I Blind Tasted $8 Wine Against $183 Bordeaux. The Result Shocked Me

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
1 Video View·Sep 10, 2026
Can an $8 grocery store wine really compete with- or even BEAT0 a $183 Bordeaux? In this blind taste test, Certified Sommelier John Alanis puts $8 Bogle Cabernet Sauvignon head-to-head against 2012 Chateau Montrose — a legendary second-growth Bordeaux from Saint-Estèphe — without knowing which glass is which.
…
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCertified sommelier John Honest performs a blind tasting comparing an $8 Bogle Cabernet Sauvignon with a $183 2012 Chateau Montrose. He demonstrates how high-end wines offer superior complexity, structure, and an evolving sensory experience compared to the static, simple nature of budget table wines, ultimately scoring the Bordeaux a 98.
One of these bottles cost me eight bucks at the grocery store.
The other one, 183 bucks.
A classified Bordeaux for one of the greatest estates in the world.
I'm John Honest.
I'm a certified CMIA.
And then the next few minutes,
I'm going to blind taste both of these and try to tell which is which.
It's cheap versus expensive wine.
But here's the thing that scares me.
I might get it wrong. So let's find out.
OK, here's how this is going to work.
A colleague poured these while I was out of the room.
I have no idea which is which.
This is glass A and this is glass B.
Now, before I start blind tasting, let me tell you what we're doing.
One of these is a Bogle Cabernet Sauvignon for eight bucks.
You probably walk past it a hundred times at the store.
It's a California cab for extreme value wine drinkers.
In other words, it's a very cheap wine.
The other is a 2012 Chateau Montrose,
a second growth Bordeaux from Sainte-Estephane.
This is royalty.
This bottle has been aging for over a decade,
waiting for the exact right moment.
And that's now.
The price difference is 23 times.
So the real question isn't just can I tell them apart?
It's whether the difference is actually worth it.
Time for a real world wine review.
Let's go. All right.
Let's go ahead and start with glass A here.
So what we're going to what I'm going to do
is I am going to have a look at the site first and see what we get.
This actually looks like a little bit of a lighter wine.
Definitely a young wine.
I see a lot of hot pink around it.
I don't see any orange.
There's not a lot of extraction, I would say, in this wine.
You know, California is known for its mega purple.
And I would suspect that, you know, Bordeaux would put some mega purple in there.
But this is actually a surprisingly nice looking wine.
Let's have a look at the other one, glass B, to see what we have here.
This is definitely a deeper, darker wine.
It definitely has orange around the rim, which shows that it has some age on it.
It's got a lot of extraction.
It just looks like an older, deeper, wiser wine.
Now, I could make my calls based on site, but I'm going to tell you something.
If you start making calls based on site alone, you are going to get into trouble.
How do you think I know?
So let's go ahead and give them a nose.
Hmm. I would say I get some, you know, blackberries from glass A.
Not much else.
This is a little bit rough,
but it's got kind of a nice aroma.
Let's have a nose of a glass B and see what we have in this one.
OK, this is definitely much more complex.
I get just gorgeous blackberries, elegant, pure black plum,
certainly some tobacco leaf that runs through there, which is indicative of a pyrazine.
I get a little bit of red fruit in there, maybe a little bit of red plum.
Get a little bit of earth.
Get a little bit of graphite as well, which comes across as pencilhead.
The nose on this wine right here is definitely more complex than this wine.
Yeah, and when I and when I smell it, I do it side by side.
It's actually very interesting.
I get a very jammy fruit character component to this, which is a big clue.
With this, I get an elegant and pure fruit character.
So that's a big clue.
But let's go ahead and taste and see what we got.
No bueno.
I get a little bit of sweetness on there.
Very short finish.
I do get some nice blackberry,
but it's a little bit harsh on the finish.
A little bit barky, a little bit pyrazinic.
You know, it's actually not a terrible wine,
but it's actually it's a very simple wine.
The fruit kind of starts, but then has a bitterness to it.
So let's go ahead and give the wine a try.
Gosh, I know this is just gorgeous.
That's so elegant, so pure, so complex.
Great tannin structure.
Great acid.
That makes my mouth water.
A little bit of earth, but just layers and layers and layers of beautiful
blackberry cassis, black plum, a little bit of red plum.
Because there's some earth in there.
Sweet tobacco running through graphite.
Here's the thing.
This wine feels like this right now.
As I go through the bottle, it could open up.
So I'm going to make my calls.
As a sommelier, this is not hard for me to do.
This is definitely the Bogle.
Not as bad as I thought it would be, though.
This is definitely the 2012 Chateau Montrose.
We'll open them up to have a look and see.
But really, interestingly, what gives it away the most?
Yeah, I was right.
I get to keep my job as a certified sommelier.
But honestly, what gives it away the most?
I thought that the site would be a little bit different
because usually these California wines use mega purple in there.
This really doesn't look like a mega purple.
I'm sure there's some in there.
But it actually it's actually got a nice look to it.
But what gave this one away immediately was when I nosed them side by side.
And I could tell this was a jammy, warm climate Central Valley cab.
And then when I tasted it, it didn't have much going on.
But if you want to know the big tell for me,
actually, it wasn't the palate.
It was the nose immediately picked up on the fruit character
that this would be a moderate climate wine, which means it's going to be ripe,
but not overripe, not jammy.
This immediately jammy fruit character.
So when I know that I have a Bordeaux versus, you know,
probably Central Valley, California cab,
look at that beautiful Chateau Montrose 2012 ready to drink.
That's how I can tell immediately.
So usually you want to go to the palate to make your calls.
But the nose immediately.
Yeah, now that I'm kind of looking at this,
I can see a little bit more purple in there.
But I will say this, I'll give Bogo a little bit of credit.
It doesn't look like they overdid it.
So this would actually be even though it's an $8 cab,
if you've got nine non-wine friends coming over,
they might actually like it quite a bit.
So if you're having a party with people who just want
essentially alcoholic grape juice, Bogo's not a bad option.
You want to save a little bit of money.
But if you're drinking wine,
you want to go with something like the Chateau Montrose.
And here's what I'm going to tell you why, because we're going to do something unique.
The real difference between these two wines is not just to be found
in a mere snort, taste and spit wine review.
It's not the initial aromas and flavors,
even though I can evaluate each one based on that.
It's how the wine changes and evolves as you go through the bottle.
That's why the Bogo is a party wine.
That's why this, the Chateau Montrose is an individual wine.
Look, I know this Bogo ain't going to evolve as I go through the bottle.
And I ain't going to go through the bottle.
The first and last sip will be exactly the same.
It is what it is.
A cheap table wine for people that like that stuff.
It's actually a pretty good party wine.
If your guests are non-wine people and you bring them over,
they're going to be pretty happy with Bogo.
Now, the Chateau Montrose, however, will undergo significant evolution
as I go through this beautiful bottle.
It's going to change.
It's going to evolve as I go through it.
And it's probably going to take me on an emotional journey.
I'm going to do something unusual just for you.
I'm going to drink this whole bottle tonight, yay me,
and give you my proprietary whole bottle review,
something most people have never heard of before.
But that's the real magic of wine.
You see, that's the only way you truly get the vast difference
between the get your buzz grocery store gloop.
Oh, this isn't terrible gloop.
And a magical bottle of wine.
And that's what few people miss.
Few wine experts talk about it.
Almost no one does.
But I do hear on magical wine experiences from my subscribers.
It's not about the wine.
It's about the experience of the wine.
No mere snort, taste and spit wine review can capture that.
Only a proper glass by glass whole bottle review.
So stay tuned for my whole bottle review of the one hundred
and eighty three dollar Chateau Montrose 2012 to see.
Is it twenty three times better than the eight dollar Bogle?
And you know what?
I'm betting it is.
But I could be wrong.
So stay tuned.
My whole bottle review is coming up right now.
Let's get into the 2012 Chateau Montrose.
The second growth from St.
Estefé, Left Bank Bordeaux.
Because this, as you can see, I happily drank this all.
This was a classic Burgundy.
Bordeaux, excuse me.
This is a classic Bordeaux had burgundy in my mind as we as we started
from the very first sip.
This thing came right out of the bottle and said, I'm Bordeaux.
I'm classic Bordeaux.
I'm not warm.
I'm not jammy.
I'm a nice balance between fruit and nice on earth.
Tobacco, graphite, everything we love about Bordeaux.
And it came out and it made its case.
And it says you are going to get an expression of terroir in this wine.
And by God, that's what we got.
So as I went through glass one,
that was the thing that I started really to think about that popped into my mind
was, wow, I'm in St.
I'm in St.
Estefé, Chateau Montrose on the hill overlooking the Garonne Estuary.
And I'm drinking a bottle of Chateau Montrose.
Wow. Because that's what the thing that came to my mind immediately was,
was this is a stern expression of place.
Not mean, not nasty, but it was a firm, decisive expression
of the place where it came from.
And that's what you're going to get in a classic Bordeaux.
Obviously, we got black fruit.
You're going to get some black plum.
You're going to get a blackberry, cassis, blackcurrant,
all of that stuff like that.
But the fruit character was just ripe.
Wasn't underripe.
Wasn't overripe.
It was just ripe enough.
And this was a dry wine.
I really liked that.
There was no mistaking what it was.
You could tell, nope, there ain't hardly any residual sugar in this at all.
This isn't a warm climate.
This was a cool vintage.
It was just nice.
And still, the sweet strain of pipe tobacco was there.
The graphite was there.
This was everything you love about Bordeaux.
Now, if you're a California wine drinker, you're not going to like this.
If you're a classic Bordeaux drinker, my God in heaven, you're going to love this.
As we got into glass two, this was like this was not an in-your-face wine.
This was all about structure.
This was all about precision.
This was all about elegance.
And I really like that.
It made its case in the beginning that you're going to get structure
and discipline here.
And so as I got into glass two, what I thought was really neat was
is you would get the tasting notes in order every single time.
There would be fruit.
There would be graphite.
There would be tobacco.
There would be earth.
And it would come back around.
Oops. And it would come back around.
It was very disciplined every single time.
And it started to beat a little bit faster as we went through the wine.
As I got into glass three, that's that was really interesting.
It was like a symphony that was playing.
And the beat started to get just a little bit faster.
Blackberry, graphite.
Every now and then a note might reverse, you know, the 34 loop just a little bit.
But it was almost the same every single time I take a sip.
I feel like I was sitting in Chateau Montrose overlooking the guy around Estuary.
I'd get blackberry, graphite, tobacco, earth.
You know, it would repeat and repeat and repeat.
And it would say, I am a classic left bank Bordeaux from a cool vintage.
And it just got more and more itself as we got into glass four.
And then even in the glass five, this wine staked its claim for what it was.
Did I get a lot of emotion?
No, I didn't.
But I kind of felt a sense of rigor, a sense of discipline,
definitely a sense of place.
And that's one thing that I love about Bordeaux is a well-made Bordeaux
is a classic expression of Toronto.
We were in San Estefé. We were not in Margaux.
We were right there.
We were overlooking the Giron River and we were in Bordeaux heaven.
And it didn't evolve and change that much from that as I went to the glass.
But it didn't have to.
It felt like I was just floating on this really still wonderful pond
with a constant beat of aromas and flavors playing over and over and over and over.
It was mellow. It was relaxing.
But it didn't feel like it transported me right to Bordeaux.
I wasn't in Italy, I wasn't in Spain, I wasn't in California.
I was in San Estefé in Bordeaux.
This wine took me, grabbed me and placed me right there.
And I really like that.
So I gave this wine to start with a 97.5.
I'm going to go ahead and give this an upgrade to a 98.
Not quite a 98.5 because I didn't get a lot of emotion from it.
But go from 97.5 to 98.
A 98 point wine on my magical wine experience is my whole bottle review scale
is pretty good.
That was a significant amount of movement.
And the thing that did it to me was this wine
grabbing my mind from the start and saying, we are going to San Estefé
and we're going to relax and enjoy it.
And we're going to hear San Estefé played, felt and seen.
So for me, this was a wonderful Bordeaux, fantastic, magical wine experience.
So we're going to go with 98 on this.
So what's better than one whole bottle review?
Another whole bottle review coming up right now.
