PUZZLING MOVE Yankees Made? Not Quite
Sep 11, 2026
The Yankees absolutely had no choice but to make this move.
And if you think, if you think that this was not the move to make, I truly don't know what
to tell you.
I don't know what you have to understand about the Yankees promoting Anthony Volpe because
of this Jazz Chisholm injury, and this sucks.
Jazz has been hitting as of late.
His defense, I mean, he's good, but he's a bit too lax out there.
I don't know what he's doing to his side.
That kind of drives me crazy when he like leans over, and that kind of drives me nuts.
Anyway, Anthony Volpe though, coming back up, and if you guys don't know, he's tearing
up AAA, absolutely tearing it up.
But do me a favor.
If you love the Yankees and you're not subscribed for whatever reason, be sure to subscribe.
We're on the road to 25,000.
I really want to get there soon, so if you could help us get there, that would be a gigantic
blessing.
And thank you to those guys who are subscribed.
It truly does mean a lot.
You guys are awesome.
You guys comment, even when the video goes a little slower, you guys comment.
I have one of the greatest support systems on YouTube when it comes to a subscriber base
like you guys.
You guys are amazing.
This is an amazing community.
I just can't thank you guys enough.
But listen, Anthony Volpe has been promoted because Jazz unfortunately went down with
an injury.
I hope Jazz comes back, at least by the playoffs.
Now, the other two alternatives to Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Ahmed Rosario.
And who knows how many at-bats Volpe is going to get if he's going to play every day?
Who knows?
He's not playing shortstop.
That's Lombard spot.
He's not playing shortstop, so he's going to play second base.
Maybe we see him at third.
That's where he's played in AAA during his stint.
But Anthony Volpe, this season in AAA, I mean, 11 home runs, a 260 average, and 850 OPS.
He's been knocking the crap out of the baseball.
And if you can't get behind that, he's 25 years old, same age as Spencer Jones.
Keep this in mind, Anthony Volpe never had time to develop in AAA, and I'm not saying
that's what this was.
He spent three years, three and a half years in the major leagues.
That's plenty of time.
Plenty of time.
But he was called up very young, too, 25 years old, same age as Spencer Jones, same age as
when Ben Rice was called up.
Austin Wells, I think, was 24 when he was called up.
So Anthony Volpe, 25, knocking the crap out of the baseball down there in AAA.
And I think it's unfair when people say, oh, quadruple-A player.
That's not what this is.
I wouldn't say that's what this is right now.
If he went down there and he stunk, different story, then I would say, all right, I think
we need to give up on this Anthony Volpe thing.
The guy hit 11 homers, he displayed a ton of power down there in a short amount of time
while hitting 260, had an 850 OPS.
People seem to forget, and listen, yes, I'm drinking the Kool-Aid right now.
People seem to forget the kind of minor league player Anthony Volpe was, how good he was
down there.
In 2021, with Tampa, with the Tampa Tarpons, Volpe hit 12 homers, hit 302, over 1,000 OPS.
Then he was promoted to high A that same year, 15 homers, hit 286, 978 OPS.
That's why people were so excited for him, because he was dominating the minors.
Then until 2022 came, began the year in double-A, 820 OPS, 251, but 820 OPS.
That's fine, right?
18 homers, was promoted to triple-A, 22 games.
This is where he needed more time, hit 236, 717 OPS.
He goes out, has a really big spring for the Yankees in 2023, dethrones Oswald Peraza.
I'm not saying Peraza was deserving, but Peraza did look good at the major league level in
2022 in September.
He did.
I believe he had over 300, and he looked good in the field.
I would have let Anthony Volpe had more development in triple-A.
He only had 22 games.
That's it.
Clearly, in his first couple of months up here in the major leagues, they were dreadful.
He needed to be sent down, and they refused.
Finally, three and a half years later, three years later, they send him down because they
have no choice.
In 37 games this season in triple-A, 11 home runs, hitting 264.
According to a 906 OPS, up here, 850.
There's a little bit of a discrepancy there, but obviously, I would take the 906 OPS every
day of the week, twice on Sunday.
I'm not saying to have patience with Anthony Volpe.
I'm not asking you to do that, but what I am saying is he never had the proper time
to develop in triple-A.
We're trying to force it up here, and it wasn't working.
It never worked.
Now, they send him down because they had no choice.
He worked his tail off.
Guys, in 37 games, he had 11 homers.
People want to say, oh, he's not a power hitter.
His first two years in professional baseball, 2021, he had 27 home runs in 2021.
That's his first full year in pro baseball.
2022, he had 21 homers.
2023, another 21 home run season at the major league level.
He's got power.
That's why I get it.
You want him to be this slap hitter, this average hitter.
He's got pop like the kid does.
He's got pop, and I hope when he comes up right now that he's able to seize this opportunity
and show us, oh, maybe he could play second base for us.
Maybe he could be our second baseman for the next few seasons before he hits free agency
because he's going to be a free agent pretty soon.
Now, I'm not sure him going down to triple-A if it messes with his service time.
I'm not sure if it added another year, but Anthony Volpe, in my opinion, just my opinion,
looked really good in triple-A.
I mean, it's a fact.
He had 11 homers.
Defensively, rough around the edges.
Okay.
I think he's earned this opportunity to come up here and play alongside George Lombard
and play second base in Jazz's absence.
I think he's earned that.
He's earned it.
Listen, I've been the biggest Anthony Volpe critic for a really long time.
I've been incredibly hard on the kid.
He was a former top five prospect in baseball, and the Yankees were seemingly shoving him
down our throats.
I just think, I believe in second chances.
I just think that he's earned one, even if it's just for a couple of weeks.
I think he's earned one.
Alternatives, Jose Caballero, good defender, but his last 30 games, Caballero's hitting
205.
He's hitting 205.
Ahmed Rosario, his last seven games, he's eight for 23, very good.
Butcher with the glove.
Volpe's better defensively.
His last 30 games, Rosario, 227, but he has been picking it up a little bit.
It's just, he's not a good defender.
So, would you platoon him and Volpe?
I mean, the whole thing, Caballero, they're all going to be involved over there at second
base.
I don't see the Yankees playing him at shortstop at all, Anthony Volpe, but I have to be honest
with you.
I'm excited.
Jason Dominguez said it himself that Anthony Volpe's working his tail off down there.
And AAA's working his tail off.
And when a player does that, it shows you they care.
And there's a lot of big leaguers, a lot of professionals who just don't give a rat.
They don't care.
And you want somebody to care.
You want Anthony Volpe to care.
And right now, I'm going to say this, I'm going to be rooting for the kid.
I'm going to be hoping that Anthony Volpe shocks the heck out of every single Yankee
fan.
That's what I'm hoping.
I'm hoping he comes up here and just takes that brass ring.
I'm hoping and praying for that.
I'm hoping for this kid.
He really wants it.
I want to know what you guys have to say down in the comments.
Thank you guys so, so much for watching.
I'll see you next time.
Take care.

