There's just as many reasons that watches reach the mainstream as there are reasons they bomb. But some watches perservere and become hits despite going against the grain of popular sentiment. Whether it's the slow crawl of the AP Royal Oak Offshore or the unexpected popularity of an F.P. Journe Elegante, Tim is looking back at the surprise hits in modern watchmaking in this episode of Watches Today.#watchcollecting#watchcollector#luxurywatches
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Tim Maso analyzes luxury watches that overcame \"genetic defects\"—such as unconventional sizes, controversial histories, or risky materials—to become unexpected successes. He explores how models like the Royal Oak Offshore and the PAM382 Bronzo defied industry logic and initial skepticism to transform from potential failures into highly coveted classics.
Hi, I'm Tim. Welcome to the 1916 Company. This is Watches Today. We've got Garrett on the switcher.
Today, these watches should have bombed but became unlikely successes. All of that and we share your
wrist shots today on Watches Today. While we're warming up, I've got a big fall coming up and
you can follow it almost in real time. Check me out on Instagram, Tim underscore Maso. You can see
a lot of watches, a couple of pugs, and every once in a while a car because I now do car reviews
over on Car Reviews by Motorcars of the Mainline. So, if you want to see the whole world of Tim
Maso, you can see it on my Instagram. Check it out. Help me fill that gap, Tim underscore Maso. So,
wrist shots number one. It's a bumper crop. I asked and you answered. We got Dan R and Robin R
joining us courtside at the U.S. Open with Patek Philippe 6127G and 7127G, a his and hers
Calatrava pair from the Tokyo Exhibition in 23. Jack J returns the serve with another U.S. Open
Patek capture of his 1916 sourced Ellipse 3738 100G. Thank you for trusting our company. Michael
C hits hard twice with Vacheron and Patek Philippe perpetual calendars. Jimmy Y takes in the sights
for Labor Day at the beach with his 1916 sourced Rolex Yachtmaster titanium. Thank you for trusting
our company. Kuyen T waits for his second son. Congratulations. In the Warden proves that you
can never really own a Patek Philippe because that one is probably spoken for. With two kids now,
they may as well fight over that, but it's got two time zones so everyone can be happy. We have
Jeff S who's in Charleston, South Carolina with his carbon fiber Bianche Tourbillon and we have
Spencer K and his Laurent Ferrier Classic Origin visiting the Astronomical Clock of Prague. Jim M
chooses between two Vacheron historiques with the 1921 American and the Corne de Vache. Guys send
your wrist shots to 19, well I guess whichever you prefer. You could send it to watch us today
at the 1916 company if you prefer contemporary or you can send it to watch us tonight at
thewatchbox.com if you prefer vintage. I think both will work via the miracle of the redirect.
Okay, these watches should have bombed and by all rights they would have but there is a twist
in each story. Let's not be naive. There are obvious formulas for success in the watch industry.
You can build a watch with features that are faddish and timely like blue or green dials
depending on what decade we're in. You can build watches that look and feel like established hype
watches and get as close as you can without copyright infringement. You can try to make all
your watches look like Rolex models or fit cleanly into core Rolex product categories like chronograph,
GMT and dive watch and you stay away from poison like weird shapes, really big or really tiny
watches, quartz movements, car watch co-brands and category tweeners that fail to fit cleanly
established product classes. Today we're talking about watches that should have bombed but became
unlikely successes. In each case there was a genetic defect or several that should have doomed
the model at its launch but each of these watches transcended common wisdom and became a success
and we're going to see why. So early 1990s Audemars Piguet built watches like the Starwheel, the Tourbillon
Automatique, many landmark fine dress and dress complications. Isn't it gorgeous? A 36 millimeters
with dial guilloche, mostly yellow gold, always exquisitely and delicately detailed. This was AP's
game, an established market. Look at that carousel, oh my goodness. With sapphire discs and scrolling
time, the epitome of class. So the 1993 Royal Oak Offshore, a 42 millimeter near half pound steel
monster was an aberration that threatened to alienate existing clients without appealing to
any proven target market that might take their place. Huge, heavy, devoid of classical elegance
and clearly in the same vein as the original, well one might say oversized watch, the Portuguese
of 1939, it launched into a marketplace that had no carve out for it and a little bit like
the original Portuguese, it languished for a couple of years never really catching on,
highly visible without being prolific, iconic before it was popular and to be perfectly honest
even more intriguing than this model's unlikely success is the fact that it did almost succumb
to the market's initial cold response and scant demand but AP stuck with the watch and by the
company's own account worked upward from a few dozen initial orders in 1993 to a few hundred
per year by the early 2000s. The Offshore fought the riptide long enough to reach the mid-2000s
by which point it was exactly the right watch for its time when bigger was better and biggest was
best. This is a watch launched into the era of 35 and 36 millimeter men's watches from a dress
watch brand, this should have bombed, this should have been a failure and I think if you've gone
right out of the gate with some sort of group brand summary judgment it probably would have
been cancelled but this is maybe the clearest example of Audemars Piguet's family ownership
and management actually making a difference for the best because they didn't need to respond to
the shareholders or make the quarter and they could persist with the Royal Oak Offshore not
just for months but for several years before it became popular outright. This should have been a
big miss but it became a hit and one of the most unlikely of the 1990s. A contemporary of the
original Panerai Luminor, you got to remember those original Luminors were cheap watches by
the standards of Audemars Piguet. This was big, ungainly, bulky and very expensive which the Panerai
was not. This had nothing going for it except a lot of love in the details but it turned out for
the best and it's still with us today. IWC Big Pilots Watch. Let's just be clear, unless we're
talking about the Volkswagen Beetle, pitching 1940s German government paraphernalia to anyone
but Lemie is a generally bad business model. The Luftwaffe inspired B.E.R. which was used by those
guys, was an important historical pilots watch and authentically counted IWC as one of the
original contract manufacturers but this is the kind of challenging history that tends to give
pause to anyone who's not, you know, Lemie. But IWC went right after it with the 2002 model year
reference 5002, an observation style monster with a 46.2 millimeter diameter that only made sense
in the context of a reduction from the original watch's 55 millimeters, so this was the midsize.
Between the colossal size and the complicated history, the Big Pilots Watch seemed destined
for a short and troubled run and yet a worthwhile seven-day automatic winding manufacture movement,
enough water under the bridge since Blitzkrieg that we were willing to forgive if not forget,
and a fashion for huge watches in the 2000s means that the unlikeliest of success stories
remains a cornerstone of the IWC Pilots catalog to this day and there it is right there,
you can still buy it and it hasn't changed much, they got it right out of the gate. Viewers Chats
number two, Matthew P and his Rolex Explorer explore Iceland which is probably greener than
you think. Bernardo O watches the Atlanta Braves play the Dodgers in Atlanta with his JLC Polaris
chronograph. Jay Sharp hunts elk with a bow and arrow plus his IWC Pilots Watch in bronze in the
wilds of Montana on the first day of elk season. Shamal D captures what we love about watch loom
and watches with his Blancpain 50 fathoms mil-spec, I think that's the 5008 reference.
Ben 10 borrows a broad array of, well I should say he browses, he's not yet ready to eat but
he browses a broad array of entrees and appetizers with his Tudor Black Bay 58 925 in sterling
silver. Note at the bottom Royale with cheese, Vincent Vega would be proud, I think that would
be on his plate that day. Okay these watches should have bombed but for some reason, we'll
talk about that, they didn't. Have you ever noticed how little interest there is in car
watch collaborations and this is always a bit of a counter-intuitive in the industry. Car guys love
watches and the opposite is almost always true but combine them and you get retail poison.
Seriously, have you seen how many Blancpain Lamborghini, Panerai Ferrari, Tag Heuer Aston
Martin, Ball BMW and Oris Audi Sport watches seem to be rolling around on Chrono24 eBay and still
available new old stock sometimes decades later? It's true, check it out, a great source of value
if you don't mind wearing something unpopular. For reasons no one has entirely identified,
combining two things the same group of people love does not go down like chocolate and peanut
butter. That's a perfect combination, everyone loves that, at least in the U.S. They may have
feelings otherwise in Europe but in the U.S. that's a great match and you would think cars
and watches would be the same way. It's not and it never is and yet we saw better than average
commercial and critical success for the Jaeger LeCoultre Amvox series and the Gerard Perregaux
Ferrari collection. We talked a little bit about that last week and I want to bring it back for a
hot minute. Let's qualify this a bit, neither has endured to this day. You can't go out and buy a
new Amvox or a GP Ferrari, no longer possible, so they're not perennials like the Big Pilots watch
or the Royal Oak Offshore. Both relationships lasted a decade and then ceased. Both automakers
moved on to other tie-ups with other watch brands and neither Amvox nor GP Ferrari models
are money makers for today's owners. They're respected but you're not going to buy one now
and sell it for three times what you paid. They're not hype watches, I would call their
market stable, I would call them respected. But unlike most car watch tie-ups, let's take this
quartz dial Tag Heuer Formula One as a good example. The Amvox series, like this Amvox 2
pusherless chronograph, these were purpose-built watches, not re-badged versions of existing models
with say an Aston Martin logo on the dial. Could we go back one frame? That is an existing model
with an Aston Martin logo on the dial. Jumping forward again, the Amvox series, many were
technically innovative. Most were built as strictly limited editions with edition numbers
to keep volume sustainable and although the partnership lasted a decade, they never oversupplied
the market. Now on the other side of the house, or perhaps the other side of Switzerland I should say,
Gerard Perregaux was born of a genuine respect, GP Ferrari and familiarity between Luigi Macaluso
and Luca Codero de Montesmolo of Ferrari. Now de Montesmolo was Enzo Ferrari's anointed successor
and he was considered to be a good steward of the brand. So when GP and Ferrari came together,
this was something heartfelt and not done lightly. Both of these men, Italian gentlemen who loved
cars and loved watches, Macaluso having even been a championship race car driver, there was a lot of
personality driving this. It was not the shotgun marriage of Panerai-Ferrari. This was organic.
This was love. And GP was not a mass-market brand in the 1990s and the watches reflected
an auto-logerie manufacturer with an interest in internalizing traditional Ferrari motorsports
themes rather than chasing the jet-set image of later Panerai, Hublot and Richard Mille Ferrari
watches. Even the astonishing Gerard Perregaux Enzo Ferrari was about as subtle as a perpetual
calendar chronograph triple golden bridge tourbillon could possibly be. Blink and you'll
miss it because all the actions on the back and it's a beautifully subtle way of integrating
things that are eye-poppingly beautiful. A case-back golden bridge tourbillon is about
as subtle as subtle gets and just looking at that dial, there's nothing obviously Ferrari
about it. So this is really well done and of interest even if you don't love the cars from
Maranello. It's a beautiful watch but not Ferrari at first glance. Both the GP and Amvox watches
were considered among the best of the car watch genre and while not commercial runaways like some
of the others in this show, they were critical successes that remain well regarded as worthwhile
not cynical. Okay, now we go to a much more mainstream brand. Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch
Dark Side of the Moon Apollo 8. Remember the Isuzu Viacross of 1999? It was too weird, too niche
back in 1999. There was no market for a two-door dune running Baja 1000 Ford Raptor type thing
from Japan and that's what this was. Ahead of its time? Believe it. Too weird for the 90s?
Absolutely. The 2013 Dark Side of the Moon was a blockbuster for Omega. Keep that Isuzu in mind
for a minute and many attempts to extend the winning ceramic Speedmaster streak were added
in subsequent years. When Omega launched the Apollo 8 for 2018 with its crazy laser ablated
lunar surface dial, I got the experience that I was seeing the Viacross repeated as an experiment
in real time. A test of whether something weird could be a mainstream success. It was shocking
as the Viacross was back in 1999. Looking at this watch, it was maybe just a little bit too
extravagant, too whimsical and they put a big price on it at almost $10,000. I got the feeling
I was watching something that was a test of whether weird could be a mainstream success.
It was something you rarely see from a big corporate brand. Remember what I said about AP
being family-owned and run? Well, this was a genuine risk from a company with shareholders
and it was a real risk for Omega. The Moonwatch White Side of the Moon and the Black Black proved
that even the powerhouse ceramic Moonwatch format could only stretch mainstream tastes so far before
volumes declined. But the Apollo 8 hit so hard that many dealers had to put clients on waitlists
for it. It was a niche watch that sold like a mainstream hit and given the substantial retail
of almost $10,000 in 2018 money, this was a lot of money for what was a manual wind Moonwatch.
Remember, the other ceramics were all automatic. The Apollo 8 even did so well that it received a
second generation in 2024 and the only obvious way to see this at a glance is you've got a little
Saturn V rocket for the running seconds hand. A success in the most unlikely of forms. This is
like the kind of thing Romain Jerome would have done as an ultra-niche controversy breeder that
would have been designed to get people talking even if it didn't sell. Titanic watches, Icelandic
volcano ash on the dial, lunar moon rocks and stones on the dial. That's the kind of thing
Romain Jerome famously or infamously did. When Omega did the same, incredibly it worked. Well done.
A risk taken. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Okay, F.P. Journe Elegant 48. Hey gentlemen, guess what
I've got for you. See this small quartz tonneau shaped diamond set ladies watch? Now imagine it
slightly larger without the diamonds but otherwise the same. Is that the watch of your dreams? It is,
isn't it? Well this went down almost, this almost went down I'm going to say as badly as that setup
suggested. It was soft launched in 2016. I remember seeing photos online but there was almost no press
material and no attempt to publicize it. As late as the fall of 2017, there was still talk about how
to segregate it from the F.P. Journe brand to protect the F.P. Journe brand from the quartz watch.
As late as the middle of 2017, I know they were being given away as door prizes to prolific buyers
of mechanical Journe watches as a thank you for buying the product. Given away as a door prize.
And there was also talk about calling it elegant by F.P. Journe so people would understand that
this was not an F.P. Journe watch. Well that was before people started paying six figures for them
used. The elegant proved to be brilliant as I have to say it's the Journe a man is most likely to
grab for the daily grind. It's the most accurate, it's the most water resistant, it's the most
durable, it's the most serviceable, it's the most legible, it's the most loomed with the screw down
crown. It's not the most, it's the only one that you can safely take swimming and it's a native
rubber strap watch which means you actually feel like it's as durable as it is. It is a brilliant
watch and while quartz, and it is quartz, the movement is actually kind of cool. It includes a
lot of gold, there's some decoration and it looks good. 18 years of latency so you can leave it on
the shelf in effectively a dormant mode, pick it up and still have it running and still have it
keeping the right time. That's genuinely cool. Even if the movement was contract built by a
microelectronics specialist Journe himself did come up with a lot of the underlying principles
and the aesthetics so it feels authentic and like I said it may be the one you grab
when all of your fragile precious metal Journe dress watches are just too frail for the daily
grind. This is a watch that you will wear as often as you might wear a Rolex or an Omega
and your best watch is the one you love to wear. This might be your best FP Journe.
Okay, viewer's chats number three. Josh Yu and Chopin Alpine Eagle greet us from home turf in
the Swiss Alps. Jed B joins us with his Moser Pioneer Cosmic Green at the pool for Labor Day.
Neil B and his Bentley Bentayga take a different turn with the Tiffany Triple Calendar Moon.
He asked me what movement and I think the base is an ETA 2824. Andy visits Italy's Tuscany with
his Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean at dusk. Paul S is in Montreal with his Accutron in a live
performance by Canadian icons Rush. Kevin J and his 1916 source Nomos Glasuta honor the Porsche
911 Generation 996. Thank you for trusting our company. All right, these watches should have
bombed. Panerai Submersible PAM382 Bronzo. It's rare that an entire era or multi-year trend
can be traced to just one watch. Fads like blue dials, green dials, and jump hours just seem to
arrive in waves as brand planners gossip and glance over each other's shoulders at cafes around
Biel, Geneva, La Chaux-de-Fonds, and Neuchâtel. So it was a shock in 2011 when Panerai jumped the
industry with a watch nobody saw coming and which nobody was ready to counter with an instant
alternative. It was the answer to a question nobody asked. 2011 was a bad time for the watch
industry and the global economy generally. You remember 2001 and the dot-com bust? How long it
took the Nasdaq to recover? Well, the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009 involved mass-market
real estate, residential and commercial, so it affected the real economy and it was a much longer
climb-out for global watch buyers, businesses, and yes, for the watch industry itself. This was
big and expensive and prominent at a time when that wasn't necessarily the sales success recipe.
Plus, Gérald Genta's Jefika had achieved middling success as a bronze watch in the high-end space.
If it left any impression, that impression was a bronze as a novelty material, not something for
a mainstream brand. There was zero market pull for this Panerai bronzo. Panerai fired a shot in
the dark and it landed. No pre-SIHH 2011 focus group would have asked for a mammoth bronze watch
that would turn your skin blue and your cuff green. There was absolutely zero demand for that.
If you focus grouped that and workshopped that, the answer would have been no. And yet, literally
hundreds of models, from $50 up to $1 million, came raining down on the watch market through the
2010s, really through the mid-2010s. This was the most influential design of a decade. It was
literally patient zero for an entire mammoth trend and it's rare you can say that. The bronze watch
fad started right here. Also, this submersible surfaced into stormy seas as Panerai's early
enthusiast goodwill from the late 90s and mid-2000s. That brand buzz, that goodwill, was
faced with the challenges of mainstreaming and maintaining momentum as a mass manufacturer.
And yes, by the 2010s, Panerai was having some trouble with that. By 2011, there was already
quite a bit of Paneristi cynicism brewing over endless iterations, new dial colors,
case materials, and the reframing of the same designs again and again as something new. But,
like Bruce Dickinson ripping through Chemical Wedding at Hellfest in 2024,
Panerai proved it could still hit the high notes with the bronzo. And as with Bruce, we still have
huge respect today for the original PAM382. Few on the market at any given time. You can find a
million other bronzos, very few PAM382s. And when you do find a PAM382, the prices are much higher
than that. It reflects retained value and a risk the original PAM382 that continues to pay off.
There may be many follow-on bronzos like these PAM74s, but there will only ever be one PAM382,
and it is an all-time classic. It was a risk that paid off. Viewer's Chats number four,
Matthew L. gets recursive with the Glashutte Oregonale, Senator Perpetual, and my video
of the same watch. Philip F. celebrates his nephew's marriage, congratulations, with a rare
sighting of the Oris Dizzy Gillespie in Chicago. We have Peter W. captures the case back of his
Omega Seamaster Diver 300 meter for our viewers. Paul of Toronto watches the Blue Jays sweep
Seattle's Mariners with his Abel 1911 chronograph. And Spencer is back to send us home
from Geneva Watch Days with his crayon at Geneva's Ghetto on Lake Geneva. Guys, thank you so much.
Thanks to Garrett. I hope you had a monstrous Labor Day, and we're ready for a fun fall.
Remember, let me know in the comments below what was the most unlikely success
of any watch you can recall. And until next time, time out.