5 Ancient History Mysteries Solved by Coins

Ancient World
292 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Coins are the single best tool at our disposal for understanding the past.
Of course, a beautiful statue of a king might give us a better idea of what he looked like.
A building like the Parthenon can tell us even more, simply because it's a larger and more
complex object. But these were individual objects, created for a specific purpose
and usually intended to remain in a single place. There is a limit to what they can reveal.
Even something non-material, like a written text, is inherently vulnerable to the biases
of its author. Coins, however, were unstoppable. They were everywhere. Their designs tell us about
the civilizations that made them, but more than that, the places where they are found
can reveal events otherwise lost to time, and sometimes, they even preserve inconvenient
realities that the official texts of the period did not want you to know.
And this is what today's video is all about. Let's explore 5 different mysteries of ancient
history that could only be solved by numismatic evidence. Coins found in places where they
shouldn't be, unusual messages put on coins, even unexpected or otherwise unknown characters
making their ways into coins. Alright, let's get started.
And we begin with the field of linguistics, the study of languages. You might have heard of the
Rosetta Stone. It was discovered in 1799 by French soldiers next to a small Egyptian town.
This stone is a fragment of a larger inscription, a decree issued in 196 BC by Ptolemy V. Ptolemy
was a pharaoh from a Greek dynasty, founded after the conquest of Alexander the Great.
This decree and this stone was written in three different languages spoken at the time. Greek,
Demotic, the native script of everyday use in Egypt, and hieroglyphics. Because the three
versions communicated essentially the same message, scholars could compare the three
texts and finally translate hieroglyphics, which had been a mystery for thousands of years.
In numismatics, we have multiple cases of Rosetta Stones in coin form, examples of bilingual coins,
and the study of the evolution of coins designs and the change of languages in
coin issues allowed numismatists to decipher entire languages.
One of the best examples comes from the Iberian Peninsula. For centuries, no one knew how to
translate the signs and the letters appearing on ancient Iberian inscriptions, including coins.
The Celtiberians were a highly monetized people, but their language was a complete mystery. Even
in the time of the Roman conquest, Iberian was already a very old language. It's typically dated
from around the 6th century BC. But grammatically, that's one of the problems. It was very insular.
Iberian script had very little direct resemblance to languages like Latin or Greek.
The code was finally cracked through an extensive study of coins produced before,
during, and after the Roman conquest of Hispania. Some cities issued bilingual coins bearing both
Iberian and Latin legends, probably a way of conciliating the local dialect that was spoken
in the region, while also putting Latin on the coins and recognizing the sovereignty of Rome
over them. Other cases of coins actually show a sign of complete Romanization. In these cities,
the people there basically replaced the traditional Iberian mint names with more recognizable Latin
versions on later issues. This was likely the result of generations of assimilation
into Roman culture, which led to the death of their original native language,
having it replaced with the use of Latin. This translation was not quick. It took centuries to
fully translate the script and put together enough evidence from lots of different coins to back it
up. Numismatic evidence was, as I said, very fragmentary. I mean, there are over like 160
different mints in the peninsula. And the first full translation of Iberian script was only
published in the 1920s. This is actually a mystery that still kinda like still stands.
We don't have like a full understanding of Iberian language yet. We've translated the letters,
we know what it sounded like, but the grammar of the language is still largely a secret.
Another spectacular example of numismatic Rosetta Stones comes from the extreme ends
of the Hellenistic world, on what is modern-day Pakistan and India. During the 19th century,
the British numismatist James Princep was working for the East India Company,
mostly overseeing the establishment of coin mints in the region. Princep did not only work with
making coins, he also developed a fascination for local ancient Indian numismatics, in particular
the coins of the Greek kings that had ruled the area. Classical authors tell us very little about
these rulers, even if they were Greek. Local Indian sources make very little reference to
the line of Greek kings that ruled this region, and classical Greek historians didn't have much
access to information about these like very far away kingdoms, they were simply too distant from
the Mediterranean for information to reach them. Fortunately for us, much of their political
history survives almost entirely through their coins. As these Indo-Greek kings became more and
more involved with the local culture, they started issuing bilingual coinage. Here's a charming little
example of one of those coin-shaped Rosetta stones. This is a coin issued by Menander Soter,
one of the most famous of these Indo-Greek kings. Just for you to have an idea, this coin is from
between the years 155 and 130 BC. This particular coin is attributed to the region of like modern-day
northern Pakistan and like northwest India. Imagine that, Greek coins so far away from the
homeland. These coins are a wonderful material proof of just how far Alexander's influence went
and how long it lasted. The obverse has this nice portrait of the king looking to the right
wearing this cavalry helmet. So, interesting, right? An ancient Indian coin? But if you look
at this design, this obverse is 100% Greek. The ruler's name and the titles are also in Greek.
We can clearly read Basileus Southros Menandro, of King Menander the savior. And as we head to
the reverse, we have the Rosetta stone moment. So, we're greeted by this lovely image of Athena
Alcidemus, so Athena the defender of the people. So, yet another purely Greek design. And then we
have a repetition of the same information on the obverse legends, but this time in a local script
called Karoshti. It reads Maharajasa, or of the great king, Tratarasa, the savior, Menandrasa,
Menander. By comparing the repeated royal names, the titles, and the grammar across a large number
of coins, Princip and other scholars were able to assign phonetic values to the characters and
gradually decipher the whole script. And this discovery reached far beyond numismatics. This
Karoshti script had been used to write Gandhari. Gandhari was a language of some of the oldest
surviving Buddhist manuscripts. So, once we'd learned to read the script through the bilingual
coins of the Indo-Greek kings, they could then begin translating other texts, like the Buddhist
literature that had remained basically incomprehensible for nearly 2,000 years.
And since we're in this topic of these very distant, poorly understood Greek kings of India,
this leads us to another type of mystery that is commonly uncovered by coins, and that's the name
and the mere existence of dozens of unknown kings. Like the chronology of the Indo-Greek kingdoms,
for example. In fact, entire lineages have been reconstructed entirely through numismatic
evidence. The chronology is assembled normally by a combination of analyzing, of course, the coins,
the portraits, and the evolution in their styles, other secondary sources of information like royal
titles on the coins, the mints, and horde evidence, of course, the combination of which coins show up
in which treasures. All of that information is then combined, and this creates an assumption
of the date of the treasures and, consequently, the order of the kings, which king ruled first,
and how their kingdoms grew and shrank with time. We get this assumption that the biography of all
kings were recorded because, generally, our reference is the Romans, and the Romans were
absolutely obsessed with recording everything, but throughout history, especially ancient history,
that wasn't really the case. So, this king we just saw, Menander, he's one of the better-known
Indo-Greek kings because he's mentioned in multiple sources, but he's an exception. Many
of his successors simply disappear from written history. Like, examples, Queen Agathocleia,
for example, she's known exclusively through her coins, which show her actually ruling alone,
so imagine that, a Greek queen, and we also see coins from her ruling with her son,
Strato I. Other kings, such as Diomedes, Telephus, you may have never heard about these names,
and that's understandable, they are known exclusively from their coins. The same goes
for the successors of the Indo-Greeks, the Indo-Scythians, the Indo-Parthians. Without
these coins, entire voids in the political history of many regions would have been left undiscovered.
Coins have also revealed to us the exact location of where important historical events took place.
One of the most interesting examples is the discovery of the exact area where the Teutoburg
Forest disaster took place. Quick memory refresh on the event, in the year 9 AD, the Roman governor,
Publius Quinctilus Varus, was leading three legions through Germania when they were ambushed
by a coalition of Germanic tribes. The Romans had been campaigning inside the German territory,
collecting taxes and trying to establish imperial control east of the Rhine, potentially maybe even
creating a new province of Germania beyond the Rhine. As they were marching over a heavily
forested area in a long column, they were ambushed and picked off piece by piece over the course of
a few days. The three legions were entirely wiped out. This was like a major disaster for the Romans.
Now, the record of this event came to us, the history of the event had been preserved by
ancient authors, but nobody knew precisely where it had happened. The forest was and still is
massive, so we know the area, but not the exact location. That changed in 1987 when a metal
detectorist discovered a large group of Roman silver denarii near Karlskrisse in northwestern
Germany. Apart from coins, he found three lead-slink bullets. That's interesting because it indicated
the coins were connected to some kind of military context. Archaeological excavations began a couple
of years later, based on the locations of the initial find and countless pieces of Roman
military equipment and, crucially, hundreds more coins were found. Coins of all metals, of gold,
important, silver and copper saw evidence of coins carried by probably all rankings of the military.
They were definitely onto something there. And, crucially, the chronology of the coins
confirmed the connection to the event. When identifying the coins, the very latest pieces
found there were attributed, guess what, to the reign of Augustus. And, even more telling,
the coins, like when they dated the coins, every single coin was from before the year 9 AD.
To make the evidence even stronger, several of the copper coins had a countermark,
with three letters, VAR. Of course, these are attributed to Varus himself. These were probably
applied to coins as they were distributed to Roman troops within the context of the moving camp,
so he was validating the coins as money. The presence of these coins, of course, provided
a direct connection between the site, the Roman army and the commander himself who died in the
massacre. And this is one of the great powers of ancient coins as dating evidence. Since numismatists
have been studying ancient coins for centuries, numismatics has at least 5 centuries of history,
these little things, these coins are so well studied that we can often determine with
remarkable accuracy when a particular coin was made. So, when several coins are found in a treasure,
the newest specimen actually provides what is called a terminus postquim, the earliest possible
date at which the group could have been deposited. And this allows us to trace basically human
activity within extremely narrow chronological contexts, just like something like a battle.
If you think about a battle, it's very local, it's very brief, it's a very violent event. And these
kinds of punctual events, although they're very important, they generally don't leave like very
long lasting marks on history. But in this case, we can thank coins for telling us where one of
Hi, I'm Leo, the voice behind classical numismatics and if you want to learn how to collect ancient
coins but don't know where to start, I have the solution for you. In my course, The Ancient Coin
Collector, I will teach you everything you need to know in order to enjoy ancient numismatics like
you deserve. You will learn how to buy ancient coins, how to avoid fakes, how to pay the right
price, how to identify coins. You will learn everything you absolutely must know. The links
are in the video description below. Join us. Not only the location and the exact date of a battle
can be identified by coin finds, but they can also help us figure out who participated in a battle.
You see, battles could have been fought by just two different participants. That's what most of
us assume, two states going to war. But in reality, the participants in given battles were often
something like coalitions. Think about like federations of united peoples, bands of tribes,
or maybe one large state fighting alongside its vassals or some client states. So in these
situations, with different states who issued different kinds of coins, we have a situation
where finds of the coins from the belligerents help us figure out this extra level of complexity
in figuring out exactly who took part in the battle. And one of the most famous examples of
such coalitions was during the Battle of Alesia, fought in 52 BC when Julius Caesar
inflicted the final defeat on the Gallic tribes and submitted the entirety of Gaul under Roman rule.
That's because Caesar's victory at Alesia was not simply a battle against the warriors trapped
inside the town. While Vercingetorix and his army were surrounded by Roman fortifications,
a second, enormous Gallic relief force was gathering outside the siege lines and trying
to break through and rescue them. And according to Caesar himself, this army was amassed from
43 different tribes, numbering around 240,000 infantry and 8,000 cavalry. These are astonishing
numbers, and Caesar had every reason to exaggerate them. The larger the enemy coalition, of course,
the more impressive his victory appeared. But if so many different peoples really came
together outside Alesia, they may have left behind something more reliable than
Caesar's own account. He certainly had the initiative of inflating these numbers to make
his victory sound better, but could maybe coins help? Could the coins left by this huge coalition
have given us some kind of material evidence for the real size and composition of this army?
This is yet another case where numismatics can help us so much. Gaul at that time was
very politically fragmented. It was this huge mix of different independent tribes,
and many of whom produced their own distinctive coinage with different designs, different types
of metals, entirely different monetary standards. It was really diverse, and this gives us an
opportunity. You can identify the trade links or the presence of people from that tribe
from the coin finds, and this means that, at least in theory, a coin could reveal the tribe
from which its owner had traveled. More than 700 Celtic coins have been recorded around Alesia,
and at least 15 of the peoples named in Caesar's account were confirmed by coin evidence,
including some typical names that we hear about a lot, like major tribes like the Averni, the Aeduli,
the Sequani, Senones, Bitubriges, Carnutes. I'm not going to be spewing dozens of names here,
but the fact is that we could confirm, indeed, with coin evidence, with hard evidence,
that this was a huge coalition that Gaul had never seen up to that point. So we can confirm
Caesar's broader claim that he faced an extraordinary coalition of troops from all over
Gaul. It was actually broadly truth. Maybe in the future we're gonna have more finds that can
approach this number to the 43 that he mentions, but it looks like Caesar wasn't lying.
And the fifth series of mysteries solved with coins is something the Romans did not want you
to know, which was the sheer number of usurpers there was during the imperial period. One of the
biggest concerns from any emperor was to generate this idea around himself that he was absolutely
unquestionable in power. The idea of stability was crucial for any emperor to maintain his
legitimacy. That's why we see so many coins with images that reinforce this idea of stability,
firmness. Here, for example, on your screen, we have a coin of Emperor Gallienus,
a miserable little thing with very little silver content, as we can see. But as we go to the reverse
of this coin, we have the image of Pax, Pax Augusta, the peace brought by the emperor.
Now, the Roman idea of Pax was quite different to what we think of today. The Pax here, she holds
this olive branch, which symbolizes the end of conflict, but this was an end of conflict based
on an overwhelming idea of Roman victory. It wasn't our modern idea of some mutual understanding.
Let's all shake hands and that's it. No. The idea Gallienus was trying to communicate here
was that he was unquestionable. Now, we know today this was not the case. There were so many
attempts of usurpations and civil wars all over the place, and some of these became so serious
that they simply had to be recorded, so we know about them, even if they tainted the reputation
of the official emperor. However, what these official records don't tell us is that the problem
of usurpers was much, much worse than we thought, and that was mainly through the discovery of coins.
That's, once again, one of the great things about coins. They're so numerous that you just,
once they're made and they're out in circulation, you just can't erase their records. So, we found
out about many of these usurpers that were either intentionally erased from public records in order
to make the official emperor look better, or, in other situations, these men simply weren't powerful
enough to put much of a fight against the emperor, so they just ended up disappearing into historical
nothingness, but they were powerful enough to actually mint coins in their names to pay for
troops under them, and this shows just how coins were these incredibly important tools of
propaganda and of legitimacy, because it was like the very first thing they did to advertise their
claims to power. As long as you had one single city which was capable of issuing coins, you would
bank coins and you would pay troops with them. I've picked up a couple of examples from two of
these very obscure emperors. One of them was Domitian II and the other one was Silbanacus.
These were men who claimed the imperial title, yet they're almost completely absent from the
surviving histories, apart from, like, as I mentioned, a few coins that actually mention
their existence. Domitian II, for example, appears to have seized power within the breakaway Gallic
Empire sometime around 271 AD. He probably came to power during the confusion following the
assassination of Victorinus. So, here we have the ridiculous situation of a usurper trying to usurp
a breakaway territory, which was under another usurper. For most of the 20th century, he was
known for a single coin discovered in France in 1900, and many scholars actually suspected that
the coin was either a forgery or it had been badly misread. Keep in mind, before 1900s,
there were no records of this emperor. But then, in 2003, a second coin with the name Domitianus
was discovered inside a hoard of nearly 5,000 Roman coins in England. It had been struck with
the exact same die as the first specimen, so it finally proved Domitian II was actually a real
character, and that, however briefly, he had enough power to actually control a city and mint
coins at some point, adding to the long list of men who held the title of Augustus. And then,
there's this other guy, Silbanacus, who's even more mysterious. There's nothing, there are no
records about this guy. Zero. His existence is known from only two coins. The first, acquired
by the British Museum in 1937, reportedly found in Eastern France, so a frontier region from the
Empire, a perfect ground for rebels and usurpers. And the second example was discovered near Paris,
decades later. The style of the portraits indicates, that's really cool, the style of
the portrait indicates that, from the style, these were probably struck at the imperial mint in Rome
around 253. I mean, this is major. This suggests, at least stylistically, that Silbanacus may have
controlled the capital itself during one of these, like, rapid power changes between emperors like
Emilian, Valerian, and Gallienus, and that's a massive claim. Could an emperor that is completely
absent from records actually have held Rome at some point? I mean, I don't know, but the coins
are real. This man existed and he was powerful. This is one of these situations where a very bold
claim requires an equally bold piece of proof, of evidence, but the coins are here. They're still
waiting for some numismatist to prove that Silbanacus was real and to explain the history
to us. Imagine what we're gonna find out in the future. Or this might just remain a mystery forever.
We may never know exactly who these men were, like, how many soldiers supported them, or how long their
their little reigns lasted. Some have reigned in, like, small territories for a few weeks,
but apart from them being, like, this interesting numismatic and historical curiosity, their coins
prove that, as I mentioned, they existed and they expose an unpleasant reality for all of us. These
intruders, these inconvenient emperors, they have changed how we understand some of the most
unstable moments in Roman history, particularly the 3rd century AD. Rome was not an unbeatable
juggernaut moving, like, unbeatable through its enemies. For a very long time, it was more like a
paper tiger. It was a very fragile entity politically, repeatedly splitting apart from within,
and during some of these crises, the empire may have come far closer to collapsing than its
canonical history wants us to remember. And this is what makes coins such incredible tools for
understanding the past. They may be small, they might not have lots of information individually,
but they're agile. They are these little nuggets of history, of knowledge, that no state is truly
capable of erasing. Numismatics is also a remarkable form of citizen science because
private collectors, detectorists, and independent researchers can still record new discoveries and
contribute directly to our own, to our overall understanding of history. That's why we should
all be very vocal whenever some archaeologist or politician or public official tries to question
our rights to collect these wonderful little things. We, as a group, numismatists,
we've, for centuries, contributed so much for mankind's knowledge of history, and we will
continue doing so in the future, as long as they keep their hands off our coins. Let the specialists
deal with coins, please. Alright, I hope you enjoyed yet another episode. Leave a like and
consider subscribing if you did. Happy collecting, and I'll see you soon!
