some other interagency contracting statutes may lack.
The Economy Act itself provides some guardrails, but principles of appropriations law provide even
more. First and foremost, an agency must have an available appropriation. Available in this
context has two meanings. First, there must be sufficient budget authority to cover the cost
of the agency's order so that the agency does not violate the Anti-Deficiency Act. Second,
due to the purpose statute, the ordered goods or services must advance the purpose of the
appropriation of the customer agency uses for the transaction. An agency may not use an Economy Act
transaction to do something it is not already authorized to do. Similarly, a precondition to
all Economy Act transactions is that the performing agency must be able to provide the goods or
provide the service either in-house or by contract. In addition to these requirements, the customer
agency must determine that the agreement goods or services could not be obtained as cheaply or
conveniently on the market. Once these preconditions are met, a customer agency may enter into a written
Economy Act agreement with another federal entity documented in accordance with the recording
statute which prescribes the requirements for a valid obligation. Under the written agreement,
the Economy Act requires that the ordering agency reimburse the performing agency for its actual
cost, no more, no less. This rule ensures that neither the customer agencies nor the servicing
agencies appropriations are improperly augmented, thereby infringing upon Congress's power of the
purse. When an agency pays for the goods or services under the Economy Act, the transferred
funds are subject to the limitations and restrictions that apply to the original appropriation.
Importantly, the Economy Act requires that any amount obligated from the ordering agency's
appropriation will be obligated to the extent that the performing agency has not incurred
obligations before the end of the appropriations period of availability.
In closing, the Economy Act is a useful tool when these guardrails are respected.
As set out here and more fully in my written testimony, agencies must keep
an appropriations law principle to ensure that interagency transactions are indeed appropriate.
Thank you, and I'm happy to respond to any questions you may have.
Thank you. Right on time with that five minutes. God bless.
I now recognize myself for questions. Mr. Fiorentino, would you talk a little bit
about the origins of the Economy Act and why was the Economy Act enacted?
The Economy Act was enacted because agencies at the time lacked the
interagency agreements to acquire goods and services from other agencies. There was a
provision to make this authority broader. The idea behind it was that it would introduce
efficiencies, save the government money, and reduce redundant activities by allowing,
if one particular agency specialized in a particular service, for instance,
another agency would be able to buy from that agency as opposed to duplicate.
Thank you, sir. I am sure that agencies put in the time to decide which process is best for them,
but as my colleague's testimony, if an agency has an agency-specific statute, they should use
that statute and follow the requirements of that statute and any limitations included in that
statute and any limitations included in appropriations acts.
Are there any common pitfalls that agencies need to be aware of with the Economy Act?
The common pitfall that is most talked about is the requirement, the de-obligation requirement.
Some consider that a pitfall. Of course, we consider it good appropriations principles
so that the agency is not allowed to extend the obligational life of the appropriations. Of
course, that de-obligation provision, as I noted in the testimony, provides that if the
performing agency has not obligated during that appropriations period of availability,
those funds must be de-obligated. It is not allowed to retain those funds
and extend the obligational life. Ms. Jones, in your work, have you observed
trends with respect to the use of the Economy Act by agencies?
Right. GAO has had some ongoing work related to the Economy Act. We have some previous work.
For the most part, the common trends that we have seen is that agencies have used it for details
and for common services. Those have been the trends in the past for the use of the Economy Act.
Do you have any recommendations for Congress?
Recommendations for Congress. Of course, I don't want to get ahead of the work that we're
currently doing on the Economy Act with specific agencies. Of course, the GAO is always interested
in greater transparency. There are opportunities for that. GAO is also always interested in
encouraging greater written documentation. As my colleague here noted in his testimony
specifically, the contracts must be subject to the FAR in order for the agency to be required
to do those terminations and findings documents. Even with that, those are not publicly available.
I would suggest not getting ahead of the work that we are currently doing that might have
some recommendations that there are opportunities for greater transparency.
Mr. Parent, that leads to, has Congress monitored the use of the Economy Act in the past? If they
have, how? There was an investigation and a report
on agency use of the Economy Act that resulted in some of those changes related to the Federal
Acquisition Regulation. The concern was that agencies were engaging what the report termed
offloading. Basically, using other agencies' contracting services, which in and of itself
is not necessarily a problem, but the report found that agencies were doing it in such a way to
avoid certain management or administrative responsibilities engaging in noncompetitive
practices. It resulted in greater requirements for documentation for Economy Act transactions
subject to the FAR that document in greater detail agency responsibilities when there
is assisted acquisitions happening, greater justification for why they're engaging in an
Economy Act transaction. In terms of there is limited data on the use of the Economy Act,
which may pose additional challenges for continued congressional oversight.
Thank you. Chair now recognizes Ranking Member Hoyer for any questions he may have.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I want to ask this to both of you. Do you agree that the Economy
Act cannot give an agency authority to accomplish something through another agency that it could not
lawfully accomplish with its own appropriation? I agree. Yes, the agency's statutory authorization
or its appropriation will limit the agency from engaging in such activities.
Do you, also to both of you, do you agree that government-wide savings do not by themselves
make an otherwise unavailable appropriation legally available? I would agree with that as well.
Under the purpose statute, the agency must be using its appropriations to further its mission.
Has GAO looked at, over the last 24 months, whether such activity has occurred?
Not globally. GAO has not looked at interagency agreements across all of the government. We do
have some requests related to specific agencies that are ongoing.
Now, I must admit, I have not read your very copious comments. I hope to read them all,
but I have not read them to date. Is there anything in your testimony that refers to
violations that both of you have spoken to over the past 24 months? In other words,
the misuse of this bill, which you said ought to have guardrails and ought to have oversight.
You said it was on the high-risk list and now it's been taken off the high-risk
list. Why was it taken off the high-risk list? It was taken off the high-risk list in 2013 because
we were able to see that agencies, the specific agencies that we were looking at,
had addressed the deficiencies that we identified. We also noted in that report that both OMB and GSA
had made certain oversight vehicles available to the agencies to use. In your testimony,
you specifically lamented the lack of transparency, sufficient transparency to
be able to do your job fully.
In light of that, do you have confidence that the high risk that was originally,
I don't know when the year was, but you referenced, applied to this have not been reinstated,
or do you believe it is no longer a high risk? Well, I definitely don't want to get ahead of
anything that my colleagues at GA are doing related to our high-risk work. Our last report
was issued in 2025, and our next one will be issued at the beginning of the next Congress.
Of course, as I noted, we do have some reports, some engagements that are currently looking at
interagency transactions in the Economy Act, and I do know that my colleagues across GAO
will be looking at what we find in those reports to determine if interagency transactions would
need to be put back on the high-risk list. From your knowledge, Ms. Jones, has there been any
focus on the reference that I made to DOJ being funded by the Consumer Protection Funds?
In our ongoing work? Yes. Our ongoing work is in the early stages. I can't say whether or not
anything related to DOJ is in that work. It is in the very early stages of it,
and I definitely don't want to get ahead of anything that my colleagues at GAO are doing.
You're in GAO? Oh, absolutely, but I am not on the teams that are doing the audits. I understand
that. Based upon, when you say in the early stages, I'm not sure exactly what early stages
means. How long has that been going on at this point in time? We have some requests that came in
in the June time frame and in the August time frame, and those engagements have been staffed,
and the work is beginning on those. Okay. I have a short time left. I'm hopeful that GAO
will be taking its responsibilities very seriously and that we will have
numerous oversight hearings on that issue. I may not be here, but my belief is that this
administration has very substantially misused both the act itself and abused the appropriations
guardrails to which you refer very, very substantially because of their belief that
the president has the authority to spend and sequester money consistent with his own beliefs
and not with that directed by law. So I hope he will look at that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Hoyer. Chair now recognizes Mr. Edwards for questions.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. To our witnesses, thanks for being with us this morning.
Ms. Jones, the Economy Act was intended to allow agencies to take advantage of existing
government capabilities when doing so is more economical than going to the private sector.
Does GAO have evidence that agencies are consistently demonstrating actual cost savings
when they use the Economy Act agreements? As I noted, GAO does have some ongoing work
in that regard, and I'm sure my colleagues at GAO during these audits that I just mentioned
will be looking at those factors. Globally, I would say no, we do not because we have not
looked globally across the government at interagency agreements under the Economy Act.
And of course, as we have noted here, the determinations and finding statements
that the agencies are required to make under the Economy Act are not publicly available.
Certainly, Congress could request them, but they're not made available as a matter of course.
In your opinion, who would be responsible for making requests of those?
Certainly, whichever section over the particular agency in question. Certainly,
Congress could request that interagency agreements be made available just generally
to the relevant authorizing and appropriating committees.
Thank you for that. The whole point of the laws is supposed to be saving taxpayers dollars
not going to a private contractor. Does anyone actually check after the fact whether that
assumption held up or are the savings just assumed up front and never verified? And I
recognize you don't report that to Congress. But how do you know whether or not we're looking
at this after the fact? Either one of you can answer.
So I don't believe we have that data or I'm not aware of that being done in any systematic way.
It would be incumbent upon the agency to have cost estimates based on their industry research
and market research. And then that would help them make the determination that the economy
actors in the government's best interest, which should be documented in the determination and
findings document. But again, I am not aware of any systematic review of that.
Mr. Chair, it sounds like it might be a loophole for FSDG to close in our quest to provide oversight.
Ms. Jones, what information do you think Congress should be asking agencies to provide
to demonstrate that an economy act agreement is actually cheaper or more efficient than a
commercial alternative? Well, currently the statute does not require that the terminations and
findings agreement be made publicly available. And so that could be one change that could be made
if the interaction or interagency agreement is subject to the FAR, then they do have to submit
those written agreements. But otherwise they do not and even then they're not publicly available.
So that would be adding greater transparency. Thank you. I think I believe I see another
legislative opportunity before us. Mr. Chair, I'll yield.
Thank you very much, Mr. Edwards. Chair, and I'll recognize Mr. Polk.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thanks for having this hearing because this is
truly like nonpartisan, bipartisan, however you want to describe it, but it's about
Congress. And I think we're all working together on this and I'm going to build on
Mr. Edwards's questions. Can you, either of you tell us how many interagency agreements
under the economy act are currently in place? No, that there is no data that would allow us to
answer that. GAO does not have that information. Do you know how many interagency agreements under
the economy act are in place in the most recent completed fiscal year? GAO does not have that
information. I would defer to OMB or GSA to have that information, but GAO does not. I think Mr.
Vogt is going to have a permanent chair here in the near future. He's going to have plenty
of opportunities. Do you know how much funding was transferred between the aggregate amount of money?
That information is not available. Do you have the magnitude of the funding that was transferred
between offices or agencies under the economy act last year? Was it millions, hundreds of millions,
billions? We do not have that information. No idea. We don't have that information. So I think
this builds on Mr. Edwards's questions, which is just, you know, Congress, we could request,
but we don't even know where to request because we don't know anything about any of these for
transparency. And if they're not automatically reported to us, it makes it even harder. Is there
any kind of real-time reporting that Congress can get short of making requests of something it may
not know has been requested? So certainly Congress could require that agencies proactively notify
Congress in advance of entering into such agreements. In terms of like the agencies,
of course, are accounting for these transactions. The treasury also has a system called G invoicing
that is tracking government to government invoicing, which would include economy act and
other interagency agreements that are not necessarily subject to the economy act.
In terms of implementation, there may be a way to use that data to provide information in a way
that is legible and useful to Congress. Is G invoicing public? Is that presented to Congress?
I do not believe it is public.
This is about as non-transparent as anything, right? Because you can't tell me the amount of
money, who's doing it, the last fiscal year, the current year, right? Am I correct? All of these,
we don't have any idea? That's correct. That information is not available to the public
or to Congress that I'm aware of. So help me understand a little bit. Right now there's a,
as I available, the OMB made for the ballroom project. I know Ms. Jones, you mentioned particular
it's used for details and common services. Do we know what details or common services
that $385 million is being used for? Now, when I mentioned details and call services,
but you know, 385, let's worry about that now. So I meant historically, that's what we've seen
the economy. So let me go back to the 385. Do we have any idea what? Okay. And do we,
have we seen the interagency agreement on that? No. No. Do we know if it's the terms and conditions
or anything have been publicly put out there? I am not aware of those being made publicly
available. Gotcha. Is there, so is there anywhere that could actually see this? No. Okay. So
Congress, could we request it? Yes. That would be the only way. So something like this. All right.
So that's, that's part of the problem, right? Off the high risk list was because it was not being
abused period of time. But the fact that right now it seems to be used much more and maybe in
slightly interesting ways could put it back on a high risk list, correct? That is absolutely
possible. And as I noted, GAO does have some ongoing work that we recently started
related to the ballroom. Sure. When will that come out? We don't yet have a timeline on it. As I
noted, the request came in, in June and in August, and we're starting up our work. Of course, the most
important thing is to, that's why agency cooperation is so important. Sure. Can you,
can you have any estimate? Because they're building right now with this funding that
no one knows how they're able to move. I do not have an estimate. Okay. Gotcha. And then I think
Ms. DeLauro will come in and probably ask more about this, but I think there was an issue that
got a lot of attention where some NIH money, National Institute of Health money went to the
Department of Defense. And now it may be, do you know anything about this particular amount of
money? I am, well, I'm aware of it, but we do not have a request for it. And so we do not have an
engagement related to that. Thank you. I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you very much, Mr. Pocan. The chair now recognizes Ms. Hinson for her questions.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to our ranking member and thank you to our witnesses for being
here today. Mr. Fiorentino and Ms. Jones, appreciate you joining us to share some
insight on the Economy Act. When it's used as intended, I think it is a great tool for
making government more efficient and saving taxpayers money. And I think it's really
important for agencies to be able to have the flexibility to obtain goods and services from
another agency. We know presidents of both parties have used this tool very effectively over the
years, but that makes a strong congressional oversight very important in the process. So
particularly for this subcommittee, of course, which oversees many of the agencies that do
frequently use these provisions in the Economy Act and these agreements. So I kind of just a
general question. How do agencies most commonly use it in terms of practical application? So
Iowans who are watching who are maybe not familiar with the Economy Act, how are agencies just
typically using this? I can start by just reiterating that historically what we've
seen in some of our prior decisions and some of our prior work, agencies have more commonly
used it for details that one agency shares its expertise with another agency. We've also
seen it commonly used for agencies to get common services that another agency has its own
appropriation for that. Do you think it's a practical tool to reduce redundancies? Are you
seeing that in actual application? What are some of the good results that you've seen
previous administrations use where the Economy Act led to some really good results?
Certainly, I think it's allowing an agency to use another agency's particular expertise
in a particular area, maybe for IT digital services or other very specialized activities
where it does not make sense for the agency to necessarily stand up that activity on its own.
So it would maybe eliminate the need to hire an outside contractor or reduce that cost for
that agency if they can rely on someone else's expertise? Correct. Okay, what documentation
is maintained when those agreements are in place for Economy Act transactions between agencies?
Between the two, the requesting and servicing agency, the interagency agreement.
If the agreement were also subject to the federal acquisition,
servicing agency engaging in a contract with an outside party, then there would be a determination
and findings document that's going to say, why are we engaging in the Economy Act? Is this in
the best interest of the government? Is there a cost saving involved here? As we had said before,
neither of those documents are made publicly available as a matter of course. Okay, so
basically, it's a justification for the need to have the agreement. Why do you think that it would
serve the public to have those be available? Why wouldn't they be available to the public?
One of the challenges, of course, could be that there could be sensitive information on those
documents that might need to be redacted. But certainly, that has not prevented agencies from
sharing other information with Congress or the public, assuming that the right security protocols
are in place. But certainly, from a congressional oversight perspective, having access to those
documents would allow Congress to have greater visibility as to because we have been able to
provide you with anecdotes of how agencies have used this. But the challenge is we don't have an
overarching view of how agencies have used this authorization. How would you say it's evolved over
the years? I mean, obviously, you mentioned IT and technology sharing agreements. What are some
of the ways where this tool has evolved as these agencies have progressed? Well, it's definitely
evolved past agencies just using it for details and common services. The agencies are using it in
a variety of ways. Of course, we're seeing this specifically related to the ballroom and
education. Of course, the Department of Education has made these interagency agreements publicly
available on its website. So that's up to each individual agency if they are choosing to make
them available. Yes. In some cases, they are publicly available just at the agency's discretion.
Correct. Okay. And what happens when, you know, if that agreement is not adhered to or there's an
overspend, what's the accountability there? Because obviously, if we're not necessarily
privy to that document, is that just sorted out between the agencies? The requesting agency were
to overpay. The agency would be required to return those funds to the requesting agency.
So, and then would they be, I'm sorry, I'm almost, I know I'm out of town. Would they be
invoiced for that additional expense or how does that work? I don't know exactly what the mechanics
would look like. Okay. If you could get back to me on what that process kind of would look like,
I'd appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Ms. Sensen. Chair now recognize Mr. Bishop.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me welcome Mr. Fiorentino and my spell house sister, Ms. Jones.
One of the interagency agreements announced on March 19th, 2026 will require that the
Treasury Department manage the federal student loan portfolio and start to assume operational
responsibility for collecting on defaulted student loans. One of the requirements of the
Economy Act is that the agency must determine that private commercial sources cannot provide
the goods and services as conveniently or as economically. What metrics or criteria should
be used to determine that the Department of Treasury will manage the contracts that collect
on defaulted student loans more cheaply and more economically than private energies. And the use
of the Economy Act requires an agency to determine that use of the agreement will provide the
services needed more conveniently or economically than currently being provided. Is that criteria
met if the Treasury Department merely enters into agreements with the same or similar entities
that provide those services now? Thank you, sir, for that question. That goes back to the point
that we've been making about determinations and findings statements. If those were more publicly
available, we would all have been here. I would note that GAO does have an engagement underway
looking at the education department in particular and some of their interagency transactions. So,
of course, as I noted earlier, I don't want to get ahead of our findings there because,
of course, our first order of business is, in fact, developing adequate information.
Yes, I would agree with my colleague here that that information is not available, so we would
not be able to know how it's being implemented and whether there are cost savings being achieved or
not. So, that's part of the investigation there. Let me ask another question. When Congress created
the Department of Homeland Security, it took legislation to merge 22 different federal
agencies and departments, such as FEMA and INS, into the new Unified Department. It seems
unprecedented that the Trump administration can use the Economy Act to break up the federal
education bureaucracy and allegedly reinstate it into the states. Historically, has the Economy Act
ever been used to dismantle a federal agency, to your knowledge? And what percentage is left of the
of available funds after these interagency agreements? I can't speak to how much of the
appropriations is left, but I can say that both GAO and the Department of Justice have said that
the Economy Act cannot be used to transfer an agency's core administrative functions. So,
if that is the case, it is
transactions in particular. Potential administrative costs for states, districts, or
organizational Department of Education under the Economy Act, and should those administrative
costs be taken into account? Information in conjunction with the audits that we're doing.
One of the requirements of the Economy Act is that the servicing agency has to have the ability
to provide the goods and services, meaning that they are capable, they have the personnel,
or they have the ability to get the personnel to do the work. So, the assumption would be that the
Department of Education and Treasury would have taken that into account when entering into the
agreement, but we don't have additional information about how they came to that
determination. So, that's an assumption that you have to make, given the benefit of the doubt,
but there's no mandate or requirement to actually take that into consideration.
So, it is a requirement of the Economy Act that you need to determine that, one, you have the
funds available, and, two, that you have the ability to do the work. What we don't have access
to is documentation as to how the agencies interact with the agency. Now, is it going to
require the colleges, universities to spend extra funds in order to do business? I certainly can't
predict what might happen. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Bishop. The Chair now recognizes Mr. Ives.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I commend you for scheduling this hearing. It's, in my view,
I note that you are a resident in my district, so, in addition to being a Spelman grad, but it's
great to have you here. A couple questions that I had. I wasn't familiar with the Economy Act,
actually, but it looks like, so, we talked about transparency. I'll come back to that in a minute,
but one of the things I'm trying to figure out is how, let's say, Department A and Department B,
Department A reaches out to B. It's actually the Economy Act to do that with you. Who makes the
determination as to whether the criteria are met for this to be eligible for an Economy Act
transaction? The agencies collectively make that determination. Of course, the customer agency,
Agency A, would have to believe that they are in a, they can transfer funds that still fulfill the
mission of the agency to Agency B, and Agency B must be able to provide those services, either
in-house or through contract. Is that a contracting officer, or is there some other
mechanism by which the determination is made? I would like to believe that it is their
contracting department that's making those determinations, but I don't know for sure.
We don't know for sure. I think it would probably vary depending upon the dollar value of the
transaction. Certainly, the larger the dollar value, the higher up in the agency the approval
would be. I think you said that the two factors they look at are whether the funds are available
and whether the agency can do the work. Is there any kind of consideration or determination about
whether this would be in the public interest? What is that factor? It has to be in the best
interest of the government, and it has to be determined that the agency, the other federal
entity, can provide it more cheaply and more conveniently.
There would be some kind of calculation about, and I would assume that in addition to a
calculation about what the cost would be for A to do the contract with B, that there might
have been some kind of review about private sector opportunities that would have been made?
Absolutely. What we've seen in some of our previous decisions is that some agencies even
sent out an offer, a request for a bid. The bids came back and they were all higher than what the
other federal entity would do, than they would go with the federal entity. There are methodologies
that can be used to determine if it is more cost effective to go with the other federal entity.
Excellent. Whoever makes this determination in Department B, presumably would document
what they've gone through in making this determination? Presumably. Presumably. Okay.
Is that the kind of information where we're talking about transparency and what should be
provided to Congress and I think the public? That sort of calculation would be important from my
perspective to make sure that the decision was made in the right way. Absolutely. I think that's
why we've both been harping on the determination and finding statements that are required if it is
a FAR transaction. That's also why we've been harping on the fact that it would add greater
transparency if those were publicly available. If it's not a FAR transaction, what happens then?
They're still required to make the determination, but it is not necessarily a written
determination. Okay. Then with respect to public disclosure, is FOIA exempted
from applicability here? If a public, let's say public citizen, Joe, wanted to ask what happened
with this transaction and why was it made, files a FOIA request with Department A or B, I guess,
for that matter. Under FOIA, is there any ability to obtain the documents? I am not a FOIA expert,
so I can't specifically answer to your knowledge. Let me ask it this way. Is there any
avenue or opportunity for a citizen to get the information? I guess short of a subpoena,
we'll set that to the side, but public citizens just interested and wants to know,
is there some avenue by which they can routinely get that kind of information?
Short of allowed under FOIA, I'm not aware of any way that they would receive it.
There are obviously various government websites where you can get obligation or an expenditure
data. Some of them identify if it's an Economy Act transaction. Some do not. I see my time has
expired, so I thank the chair. You can't be an expert in everything, Mrs. Jones. Oh, thank you.
And I must admit, he was awfully nice to you because you were a constituent. Normally,
it's not that nice. With that, our time is concluded, and there may be some members who
like to submit additional questions. Let me back up. Mr. Hoyer would like one additional
question, and then we'll close. I would like you to provide me with the last example that the
act in question, the last five examples. Right. Thank you. Thank you. Can we do that for the
record? Yes. Yes, of course. We will do that. Great. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. And
with that, our time is concluded. There may be some members who would like to submit additional
questions. Please submit any questions for the record to the subcommittee staff within seven
days. I'd like to again thank you both for being here today. This hearing is concluded.
