Thrand and Eldgrim after Roland Warzecha's suggestion compare Roland's Cast Blow to Thrand's overarm throwing spear slide or Gigging style technique! These techniques both come from ancient depictions an artwork and may prove what the later century fight manuals and treaties meant as the ancients method of sword and spear use differ from our own. They prove very little if any body motion can needs to be used with either technique and they both generate more speed and power than the body motion can alone in cutting. Thrand explains how the SCA uses the thrown blow or shot which is very similar just stream lined in their combat style.These techniques work very well in early large shield combat, shield walls, phalanx and mounted combat were mobility can be very limited. So sit back grab an ale or mead and enjoy this video of techniques tested on analog ballistic gel head and tough rolled wet newspaper in this exciting reply to Roland Warzecha and his cast blow sword technique!
This video compares the \"cast blow\" for the sword and the \"overarm throwing slide\" for the spear, techniques prevalent in Viking and Migration era combat. These methods prioritize accelerating the weapon's own weight over full-body movement, allowing for lethal power and maximum reach while fighting from a stationary position, such as when braced behind a shield or mounted on a horse.
I'm here with the Viking sword and the spear, the one-handed spear, the techniques that
I use where I do the overarm throwing slide and we're comparing it to Roland Warzecka's
cast blow.
Cast blow is basically where the sword is accelerated and thrown with the arm.
It's not even necessary to use the entire body to generate energy, just the arm and
slight initial body movements.
That's about it.
You just accelerate the blade and let the blade work and follow through the target using
the back of the hand to grip tightly and the pommel on the back with the fingers tightly
grasped and loose in the front allowing it to just flail out and kind of do its own cutting
while you control it from the back and letting it do its thing.
The overarm throwing slide that we're speaking of is where you actually throw the spear with
tension.
You don't allow it to fly out of your hand.
You allow it to slide through the hand and the thing about it, it's loose.
It's not you going out there and gripping tightly and planting the legs and using the
body to drive it home.
You get more reach with it, plus you can find it closer with it if necessary, but I mean
you get extreme reach and can just pull it right back.
So it's a beautiful technique.
It has a lot of power and it has more penetration, initial penetration when you're trying to
penetrate layers of armor, whether it be leather or gambeson or what have you.
Most of these techniques here, the cast blow, the throwing slide, this was used for a long
time according to a lot of the depictions that Roland sent me.
Later century it was still used.
I believe it was used in the ancient warfare when you go back to Bronze Age.
I believe they were doing the throwing slide.
I think the javelin and spear were very hard to see.
The main point today is the actual technique with the sword of the cast blow and the cast
or thrown blow of the spear, but the controlled use of it behind a shield in early combat
was probably the common method of use because you're allowing the weight of the weapon to
do the work and not actually using the body to deliver the blow.
Later on when they get into conventional fencing, you'll see a lot of the screening type cuts.
You will see other types of techniques, but a lot of that was bluff fetched in an armored
combat where in lightly armored combat or armored combat with shields, it was much easier
to use the cast blow or the overarm throwing slide.
Mounted, I think the weight or possibly the shield wall when one can't move around a lot,
you don't have the advantage to step every time or use the entire body.
And that's when the weight of the weapon and accelerating it is a major advantage and it's
effortless.
It's not as tiring.
Anyway, let's start with the video and compare them and see how they stack up.
Alright, we're comparing the cast blow to the overarm throwing slide.
I always put the throw part in there because basically you're accelerating the weapon.
Meaning the weapon is, the weight of the actual weapon is generating the energy and how fast
you can accelerate it.
And of course how most people cut targets like this, they will use the best portion
of the blade, which in this order would probably be somewhere between here where it has the
best cutting ability, which is also the fastest moving part of the blade if one accelerates
it.
If one accelerates the blade by swinging it, that is going to be the fastest moving area.
But what Roland speaks of is how they used to grip it.
This one's a little bit longer than it actually should be.
But as you see, my little finger, my pinky, is right here on the inside of the palm.
I believe it's a type S palm, but it's on the inside of it.
It's not out here.
I believe, I don't know who it was, I think Matt Easton had showed him doing it something
like that, which is an exaggerated ridiculous thing.
Could not even do that on this one.
But this back part of the hand, even like Matt Easton says, is supposed to be held tight.
In other words, the back part of the hand tightens up as the blade is cast, but the
front of the fingers are held loose.
So you end up in this kind of position, like you see in some of the drawings.
But it's actually an ending position for the actual cast of the blow.
But it's actually an effortless blow, and what we'll do here is try it out on this medium.
We've got a rolled wet newspaper, and cut very nicely, and we've got a clean cut, clean
through, and it didn't take much effort at all.
All I did is use my arm motion, and I'm standing in a back stance as if I had my shield out
and I had to come in and cut.
That means I could have something out here protecting me, and still throwing a proper
motion, a cutting technique that will cut and be very effective, and have lots of power
without stepping, not doing a stepping cut.
Not doing a push cut, or say a slicing type drawing motion, like you would expect.
And you have maximum reach.
I'm going to try one more here.
And it cuts effortlessly.
All I'm doing is letting the blade do its job.
That's it.
That's all we're doing.
We're just letting the blade come on down and cut.
It's not a technique like a push cut.
You're trying to cut into it, which will not work on this medium very well, as you can
see.
Or be trying to do something like cut into it.
Because if I try to do that, this kind of medium is going to give, but I'm not able
to get that type of cut in.
Although I did cut into it using that.
I stepped in and just really cut into the actual medium, which is interesting.
Proper push cut of, I mean I could cut into the material, but I'm not going to get that
kind of cut.
And if I was hitting something like really thick armor, such as leather over a gambeson
cloth, or multiple layers of cloth, I don't think I would cut through much more than cloth
trying to do that.
I probably wouldn't even make it that far.
But as you see the fibers here we cut, I mean, that's beautiful.
We could cut it anywhere the same way.
And even at the last bit there, we still cut through totally even after it was weakened.
And that's effortless.
You just sit here, just let the blade do its job.
Alright, we're going to talk about using it with a shield.
The same idea.
The cast blow and just following the shield line.
Because you can do that in all manners here.
You can just follow the shield line and come in and attack the target.
Which is a good thing.
Because you've got that to protect your hand, the shield, and to protect your body depending
on where you're behind it.
You're not going to always want to step out to cut from the shield.
Because if you do that, you can get attacked pretty much and injured trying to do that.
You can stand in a front stance and do the same thing with the shield.
You can attack that way and this way.
So it's up to you if you're standing in this kind of more of a human style buckler stance.
You can stand in the back stance, which you'll also see a lot in the old drawings.
It shows up as well.
Let's say I'm just using my arm and I'm back here with the shield.
Let's see how effectively it cuts.
Beautifully.
It goes clean through and all I'm doing is letting the sword do the work.
I'm not sitting here trying to do a body style cut where I'm holding the sword and doing that.
Because if I did that and tried to put body and step into it and cut, we'd get an effect just like this.
And that's what we were trying to show.
Yes, I can do faster body motion.
I can step in quicker and try to cut like I just did.
But it's not going to work on this kind of meat.
Effortlessly.
And we got through this big roll.
Look how big this roll is.
Come on, check it out.
That was effortlessly.
I looked over at the camera and look at this.
A little tearing on the back.
That's actually how the stuff rolls.
It unrolls as it comes through.
That's what's causing the tearing.
The actual cutting where it's densely rolled is all beautiful.
That was me not even making any effort.
I just let the blade do the work and accelerated it and that's what it did.
And that was another effortless cut.
Come check it out, guys.
Not much trouble there.
That is a lot of newspaper, too.
We've got over three inches.
That's about three and a half inches.
These old one-handers that are blade heavy and the heavier models cast like that do way more damage.
I think that's why in the 13th century they had a lot of heavier one-handers.
Because they were wearing a lot of armor.
A lot of them were still using shields.
The cast blows worked very well for mounts.
If I'm mounted, I can't move my body much.
I can hold tight to the horse and do my swings.
I can actually swing down with the cast blow.
But I can't really move around other than the horse's movement.
Behind a shield, a lot of times, if I'm trying to protect myself from multiple opponents,
I don't have the luxury of trying to step with each cut.
Try to apply body weight to it or push the cut through, so to speak.
I believe these are superior in power.
It's just, are they as good as the screening type cuts?
You know, like when you're fencing.
Well, of course not.
It's not the same thing.
It's not floss-fetched.
It's harness-fetched.
You're in armor.
A lot of times, you're not going to be worried about trying to parry with a sword
unless you have a really small shield.
You end up in that situation hunting for niches or something.
Otherwise, if you're trying to damage somebody through mail with a sword that's capable of doing that
or cut into him where he's uncovered,
like, let's say, some cloth on his legs, you can slide straight through his legs
just like they speak about in the saga.
All right.
What I'd like to speak about is the cast and blow, the cast blow,
like Willem Wozniak speaks of.
The SCA does something very similar to it.
They are hitting for power, and they're counting how much force goes through the arm,
like what they feel.
If it's solid, did it skip?
How hard is it?
But to generate power, they do what they consider a cranking motion,
which what that is is they throw more of a straight kendo-style shot out
and let the blade do the work, if you're watching what I'm doing.
So the idea there is to streamline it to get to your opponent,
to get the speed, to get that speed of the cut.
In a lot of ways, it very much can be performed like the stringing cuts when you come in here.
So you can use an acceleration of the blade to get your cut,
get your cut a little sharper than having a full cast from, let's say, a position up here,
like in some of the drawings where they cast it out and just let the blade do the work.
It's just streamlining it. It's the same thing.
You're just pretty much throwing the blows out and letting the blade do its thing and recover.
That's all it is.
We'll go ahead and try to throw one here with the cranking technique,
and I'll try to streamline it, make it go straight to the target.
There was no chance of cutting through that with a push or draw cut in a conventional manner.
Like from a trim slack, like a springing cut or something, I doubt you would cut through this
because it's not a body motion that's pushing the blade through.
It's not a draw or pushing cut that's going through.
It's the speed of the chopping or hacking motion from throwing a blade, a cast blow.
And that's how we're doing the speed cuts, setting up like that with no pedestal.
We're just sitting here like that.
This piece was up here, and we just went clean through effortlessly.
I got a little excited about it when I did that one, but it's still pretty much effortlessly.
You're just letting the blade do its thing.
You hold tight at the back and letting your hand follow through.
We notice this on these type of pommels that it seems like they're set up to do that.
They're set up for cast blows.
I don't think they were doing, early period, the transitional blades and early Viking blades,
I don't think they were doing much sword fencing.
I think it was all shield fencing, as Roland Warzecha says,
where the shield pushes the other shield, manipulates the other shield,
and that's why the big, large, 3-foot flat rounds with the center boss were very common.
When you start getting smaller shields and domed shields,
then you start seeing wider quillions and smaller pommels in the back,
more like Brazil nut, which can do both.
Some of them were designed where they can do screening-type cuts and sword fencing
with larger quillions or cross guards,
but they can also do cast blows as well when you have the Brazil nut pommel,
so I think that that type of style stayed prominent for a very long period of time
in the late 1300s, 14th century.
They're probably still throwing blows like this until they get into plate and so on,
where a heavy sword and just smashing the plate probably wouldn't do any good with one hand.
Now I'm going to test out the overarm throwing slide technique, is what I call it,
or the overarm slide technique.
It's a lot like the cast blow that Roland Warzecha is speaking of,
but he's witnessed in different depictions and artwork from the early century swords,
such as in the Viking era and the Migration era.
The swords tend to be made that it looks like they're used for casting,
to cast out the blow, hold on with the back of the hand, and accelerate the sword,
more or less the sword from the hand and the elbow and just not even worry about body motion,
just let the blade carry itself and do its own cutting,
which is very efficient, as we can tell, and very powerful just with the weight of the sword.
Right now we're going to go ahead and try out my overarm throwing slide,
which is to be used from behind the shield as well.
It's a one-handed technique, and it allows the spear to slide out like it has been thrown
and control with throwing speed.
So what I'm doing is I'm not using my body to drive this through here and plant and push.
I'm going to literally throw the spear through our head
and see how it actually does against our analog wrist.
Let's try that out, see how it works.
Now look at my hand.
You can see here, if you look at my hand, I'm letting go of it.
So I keep my hand that way, I let go, and let's see what we've got.
That was just me throwing my arm.
I wasn't using any body, and I wasn't pushing the spear.
I let the spear do it.
We've got a hole directly into the skull.
As you can see the blood coming out right here.
It might not have as much blood on it as usual, but we have a hole directly into the skull.
That's almost no effort whatsoever.
We have one more blood now, and we pierce the skull again.
That's my opinion. Both of those were kills, and it took minimum effort to pierce the skull.
Exact sort of same idea.
This is the cast blow, where you can follow the shield line, but you get your full reach.
Even with the shield all the way out, I can reach the guy.
If I were to have it in this kind of position, there's very little reach at the end of the shield.
If I want to cut somebody out here, I can barely do it.
I'd have to be right against it using this kind of motion.
So the cast blow, if I do a cast blow, look at the reach I get past the shield.
Even with it fully extended, if I were to be pushing it out to push the guy back, I can still cut him.
That's the beautiful thing about the cast blow.
And they use three foot shields to a meter in diameter.
So what we'll do is to take that into account.
I'll make sure I have full extension on the shield.
And we'll try to do a cast blow to the head and see how it performs.
Chopped right in easily, with no effort.
Let's give that a little more power and try that out.
Oh, that's nasty.
Took the top of the skull clean off.
Well, I hope you enjoyed the episode.
And I hope that it showed that the cast blow, or accelerating the sword by allowing it to move and throwing it out,
was very similar to the overarm slide or even the underarm slide is possible,
where you cast the weapon out and let it do the work itself.
And I hope that the video proved that and showed that it's effortless.
It doesn't take a lot of energy.
You can stay in a stationary position if necessary and still throw damaging or devastating cuts or blows,
hacking, chopping-type weapons.
It'll clean through arms, legs, pierce skulls.
Even the spear, a normal spear being driven into somebody's head is difficult to pierce the skull.
It only bobs the head out of the way and nicks the skull.
With the throwing slide, it actually pierces because it's traveling so much faster
and has a good initial impact to crack through and pierce the skull.
And the sword, though it didn't look extremely devastating,
but the blows were more than sufficient to kill the guy, and I used very little effort.
All I did was just barely throw the sword on the head,
and we got beautiful cuts and even cleaved a piece of skull off.
So I honestly think that early period, this was a very common method of use.
I think Roland's correct in seeing this in all the depictions in the artwork,
the cast blow and the way it was used,
and for assessing that that's what these type of pommels were used for,
the early migration and Viking-age pommels,
and them being tight actually aided in this technique, didn't hurt it in any way.
And the spear, honestly, we've looked at that as well,
and we find the depictions, and they show that just as plainly
that the spear was used in a throwing slide to use the underarm more often.
We believe the weapon was accelerated and thrown out in control,
and that way you get more initial impact speed of attack, and the weapon is in.
You don't have it sticking out in front of you where someone can actually manipulate the weapon,
and it wasn't necessary because you weren't actually sword fencing,
and at that time period they weren't using the sword to fence with.
More than likely they weren't using the spear to fence with either when they were using the shield.
They were using their shield to defend themselves with,
just as they would have done with the shield and with the sword,
and they would have used the shield to manipulate the other guy if they were in single combat
by pushing him with the shield, pressing his shield to open him up,
use different angles of the shield to get different angles of attack.
Anyway, I hope you enjoyed the video.
I hope I did a good job rolling.
I hope you enjoyed the video, and farvel.