LIVE: NYC Mayor Mamdani Makes Major Immigration Announcement

Live News Network
1.4K followers
19 Video Views·Sep 14, 2026
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani holds a news conference with New York Attorney General Letitia James to make a major immigration announcement at 11 a.m. ET on Sept. 14. Mamdani is expected to take questions.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedNew York City and State officials are suing to block a federal \"public charge\" rule that denies immigration status to those using public benefits. Officials argue the rule creates a \"chilling effect,\" forcing immigrant families to forgo essential healthcare and nutrition. The city is providing legal resources to residents while challenging the rule's legality in court.
We're all good? All right.
And all the advocates here today for your efforts on this important issue.
In
2019, New York City and New York State, along with a coalition of community partners,
prevailed in court to block an unlawful federal public charge rule that was damaging to all New Yorkers,
citizens and non-citizens alike.
Unfortunately, we're back here today
because the federal government has again taken aim at our immigrant communities with a new
expansive and unlawful public charge rule
scheduled to take effect on September 18th that changes the meaning and the intent of the rule in a manner
that is even more harmful than the
2019 rule. This new rule will impose
unnecessary fear and uncertainty on immigrant families who are already
navigating complex systems to build stable and productive lives in our communities.
Accessing programs that help people meet basic needs,
healthcare,
nutrition assistance, housing support, should not be viewed as being a public charge.
The consequences of this rule would extend
far beyond the people directly subject to it. When families are afraid to seek medical care,
obtain food assistance, or access other essential services, the effects are felt throughout our communities.
Children may go without the support they need,
families may delay necessary health care, and trusted institutions including schools,
hospitals, and social services providers can lose the confidence of the communities they serve.
New York City understands the importance of welcoming immigrants and ensuring that every resident can access the services
necessary to live safely and with dignity. Our city is stronger when families are healthy,
children are supported, and people are able to work, contribute, and participate fully in their communities.
A rule that discourages people from seeking essential services does not make families more self-sufficient.
It can make them less secure, less healthy, and ultimately more vulnerable.
We should not force families to choose between meeting their basic needs today and
protecting their ability to remain together and build a future here in our city.
For these reasons, our lawsuit that has just been filed
seeks to permanently enjoin the Department of Homeland Security from implementing this dangerous rule.
It gives me great pleasure to introduce the person who's made it possible for us to bring this case,
Mayor Zoran Mamdani.
Good morning.
Thank you to everyone who has joined us today here at City Hall.
I want to recognize our City's Corporation Council, Steve Banks, and the countless others in the Law Department
for their tireless work on behalf of immigrant New Yorkers.
I want to commend State Attorney General Letitia James for her ongoing efforts to protect our immigrant communities
with the full force of New York's legal power.
And I want to thank the New Yorkers and immigrant families that are standing alongside me, all of whom
proudly call our city home. We have among them New York Immigration Coalition President Murad Awade.
We have Make the Road Health Program Director Arlene Cruz.
We have leaders from within city government, whether our Deputy Mayor for Health and Human Services, Helen Arteaga,
Deputy Mayor for Economic Justice, Julie Hsu, Chief Counsel Ramzi Qasem, our Commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs,
Faiza Ali,
HRA Administrator Scott French, Health Department Commissioner Dr. Alastair Martin, Special Advisor for Strategic Coordination and Operations, Vita Mustafi.
We also have leaders at both the city level, the borough level, and the district level,
whether our Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, our Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoyleman-Segal, as well as
so many friends and colleagues representing this city in the Council, in the Assembly, and in the State Senate.
We are all gathered here today
out of a belief
that New York City is the greatest city in the world, in no small part because of the immigrants who helped to build it.
Immigrants laid the foundations of our bridges and erected towers that stretch into the sky.
Immigrants wrote the poems that stir our hearts and sang the songs that make us dance.
Immigrants fought for the eight-hour workday, for fair pay, and workplace protections that deliver dignity into the lives of so many.
Immigrants from every country, from every continent, who speak every language and worship in every conceivable way
drive our buses and our trains, teach our children how to read, and tend to us when we are sick.
Immigrants are New Yorkers, and yet we know that all too often
they are not treated as such. The federal government has waged a campaign of violence and terror.
Unaccompanied children have been forced to navigate our judicial system alone. ICE has broken into our neighbors' homes,
worksites, and schools, and it has targeted those who have come to our country in search of refuge and in search of opportunity.
These actions are an assault on our civic fabric, on our shared values,
and no matter how much destruction they have already caused, it continues.
Just last month, the federal government finalized a set of drastic and unlawful changes to our country's public charge rule,
a rule that makes it possible for someone to be denied immigration status based on the likelihood of their need for public benefits.
Set to go into effect this coming Friday, September 18th,
the new public charge rule expands the list of public benefits that might count against green card or visa applicants.
If you are a citizen or an individual seeking humanitarian relief like asylum, these changes will not affect you.
The new federal public charge rule not only sweeps aside more than a century of established law,
it is intentionally vague as a means of creating uncertainty and fear to isolate immigrant New Yorkers,
to force them to make an impossible choice between meeting their own basic needs and continuing to live in the city that they love.
Make no mistake,
this is an undisguised effort to strip New Yorkers of the services they rely on, the public benefits they are entitled to.
Families, including those with children who are U.S. citizens, have already begun to forgo essential services like SNAP,
Medicaid, and affordable housing out of the fear that if they use these programs,
immigration officers could use it as justification to deny them a future in our country.
The toll of this new rule cannot be overstated.
It is estimated that up to four million people from across the country could unenroll from their health care alone,
including 1.8 million children.
None of this is abstract.
People could die.
As a result of these changes,
the rate of premature mortality in immigrant communities in New York City could increase by up to 10.6 percent within just the next five years.
The data is clear.
Denying people services does not erase their need. It compounds it,
generating a greater cost to our system that will be placed on the backs of working people for years to come.
Nothing about this rule will reduce waste or keep Americans safer or improve New Yorkers' lives.
It is simply a vehicle for confusion and a vehicle for cruelty.
Here in New York City, however, cruelty is not how we seek to govern.
Immigrants are New Yorkers. And like I said once before,
to get to any of us, you will have to get through all of us.
That is why today we are confronting this injustice with the solidarity and action that it demands.
New York City is leading a coalition of cities and counties, including Chicago, San Francisco, Seattle, Santa Clara County, and King County,
to sue the federal government for the gross illegality of their new public charge rule and the irreparable damage that it will cause.
We are filing our lawsuit alongside a separate challenge led by Attorney General James.
I'm grateful for her partnership in this fight and for everything she has done to stand steadfast
alongside New Yorkers.
Now before I close,
I would like to take a moment to speak directly to those across our city who may be affected by the new public charge rule.
Nothing about your or a family member's eligibility to access benefits and services has changed. If you rely on SNAP,
Medicaid, or programs like WIC and TANF,
do not disenroll without first seeking advice from a trusted legal provider.
And if you have concerns about how public charge may affect you or your families,
City Hall is here to help.
To connect with a trusted, safe, and confidential legal services provider for free.
You can call the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs Legal Help Hotline at 1-800-354-0365.
And to ensure that you have the information you need, we are partnering with organizations across the five boroughs
to host community forums,
trainings, and clinics. And we are training city outreach teams on public charge so they can support you throughout this challenging time.
Government exists to serve the people.
In the wealthiest city in the wealthiest country in the history of the world,
we will not waver on the commitment we hold to those we serve. The commitment we hold to one another.
We will stand with immigrant New Yorkers every step of the way.
And in doing so, we will once again demonstrate the power of a city united. Thank you.
It's an honor and a pleasure to call and introduce
Tish James, Attorney General of the State of New York and my old-time Legal Aid colleague.
This is what collective action looks like.
First, I'd like to thank the Mayor of the City of New York for his leadership.
And of course, I want to thank my old friend, Corporation Counsel Steve Banks, for being a steadfast partner
in using the law both as a shield
and as a sword to protect vulnerable and marginalized populations.
And thank you to everyone who has joined us as we take action to protect immigrant families once again
here in New York and across the country.
Alongside our Mayor and his coalition of municipalities, my office is leading a coalition of attorneys general across this nation
in challenging the Trump administration's new public charge rule.
I also want to thank all of my colleagues in government and all of my friends who are here
both on the state level and the city level. The last time the federal government
tried this in 2019,
New York City joined my office's
lawsuit that successfully blocked
the law.
And we will do it again.
This time, my office asks that local leaders organize a municipal coalition of cities in a parallel suit.
Because the harms
threatened by this rule change require an all-of-government
response. The administration's new rule is much broader than any public charge rule in history.
And it will provide so much discretion to immigration officers
that the rules are so opaque and difficult to comprehend and understand.
The harm is that much greater.
The rule would allow immigration officers to consider use of critical benefits like Medicaid and SNAP and even participation
in school meal programs
as part of an applicant's circumstance. And that means immigrant New Yorkers may be forced to ask themselves
impossible questions.
Will getting health insurance hurt my chances of getting a green card?
Will accepting food assistance when I fall on hard times be held against me?
Will my children be able to eat at lunchtime in the cafeteria?
In a mixed-status family,
will my child who is a citizen, who has asthma,
who has CHIP,
will that be used against their parents
who are immigrants
seeking to get
permanent status?
No family should have to grapple with these questions.
And the circumstances of this rule will extend far beyond individual immigration applications.
When families lose health coverage, they may delay care until they are forced to seek
more expensive care at the emergency department.
When families stop receiving food assistance, grocery stores, and other small businesses lose customers.
The downstream effects will hurt our economy, will hurt businesses, will hurt government,
will hurt our ability to address the needs not only in the state, but not only in the city, but across the state.
And when enrollment in programs like Medicaid and SNAP declines,
schools and local governments risk losing automatic certification for free and reduced price meal programs.
This could cut off meals for all eligible students.
Regardless of their family's income or immigration status.
This administration has exceeded its authority under federal immigration law. This is not what Congress intended.
This is an interpretation by an agency which does not have the authority.
It violates the Administrative Procedure Act.
And again, it's a term that the mayor loves to use. It is
capricious.
When the first Trump administration dramatically expanded the public charge rule, New York challenged it in court.
We won.
And we intend to win again.
Today, we are going back to court.
Because immigrant New Yorkers should not have to choose between putting food on the table,
getting the health care they need, and pursuing a future in this country.
And mixed status families
should not have to be torn apart
and make difficult decisions.
I'm proud to stand with Mayor Mandani and our partners
not only in New York State, but in New York City and across the nation
as we do the work that is critically important
to support immigrants. I also want to thank the members of my office who work tirelessly to protect New Yorkers.
The chief of the federal initiatives team,
Rabia Muhedin,
Special Counsel for Immigrant
Services,
Justice Zoe Levine, Special Counsel
Natasha
Kor Gankar, and Assistant Attorney General Ben
Leibovitz,
and of course,
Megan Fox, who heads the office as well.
We will use every legal tool available to us to challenge this rule
and protect New Yorkers from unlawful federal action and stand up for immigrants
who are our neighbors,
our friends,
our family members,
but most importantly,
New Yorkers.
Thank you, Attorney General. I'd like to call up the leader of the New York Immigration Coalition, Murad Awada.
Good morning, everyone.
My name is Murad Awada. I'm the President and CEO of the New York Immigration Coalition.
I want to first start by thanking our Mayor,
Mayor Zohran Mamdani, as well as our New York State Attorney General, Letitia James, for taking legal action
to put a stop to the cruel and inhumane rule change
that will result in thousands of immigrant families having to choose
between feeding their families or seeking immigration status change.
Imagine
having to choose to feed your children
or
being able to adjust your immigration status.
No New Yorker should ever have to worry
that
accessing essential health care, nutrition assistance, or other life-saving programs could put them on a path
to detention and deportation.
For generations, New Yorkers have relied on programs that help families stay healthy, keep food on the table, and build stronger communities.
Access to social services and other public benefits is an investment in our neighborhoods, our workforce, and the shared future of all of New York.
Immigrant New Yorkers are part of that fabric.
They work, they pay taxes,
raise families,
care for our loved ones, and contribute
to our communities across the state.
Instead, this public charge rule change, due to take effect this Friday,
the Trump administration is creating a system where families are
are afraid to access the very resources that help them remain stable and self-sufficient.
Rather than supporting families, the federal government is funneling billions of dollars into mass deportation
that is separating families and creating fear in our communities.
In New York, we cannot allow fear to become the price of seeking basic necessities that are life-saving
for many of our neighbors. This is why we are grateful
to our mayor,
to our New York State Attorney General for standing with immigrant families and taking legal action to protect New Yorkers from the harmful
federal policies that would be devastating to all of our communities.
At a moment when families are being forced to navigate an already
increasingly complex and frightening immigration system that continues to funnel our neighbors into the deportation machine,
our city and state are making it clear that New Yorkers should not have to face these threats alone.
We thank our city and state leaders for using their legal avenues to defend New Yorkers.
We will continue to work alongside our partners, elected officials, and immigrant communities to ensure that every New Yorker
can access the services that they need without fear.
Every family deserves to live with dignity and respect, have the opportunity to live safely,
care for their families,
build a stable future.
That is the New York we will continue to fight for. Thank you.
And next is Make the Road New York Health Program Director Arlene Cruz.
Good morning. Buenos dias.
My name is Arlene Cruz-Escobar. I'm the Director of Health Programs at Make the Road New York.
I'm here today because we need to be clear about the serious consequences
the new public charge rule will have on the health, economic stability, and well-being of immigrant families
across the communities here in New York and throughout the country.
While the new rule may directly apply to only certain applicants of a green card, its effects extend far beyond those individuals.
We know from experience that policies like this generate widespread fear and confusion,
particularly among mixed-status immigrant families.
As a result, many people are not subject to public charge, including those fully eligible for public benefits, may avoid,
delay, or withdraw from critical programs out of fear
that doing so could jeopardize themselves or a family member and the potential to adjust their immigration status in the future.
The consequences are profound and we are already witnessing the chilling effects that the new rule is intended to create.
The federal government itself estimated that reduced participation in public programs
could decrease government spending by up to 13 billion dollars annually,
largely due to lower enrollment among U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents,
especially children.
Thank you for everyone who's helping her.
So the stakes could not be higher.
We risk seeing families postpone medical care until conditions become emergencies,
more children arrive at school hungry,
more families experience housing instability, and more families face avoidable financial hardship.
At a time when many New Yorkers are already struggling with the rising cost of living,
access to public benefits should not be viewed as a sign of dependency.
These programs are essential supports that enable families to meet basic needs,
safeguard their health, and establish a foundation for long-term economic security.
Although the new rule is not yet in effect, we have been hearing the concerns about the rule for months.
Families who fear that participation in such programs such as Medicaid or SNAP could negatively
affect their ability to obtain or even maintain
a lawful immigration status either now or in the future.
Green card holders have asked whether they should disenroll from public health insurance.
Parents with pending green card applications have questioned whether it's safe to receive
SNAP on behalf of their U.S. citizen child.
These concerns are not hypothetical.
We witnessed the same fear and confusion in 2019, and we are seeing those fears resurface today
as families seek guidance in our offices daily.
I spoke with the mother of a U.S. citizen child with a disability
who depends on Medicaid to access essential medical care and maintain a stable quality of life.
Despite her child's significant medical needs,
she asked whether she should terminate her child's Medicaid coverage because she feared becoming a public charge.
A guardian for a child with special immigrant juvenile status,
a category explicitly exempt from public charge considerations,
similarly questioned whether the child's Medicaid coverage could place them at risk.
Increasingly, parents of U.S. citizens
are asking whether it's safe to participate in programs such as free school meals.
No parent should ever be forced to confront such choices.
Yet, that is precisely the dilemma these policies create.
They force families to choose between protecting their future and meeting their basic needs today.
No family should have to decide between feeding their children,
accessing health care, maintaining stable housing, and pursuing a lawful immigration status.
We commend the city and the state for taking the steps to protect New Yorkers from harmful effects of these policies.
And we continue to make every effort possible to ensure that we do not allow fear
to become a barrier to health, nutrition, and economic opportunity.
We must reject policies that undermine the well-being of immigrant families and instead uphold systems
that allow all eligible individuals to access essential services without fear
and punishment or stigma or discrimination.
Our communities are strongest when families have the support they need to thrive.
Protecting that principle is not only good policy, but it is essential to the future of New York.
And now I'm going to say a few words in Spanish.
Buenos dias.
Mi nombre es Arlene Cruz Escobar.
La nueva regla de carga publica puede aplicarse solo a ciertos solicitantes de la tarjeta de residencia,
pero sus efectos se extienden mucho más allá de esas personas.
Sabemos que por experiencia,
que políticas como esta generan temor
y confusión entre las familias inmigrantes con estatos migratorios mixtos en Nueva York y todo el país.
Las consecuencias son profundas.
Corremos el riesgo de que más familias
prospongan atención médica
hasta que las condiciones se convierten en emergencias.
Que los niños lleguen a la escuela con hambre.
Que más familias experimenten instabilidad de vivienda y dificultades financieras que son evitables.
La nueva regla aún no está en vigor,
pero hemos estado recibiendo preguntas al respecto día tras día.
Hablé con la madre de un niño ciudadano con Medicaid y una discapacidad
para ceder atención médica esencial y mantener una calidad de vida estable.
A pesar las importantes necesidades médicas de su hijo,
preguntó si debería cancelar su cobertura médica por temor a convertirse una carga pública.
Ninguna familia tiene que decidir entre alimentar a sus hijos, acceder a la atención médica,
mantener una vida estable, o obtener un estato migratorio legal.
Felicitamos a la ciudad y el estado por tomar esta medida para proteger a los neoyorquinos.
Y deberemos seguir haciendo todo lo posible para garantizar
que el miedo no se convierta en una barrera para la salud, la nutrición, y las oportunidades económicas.
Nuestras comunidades son más fuertes cuando las familias cuentan con el apoyo que necesitan para procesar.
Protegemos este principio en una buena política y es esencial para el futuro de Nueva York. Gracias.
Thank you, everyone. We've got some time for on-topic questions.
And I know we've got a lot of folks here, so please raise your hand and wait for the microphone.
I know we've got Maria from CNN here. We're going to start with you.
Hi, here I am, Maria Santana from CNN. Mayor Mondani, you have said that all New Yorkers will bear the cost of this rule.
Can you quantify that? How much does the city expect to spend on emergency services if immigrant families stop using them?
And then my second question is, what protections, immediate protections, can the city offer
these families, including protection of their personal data, immigration status, and information,
if a judge does not block the rule from going into effect?
So first and foremost, I just want to say very clearly that our intent here is not
to win a temporary injunction. It is to stop the implementation of this rule entirely.
And the reason for that is we know that this is something that will have devastating consequences
for immigrant New Yorkers far beyond just those who it technically applies to.
And a lot of the reason for that distinction is that we have seen a climate of fear for immigrants
regardless of their status. I have a clear memory of going into a Dominican barbershop in Harlem
and speaking to the barbers about ice raids. And one of them turned to me and said, we all have
status. And yet few of us are showing up to work because they don't care who has status anymore
when they're picking people up. And so we're talking about something that we know categorically
does not apply to certain sets of New Yorkers. And yet we're already seeing evidence of those
kinds of New Yorkers unenrolling from lifesaving benefits. So at this time, I cannot give you an
exact cost to the city because we are trying to do everything we can to ensure that we not only
stop this rule, but also that we communicate to New Yorkers that are not technically affected by
this rule to not take decisions that they otherwise cannot undo once they move forward
with it. That is why one of our points of advice separate from our legal action here is for any
immigrant New Yorker with concern to call our Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs hotline.
Again, that number is 1-800-354-0365. And we encourage every immigrant New Yorker with concerns
to go to a trusted legal provider before making those decisions. You've heard it not only from
those of us in government, but also outside of government of the kinds of concerns they're
hearing. These are actions that will have devastating consequences for New Yorkers across
our city. Thank you. Other on-topic questions? Yes, over here. Henry from PICS.
Hi, Mayor. How you doing, sir? The city and state were already going to have to grapple next year
with changes to various benefits impacting citizens and non-citizens because of the big
Republican bill, SNAP and Medicaid and the like. So if you have to deal with that and this, are
you just generally worried about the health and safety of citizens in New York, both immigrant
and non-immigrant with these changing federal policies? Yes, I am incredibly worried about the
impacts that both existing law will have once implemented, as well as this rule change. And
at a time when we are facing the reality of being the most expensive city in the United States of
America, to see the federal government pursue rule changes and legislation that will make hungry New
Yorkers hungrier, that will make poor New Yorkers poorer, it is a slap in the face to everything
that we should be doing in this moment, which is to make it easier for working class New Yorkers
to afford their life here in the city. Thank you. Thank you, Henry. We're going to go to Melissa
from NBC and I'll just pass you my mic. Thank you. Hi, Mr. Mayor. Good morning. How are you?
What is the city's backup plan in case you don't prevail? Can you tell us just a little bit more
about what, if anything, you're planning in terms of helping people access food and or medical care?
And can you go into just a bit more detail, please, about your legal argument? And do you
have to prove that there's a chilling effect specifically because of this rule? Is it about
the chilling effect or about the people being entitled to the benefits? So I'm first going to
answer your question as to what actions we're taking separate from the legal steps. And then
I'm going to pass it over to our corporation counsel, Steve Banks, to add some additional
details there. In terms of the steps that we are taking, we are using this rule is set to take
effect on Friday of this week. We are spending each and every day right now looking to communicate
with as many immigrant New Yorkers as possible about what this rule does and what it does not
do. We are equipping a lot of our city workers with the information of this so they can also
communicate this. And we've set up this hotline to ensure that New Yorkers have a place they can
call so that they know who they can ask for this kind of advice. Before I pass it over to
our corporation counsel, I do just want to bring up our public advocate, Jumaane Williams, because
we've spoken about the fact of concern for immigrant New Yorkers. He has been a leader
in this issue and has also correctly described himself as the highest ranking Caribbean official
here in our city. And we know that these kinds of attacks, we have seen them every single week.
And we've recently seen them against our Haitian brothers and sisters. We're seeing them continue
with a broader population. I just wanted to know, public advocate, if there's anything you want.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And thank you to the AG. As a son of immigrants,
this hits home as the highest ranking Caribbean elected official and Black elected official.
This hits home. Oftentimes, the Black immigrant experience is left out. But having also
represented communities, particularly high populations of Haitian immigrants and Haitian
descendants, I need the media to really understand the chilling effect that this has
and really drive home the fact that even people this may not affect are really feeling it. And so,
with the combination of the raids that have happened, the combination of the
getting rid of TPS, and now people trying to wade through legal arguments they may not understand,
parts of our districts are ghost towns already as people are no longer coming out and supporting
their businesses. And now to have to make the decisions of whether they feed their children or
not. The purpose of this is cruelty. That's it. Cruelty and fear. That is the purpose of all of
these immigrant decisions that are coming from the Trump White House and absolutely nothing else,
particularly to non-white immigrants. I want to be clear about that. And I say that every single
time Donald Trump has said that only people who need assistance are white South Africans. Everyone
else is left to fend for themselves. There is nothing ever that helps with public safety. None
of this helps with public safety. All this does is create cruelty and violence. And I know it was
said it will cause people to die. I want to add it will cause more people to die because people
have already died because of this Trump's policies. Thank you. Hi, I know you're telling people not to
disenroll from benefits like snap, but assuming that people are afraid and maybe they don't sign
up or maybe they do disenroll. Is there a situation where you think the city will have to
step in to try to make sure that the needs are being, we, we are going to exhaust every tool
that we have to take care of New Yorkers. And I want to make very clear when we speak about
immigrants, we are not somehow speaking about a separate population from New Yorkers. We're
speaking about New Yorkers. I myself stand here as the first immigrant mayor of our city in
generations. And we are going to exhaust every tool to fight this rule. We are also going to
ensure that everything we can do, especially in response to HR one, we are doing all with the
knowledge that there is no city in this country that can make up dollar for dollar what the
federal government is looking to cut in terms of services to those who need it. And the argument
that these kinds of rules will save the U S government money. It is money that we are going
to have to pay at a lager stage at a higher price because people don't stop getting sick. People
simply will get more sick. And then the first time that they will interact with the healthcare
provider will be at the emergency room. And you look at everyone who is here, you look at public
advocate, assembly members, state senators, city council, people, advocates, the attorney general,
all of us have spoken to healthcare providers who have told us how difficult it is for them
to be working in an emergency room and treat it as a primary care doctor, because that is
the world that we live in now. And Steve, if you want to add to the legal question,
just very briefly, Melissa, it's a hundred page complaint and it required a hundred pages because
there's so much illegality in the rule that that's what was required. This is not just a
repeat of 2019 when the city and state went to court and beat back a similar public charge
effort. It's even more harmful and more extreme, um, read the complaint and you will see that
the chilling effect is an illustration of the problem with the illegality. But on every one
of those a hundred pages is a legal claim that was strong in 2019. And it's even stronger now.
I've got time for one or two more. Yeah. Just in regards to your question, it's in violation of
the administrative procedure act because it's arbitrary and capricious. There's no meaningful
decision with regards to these rules to the agency has exceeded its authority. This public charge
rule goes back to 1822 where Congress basically said that it only applies to individuals who
cannot support themselves, not individuals who apply every now and then for public assistance
because they fall on hard times. And so you should not also equate public charge with
dependency. This has nothing to do with dependency. This has to do with opaque rules and rules where
you're giving so much authority to immigration officers to consider every in any public benefit,
including school lunch. Thank you, Attorney General. All right. I've got time for two more
on topics. We're going to go to Monica from Radio Rambo. Hello, Mr. Mayor. Well, I have a question.
Have you spoken to President Trump about this? You have successful conversations with him in the past
about topics that you have different opinion on. Have you spoken to him about this? And would you
expect anything to hear from him? The president and I have an ongoing conversation around
immigration policy. We've both been very clear about the fact that we have deep disagreements
on that policy, whether it pertains to ice raids or TPS protections or public charge.
This is a disagreement that continues. And the case that I'm making is that this is a rule that
will hurt this city. And we all stand here united in our commitment to protecting the city. And we
will do everything we can talk to everyone we can to ensure that we can actually protect New Yorkers.
Thank you, Monica. I've got time for one more on-topic question. We're going to go to the
gentleman in the front row right here. Hi, my name is Abu Tahir. I'm from Time
Television. And my question is, the Trump administration is saying whatever they are doing,
it's previous law. They are just executing the law. What is the answer of this? And number two,
number two, the immigration, you know, the people who process the immigration for their families,
they're imposing new rules, which is they will check the sponsor credit history,
which a lot of people are afraid about, that they cannot bring their families. Does it include your
lawsuit that this is also illegal? So first, let me say that the difference between the 2019 rule
versus the rule that we are challenging today, they did not allow federal immigration officers
to have so much discretion. The reality is, is that it's the guidelines fail to even indicate
what immigration officers should consider. Two, with regards to credit history of sponsors,
that also is included in our papers as well. But it's important that individuals understand that
this is really all about cruelty. Cruelty is the point. Having a chilling effect on immigrants
is the point. Letting individuals know that they are not welcomed here is the point.
Immigration animus is the point. The fact that you are different from everyone else
is the point. And the fact that you're going to deny individuals who are sick and hungry
and homeless benefits just as beyond the pale. And that's why we are seeking in the state of New York
to vacate this rule. It is unconstitutional, illegal, and we urge the judge to make that
decision before Friday. All right. That was the last on-topic question, unless there's anything
else to add. Thank you so much for Attorney General, public advocate, all of our speakers.
We're going to have time for some off-topic questions after we clear the podium.
How are you? Good.
Okay. We will now commence off-topic and I'm going to turn it over to Morgan.
To not answer. With the UN next week, just wondering if there's been an update yet
on your security clearance. And then speaking of the UN next week, any sort of message you have,
I know that you had said that you would maybe hope that people protest the Israeli Prime
Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. Just wondering, is there still a call to protest and what are
your thoughts? Thank you. So I just want to be very clear. My prior remarks were that if people
choose to do so, then they are able to, because that is the law here in New York City. I continue
to leave it to New Yorkers to make their own decisions. When it comes to your question about
security clearance, so the process of my getting a federal security clearance is ongoing. It's
moving within the typical timeline for receiving one. A number of senior administration officials
have a security clearance at this time. The NYPD also regularly briefs me on intelligence and
investigations that do not involve federally classified information and we will continue
to move forward. Thank you. Thanks, Morgan. We're going to go to Jesse from Hillgate.
Thank you, Mr Mayor. How are you? I'm well. We've just come off the back of a couple of weeks of
really scary news in the AI space. So just a few examples, AI agents hacking and covering their
tracks, going rogue, AI researchers quitting, citing the potential end of humanity. Also in
New York City, there's warnings of AI taking masses of tech jobs of young people that have
been training in the space. I feel there's a sense of fear in New York City. I know it's not something
city government talks about frequently, but what is your message to New Yorkers who are feeling
scared and confused about this information? And then secondly, there's a city council member who's
calling for an AI emergency task force to be started potentially in the mayor's OTI.
Is this something that you could commit to? So first, what I will say is like many Americans
across the country, the news coming out of this technology in recent days and weeks has been
incredibly alarming. We are speaking about reports that, as you said, include suggestions that this
could lead to the end of humanity. And whether it's the hugging face incident, or it's the
assertion from one of the heads of Anthropic that these kinds of incidents are occurring at every
single AI company, we should be seeing a far greater response from the federal government
on this issue, one that has the urgency befitting any conversation around the end of humanity.
And in terms of what city government is going to do, we are going to continue to explore all
of the avenues we have to protect New Yorkers. When you speak about New Yorkers having their
own concerns, recently we made the decision to ban the use of generative AI from 2K through
eighth grade. And that is an ongoing conversation within city government. Thank you.
Thank you, Jesse. All right, we'll keep going. Joe from Politico.
Morning, Mr. Mayor. How are you?
How are you doing?
Oh, pretty good. I had two questions. One's actually an on-topic from before.
Oh, sounds good.
So the public charge rule change is obviously in addition to existing rules,
this concept of public charge. I'm just wondering how you feel about that concept sort of
philosophically, sort of taking aside whether it's legal and setting aside this latest change,
like how do you feel about the concept of public charge and its use in immigration status? And then
I wanted to follow up on Jesse's question. DCWP, you have a lot of federal regulatory folks in your
administration. Do you see a role outside of what you did in the Department of Education
for the city to get into regulating AI? First, I just want to underline the importance of the
federal government taking this threat seriously. Too much of this conversation has been dominated
by concerns of profit or an international arms race and too little about concerns for humanity
at large. And we will continue to explore every avenue we have in New York City government,
all while knowing that there needs to be greater leadership at the federal level.
And then to your first question, what concerns me so deeply is that in a climate where federal
immigration officials have shown no interest in law and order, despite that being their
stated objective, you have an entire population that spans from those on visas, those with green
cards, those with citizenship, those who are simply children of immigrants, being terrified
at any and all immigration policies and rule changes. And the decisions that that terror
and fear not only will lead families to take, but has already led families to take,
is one that will change people's lives for the worse for years to come. We're speaking about
taking people out of Medicaid, of SNAP, of so many of the things that people rely on because
they're life-saving. And that to me is what is incredibly concerning, that this is, without
hyperbole, life or death for so many. Do you have any position on using cash assistance in some of
the pre-existing public charge rules? Do you think that that's appropriate? How do you think about
this in a more general sense? I think that the policy that the prior administration took was
the correct policy of refusing to defend this in court. Thank you. We've got time for two more.
We'll go to Josie from the Daily News. Thank you. Hi, Mayor. Hi, Josie.
I'm wondering about your reaction to a recent lawsuit against the Strategic Response Unit
of the Police Department alleging that overtime assignments in at least one of the units were
distributed on a racial basis, and also that there was a supervisor in the unit to basically
beat arrest numbers from previous times. I'm wondering what your reaction to that lawsuit is,
as well as that your administration is now in a position to be spending money and time defending
these allegations. I think those allegations are incredibly troubling, and this is the first that
I am hearing of them. This is something that will follow up after this press conference. I continue
to believe in the importance of decoupling our response to terror threats from our response to
the use of First Amendment rights, and that is a long-standing position, and that is one that we
will deliver on. Do you have any sort of timeline? I know the Department versus Office of Community
Safety is not totally in your control, but do you, I guess, does this give you any urgency to
get things moving on that end? The disbanding of the Strategic Response Group is something that I
would separate out from a conversation around the Office of Community Safety. It is a conversation
that I'm having with our police commissioner in a manner that we do it that can respect
New Yorkers' rights and keep New Yorkers safe. All right, I've got time for one more, and that'll
be Julia from 1010. Thank you. Mr. Mayor. Yes. Legionnaires. Yes. What is the latest that the
city is doing to investigate the Bronx outbreak, and are there any lessons learned from the east
side outbreak, and what are you doing differently? So, as of yesterday, the latest is that 10 people
have been diagnosed with Legionnaires' disease within this cluster. One New Yorker has tragically
passed away, and we are heartbroken by this loss of life. We are thinking of their loved ones and
sending them our condolences. We continue to encourage any New Yorker who has experienced
flu-like symptoms, be they cough, fever, difficulty breathing, and that they live or work or have
visited the area, to contact a healthcare provider. In terms of the steps that we have taken,
I want to assure New Yorkers we are moving aggressively to contain the spread. The health
department has sampled all cooling towers in the area. They did so on Thursday, within 12 hours of
identifying the cluster. The community health outreach workers started to canvas the neighborhood
the next day on Friday. That continued through the weekend, and the initial screening test results
were completed, and the orders to clean and disinfect 10 cooling towers were issued on
Saturday. By the end of today, all 10 cooling towers will have been fully cleaned and fully
disinfected, and what we are doing is, there have been a number of new policies we have implemented,
I think as of about a week or two ago, that we have announced. We are always going to keep pushing
on the question of what more we can do, because this has been an issue that New Yorkers have had
to deal with for far too many years, and we are looking to develop any kind of tool that can help
to ensure that Legionnaires is something that we're able to combat. Is there any proactive
investigation into other cooling towers in the areas, and how often, I know there's this 30-day
rule to review and inspect the towers, how much of that is being taken care of, and is there a
database on that, that these are getting investigated, and these are getting inspected every 30 days?
Sorry, the beginning of your question, could you say it one more time?
Yeah, just any other proactive measures if you're looking at any other towers in the area besides
those 10. So I will just bring up our Commissioner, Dr. Alastair Martin, to speak to additional
details of the proactive steps.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So, first, let me just say that for the one individual who has passed,
our hearts are with that individual's loved ones, their friends, their family, and that death
represents to us all the more reason to really make sure that everything that needs to happen
happens quickly, aggressively, and effectively, and that's exactly what we're doing here now.
With regard to the cooling towers, the region that we're looking at contained about 20 different
cooling towers. All of those, as you've just heard the Mayor say, have been sampled, and over the
weekend, every single one of the cooling towers that had a PCR positive result, they've been
ordered to do the full drainage, the cleaning, and the disinfection of that tower. We have
the vast majority of those that are done, and the ones that have not been done yet
will be done by the end of today. We're working to identify all the data with regard to the history
of the monthly compliance with those cooling towers, but I'm proud to say that we've been
on target with our annual inspections for every single one of those towers.
Thank you, Julian. That's all the time we have today. Thank you, everyone.
