What should you do when a student refuses to work? This video shares practical classroom strategies for responding calmly, understanding the reason behind the behavior, setting clear expectations, and helping students get back on track without unnecessary conflict. Helpful ideas for teachers dealing with challenging classroom situations.
This podcast episode discusses strategies for handling students who refuse to complete work or follow expectations. The host emphasizes that behavior is a form of communication and suggests using observation to identify triggers and offering controlled choices to avoid power struggles and empower students.
Hey there, welcome to the Happy Teaching Podcast.
Today, we are going to talk about something
that can be a tricky topic,
and it's something that you have likely run into many times,
and that is when a student refuses to do their work.
And I say work, and I really mean like an expectation.
They're refusing to do some activity with the class,
refusing to complete something.
They're just not doing it, they don't want to.
And this can be a tricky topic for us
because every teacher is going to experience this
at some point.
And it's tricky because we,
it's almost hard to navigate
because it puts us in a situation
where if we're not strategic here,
we can end up in a power struggle
with a four or five or six year old,
or a back and forth argument
with a four or five or six year old.
And that is not where we want to be.
We do not want to be in that situation.
So when this happens, because it will,
we need to pause and we need to come up with a plan.
So that's what we're going to do today.
I'm going to give you my top tip for this,
and I'm also going to give you additional help
and resources if you need it at the end.
But first, let's talk about what's happening
and perhaps why.
Now, we've all heard many, many times that like,
oh, behavior is communication, right?
And you've probably heard that.
And sometimes we can feel frustrated hearing that
because we're like,
well, I don't know what they're trying to communicate.
And it's frustrating because I have 25 other kids
and this kid is doing X, Y, Z, right?
And we're human.
It's hard, it's hard to navigate.
It can be really frustrating.
But the truth is behavior really is a type of communication
and we might not understand it.
They might not understand it,
but it can help us kind of pinpoint the issue.
So if you're in the Print and Play Club,
go to your dashboard and search behavior detective.
I have an hour long training.
It's long, but it's worth it.
It's probably a little bit shorter,
actually in the club as the replay upload,
but you can watch that.
And it's going to teach you what to look for with behaviors,
how to navigate behaviors.
And it's really important that we observe our students
because it's going to change our approach.
So I'm going to give you my tip
for the most universal approach with this,
but as we know, every child is different.
But a lot of the times when it comes to a student
refusing to do something,
sometimes it's that they can't or they're overwhelmed
or they're frustrated, right?
It's not, usually it's not that they just want
to ruin your day or cause you to have stress, right?
They're not typically thinking that way.
They're not trying to bother you.
It's just something going on.
So one year I had a student who would,
he just did not want to sign in every morning.
They would kind of practice writing their name.
They would sign in and move on.
And he just was really, really adamant about not doing it.
And I was like, I don't understand this.
Why is he just saying no?
He puts his name on his paper, like what's going on?
Well, I observed it.
And during the day he actually took longer
to kind of put his name on his paper.
He needed his like little name tag
out of the pocket chart more often.
He, it just took him longer, right?
But there wasn't the pressure, right?
It wasn't signing in when other kids are waiting
and then they go play.
It was a different situation.
So he was feeling this pressure
and there were letters in his name
that he was really struggling with.
He got a little embarrassed.
And so he was like, no, I'm just not doing it.
I wouldn't have known that if I didn't observe that
and notice any patterns.
Is it always the same activity?
Is it always the same time of day?
Is it always after recess?
What's happening at recess that they come in
and they automatically refuse to do the next thing?
If we notice patterns,
we can pinpoint a potential trigger
and we can get in front of it.
So with this student,
I gave them their tag to use for a helper.
He had his own folder to practice specific letters only.
He was much happier.
I was meeting his needs where he was at
and the refusal went away.
It's not a magical fairytale solution,
but it's much better than me getting into an argument.
You have to do it, you have to do it.
When actually there was a valid reason,
but he couldn't really explain to me
that this is really hard for me, right?
I can't do this.
He didn't have that knowledge or understanding
even of himself.
I had to observe it to see what was causing him to shut down.
So I highly recommend the behavior detective video.
We'll put that in the show notes as well.
So sometimes there's a reason for things, right?
So now let's talk about though,
when it happens in the moment,
we've got a hundred kids, right?
Probably 20 plus kids.
What are we going to do?
The best tip that I have that will help a lot in this
is not going to be a magical fairytale solution
for everything.
We're going to talk about more unexpected behaviors
in a moment, but my number one strategy is offering choice.
Choice is huge for students,
especially when students are fighting for control.
That choice gives them that sense of control
and can really diffuse the situation.
It is not about giving them their way.
If you're thinking, I'm not going to give them a choice
and just let them get away with it.
They just get to do what they want.
Not at all.
You as the teacher are in charge of the choices.
You are still in charge of what they're going to do.
They're still doing what you want them to do.
The expectation isn't going anywhere,
but the path to get there has a little more flexibility
and you're still deciding what that path looks like,
but they get to control a little bit more.
So this could look as simple as,
would you like a red crayon or a blue crayon
to write your name or whatever?
Would you like to do your work sitting or standing?
Some of you might be gasping at that,
but I promise you even something that small,
letting a student stand up,
I would have, I love standing up while I'm doing something,
standing next to a table, right?
Does it really impact, is it that big of a deal?
If it changes their entire approach to something
and they can focus, right?
There's a choice, sitting or standing.
You may not do your work upside down on the chair,
but you may choose to sit or stand.
Do you see how that's different than,
nope, you can't hang upside down, sit on your chair.
That is the expectation.
Yes, they need to not be hanging upside down, right?
But now I'm giving a choice here.
You may not do that thing.
You may do this or this.
So I'm still deciding what the choice is,
but they are having a sense of control,
which for some students really, really helps them
as they build up their behaviors.
Now, yeah, you might be thinking like,
how can something so simple really make them want to work?
Because choice is really powerful.
It's powerful for us as adults too.
And it frames us to the expectation
instead of what we just got told we can't have, right?
If someone is serving,
yeah, and this is totally a silly example,
but as an adult, and it's a fluff example,
but just go with me here.
Someone is serving chocolate cake
and we don't really want chocolate cake, right?
Too bad, right?
As an adult, yeah, just too bad.
But think of the difference here.
If we're trying to go over there
and we're trying to go in their fridge
to make our own cake, kind of rude, right?
They don't want us digging in their fridge
to make our own cake, right?
If someone says, no, get out of my fridge.
You just go over there, buy that chocolate cake.
We'd be like, oh man, I really wanted a different cake.
That's a bummer.
Of course, this is a fluff example.
And as adults, hopefully we would just get over it, right?
And not eat the cake.
But imagine the difference if someone said,
oh, you really can't dig through my fridge
and make your own cake,
but you may have chocolate cake that I'm serving
or I have these peanut butter cookies in my cupboard.
You may have one of those instead if you would like.
Which one would you like?
Now, I've kind of stopped focusing
on digging through the fridge
for something entirely unrelated, right?
Like the kid hanging upside down on the chair.
Because now I've been given an option like,
oh, I didn't, there's another option, awesome.
Now I'm thinking about it
and they gave me the choice
and I go, oh, I'm sure I will have a cookie instead.
And now I'm sitting back down with my group of whoever
and having a fun time, right?
Again, fluff example.
But immediately when I gave that other choice,
you can see how even as a silly example
as an adult eating snacks,
you can see how our mind is now on what they want us to do.
I stopped worrying about digging in the fridge.
That child stopped worrying
about hanging under the chair, hopefully.
Not every time, but often.
Because they're presented with additional choices
that now their mind can think about and be in control of.
Thank you for hanging with me with my silly examples,
but sometimes that's where my mind goes
to help me understand
and I hope it gives you that perspective too.
That, again, you're still in control of the outcome,
you're still in control of how they get there,
but you're giving a little bit more flexibility to do it.
Choice can be really, really powerful.
Now, I probably, I'm just guessing here,
but you're probably thinking, okay, great,
I'm gonna give it a try,
I really recommend giving it a try.
But you're also probably thinking,
well, what if I offer choice and they just go, nope.
What if they say no?
What if they jump on top of the table
and start throwing things at me?
And I'm not exaggerating, this happens, right?
You might be thinking of a situation
where you're like, they just eloped,
like they ran away from me, they threw a chair at me,
like all it did was escalate.
What if behaviors escalate, okay?
So I'm gonna drop in the show notes
because our episode here is coming to a close,
but I am going to drop some information
on related videos we have inside the Print and Play Club.
We deal with a lot of classroom management struggles
with you and support you through things
like if a child really says no, right?
They're just not doing it, you've tried other things.
We support you through what are related consequences,
how do we actually implement them, right?
When is it appropriate, how do we do it?
We also support you through unexpected behaviors,
more violent behaviors to keep you and your students safe.
So we have a lot of those related videos for you.
If you're in the club, we'll drop the links below.
If you're not yet, I encourage you to go to our invite link,
get a free gift, take a look around,
and if you're ready and willing to try those tips
that I shared here, I promise you giving some choices
to all your students is going to be really powerful
and it will get you set up on the right path.
There are always exceptions, but choices are powerful
for all, even in my fluff example as an adult.
Choices really help all of us, give us things
to think about, give us new things to try
and can ease some of those tensions.
So give it a try.
If you have questions, reach out to us anytime
and of course, join us in the club for even more
and I will see you in the next episode.
Happy teaching.